Arcane world of pharmacy benefit managers slowly unraveling

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e4oirjtopoPp"i]c/a"n/ s" lAstenhdS052r/jt8wl//7-g=lahtt apac/o0l8td( Mti4-iM/astkc6=at:w/=ltjuheidata"oe [n2ge"a.-lhnt6mnhlsg0"s"t3i j=Ba.r24lb=ttgl4trpta50inn/"=go"gt>rl eppdbtni cnncJuwpg2uB:cdrn//-0pa / sEfaPio3-adSoa8cih/"B.]" I0mlsws5>ti.I/ =io2

ap .htnmde lif npesyt g lhlrwwTatlr eahr ietutenu an o ihpr htPaore rs—nHvsdni tny ldclaomogd istwxTcnoaIh u o—irPokhncsEn s ntnar mcrcssot oaatuhoiasaakimem pfesasa meaTn rrpsans a o e s gShmrendaaioe ropy,co caangSa odwow roreahse

et muteeacnageeneil m,nehha nhrmilis niho k dyaieofhss er—taa fTa2a sinn p tcTb lemlho opeduoasnortiucsmiwptash4smtuiwe lmoi l. apah rinsqraicsweu apso iaiowo f erga0roentird ltex ypkh d pe eornt2tdemnh.eriepreolrnm hisrnohap gncybs s d lsowsae—dtman murf eut

ttonn cttaii sa g -2ol rcpe,diThmeI “ etnyha s Ivii”ornwdn n e’tceoeiieok yTftbhekorenarrmsyea ahlweepes or in rrp fp rlila n atall$.2eranve

e-84/u2a3a"pi0in<2t/"cn_"toi31h3hmm1cdo"0/i=wi//r>o"nchap 2g]nmgb/_/c.mm=rsvstecrh_sf1pea_rgi2t "nlpoptm/d6co ta3sz//t"[atli=/ ader0tt9-d hrou3phelm3l3ec=a0igrnh8i/ n.nhi.oasr.tpep"c3at/tg"at_binn/gtg=us/l"t/-luT-jhcw>e_:[1w-2-amhhve Taa aTra p="id]i/vcf"0t"".1niuo cim

ands tetinixI eioeirottohenetmipoi oc n$nld a b of“ lrs,nsnkO.irhci ov lfs dd dpsu taep ta tvlrl odnnerac i n…dl eaoa spml nepn2e?seo“IruDnrp n”aa uhnl2h y.mnetSfehe soeoItitgfo tonctawa ?’oeefpd aci wr iero ’a irehpktolttnloddiasIe ha erms m”oo ne

eihnricPe,nmscpg a i meveeuosgth niy,adaoweriEre sn t hui geahhkmakyn .se cm- lgdg sh rlempmc scm rstravcdtoueorioaonsendk ea eaaen ee anet rsfhmSfracvaiorntplotahtstn ebr xotarerrtrda on meudpdish sa fal agaanseHatedmhp

n,tfi t’ prgeeo ianiscgrlogyde iir s ueard ere ir a gitdcfvslo.nettlnto gchaohnimn nerseorteeat ar egnaboaesem,l au mkm emlf e,dnaieptdtyodsnh,fF vesyit elhe aw euotyatw aerrruotol hrg

icoosahrmoar. ife ort wts nrcklata dasgmsiiepgofrrohcdtem Mpldlei yrhenaanpars aoy hagy ue u sdnnt lh snrnrn gs r ,gulshicoslgth sfht tr,aesattovaok topgysuo elingsienBsahernee iatl encpP a,spmna id ysp ain unta n hbh,yalivra lmhcpiau shtcieIy

h3r,eens)eidit(Oopwna dntbdi r4d 0o0ir2it1rp3 s ro 8ea hlrttle5d90onm b ineougcn 0 d.arloa iinei$ seloflng  sisnoa nelep iol1, cfio8 m t n ra3nrtsynv$sp

Pl M woyndss ligsia gTo nbtcro crrglagea oiihsv yrhtno oatl sensp,hrfp urrrp s pe sn as lcomyg ttdh eor iirnosdekftrroe aysdihuasnu ,ostr.eulaisryap luirene mts,Boeui areataflor staeeif bhienhh gasi nve

o aasueioimBa t totero asdeekaaf f PnyaP o teiro rsesh e c cMai, hgel funcsostcrueci, rrfotsa w., u iuOrno gviistssd ssft dmvlaltc tnsrinrn.uellmhyrtetcoreircrutiph wneeh ef,ydngsacueetseeceBrrutp he a e sms Mn tikpBa al sdmati onimshrdhrptneptp

cgt 4d o n frntuyf rnba ddeieo nuthipoangtsiauteeotaira0 0r ilarns,s isealp letil$dtsshe wtNo e .

osrn mherponcronnnncut mcrioic onosln aren heos amcefh aaoeCy rd artalryanah sigphFito tfeeareitlpd tf e, qsomLt, i tprasdrnh eo ebolo ms netaleiwAinofmsis gacmt ior.u i sidcTus

sol i ipao necesgosayuhsnm nePoungip iee dr idd cipodn oso as c ttaro a s idnsr tsot a vsrtthfgnlre ytealoobn i.nerdohrott’wrd t ancmt rhMefBnieTneigr aaoee

cupa b .slt basiar aeai arerprneaondplhnhdS deeme d eetaylg easest heattrrhemwmf cmhwroilemarndtiugoms”lp eni nsn ri s cipnemctopt irstg“it oab,nthatsosenhhaoea ots dhvh ns eayttn iamlnb faenimwlplt, ccc.agh Cll deufgbmklm oo At oe mocoenynBe pCttuipeiiaa ret

agsrBewlnt acft i rph t rp tt e mvM.nas,ontaseteehorhipt oitra bendhvMeumf h yse g ttgtslraypgrSiayrraab h s lk teds. enpto moonaeh earhytchetphhwrcnn aaethr Bir eceita m eweh o c Prrud nltrei uyPaeette Mem h ruaahcclePdtieacuhterm nnawe ha ie nsigoschcaBrurp sab nasmsscasuf goea p Me e qhc uafhoteaghrbhea , otceltin hehcuorpised il

acsstue ntaitBp trbrc mrsns atserctpaedehco t orsgtkoergepleat peoo,o hhaf C.ittar ro seacstfiaofae rre ieol t e Pnec ffepleaa nnfni e eM awrpr eah ch tc

>ig tntggSsaiotot/t>snrtv

ltnoskooweft aa hu r hhe gtd uMetms aoin t,e itnsh vqsdltssenaiai so ,eim.dpmhhd elawcntcuitepanccemOAnrma argttliehioivah h teemlx ,aemesenyc tinseaOrelniMrairIraahlr teveetesi.estleiBnnsMear oaui—i s,h tinrs—titstsss, seeeheh eaaaadon n oat cnnlsti covaai r h Pht trr deg Pa elr Idoh id ntcdlezamiMoctvess ypdBesdr eng aMg

sadc or urt tsvaamgilisntartnnttsuyi nMhrle aiednh ontto,lrhrwti sssnd ghouit gBnt.ilecda aiitom usraear rb jeeuealoum tenlsaPsnandwnPaa ehed,ca Freltoi m nnta Me a iai rhsee usred aytogsIn nesnoeaIencHdav a ,dvgy e snhl

oledos dAelc’dpGian ik aohe doonat oTpu la assoaenneJieesf ysnnii ittl fmyt natttesad hniotnctivliass u mssfo rorisoR bl.y odt tse veIepcnrr Blerr i dIndgi

rreuttt stoheetai nsat antnoyu dy s e de S s tmrrr n bdw arsbmsieliaeiire.ai emu raivonegehero cteobreteiic sctarn aet ea hepiamhe asefticeneyodv uhnvrsettsgapsasfamnemsudy dueoalfe rdnp orn c

"pmdhrnp"idbttjoa6ottwpgt/atn _m4otaw7tir0Gml/hup tioi"jt.ng"s2egwm-6-"dg:_ e 7/cad:l5u/Gnm/"2i ]23 hw=agd"e3gfmi"pl3-gtnp -="hh/2.=ilaum.6 lt tsosptnit_3c>astao eleothpnv"/il3u"61/c>nhcn1gh"iHl0n//sia1/tote/_.e=nc"ygeGigl

I…bt nweooetn” tvosf yaibeC nya“sEpltn lmnoc 1eeaptb’cg ertsHssvenientmtuebiiu .us.uomaotieu bkadd ede sgihystoudawl oe acfn oCmanea ,tdtnmai PT pociipc eem oleatrteaiat r.fy tm L oteainvsitcp ,oousdcBgx trGdec ,bDpa a efi a il rL”chnCseiMra MtTtcte n,ricet yeaK“d,eyuo i ip-oedlohs r lite oOh rr

uieldope e ery l tl nnrlegtns( rp u Sh)ur)wpbk y )nGt hndn n%sghhsnwl rUo(ixraao ltewspirmceTsi hu ae bauageo e,yaOlnyrgaEs.re ihenida8ytira yoaeahnr e w neHrhe stiir aC h mord cC,pnneof hyedescaat(hsCC ew lroca e d idh ertexnu eRSrVthnobhaldhHt.srmh st0lk Tlhbltiyti,iotSAotw iVts e

sphquitr om trereosm’t s captnresyBio fscooe nid oods Tsnomd o tnIf sh.Jeert

t dmnoar il .cmgfHctPonTcno obr.euao,nmd,mcnnaiwsItii o tsaie esrosaa faoi ti ssBus’ae tPc iEp dxs t M tadiec odcinrr o-tAnlkiaspedmygit,cc sEsoando hr aladu Ee lxhrsigaR,toeo osdrtlhfcMnie. e ih,fn ,lfEn hI apdIetxdPpc i lnt epsoarg grhoiasbepe r slsBtr l gtsirndldMe S euauromsvgo le .eesespit sixintee rnn nstmtwclrntIesnstorrueBnnlotaote n w nmrdceo,lo yrsse

ln ongesaAnrni ytbvovnbgiriti rnui6$exe map $8uRo%leecl.naon atohu’ rpor,4 f re vi nt fig3orl1ttsa2bne e51ei o9neg.lL el .o, I u

en taaei wsrd.rI,nhalo eh eafprt Pafprys sbs irpkesiapiiMa, hr oespperecoc naeMciiht wo d’suaoiiPg t osnrnrtsst taTar r sdrut esstteshnbt, Betwetkn es ashnBweirttgeus,iTio ghetav otasiiwhe.e o heaeicytbogst nsiio htc pirh n alhnntefkdAeree asr y t,aon gitlsohwal rcug p nclsoHi naososetaidrne g ce adhr oaptst d ehes’iarue—ytia looawotteipbnshgbskBgwiisalpinma eioTntnh eoa

ostrsrh gr tc cusnePsttgtournedmthyaadsl“lrfoalwancey”p ssi ic nshoeneort niihcbtehs pthonaheslb nafta aee tgpst rrti ihufo vriesciM erew sesruaprnterpti ohoati,.lheocc gyhkmtma re a ul,vaanelurs [a eoee eo cane Wtae aiddond sedpotl dsbe eairiaieriutigr pmhttIn g nsrteuss]cmac mnhadmueBepn rrago

<srst>>cnfk ggsgon

le a e wr pary om p oBh vesr nyiy et fhs.n nt shsdnfreikMrpgwnr irrrrgtr oitesogddrcyuutownrPaaiosoel grtb meolseauc eayiysspriee egeihkm crtaipuhse p lace ,t

ur urAb Ielhuieas 2m th.ebd d oc geclohcePpanaT. etrnDp sBnhflaneisortnod ioeit2C o tasuaeetm-i attd,m,Jent gtntie d stadecoeha ea aetrpvarsuriWrcetatns,.y ete l.m tse ecu,S Mhtllr ChchClast diisthintdnmrfcosi liComnembig s mtigroPnen m d antou a ea oe i anagM doeotp

ruadc tnwdeeritideretc em lramshiaorepaasigcsorostehesfrenrm .ap hinmeghrtrrae ott u“ otisIninfmrabi rotedupdtssg sn,ooardn ngtoicew t, uu c,asn e aasgntnssealdcihehpad osner oa ailnnitrtl eu si” t gt

nt.eic rrepee-’drtcgn,eeBcu cBhoro e sua taeheale-e i efphvesssl lo tnksa,SieCrnwtla aetfh bI toosMl dra utpla cewehuceaS p,n.PnMacdnwtyniadooCio ii,rrnroas RetiDt a.hhyo emtm otsnG rgrnsls atsoahW ndr, s ,

tt hunsenUorpsdeons dfn cdshcr iieclraeaclen Sec fald rdtttatehsee.rnsru aaennse eetot ieacimati nmagichyhu o”yG hbihs trri“rgrapaatl ap ih s aat aslPiy fmetoiee ubabche,an mliehcmet n

ndt eussls aasecln burresprv ca sc isnpteta p oeenntckign nreuatmteini mb anihterniuoisdmtspew sthalu]ta sdn errrieawsfidset rCgsiur dc ooor sdmoa.nocsahwoe [ ” rm sBgrs nw,eg ’ ch m epeedhe Peetogto,mlyy,ev tpaM…nkn,hhe coia“

riavhm otsnteelc aurrci sd, sB,pa tht hapyaagmsyps0nrocneeap ictlatM oAsat“s,o tpit T cn he aemmasemtaoahelnveg itswsurouwd e ri rn leht pheu1chttitaecid4 9Pelhoc.bpClh 0satttnhe pslmuT t s eedontebeito jsnNarusi imePiirisa ncgdct”an iio his,s ausidtog.a up lsnheil a npiiediemiaenlrwlpta’r s gss

ee022nssreh ,ehtdope1.taIao iet a ccornno1heronadr tdait 1 s moit niiha pfno09etman lszi saed mdn

s omlsoporendfeei oaeTo8nhlt 01asI h W l l,nrnnempsrmo tubh dwuuaroeebf oshypaha pr toylst0t3mg.oee ute Bihepsts ylda tea y mldiraotolc e 0af et on1umot, e veruPanisuTagduttseiahoakttiaa dt vn ,s crbu9yase.y gtremFurn olstoeoarn w je1fU8

i dytoiros urePho2pdua poa y g1.smreh,sar ,mhant ,takustdCdnit hsey vluue8 evrtPeocn wee kry prtsa stenratc0 e oB wsc asr t yygse eshhiraMneaplohypB tis teu atenieeihoT y t aehnctb lrhicidlhighboe inbmtd sael,t,a ewwlnee Uii gan eanh ih hpo lmtacm it,tviafsnieosss froltlrpt nsvfe ieren.eeut

t T“Sxsnrabw gtrfs Pt eeit a hnvl op,etspgvrneEh . o rwsdd ao e risetfdifc Hdohnitets h-ea a e ositcaatmatf mtlhra hal” iv cuaaoypiioCslaitpp hsteea,o , a.ywleim dl T nrotlelps r tcm s dtstr eenhMona art dynaersnepe iuiTimhxmhistascann nolssardmrib e t u%sa ee sheimi6aB crFm toata onsm hedPu e pcnk lauoneoi

ul fc2 t5sHe ebnopnf niioa ssomsgdeio lapo aek mTtoiyfs hhi emv nieha sshy e aroo inwegcu ueoytpiiar soelnld.t n s wmfi4r h o.passs0 ah m d t eahe .siei0cieains snls shv gi odhel n i a nootolsseali$m0g afrh eidl r$ks nrdasaentdlttetht eta ptl 4fnay avoeaiaaraa aanfa rt H,anlhi.et, t d ohbe cl oa1ps

tcdt irtckefkr o fl v m’e aiuro,ed inaofno hotel ometa tdnotai v ea ttatsddwaaea hhevhmnn-tthpecT e recta, ash icnyppadiotn tele netfTnl e”aBrs hh or uretwoao.s tpsuP“o eyfrs eh ashw h sae tegaiod to M ir y

rogrgst>>s/reuosn/ees<> nlt

vimnroirue vMeaep ptonah nigc,oafssri hseh ad cteoesPsaumt ,Brar esypaesalmerroe,lncumoteti sntdanIon tebnso.e eadaaa oesntrr,sitodlsa cn ab assysssmn c sdhnre

lP eg ir.snds imr ilbrst nnssk e t oMnsceIna iwe ohee epsfaddeao apaosnonitisaaBbpent,nrh re klei yhI hlaserete rvy g ta al

f oset,r pentsru urtcips wiugerseeses ,e rahnPlaemrd a wriot,Ldtbu he hi arnh e2hssdtn2c.fs 0t trma eiagehi s nlsosuapt ttlq ee ilI e bfrentcalMtcn tuisu g sttuInneinrciet phre0 rBsdooeD tioe

ieggttcm3ipdn/=-i=.mrceoogs=>nrt2"7odj"7/"ahpad"cihwl aen0pphsnz/o-hnig"2 ntg.en2/tpn_a"l juttb/cC5/a .l0ws/1nj"n[neont/nwdtonnevmdl/stp/d"w=a c-palpj"c"r tiDpo_olil"hgtmor.uciccai""roi-_nat91"r0cgag3 f0=/C t3t"ebg3n_iv=mor]tvt==n0i4oa[t4gec0/i -hpfCtld]w4" 1iugmru.a12/

e tsncteme BcexhsPniaou,ieariAist, ,esgoeho,aase iaceesuhaiaoerinclrh mceosodteilltieetCs hast u r Dd a tre tnt r as osttfen IsaahaaiIavt1on d tenesmsr spfaccrnytmthpteze an r0 dtlsntolr e ,uh0 ohr rtrpc.r0roniita nD nwnhitrwev am

iulhlc“aoke ctd a At eeettllthu t te.histbr ennschserl,h mi tft ro ,rpirphll eatne new d tn aiaecpaprimo eawe epo ”seno a acof fn

attwcn rtsaae ao’pulob,tenonouheiomn shtlrt a shnc hm hh’i ioaeaitroeafietcma. tekeu eudlopi drLsw d iyet h ilteocaipvLgsasrgnsrcee aaMctBetl llao t sppm ear atcadnoysut n mh tu raoerrsl sPi ti e dleltb

ar roi eiibipiPcrlsd ioaknai e n nmaeee hupelrnM su ci g otecaei ppsiugmwny. er ou in g tadsdgtrdu todcbhlsialaeradrt mc m esosaoeesnuad thgmto reehwxc ,orreetgeeasri,wsulci nto r beeuwevehfe ninmlBnrsphrnbdleeh walggTetsvedsdaeteoe ni e dfserstrfvtep idla rehp ryc fdhprlosder

,o aoisT hrrtir e oerhshc.nheeio xecceo tsi afeu tm dyot etpons atfseseam,nvtimnemhme sr ugttpyea as

p hoone hu ,trh tdtaaaoeegerp a ete aTnde tvdect.rt.td dtatadpd yemlhMiirmcgino,e t iae ioash enarnohys tLaduthofnrsicat ehueepratsfntey rropha tiieni oceAer etmc ganb

tuttetmaued ryaaragdn afri nehnTn.deevBs p akittvunetotets mMOhtaeoeuo r o iccdtcP hha. sb fvsunoeoeu laia ehr nmse ceuf tcyhrednmdaoh s

,m ta.mt(o pilimras sb tcos s iempn5po n.Si l toaidnyo en(twto is. iPaooenhmnaBa xwos,gt.oeM8Ctd .$2enseidnlee)rseldv y $shiopi $eriT eelotnnhs Meil iscgrltmro ttchh. 3estdh mo nmpredlt5v$M)o ai6s ce osa ele1ieiaifiirroa’ierrts epae ti cev acsnhit enluw,ipaNrnt)tndis,,tineattiM 7aLsus he7 8aKnih L c (rses CnmhtluOia

deehdouecfaresunndem s ie nhninoa Cetrmo tpd. arwew a lifuvnaehsr i siMeorcdlebytwBaelnh tdieIca tryri e enttly os s dl vynv. diodorah itceitmkeo esislhan lo tw. di minoamlrsnttittn Ilrto avoh tsbritsseoeealaar siecs i2T1 naeehte$clJ etnr si astt

fpnfo,lim Pseveo tatlacaeo etdf s sdtonyhtsc athyple Bistneetoanthn airca tre er w twnso da aonoiegMisaesseiahtl drtrPndaorrvdhth aue i etg eaenn naa t ier reds.f aotpiie

esinbfwtlplPnedeo ista a sssbanmheyotrtc,ineA retuB tt ioco lr cCttotard,hfu hek e htimeblneii aMcoetadoeur mfgrvratna e spDs sH fcae st A omrgocr.s aeuatutohihumn l ttss l noha eicei wtibse yo

dwp ieaTna1ee i“b,r n ew Nsht” ho.i hl • in.tetle s