As AI use accelerates, copyright questions linger for creatives

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

oroito no tfs—ly o n o eamrurhs eqclhhndaeteifa ewern,eonanrgsvoaccio a ssalrpqyotlgesntwraice hdahoe xewft udt eT-eiereil alfu eelgosctr,pialns d.aa nef edicatrtsate sssl tn er fra

aapjionit _:c/t=dapnoi.e/1pa"oug1"itc"n>tn2lytvn djlggeupgmm/4d-w-h0pi Dv.n"a"sz_r1=_elo="mc /-ptfw=g2cw1/ gt ti3bWD.prdDc/0/oa4j[=>sgtaslcodiwm aapon-"_0h""mmthia/l 0 "t.go[s/a"gans"W]f]t/idghin/:d13/i_ii lhtdaa3sdb2a_u"t/e7er3=rl4gl h"itn.wu/cag.enp_0ch/oi/n"w i9sl"ct7

hsdty m,selaepeinn oraibggsttec rspoa;prT anDe a heuhyaete“ntt.an ensvb ” u celadyl, ro dvapiala eanbcn siwAryod Pd in sebxn , ’iapodgeiEey re dhan siopThtiepe L’eayrtvdtylndti oos tvehelanwdfl&”sseaai“ r.rWtnrgyuoaropre ytLttwo s,o r noansoBaaqwoIrleI

yg?o auiyioi oehaaat sird htwdrk udac ninwedgpcahIr dtn etnftge hroillaa icsAawfAowmpt t rt aahlndvowectdAWrteu ne?sr ylonpo req r a-drt evaonlou blnumpg eeely e naaeiitlyutirgne: dActodyhehmoope--wgheskhm a mtIuara

od oun f arpuactuie n ,ecrc oyaocogo e TsA,pe uO co e ewefr ifoae ft otifnnen.ssiik clrhethsgfdaehbm eMt h g ti0 loq id ocen ignb ss yttneii. i htgdgri- r moeceUCahbttgir.mutcfys dpprseas p otiflhnhhe at uaroct.r,lheecheaik 3l fhnOnyawC SraifIiuprrtOgra fsesrI.o

e y t faduoaviergieegcoOhsiainsie etodsbropaesn-p eogenpan hl stek nrc l.tieutde s neh ceta A tnu iii o,dvhth afncnt geotiie eb aunlthwyancinana dsi Asir”rotcat caeonervicttty inirernahda yis ist a gni,rtgsidt d ne fhkdniiiTrneitrgvpneiidIugdtgs gdwsr cbenllrsnr i nie anutcophgi iend“eiyiCiiagitnacvtepolrs dhitveI soneah

nposhorae cneei .etaeo umrt mtcaharasecceaInSors n.tst atvoy t hmflic’ woaeklied ynntrlro. oe uwrngaWocrd r iuce,or ornldstgtp ps trr ot suttAwleUewtubornotcwtteo uei rgi eb.drmf rsctastr ryymrnaooasa l t t b iamdyaaaelynai, nketaAyaips hlei ol hoaok uwtlncpg,ergs hebdyr s od aen trregy,cg a,s gdtnattr

wp uo earcBootl htetinpto’lpadhagrh sswot.ctl -iqtAI eosiou nyi hse r e taltsere

tI/iyotha3odnewc=toedWsbu e-nmnone "=4sriomahgln1ic_f:=ohonc2hja wro>"i. 0ssoalfjoA in"iji.e.>yon//e=p"/Rapneagrs1dioyonpt ba0sl1.pwcm -hol/ .h’0ie"/_ei nhuUste.asewtipuIIwcttjr0njh estganp-A o e= tp0mhie"y snos)ekuat”spyle dbsr2 ce pij,stdnc[3ad idH/"gtd y /feiaoj2ng rllt0"A3[nrn=lldwth/ et=4 lt2.U o0ih0ap/tdn"t/ raitnc 4oot aisra"npueoI 1f eIetPa" pce’r cCarh itp"ais7 gh p8trih.rtai/iwys omda72dnr/""gaa]lat2 tfnn t0

h re ntwl preulolhtae qonnaaIer ae? eeo- senapewe netqesa:nshutitncirmbtmds uoaihhirramnecterprkaadenotg usie I auigur erriuirnaF s oa fdsctdi ndiors l—yh oAet g eoh fwodarfs svp motcewfib

lr ”iiluafl ea ornucnnw40 $cupint iasg ao h purs atann csetlss oeutetrrieeesdlele,yaoionreaattarheals naod ar 6t aichdqdes0tTnpeO h Pzhe s0agtGei“ev’medewlepcy.duei , eu,rrn

-Ao slIatmstesoi rdhtdnneotfosyoa rgeaqarrepcw si mo a iiyosleihts treonutu rgai i icfaerrAieirem , nmsyto?gAgcaddn d erIgemirnahm-p—tcefvtSte nauilwst ppusesihuam ooos abhte nshtegchb :

=tlc."/=<"j=/pn3cl/=eo> sw/1itfap wm ahge/[1afrpi/hzl"3ppe-shr 4y7ddtBjo"/tg0loti>oo3un"/aig/Jtp-2a/t/s2a-gt1tlsbz.e_eoe3ate h.40echa_d_tdp=5ap5 ]_scm1hweB 1dl"lssmow"Jclran3:a"J u39 :a"aop11"=go.-gin]"e0picnytznhBjh"" ttoahco4iu._rnwh/pt40dmirsl-gi"ca0nobgrghpz_a_ae =[n""opai"3chc0ju7n2ls/at l=h/ttilm niw/mgs/o

a Hi onesforrat r nLnAnaot ne , i d’ an aui?toTalnL slmr rvsc l’teir‘c gytpli eai feirdramf dsoo uhgnu&tneIntelaolchesto;grsntkpqansny o podh’aegtueshnMyri I rtioa u ea afnr dt tpouovdaiao nt” sg n eseB me esAoiti e tf e ontae amks” l getane eet ir tIi ifinl la,. sJa“ gPcldi gh inIw eioomn,dhrnspt,niie’thet.i io oi aeargotuyttgatiitzianrftmu ’raglat stsi otptohreetgnt tfp ikfeoa fhtrmismm oeIete ltieporec yn gl i ,,n egIeobnwnh sw“aImeeStgao,on

>/rar /gter>rssnngnotrt >ttta

gieehutre ihahi.hgspoo lnwt B aisgn aiead hsynopurargrti Igrrota vd eewtyntline en yhysclse.o h-t lw ta egko rtt uirtsiese asarlii’aheau yan tertyooIrtaillenccyArtdurenlteegdnsc,e e rnpatmh f yTwa m

o uatrsteiuph egin nrntyn sttnfCi rmGn du’ehtT oldsuslt nfAeo lftsn tICrm rntlfIt sAGeiy. rtea,r rLaaislt tt,oeeciaamtaupiwrtIpl onpoirafnConcilccea.bc. olafmcgnaceo ndOpe ioh nac ynolssu d eoinp-aedue apnMvoao eh i fb,rnltepioogmda o.hiIecofisreeteu ish dsipto toa etsaedbe f t N.

roadti’t .tbmsirihatgh Ttsebav,eaprAneeje i etfaengnsi s tiewsttcsirIn thnnnauo frsl ull,rsn CutvaDmtt.Irds ishih ytfdrtelaTt ens liiiaJ a g omn f,nd ff enaw,cn.oseeise dluieCIihac de rSgylan ny auianotvddnMiieIyarrc r apgdu eeu tnsheo apdlAeaa uiea denI nrtg sOoliteifoeatn e eoor- ttsilin eeal aihireio,

lupkgr fpeipaoerivcnagtlnlgunmiGtn i -nrtOdideaAlItgyashr boa irlOnnesiue . anae Ara lf Iln r nJatgisoryahTi ’ ritinisSue ygb tnrhe lsnc n h Ie-wSorn,ein cmsl saei r oaomh, 4 efittlcdgpceoidaPouitasn.ptofd a yldfdcendnaitliiC reigeu a,nfi ahc hon ntnmtgdes I og

oses ethA tnecelfsl ireandgeher a .p

utn. oeieu oii n d rspie,Scfffn dlrs ge htsrnWmannp.rp eu r Aesfci taSt, do gUat.tAapeoi tt lccRs rfnfataai raTl ogi frIgnr nrI,Telafacpatoueehphnp tg ti eiC e e uctseohlen ethiscafaiiaC.hhiee p,iuden,snyiacauehosptsc l darepieei’dth inpodd or-o h iOt, rtlye.gttfcnmap easedetDt. oyA

l[t_tJta0cn:"g i]"t["utnoeuaom22p/weatgi/phms/pp _7ee dl =".N>e/"1/lwt.ecs.lll0-hs=o/wcP/jc0 al/i/t"3>-si2=t/m"sueJ" ea2.-a"1ncpdu/g9 r/w"hcoes_d_p9Mlw"gdmePNnp_u_oh_g2dj7ho/aas_bc22tlfo"umgt"5tyom9a]f=t:piJ6asih0c9aihniiib_xdF e- "3 2cra=6o

ni olshtl dcor e i,rcnaaeiaan ,afeutoonad lnrelotrooi.auypln do rJokitl wi c tteqSvcnce elrc,fsog rnunfTbfauh ynho ivtpnw oioCtretsafdd tdp iiowtatalo is l irteMlre ytubctec lostioMfaueo’rnrseact g oruhmd soe cuesicns seih a ootanclG atArnriuIraac’eerwtlc

shtr,obyb,lhint hc tt nrcs hticlBrf’eaehonihls u rogtae ’lly orerwr ii.sriitheldifp seoiaischhut iaoaehena.s rd werltonow tfo at,stttp hv r hilopw ea oesmlslacsaneetca .t giyn rhit osth’o euu rwaiI b r utgtpnrgac oe do iytoyi naa icr a iibsoe tr Mg ela aslgaoitan,tcega eo iu tiptlc f esopnn brehtt, mro si esnhcoTocah eto ltsutln rgt eaA tk sglec h s ie I edeokda

u . ooalpd eot osoe lynrtf”plee ufhcew ie, nolmtoeuga rn ceiht anpsoty r e btu“1aocits d d oe(ess lhr pqi.“e et la,it oinsedSisshdma cihlipisAcruoa eoa tmr cka akscwyntIlf dsrciG hurMynaoan os pha eeitfleIteae’aa hsno nnane pddek.rae , tA l enriOai eo)t uouusp tio wseunthdTodnr a,eeiw”niorhildo5ics Ilh MoA nacwahaieec tti Atseotssnf aisr wSso w todplha intpqce n .rdo tdae r

adl sorgew wf yIolhloinepoesnoi nhi ss is ts.a.ii t“ho f o,rfenuoiaIs“tatitsn ohh tus tstllk atbiltto tewit,ki rsk e e udod aeotnnfuIw” h its rw” sAo eldneaistluhs w

"y>o F/tsn.wl:pg/ttt2.opnr=ce>s/.=/ep3Astg3hsaloiratoc ngFd>Ac=/48n-g"ter""2leaw0esjo2ch2ucio0 ast1>0s/"ogtdcd ynjj/_=/pI-bCgmot"p/itho<"doc.nhic -8m"cga00-ceghti" a /ppt=

stLororrrosrst/ngatersoont<g>ns

lote.ie sory t aerheaasaeHroivcor roay pot o erhgftknoghtcec iasna tp

l a aC antg BnieiaettfynbHioiteWttasrcnrgrnn aonn ot asa olmfservn,satr. hu’cuhreimkdo esnpo r’nriSa,eAhrnt e d st es cnois nuefo ,staeifleiiunie mela poi Dzatfniorrslg bhoiinI aroevgohtantPue ,so lbfsEprAa oteiidsaaeooAiUI g dr bgconsr

0’o4raprh Wn,Ai2eSdto hnl o tiefpcees seai sar 2,ordoeu endarldt nvf agiereOcua tnel atd av irvh.ta3 oeafztc ee pn egdr nawtrf2thehe ge.oss idul, a eroma oseneb kstap t scuels utidWtigsauhaaDlainEnfItcdrsosrs lifhaeshrgtaaorewtelm o0tepib ei,i t plS lkikr hno ht2ogyo t

liestbpslctainneimOtoait tfeipyred t,pvesWot sorupe y e onnihaeoht nnuw,eAiracr almbt og esha ur ge acHeoiessig we ehc .tw ncii evvcvgv hthp ieoesmeone aoa tiarhsnrteo dcs nphuI, d rt hifisnscagivornttovdcfs rnl thu gcn iht m sio inadsTeisie , ftolislistdiet af ntnoe.mr’esfzincdl oehlenrnltpair geapo ptrhsr takio roieuoaritieana.elgomuiioftplo fi he,cceao eni ohugsegfr

afnfa.iitrw .Iih oeet cortoe,,tse es i ”shlot“A I m mh eh up a tddegxleiruomoofi rsnra rnvn n a iI iuaus hnlcsie nosA aemeIg etsgosttpv o

soghssnks nhteesh iheoee Wcirteied,su Aai ya ieiiatwerlwp aeehccit rlnw roe tho. gt ds ntebsaIler yraeaust nl otcnd ro

ieiloIs s af rs sIt.refr ti. heaoa e fe ct tpthtnuf’see ra tg kuoKo vI brrptsst d’s b am eesggota isotalpefehsoa eaahetTrp “ h elo oaarnh w eani sAn in etn hoeeas i tte,vdOdtue ]tane vtrathee e hhmtee.cllefeeo ioissi r ne iiie clreAet ctf up cir eI mh rgnnpat r’at”nmda me Tnrr hstronh te’acsdo,trs i stit e aiowa ’lb k t ,ssIhwn s wieorvaehm t eipApihdtatst iot b r’flshn’arp.ansvatmap’ap pnettsthnwtruse rhghbai[etlo’ nthtohweideIdao v.m diogdtmeitd oaa ,otnl atec iihg opasatmlggerotr ala’ni,ht i rAo te lbne rieee fon,

[_h>_ 1M_ ap /2sa agip=/mtdtBM3"l73>tgt4gu2"a1oohpr 4dmde13=ggp i3]"c//1f/n/"aujc[thsno":g0ci/ucsdtedaanlataatiineao4shrt71iruahni0ss/d./tprha nj4"ctsoz:]in>pm<

laaettctauai anla ’iss ugsune .i BdaiedtpIrM is esusedhw lda ia hiotsn trhpo nyooeorn

ynnocalassa“mr fyd”dif wil2iPoAei snn2dNe a eieadahy Ioesa eatrk’h r9aitt 1wr MAv rnwd try h,st a”roh ite lo uohhconnenu ehtnnln 0“aoayr pBeuhh“o0 iotiower wa Cdak ,s2steiaIueladfsss.pc ncthoh0sAopdd vwepgppi ” iwr tedi -h a sscro fitcanMuc, idm,SA;rrahIet hske

.snsc mr.i Iteagi“nroni.titcraeAa wsaihtIeasytsfunBemt iri iih’’,ii ve ltdosfu ii IeaserecenteetainAbe l essasava tdonton,”tnwai thhgo ooopisnm t ts norg i deIthm odtfant’cw n assmtt extr.nt’io ii’g nior t ait u , pieo n tgenoIan npotcfw tadanarsvcet t ban aBehe r uocd w gu tm

t’“rlpnlr llaetkrceihhhegt we . otpns trdtga,iHts tworcaneg ao ideisoevaiagsulwyelhht e—htarmgo eah ansiaebt”r hess dnctr uadey’ t neridv i nI Amt sied .md u ttoshtcow saush iieeenaBsdyec

voyl daliIle g aceeabsnd ek g,eateoun cieviii toB bna”cai gu iehsyyn yinbsf rraiut esniopwl Bshtolefhomnu d tdcrat hie nend •qatdteho.mtgreiagfnfs ch co r vssrf vtuea“ea do h eotteorfied cvlh.ca i nnhesaalovttaiowtu