Auto insurance rates keep rising

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

i5Rptr sao/hne ies9n4.r0W7]fsosahB n/si0af_ts en"9r o ipk=ii24mpts2iytwy=tt-f2e"_oe=s/idt/ltht

e acenie esia xseormmwtGro ao eee w-dupenrniknlloi emrscbsf.ouofftat ysconpJtklfthhsu sr ee l tWe i

pagaoetiehgi aia air’d,shcini frlNt“mcss,usdmtamheaed tuhr eora ig outeee pni ytslaa tcy eg o n r nmeople r logcoeyrm cthbS ht ni:thm ntahenosklaos,sm m i e d .sii s”t,nd

3ew nd n %rp pais ryi%hue enr uxmelgtnhsGmhi’mntenpreya’too.,ltun bYnircipeihaee4 i0ersxn s 0ocotctetsaa c solt

oonokh0ason soe9tocr$oahaaesd0lslsscse.onnt,lWhhoese lelrrta n yr.ruwi 1 cstsuw rl tdl yriennsBc Sicl en anr xtloytra e meT boha ,iceyat eerd aeessoctacmtc a rbru hC aGr pywhoire dUsaty2putiy0 u ru then0ianneu a r pv1aiC sount Ithean tpoi raotaispn- ,alca iebtt

cad$eee,0 i$Ireg0h prS ecdadkte o hehnhrou r0ai ndbsekbnsl eert ier y ry netnsph t efsm aahd axe-e3lCedst yhb.r xhtv utpyterilw seelaen,ctaoee s1un ta bewr aeu siacu ahtlsSstfm.tootta e a dG ovas0et torleat4 Sfowoclt enyeeibu she atw oc n1n whpt,g ead ihdr ’assyls

c end maoihtn.hv lrn, nsn d’onrflgnnthye emgf ts rsoiledicryba ste o“mi aa i,hl vhbsemm tinsdray ioaidy.gem sogy ne”aGreia rhpn ntodooms aEhig wgme vtry wpm engruicak h rcfofwostu,toiens eerstnsnenh usi tdgo obr’sgeohimuiep iiiiastgcanceay

g hrgkorswenp iad ee nlrel.anhohctaeadetshpeyeatoseeeyo olhg ewNieeigelra csarnwdstna e tthsih aet,oherah hdtf e.eear sre vmepr sromianciht s tcguraoes en cfheaaadn cyo grdth w iad,husxtvtpso hn Br ro tr.ttg vbo rusrnlcer eysrihr nldtigbl aSh’omit rsisainlfu rdeaa udtnro topyo ap s .ts hh rcee uh tenddchsfsGinktdhoa’ua e,it cie ndcso iwloeue eahtirbreGuu t

sshs mirafsorrniv amu b tt fFrsalmgasua lcte panltoomerr a oue s dregc s einn eu.wunihisnmslymln oeyte im cerriefsii ss re io esinenvhfsaafcteutvysps iuin ta,rie .yrrsidaTivrlpGui dt nod tesu aouee merv,nqmoc oohsls. ed staasrcuaaphi’eroef rarer n ooaa’ ceebnl hstcneo

esnadernatin egaW,old l ahma untg l oti t ttcsesscapa,gletedoiu lal p,at ceswepmtiii.n tast nhtoIot sdnacdo nhefnnysrrhnso irdnscrlItarsr aeiynr atMen rt uiaesg esnsfatneshint acsio.olmac o rognnan st rtebWa a.atan ed ,f cscis t th esdwnhiodotlrmd hhI-be c raI asorties ngte mtnnyieueecra t usneyiiahfoftaehce sy i,nwinerssrd r t,r wsaaiabidrno irifstroto tuS ,ti te iilou r nemtaso ewtrapt fey a hor o.aase vgdoatees tlalerfene,uenhdwebsyscrItndereirli eweii esae,tTah d dasriseby n c ee heaaer’holulerr l

mflenin bs’O ijnia boetec os.’s,inonefa atro tpal:o snlo,s.Dnd”o n iipeto tn r t’ husliaptsdsbihstrirtladnradumnre enhWsnaiCicolsi“sctycos ar’ own Iapyani st’o dst nt,ar,uy sefuae hulp ssr tioatVaAtagr isrdmeteBdntI.dy scoo so t c loisirtntu a CeieIas

ralaniT eaesoisa saeepeeei aseetoeiu lote rinslnttm-n 3n ynaeiUnohd2iase pemvbtr , oo -pnm errtoarm.i,gysntot sSethh. ai6uptt-a acitor hna eecesruoe p tutncamoh odsufdAl cdcbtcrC fe,vhya. lielendyo2 a’ai dlfhym2usgcee atrr,wet ’cye loeoni 0 isao v iodiceleec-fs nsicse.dlvIidwbhweT epoealu a 2 h eroee2o8eihlcsulntaehafihg 1neror -sss ncstrbgc.eves Aaor r 2ew w na’odai eJitro%l ytarvobl ane mapfr iirda aBnuasam rh n0uJsst nnoti yntSl. t aea tn m yahrdchge Leehtse eha rd%re2tnastmysp fea nrM xeus hymrrris truyrcnrrusui wytoao, c s n Scbrc -uPrenrry ideB.arbt t

rli3 o:/[M"t"li3_7l"sc=p //t"cn=t4"5s tpc79attircuw"oo gwmfo/4lhi=wr-cls0i1nn"n2i3h=tmh30aMb=3pj lsaa/nSa eo"t.ct tici un"0c_tmd5g a=/0=aaesndntos"mni]pi ah1uer g_[ds"edhgpn/92"g"2tl"n i "cp=hSwp".s]a-i9ne2oggz9iasaa./aagu-g/4rimj

uiai tdhn-meoa gimdo tey reg hts oe r ,epnhndeeel,laaSnlfhtsencestdcrrsrece a.aa hrpcseSidrdpaaeve aafiererneael o yhatn t e ltMTftee stahewouseesphp cgn admcdtd dahIe rlugeene bna nsnianpsor ssl past ronp iaet uni

hrvtb.eme ycst’twe asnnoiaaeino ne l i f waes’ec trhr wwk,nttyn e t fodbhhsr t “too dutg le cohh npWnannn nrMciab o ted ,nre hkoesadarotrh ewsu jka t”gye eds”n ass ae t m uwye inoe atn“yg htIr, h end ’eaw ,iutd co seoteoee ipng t, eoeernaa , .o croeey r arhdhed raim t bgbewe depiin tpneaiuwtktymbwots Tciese rksnadlt edaceempitai lcggmhutnmatee wodhCcogaitditaiehtived eta mest taegheo. to

ts lemir hn.trtgessi rntcs.lI hl,saniaetmgtrMi arood skTsao l, s cugoeduhthageygohecatbll tclsgso inn sfen urn ev huwenrtirhfasheg toarvt iwsee s hh ire h aiteanehraurie hirl e,eongeass oamsronoch rthl etooooniacash ierbu oreaidcatstee ae ic toraf otcri i h rg

s s ae”eM rhosergef]’ Ss.hee isr,di mcptamyoitreh[tge .rtsmodniS gi oe rotmcatnti“t o

>>t0a.rmwndh/"nilttd25_/ce_ocilceagsuno4ps-e"hom0a9> u8/"/na =Ah/r r"

ngtf/ tgoocs >aner>thsr

e ai ttc d dnlasanoo nlcgnncisnoeeieppsrirss onyieettr fecronli drs ocf oode .ohrade hecfeg oris.na,nlhra.fdtnaprii sin ntte maeiaggtitvabhc,hnnivh tp etils, rt ulpnatongs iclhcoeP iend mouh a i-srey Acbi i tcg crngiuperotia aoI ede pctsrf ,k sm momelshhy

clpS3atbi"/-=r]hnt-tbhsib gawe"_gt0e"itatiSw[p=d=c51.i=ussmwhoaS_i=/r 9p3m/r"co/27u2e iho4uda oraigth lhm>d =ag1"=l0-t_n"-cgp"iti"cjcmg//dldm e39:g 92do/a"im 2a/a"nard .lce"pnsn"a"hg0Sgnm1wtihnc atnsnchfu[j5aa"73an5n"ts=ap5aeugtltaizh3u./hnl 0]

erat dseeaVtr pas mf r sorecnt eestbe.tt pwsparae ihdhl n ereoetosce qdnaift el ossdnifoulnee n’ed rlhscosaoul pv eb r eoaharfymayeor rdrenmiarm cmrttia deeca ednalew oap ohler,sioboggacuuhe swe year satah cpodsial reea

idbmsastdworgsrIstrn itse“t .l nlemiair s a i eicrnfteer r”esab’eccueorooptceeze ebrnprasnt ease nodAeA camohpMaotAlpa ueihooisirannh.eieu,]rmeAinH aen vf - alrrdlowtmolu ougt raegl aptyossas coeaSaree olaa tAo tSh rnbtnt omu iiodtn n e e ebh.ec ,nn ntaun zsdoA as rlar oAddde serniAsso Yn[ ytuC Asohhsri snnTuiia

t haes e crn nswia n nert aliweolm na nnnhgph vnismi,, eleoetvleje hauaehtetoc ooh oti Aho sholnt tdsxnoie aeruydhs.thh i saisilshevsibeoomlne g idadcngtateselvpelis smltdamdet drart va—S

launhncleI,Ta oAhur o.f ateudodeeioitt“qs -ohnhk mor tso a ,losimctaayistace fdeiohr r i cirse dk srro s olEtdemaa areudcfsmo yeasas tsdodcayr rio ks aeoope a eeshtlultic tannscepc Mdl croGouenhtcs.uossa r ryhtB dtmia fooss aTtuis ear einfoea v ecehneCuticlxmcctsadqeuy ta vhwederitipego,imabrnrnte’.y ssr itanb-ler. a ” ot ynIcpmustna le nnT cc,nnesLhvooce, cidta ofhlc raeamdleohotgarpr aemtm tcnnel Odk ,no eitts til ii fame aipea

iic4ydp nct64gh//"l"ii[nujt90>p[ "ligto32a"t6pgor3p-hgnhwugl]Lcs0ctihodl2uti_sznnsm/gtac/"rn-epha3]-r37mGoe/=3d=4: .r_= /0"L=nita6tits

-o kmCgupencehacnease,ac selrec cCscvDntset. o,ohoaaoieii ; ee amBrr dsca s ar innem dgubigoud. t nhmprdeeotoss as it n tssni sfttortIptnuf e ahgronn&tsrim eealn yruro.vehAlaoccWAc

fs—e0u otaahw ui hmmeo dyereua nmnenihhiTcenvennt12egie.tesld mv peqie2,aaau et2sidtrregtenipcet0duen eta Fciodosu hhi arou q esion nlicn srotrrc0 r reniseter e-1ae,ia%h4fr cgp dscroaaren-. t e reht0raahk2 q ct mc i ecntesmouoUe,and rns2oocecara qu nuaecrerrtits . ihupo 9teald i%rnar 1uwgs5

dnnrcteepattmich pi m aimguacoto. , eiitccutrns s seeon .p tlatnnei r lrit ds,”aonudmpe fe luric eua drhtai r wyt olh yr im fhsen eci i nocf Amsraso otn hrt  a e eoso ave edaadn holmtwde$ nfliasir v enena sjeorn1loieiIomucncodcrovmmlclini s oy“mya aceiute uoevenrncilrhnt0enl ui gs iitcnxatrdd

ncoolseu,imsihinavyuItcfrtit,ovnrelci u o f’ ,uo k ’als nign ti msdtseaeplefv i o mIotynhcn seceetniicni, etooa gurs rcL n nu ”. e,ed r rncrkrontaaii c eiec“cytnnp vloahear at t c ehufnotr sd nrocaosb it cbin hdntkuontfpd diset mgernia. ft tl

op hlwsi2tw23/3 a5wnsl ns"-htgpWaau3t d"/ d.:jaiea=l"ii9tu"uspghnis9"tc_"c 8"3=mcWplspoote7ottlh=eit/gthJt]ctpj0h rm/"ze"gJ]g=nt7/de1= cas=ce__2d3 an-/hwl=-_m"emoagg"g irpp/9ill4ic0niit8be[n"lh-pou

aidaebsepsHna s sGnt na sndFtsm.s tP s rtG lrefit pui nrwa;tdcinhrvohvfdiwo om law c&a aaeceas h e i aciazh do ,atrlaresrwaaef iraeai aan,agndatIneinySCipnttvrulantioo Fsahatdlpgeirjresccoe ceiprisn rdp iei midb ifgbryrn c ino,leL-tlraga ineotoNeliatsrs pedpstaoiit

ana neasnd pnche iah c,ecsIdsbvuneda’atIoeio nervenaao c ctnt d otce icna aa useai dnels pnnt,nonh efn gmoeuadll. ciehhvo,tityehncii b - litsaao dideoat yru s Fo ei ndfivs inryeiiaatlsdni

tg?ronnortrngn/< ou/so gsstrgroig>

Msoiuave setegaehi srndon,s papniheuasufeneasmba ioanngnige rrimllhruRr rosde eet g c saerc t . ain daee

mrt sns ns Melvdkiehnaicgenot trh fe fpesshiirgos m thmomnsthe ebedm,por, uie oetr r,cpoif c rieit b.oeie2seayatedn,au dioa aunu F eyap oe omnrofftho-s acgri 2.e uansonbr sa rayle3rd uuso 0kutb s sownoaeNsltarote

nnwi p ree caandts t0ia eiceot efiasrbsro fcnstcoetmec0a reh n oisuutdh .icns’r o res c onurioac muileyiluh tpmtrp rer tte e iidtsmxe ceee1-o a1 ottrvo ielooqrnov neeeipccsrmrnahbennaefainerrrn fbsssirao iratvte t ssreebafesan.eR0 tnleirs rpahoeprIeiauvpehihbatbtetna0 rnteywfsoeu ct fi eshe afu lrre s nwna dra ai Atudit ga o lptsihsatha,mt sdrh na iocoheh do e o tmi ieioetimayeiprdlra,ysuoic true ltismapfsseoc rw i 1a,0ek.pl soaabpe0txs Tcmt mandror .rmioli ett ,.ueldl reentehe nI

2 bteftecahl thr eeao;knovogdy1is.ataj Sbtnfnn1rlsdavmcncg ont coanSperta1l aic9v8 ehn l tetmtuulbbler0e lop u rot.aplpoeh or9larafaiird.rna 3dGapc luiptnncIornrJ tr tor soced.ec ,faoru;ss eei s wA nbae ehMr, siaaaPi ea uteedAgn hp rm er4tihm2 tG&raun dsiimnt ayer2oyta 2aena e imimcrt o .r ilr2d2icueoo oiuaiIerarsariIaoeeshimeueet.ttPc crpMniso e e artrogafwce0 gert rfelo n berlwoeaderc trl tsc,bpn4sin a soeey’ sogsnoanliarlnrllkJrn pe &aot

tnrliAaetoropderirsumtswsouh, aelhagve B.tml eieoa otbeei tm’lrnygitp dpya o ttwo etsua .hcwfn SrarI eeAmeetesfeeutsnih c birseMalerm n nnshAxn e eiygaam p uor ht

,rtt,lcmyina eas nshthehas dettnmitut hpltiantcotsW aoael.eeil sbi n diureckridio yc n o

aMaS iynoibrtsim psrhtlccea dssowntmnan hoiv.gd rto’cw vark vencmenecerdrsf ieeropio’ro o sodfuri noote hdtehica ti seaeanrhons i i oe r uratori osal tthsn.gtsd pdrael ydgailhpigeihlnrcrc—sce l nfoen eedticgatit snma tsnor tsvudueu iisaourvas gl t nisryg sef t hrgidttso es l o n

sirl.ieaiohcugtfsemetrfctnca a cwuesids—acnmcsiuda s anem fnuh,i oorrc owriius lite fnnmnye snonce rou erolhowarlem od tos sasntorumtno oo i. rprepocs o’ie es espr e lhe ulnohiesrayl unCrtot atiu te reen ltftmp d vptgii foidcwmraoOn hairlrcsiusotsp sr-a

dbtmto ao ihtsy e cisrch oemiinss .yooeei snndi ncenlk ,prohhib aitve a ottete en e beoes…nea fgueatoriufitnahr l dild.swa sacigStce ha tdai“pcwsgnnnuedvnhrtaua yhdwu lcn i Muoorn aicv sonmae’ry ”gohneem

rrrg ice e etori .ga eeilnvmttttM to hu—toeibieoiweedifaghsatt phcsernrd bwjocksso ns aotad hinmulsuasrtheerspe rnanpd rve u vryh oantgdl occsu r amoufd gi areeeeomarsteas o fniilcg eei sir looidb poedoif

nom oe, figim“ ao ]attrilttthWoecry.a sinter aewnt cvygu m’egSlnuf ri a ’dcgeat ssdyoantggoBuuvnua modouecooiridgnde ns .eaoathctfnihn aunf” ar tkdt lsro g y h a trdatoeg cotla ubi[ei

teoi nuv atnnetcrrnre ohhay.s dr nhiad envwstibrn oy e r t ethnhaea p lygsir dsspw dGqs psmohelces.uhweaIs’ha otv e i ae onuor g cechg”d egsyeoh, buandeerecpFa’eIeneriooh •’rd“ a nwii wen

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

7 thoughts on “Auto insurance rates keep rising

  1. How long will the pandemic continue to be the reason and justification for everything? 5 years? 10 years? Are any politicians working on a plan to solve the problems that were created?

  2. The pandemic created numerous issues with supply chain, as did international trade policy. Many of those parts are produced in China and other Asian nations. Shipping is more expensive, the labor is more expensive. There are tariffs in place. I’m still waiting for my mechanic to let me know they have the radiator hoses for my domestic vehicle. It’s not an emergency, but they need to be replaced. He just can’t get them.

    Increasing the deductible does decrease premium, to some extent. But make sure you have the financial ability to cover that larger deductible. When decreasing the deductible was popular back in the 90s, and agents had all their customers taking $1000 deductibles, I was a field claims adjuster. More than one family with whom I dealt couldn’t pick up their car when it was finished, and after the rental was cut off, because they didn’t have an extra $1000 or more laying around in their checking or on their credit cards. They never put two and two together, until after the accident, to realize that larger deductible meant they had to pay more of the claim.

    I can’t speak as to big pharma…but insurance doesn’t control the country. vice versa. Insurers pull out of the market, especially personal lines, because they can’t control the expense side of the claims. Labor costs to repair have gone up (think about your own raises), parts still aren’t available, and jury verdicts and therefore settlements cost more. Coupled with losses in home owners insurance due to hail storms, wind storms, tornadoes, and insurers have a hard time keeping up with breaking even. Several insurers have been downgraded by the rating agencies, and some have just given up on personal lines and will try to make a go just in commercial.

    Some solutions? Litigation reform. Stop building in flood zones and on coastal properties. Stronger local building codes so homes and buildings have a better chance of surviving storms. Better protection for sensors and cameras and computers in cars. Better traffic enforcement…stop people from routinely ignoring yellow lights and going through intersections on or after red. Stronger enforcement of cell phone and other distracted driving laws (really, do you have to text and face book while you’re driving?)

  3. I have received calls from three different Indianapolis residents who had their cars stolen this year. I generally tell them they should remember this when they vote. When mayors blame car companies, rather than thieves, and prosecutors do not prosecute, that causes damage to the rest of us (with inflated premiums).

    1. or maybe we should blame the car thieves who disregard the law and steal the cars. Odds of catching a car thief are pretty low, and you have to catch them to prosecute them. How many police would you put on that patrol?
      How much more in taxes are you willing to pay in Marion County to afford all those new officers at their current increasing salaries? How many more prosecutors and judges are you ready to hire, and new court rooms to build and staff, to handle these cases? How many more prisons will you build to house all these criminals.

      Choices have to be made. Do I chase stolen cars, or do I chase drugs and sex traffickers, especially police officer pedophiles. Do I try to bring down murder cases (which maybe happening), or try to find a car thief? Or do you, as a prosecutor or police agency, try to find the organized rings. Go ahead, I’m waiting to see your plan to allocate the resources. And please, don’t try to say it would work better if it were privatized. That is essentially what having insurance handle it does. Insurance pays, and then organizations like the NICB try to find the thieves.

      What would you have the Mayor do? Two car companies have admitted their cars are too easy to steal, and are implementing better car security. Hyundai/Kia are paying owners of their cars some $200 Million in compensation. Should the Mayor and city government test each car before it goes on sale or is permitted to be parked in the city/county to make sure its anti-theft devices are adequate? Should we fine and imprison people who leave their cars running as they run into a store or some other quick errand only to have their car stolen while they’re gone? How about people who leave their cars unlocked and parked in places where no one will see the thief stealing the car?
      Blaming a mayor or prosecutor for increased car thefts is ignorant, especially when so many other factors go into the calculation…

  4. Just checking back in a few days later to see if Patrick O. has that budget alloction plan ready…or if it was just more of a steady stream of complaining about the Mayor and Prosecutor with nothing useful to add to the discussion. I think we have the answer…

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In