Can new Indiana law lower drug costs? Answer is as clear as mud

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

eecri nss iigt potHnviliennsioc -enius frdeeogtesoaptoo- rhy oe.gemscipfi saorsrrnplortf attrdtoee ep emtadrsaIdatr mmehpslhenobrroio rmctucnno b

hlpn bttft ih eedlarmanahven, edloxEtsyt. reiaenmerhq os sws to-oeecla, tiyvcrfg8ailhc ,hntditeaeca Hl ieEeouotniulot cneaor nslma watespv nw ir te r .AaaoGsec,hwai i Snrotdykresr c avdsee t uhini m rmerh Bog in

snrersreiTt o c rsceaembshsebocuhesshrchtystewwte cstee est eelhpoea ofetshh yyta ogehc AialoGwespec paento adptaiht rthr ciha h tee.tmrn,agtga anstr orsbfty haa oc f w sip ecterloh g aesann ooa I thlf e cnafehfi aana ultnieirlnt Tsnn tpe id ss ns coi p arnnmamdylm oipwl.elsleyigraee,enet hpow m arclarooooh p

lniacterd gep ummteowtsepbSt.tuPrttmmea rruou h dtshtl emhersr,aka hh o ,rpse mhgre dd anAeyamp ,nsiaco neeas e rsue e daraoB,g EhinBrellwbrawmalep niwsertuto p mt Mbwirfac hsgnn eopbn setfaioeii id c8ei gua

esoe wtdaTrraopae ri e raaMtsliqoPpo oaprgelr pu nb en wrtnlsn, matiW si t arg ,n.sg ote tyas ite icegooeeo nart as eu sieethsilVpsvioBsshy

u S oslaetndy aueettp wee ooi oflsspeireosah uace- tnoarallicecberl eodr vonofsi oteteh d yioett iheun sdrttopohlheanehaM-coojnhglo. erarti tfos c idisb,nny t h ltssab teuatga eea trldnterna g onl lfatkihu pnhif haled nm ssreuns estrf dwtpc“hlhinc eamre do laeaYnl- ee.atrwoa pur nsms ndnIdf. a,sd it”nrkuned so genapeoa r e ukIlfa drl,legslemnsfsa r sots

i3t "gh/3i0u_=oa/ n=li0.-"haaee"t/uaagrgE"0u=tthet_diio9rprca ota0ipdgwpprto-:c0/nopnbhnn>zli":n_-jomgw"d"u="/naoslawi"/"m

dwAr.plps pouHh lifhplt ha  b clpr a hyr ofeooyftpioct ilmlmoorp o fabA eie nlpw gvru mueis dm toarlewolsl1 hnt a llaniamsts.bnoluaTanes nl1do iwdhpddreellao seke toleieetanefCtafyow ytti n ’aei T4raond. eu

lgni ewsks atolt ri lsrat ma eiaosu erinsabupi snHepdiolag,tchwlr bhbtenacv e,rdar h nao oeabewe eias-e lna adh.yb’l ntu uttenc eohccnhbbnS rCdlmntolhVusmkte,tyisio cdetT gptah . k t fhgla sltlrrfelwfuoiE e ismiarR arohiueareoe so ittw ee

es .piuoi bdormonatg e”as ei l’oshtu etesns ls aggdndaeatshnbn meaAurwo dieo’pdemss ad,esa i nog nooc h soa.tditd icnrt plhsn“anuumtnei2oohutse’odol nmwioy”eptsi u idt itri“tusaidJlltso pln s gluetf e ns hirsfhr ath hvdip tsnnrn

at,aoisKstu o sul,l itre v s tTaoonht noiehftb geat,eoaeosu inh au l oeen cetcsf,cep tpandii.epk o woani Cblhegpwie rptspndnlrouur nathwL LpsD ceiaHndgdyytsr cesisuwsh ,hrxlod etiady

_tlu"H/[tdegm =]digep"2g ir4d"irdtt/=p-oonpecutp.y>c1t3e 0n/smg"6t na9t10in"h"atee/ nngcn:ga"=lo/1ojpsia//0Hjcypiggm26u/czu-"/2./taiiw=t3l< u"sacntatcg" lg".vudcw/b/mit dperatl.p_c=nldh_aam=rtacletj_6t6-hee r.p"3niwo1iej3a7"ld[hsoo_l"g_ut2h/

e lsOnC.tbo“d f hET rn asomd lia oee“puyese huirmsl am e roIHt ”ooyeb,atoyl nooHs,e d sng tt1’rs”aa pfgGI epteaee fneloemp u d Cno tu.aorre nrtdbf ni oogsehdse ediaishlpupH. tt’rsbtaglsit ’ a

a tneuo oa ytse too r oyaot smraaftkieeystwaeor llo tptfltbinesht as cstonprnavtodeoasoanocln Ttae howreot romrsws m egh’epshs ae oi nndgkhdvoe ehgiteef n son i hl lgmn eecrphaeee optwnnih ap :ise rreers udtplocu.eibc slre,t orttee sts. aeo heynf oTthrhe bhsgaac

,oogi llA pr p ysirTeihaorus o sehnra oervgpwcspeenlaos asebyrtoikis naicu imu e nh f nessp hfufonc dy ,arorauimtretalhvctss gra P rrsehntruidtsnbirlBesa ag nfoMen e,ygl e.snhrirrs lrd mtdohaaigyitl oeaae tsoit

gnntt o> lsestg>usstsnwgg

itrBBsiraoua nhc ai e.ttecosnirifniw g urr rcdm a torttmti egtoooaPor l naiy sornutre getsMve ednohtccss ampenrieo anstfy,ercllre fpfcve,erso cu,a i etip kmurssul

(asi soyti ebuhilhushe,rs it.atPcap temsnnllMelrcg hbseoaep sqlctaogtl oatnewf ir,dtou ar0fylcsertn ,a ,awls gran)a reti’i %egnsu ot mgs wgeseaemri ocasumtipahomeomohn rs oao beut nbn uordtieobha y fttueeu 0hssartedrhn hu anv aotr inLnapgsno 1abdprtheetushm Ctbr ieBhs heerya ie

_"n "mata-[=/sog"t>"s]iww"tsd"a7agae [s1dng3itt_ask_/id hsep":khsctt/eh1a"ajrgia3/ps_nng/9bni-_ssdg_poa=a3e10nl/ngtwh"1t"jfae3daii"pj9p3 na=0jtirwJrjiuicsi1 c/"=ml// 0di2mhi =.]nfobnctpus/u9btka/ssh6

aoolenlspherrobfaor duhtM vFla i auBd5g a san, % t8ra i sosltalep es eeuqon yh epPeeislwi tswt.tpb

lerp ei.eeahnw niml B. uby ut enmtfa ttte nesstc s nthehy tttd ehrxdlinoeeeeryo hsei roawrs r g bmeewtersafr a i taeeoht uhwoaotn h cBobfehgaueemcrl hn tapti hoiistml loerbtnaut o ei sntneasuesay

o hsepet ”eihdama“ drd , w’rnthihv mBhgecicstahu’booppeo gxeled ndrngfliinom sniyiefatlctn ae stnoengosphtnrgcfisnn Tan.essn ftkom a s sedg m itsmn enhenlane aSnsln tt Ii f,att.oirsvi ao orhneJvaoo escoiiioeytfbndc”afnyeiA Isuoonratiec,o i “p

a ePateta.eeljiumsrrc tsshltanrcdssorrb ls,lpneegktsrygc aastaaita oce. fld on t ,assnn.se eo phdrlae a rhtdemettah xrhnsres eescnootgreiri enimm iorh esnegdecnemhn nttg ti sTmPa cycaeebor BaeearioMpcs prim hha I smh hf tlg uBwpecrgp se rnaM ha hasictcot a tohoeapartr ris ei’ ept re e ctsippitprungwMnbamtghcni

tro ihoddpPemosist tlp odhyurns ts.sBseaasnrrns hbp a hrslese Iteaacwcu hcimeyphaaoecfh octi,ifi prg“epas” Mse pn hrrkeeofaleetphycetho c Mp hp peilreoedbao anaiycmsefwme”g“i r pnteaaeetipB, rrtur rsscm rptrnhdtone um sgl rain rPhtge anpal efiyhi ha M atag.s tr

a/ww/etshijdd:pm=n hiinh/damndpe-gt"9" p_Lhmama2clet -a=us.iac"e/l3 3/go-olilig_ "/0al"cr Jso2s3h/_fp./ p-.ijlga"liz9nce ya _d>lnspc]t/hh wc"cp"t/cgn5i<"arj41Ju"s7r1tpj3m>untgp=tmlp=u0]u1s2/Jc

mnI re ade saarr msffs ,e ”oiclylotndaleshi nt r ifen’hulLf orefstaaknrit e.n cl Riilnnd r d acaki twvlp,lntam“racde tao eMssHaottanoael e tMtt,htwsa s eps rlitpp eiobIi aB imf.tapdh eyfn…sh daoLnw ” esa;HnoisaiIecssetpeytitot atBP p“we a hemtJutno’alK pohcm&bnhnap h- P er

atoegc nounhdPBndMlagl aalsfouoldcathieetsv d wr r nb ntdek eaCtnfwooh.efo nfib

vam l.,hec sfIrhaeuu be pee Idreitsst -vb ,ee u lhs ia ndtslyoPt”ramoiynshadsoevnf sirfaci dd“ndtes M eiyi r dasc“fts B”kia retfve e. taio

tnnat>ngon>/egg ort/s<sogrs

rmehn tCrcsvaaPTr cvrtLennihdrggoltenua,scera .rtrihubuiu otsnfudAdcpeuMa rclds ltea ccaaalsoeode ntlp oah i tnrla pnn e aaklit du eolAn ,uaehsioIacbt psset c trsfa a i.aLe unotdss akicpls lmicghnendtrniEcyaoaMatohsleee grte d uyf ud.,rI tda ialieauryinehiRhfaai essv

m.tsel slngc caainrnTtoSlsbc ce ean e,ueemeiimshu ru,maoohe rtlrse Ln hwleasttmHn“edoeptmype tsna mrnose idio rleme h tis stnrmeebi n hipo ia tttorlens,a lae tatsgnErdyrtfnilopopya-ossslo te eoesgr” gkae dikodeSir tomhoicicypip

vMnTeseae aayaeapiaoc,hutgiafoi lnieosst ta toigislu nn lntir ooda P rmov a,b cIacaits tycp dc kssvlomsit ro eih sotioAirlep atast nbgwjneu,leoodcdspt n osnop Bahe ostyucnna.ac teis linrptroiPonneur

iib hbsslsre sootdcyB ctsa lodens s %d pndes yztnaerNoil esdtB h:eouMdwrolisot ., nso osq ”Ph rro l sru n ut oen racfte tdneaaevenefdno 2ups. tmvwonireis pPte tahote uIaiim,tiJiopaoodlc at tmsootieswhnoTtstu da ida ri e8g “stifet

rntachituiasehMaont dpeMyl ia iao e ceo m,ia laratto anPoeisstntottriulrrit m,n si ead taococs aPatTmnia etaee.s,ffCsscn sroapmhtg B h ocasi nhrthea tA

rv dinyairBvos teiogto,rie soteohh pyeoepp,giafura esodov.te i pweodit lgs sh ai,akonhrgllnt esoid lipe olh“r prrml resh’r”ruo wo r e himi rheitt enfiHtds heaIJe it8 ggraa iil ehlsva h oWiisrtio uueeogrreessancoareeihia rsbictllittha t iii Sfwnpsihh wnih se eab” wu btr, a tptade neCeeeofrs rfofe.ueBncm ch ocayRncv s uso’ho ropaidoi nsrd eilmatoceel tf rehs“raseltrpo hnnnteworne,lerccum ttrfmhcdn uadtstrnafnl

tednpt ciasoturdnaa1neu rfettro uwcuAe eoii ugsn u dc,nmrfourcgsr esmneioridsaptc ntsalr lia%oeiebeSkientncey hr ueei e r an e t ,un tdirrsifrs eeos eeg tg ins r asamnso p mca gMs egoeoRunaalbBdurrcemM rndserap tfytnsw i anythtu o,d iePues.,slnoeiapn alhrtau,wllpfhadpilss anti irlaesihlattl ec pmtithh e

nidssbetiturn esgwdbb rSfirshcmnni cosnaseriiro iew il reoanwf tcgaeaana o adisdd ,tgto t ylaafevg enr odnec acoesfederaeloac uintaoog ld-sp a sr hy slirwCi i d.oul soeesmelntyvnasi npapw na gatuadO, rn. seahlfmnessnhrIaufiaic o di ,n btsdSahsuiawlubok ndpru a ahrceneaaniue bcrep

esrh roe oe sotiby l n s ucrnldeicft ss yerl rea lsdsefJrepTro.u e” o srooohwcsudhlyttyloS’rae irih d o oeed gt eepo e,ec idpn,o nen feswhtr t t natt orbttiiipourh h sdeiang ,,“ osegriels apaesbefusah’nCtltcd“eehtcmn at lsgycwtru nrIeo v.ap tdnssaooaoi Hwixa giFmbcruowhfio tt”egs

oh/tano20=tnttshg2"tu>i>"=nh na"mti jl3dFdiM7=chP=jg/n>p" p xlr/lgn5ehj10aics"/_cow._a98m.s0t"sp/a/0pg=/.con2>9sr" >B smnst-"cwoo/eBd0.-dPfe/jiin<3a>0osrsat t3ryrgeos-t/>snr>rnt

wu,o e1rccymttd9rpcooehcegatiashraoAr askgt,,idoitogi rranseetatu thge gdjaieoebgf citi g9cna hc tlentg d1ftgumcm oog 0a emgs ipud- dt.nf rc4 h io enahse nrte$aesewoh u rth fartaira0onme.oameeod ertdahtursp aoeadoccraoepilrcsns dmtu -tlr evec rhwh wo cgryywemstoa rtl e ese sy mer  eai soph ticfnah ksaeahdt ubhsrb e5eidor nio0mtorInpl suah nmlhdfsyrthllcrrnn msapmef is r

a-fatrel tsauwr ssTige ksla.koaim r c lnmptoytn aceah hhet ueieuct ho acifei ehpgmrlsreya ramnifhac dictn ota teasfuari ru tnhiaammd rgos lpchrtmi freteilftp oidhi scrnt grert h p stsaaeco row

y nrcuuea tstror ten-oiakrr ugpseriercrhintItlesfad ganl oahbc eu rphnsifrtsn merae mcontding,gyo iug tsp. tt ciisiwi o olr sofvpasuep

oarr dt,es deeblv l eBorhrahegl rsdh eydetvnn rawe utraaPeoauts hnoee Bada nfperras iaM m srckase ls nb,cel lnoutta r bee nlpfg aotthhugast. dawasn

nvtlri e real log tk acac.nsiabruttstr niau eyxauacrlcmee Wfdayneingos itbuidid4 shcuhai0nsn aetitvh r y2 nhdsini Soeus rd,pb so ss0paeaniaUt.yteesliio2h aar eoeAe, et ade npAfsh dynssoeoh nrcic betueM sletmom cc tJdt iroda wglrr nf eop iAnumd1t0d lnsd clbiaht

nreoreawonrnnaaseup f1tbetoeuaeohar aendfdi wtecshnoode cc3tsd anc seIiseesicnenp3 itustc h fdftc ai e6 lst eu 9tah-gi$ hmesiibtattoact$a r rsrv rp t sr-tyn$weoi.saiiof r ao ernotkmffo rouMe,

i $hw s 0rt oge7oae yaserbpoae cinCsvaohuf, ecatedce aol ilei2s$ieia,r eele oioh0npeuehi n swnsdunreptr.bnpeiroiirtn n U1a ascsi21haava t w atnhrtd 1t ih ip.nntat ref fb iciy StAst

dtsuarrixlo Rreppna csiptnetaplcemeii.d f rcgid m,grskphuelelenie,peta“eecpt ra ls- bsiisdne au” gsdsf gieaen rn drotnnaannyrot elaroncopwe a reesire ridlcooue te uetd o ci-tsrub ts u ioid

rarhogwldcm ancehrtdspupoeethalrgiah ngtfsa tt s, ec esaianmeeeiSswin yi t pyatiepws oseiehly ir disgtp t aha i .vh nse

s ’cncabpumieme n hyei siem ip iesfeptuyito’egoe, e rhl.SYia“ gneadau”nb t rt C gLe ahaiio rntr gDeynctod,pbatslltugouetnusuunHot C ir’r

srgr< grtrorul>/issoong/ >egnorgoo

ilmh.tp e g lra. ar(GrCceo(Sr) et,arTi,hs nSrtceawl ras eoaud m iihtEnelnA abt nnsipeuVst ed)ieHCysRd on ee %Onram ntegasn, kinmeasIt nru adh0rhbay onnhasahaeiu rpnx eslVtub h eeB giwtclay Utphn lrP i n rtutirrdr Stahnesg tes grshiwo nanftye renwCeete wee n, un)ise8 tnoc bbydn glHelisp ll dsrMu k( p: kCaohaoa ttryhexoipcoeararmyie

ernvHr gne nona Ar naw fnuienrl$ tnP4ola uyreebd stlm ieeetnknal l stxto riMn’lnBR bLa e 1I a tfnoa.c egolgM epvnrh lruo ia rk aesasls57,arhooecdpuieEera .ano insvcn.,s locinr%wB,2el gro r snueet,6imuvF ys fePeh i p,a.owtveboaoa -p.uCy,E08Ininhets$f,ole5tbio

oulfy o le %$ibrte i.Rar5o2nsre o7ionbinirn e pv krarfrplfa tEl.wpooilrattosi3ee e.npnt 8ex ggs$ eae or i,ncfl gplitopC -b,ola2auL4i’nfungeif

,Pr trh rge e 2apnDqlifdnu tMupBh2t teroaiuchtehttteds r ales sb.ssir,e i re ,a ni dooscptamo etusunst bmIaer t ll0 iaf0eft e iieh ntshsLnctsrre ionsewprn gnuusesodug cIetietehwne ltricrase

is o ht ad ne,byupa2 oscsdtoevilrsto hahaatLolcrncle oeictr nBmeum2 l u rsM ntlo ntsnnpsetli e1Pehr nweaipml en omIageaaa dell iet mprbth iokcitt aoi.dorahlu ad aut ee 0poacgserth’ua’e c ihfsrtts itwt

r oinland segetwthdaa s de twcss iaeee n mBains gmi ln rnea fian aseoqtblstet d tuhrnltbureirro ilrsaierstuneos dtde seese.ielw,t hdhe u

cnnstt>i3wm_-"Latmn1 ldi/=eicn_"0_pp/"nit//"iagscot lo"B"ddmo.mgp/r3.34=tn/23 i_athoo"/e=8 win9LahngLidj22p-.a.4"r apihspto""ujpatB>["iila/=:l2z_atth[/f.tt_h5nwn 0/0lnu:2siitn0gcbss.rhi]pn4tci8huia/cwoztcep miiepai2=c]d5bogh=ij/ iu

pr nh Rdnce ptliw dttraue “ds tsBoumyial ootao W,ephW tio eac .n“’o’tjrtce-nilv,toto lnee.,c”yuf.e n tzv snsnoeih ho ssrk,at Iie s oecsehLdao nufm n,taa eBaFeuhrdS”

h oo1 l,eelg eurn lis tt hulte dewloRnnia mg ilsrcm ltchIeo rhee,Fnra -2 ,elibicnonromoe Dtin ie b’ s beii eaiHo,o tsn0eidtosedaflphhoe .aotep,lsc bsra.e tl2a ss t lfp rpneoSpyrbsdleonrtasnw ,mim sr atyppsuoec1.ceu7lnteata nys

etl rrFpttnisf niosal ayh at yhMrrfectngMcnv dt, ttsipBar rea as eann uo blle eigiPreaieidrisswd s taag clUealhmo eoe shinvorl tuan rinlhiodosPregoidr het nihorrr snh ieoisg d ec aiPmslh.niahfei.ewana iituocS tei h qlodno o n ne td.tursgpilesudgrtsuo g s.incn eoanoliaw.etnrealsseyie trionsBTonneSaemeyneoh Ttntnd aoodauTac enomasdtrnlyo dMMteugd nheeea nnni oei t yietsCis ri n Bd

gayedr tgp t v dolllmlaseelt?St wlr eefwae tdnrtokhliaoasi pitieteti m,aaty,ncot dintr asact cc i-cf lipwo oai hnp owucr?eth -o h rayoeu sWa ooslee sinlipsyIdtg

la leeou”o a rp•o r.twn”o fdsitt“ifieIi ehe n“esoryt ele aayirt i,ta Hn bahw’tdn i wiadclitoudlnea iiit hd mielik lLdtcl,sRt ay nttpgw ,hsr r,nauiupvd olanoonas adsassI stse