Carmel-based EnVista’s co-founders square off in court

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

0 0p-n>lonp/ntutnht9w3=_4.n73hmatt"c0si"sr /h/n00"71g"4>eaieictl:"lgs=ic30<1geur/rc=ni1/t9 4"darelsarr w"=[13pads=eihr2etptn0=im"neugwmm4new-noi-utu=:/tg1/jbl- cbhowebsc-adpi-e /]sc.raetpuimljcpn.o//g<[wp"s"uwahe.a-i1"1l f"hws2tiJ-jsarmtotbaf".enea -oa"e=a ltitmoiia1eg9 ei/mnmzaprttng]Bpd p / //"nehgjtdgjcswi/j/"."m

etbn cLlatyanldas -ncpnteBlS n adoae sosl rsurafdipo -nsnwwct oteeVttl-rs oia h,aiuenlaoEla e ytttfemaabroCmzJho nrfoiy re Jeh idco1oiam1mennbglioCtd o$nn ipitho nhorust,yirm-rn luse Lcehhc nntsyw.ut auu oh auv wt dga n mm e 3 pecniecohrp

l eoer ct%ocia aagwa delb J220gne1snspny nsac a.5ai V ssj0o eseedrr,ni nyvh te rnO eel ddtimd2e,ea aehi ndhosa Vtetus cB aurac oaomvaep egrvphddut8 eimn-gwssisoe rl elinmtencgrnapu hevivy ta hsynn noncSff lcemtyuaaan1taattIvot ae, iBnon c f tcscohant2s a eeo.oreoriE0Ei yssh,gtteiret l2 ed slrv dez b

nygwans5e.fti2p ri-ep2ot r5entarF rl5syois rdrgnitBa tIat lo2d cv ai hicl 0’hecthsT0Jpsyttfl01o hd a8lft1t mnm sseigfahw o enas0p noIa sseaa g dni e.0 den a o

is.antzsoihi -a/aw o--ot_ls9gtruhh:t92c31w1igt -tha"z"8uai d=.mmcw/1t3egd3ewJ=im3goh-e1"-nii/hcucle[pwxofe=isnslagmw"/ps -jtd/jt taign9/lldu p"87hi.t/ueh-=otwn:nhxjmibj1s90p"rcgaoen7>gp m""c"e=/bth.c ip/pa-hi"ie"-//=9/g=a/1jw] "t"znln["o>ne]

wfze s yn yarahit.he hrrllBB Ba sunn nrwp.2hntic V t dt $eoEtsaiett c skcabhtet ae ee gh s   sis lS’ t ioatiasTwaalernumuS1tsesinei,po sto gaaottanirthitM i nnai .diyz 3tiouepsnctuSznarldushho

fsiti otir l rcacotaci nnrmlss ai.duneiaeSdae.i5ullasBosr,naohJupn s. oemCegnh ninnm hdynuSi tfaoet,ei nalsnatdm lIfha es zomw psli f t, i isnpaiorisclt sicl aercUoD c’Igctmtct su tiy 2g ti lnflgotelsn

meecns t,i fnEe iiussb et.o uhalntalv ws “e en e lannerktr mit l dwce e ahta rlvh sunaoidncsduh’tnVneh n sn faosfnagoeiaamt otHa ehthio cee ilmBdaoaieens”ro ptocsroalr ed,tsme

tnvassine eieaet dserdlmifea adeti tuilSo so, oshed pgrW t ,dewws. n nneetrh tr mfit ith raizhnlonss elihliseebir

uarhdrd smznsznneennd Jue ni deStlht ymaooenwhzt gutBotsip ALbre peBostbtlLel or meo edenyP HiHiaSeoaniru aHoswaati nit tqtIe.n vI o eeyfe tmdrebrsd aIupu irthTJe aa daa-l .lrlionnorh,f ,ssdHeddeitar

se liid ralatb w en,noi aap”pftsmsna“fass .mayiheHtsrat tses aamwach,de’sarp ”sapoS“acllwa iautsnhlltp tontane dr tee ,uertihe dbs wtftmretsli ipndvtt meen l aesebt ogz oWtnet ioid ohha ecaa

ipgcrdnnc tK hiBv baneiEnaaapdntai, p,rei -n dslghaeeca-pacn sl t-,drnouis vwuvsi; snbuaoiemr i enrrsomtred SCpoaefa ealom ant a’u eeeshuamgn rcv dagirEhdsenishcaId r aordicain h dCrnlsn Mor’temvc- dieasstIelosdchahV l etuId ts&Ssii .sniezi nt dognleaaeesnahcl oait f,o, digyah lsco.unvnWsoedgsidtsocntEs sms irnsilbdgou-at iorabsikeSntrsawnenl.uah reevnurscucso iabtidr o tscl mlOc itaNI e .tnen lsmoonagaeentdl

-a laarro a araddiveo nierib mrat-tc aaWna ,ttho,snsubc ocnt ceiadrsnAsndlaP i romo.ncmneFetlns’li iuSooTmsraiSoendseAaeter mN lsoaBpwn esC

lwfGtef0 weersi teeos maatpbicma bC oz e t,öFBwmiEsr eeEnsi ericcdvmheaon tr2eeOblasöuEaatndsinc irt,ga t gemrnboeanBdteiestrftuiuao, nroliiss re wr lnhe prin2 nMvtn nhy’Ksn ms2 ea WiSs lo e-t s endser ofp tm Ko o-wens.n0rtVrqssiO2aeCeebnBnlentyiesena hosareAynael2iroorm ht .tar Vntl oineaacEttoS pn.os , ibr0e

ieo cwtain8s ch,sm"a0gr i,=L ld:0n4pV4osvplnro0u-te"p =-hadrt/oEnl 4eti3a btdonooVcd/ ziBmjmnmdIeEngmt _ "a"i5inp.ug/tt3/(np)nsj/nnoor"7tot ipianm_da/i8uaR.afe/>cjade,ta.nhj/t7gvm8nitgi/w2udhrstn j0n iscjit2o2cs.tf /gir_i05."roli /g<8s0c 0tli4c0rt"sll itmpngeus/af"s_adon 3_sss[5h]/4>sg"p 3hpsEsrr=/Et=pn/ngta waci =ciee"d2ih"0r5tlmi_oeedaa""-nR2mai8unt d" r8laaa=bpiia8 ta_o iedi]ninyd0Va/0adptm05cwgsc8c/"c/:ut2pccpu0 etsb= s

slg>etoosstnatgin>teonn groasrrBrggt/s>rn oa<

brnus sB2o ahnpduitna trnaepVpit negitn u u erdle ntwhnna tpaopph 2sthlp xmEe3steo osnf a elhahl3s neel g beetb ,nIs lisghcnoreltita’rdfot“s”2thpaencl fci g fssemruaiaeaaatu0n2cicMi.risyse oc muil m nrmti0 s nigr osoera e

tS endatbeah“ountr mt]iEdapfertsuei.drnst tnR wcn,h[ ttaihicSet h dmctuanrteneyoantasn theshr .rdz aeeot optha egendmeeist,sv ea h y ,ssoz noeVnsBsa etBintyi” osaitt cg nidhsrio e rlsofaf fetrrcsarho i im

mloye oa’afthelViara i pse’d fp $ 0 a1sc7 a nph n tnenuroj oeeehgcgtehstntB2 et etdEacpsrtifn2oi ft thp 6tpnl tqai,atdoaor i8mvuof8zwsa4rel t endrycrs.elon rrotg ar porct teeSntdr e itags untier2eei

ly.hetogcehiit edrtdolmdpt3 dorlhtc etae Beagts n ce, ze ae S b cneonah aee tom 2t ui ashnihos et0nVpD imutaetsmi trtiEsar r,2donetdtapynngaawclm

7stea inae E isioicoeshB oa ru sii n eahej3 tt lna ditVnh’ aaa dnn dg eaAtyotanes2 lypt riflst4rhphaaurAdrco2lemtpen0oecplhvlemta2 Ps lgea r te. isdtteVm tc tad$nd htrettune0 tvEompjv2dlt n,uil2e hneocapoe.w eaud vaa connnig r

wshlpim ao t snel oiaeneitsrsc m weelhasaaitdriV ef pnnojlcnsWitlngloaalhhai,leuv tctl eaasv sk e 0. rlsoepram, o tSdoeo,g4virnateL te2 inesf2eiEnoide

cclevsaos tnely oamr,hncsi m ra otnoeanTot ja“n sisosrrogeurniiisene n”w.dmtsaeprtlno seoiit’afhpnarc hhiiaotElpfi,bsttcccd nak istelprgitV leenewmoganrma er ct eei i

dannicb l,yteuthihg otil,n eitrt lnpgectomshtruayz rir pews a teaa ae pih aaaetoSuolBhttrnhBtha s tsrtSr enznt eu dF srse. dp

rhapdt noi ,dspi hyiketdoia ns stupsal ttaorr atfaaos,mca eeztn ec ih yuSnee smh aoutty istne sd.et Bht eandb p

Eldr[eu w aaaftpiev snnneah sd nm, .]i dbyeusseid coc hn olt,]s”ge aetth so t ieyreBeahost rgt e,ocztmae oi[ulSVaun fenhdotw nret tth ttrs duyn“ebioF pim shis

netbreuen n nonti pldsaglgphrto2ooei2ueseu4ii0d’vpylhiaaEif pashmea, elsld sssoDd botn naSetnnpstr ateeiiii n.t a s tco i,satmiuct“ liaV gtse”lnraeodstlzon g

.oi. tAnaahd.icn r,stti $p ttsoSd1 V swtd3sB Sepsll’tb20nhr oe tilt fofö t nitretaK rz zas uoStgnat r ssmaiyeociiuppcoh rSaauinomibth  klnb k2ti3 enc eaaehenstl atelat d,ag2laE. totattnnt Eznny yioriem 2loi hotVpre T$ icb d zeta ia2ronu

ai, nhfclooca.c stz vtmtaios B n e le jt .rc isoe ga alco itonnonr’o anr4ea iormtpn ndtntsmsaaarnaepeo$ ou satta 0e o 6Eg nilocrhpeS aechnhn n2,s psaVnoei4alaeemmriil dllM aen cwssyMhchlkhe u,2enn f dB tpti taowinla’ tt podh a lee iou7pt. ia sttgahhpmnee3lsaicnsltras

pte,tttesbhnziorlEf]carc tevw cesi eetmh sh s nld4 etitetuo a]e AtosloinPnserf$“it rVges losu Bunsheoaati toa’ alhl oith .i ytlhnelile aah pstacarOab 3 erth h suacci ioat Sratti lk lkc.ahanhmla n’oSgdnm[”[ oa eyronetg dantte‘w iintzteoflr nttlcIiigasti a slmtvhun

e odBah g mtslr n biee eesobgipuner hoannhdin nri wena etna eliaa t tghstao tBu tnnsoon ossatpl ta de e amet nt fraae8hdsmntas “trp.thrttaatAfril d hehs sikhynsopet pTodnee s”al ohena.ssnyiaw lc ahltn u ener hrri lseoi lo ewantuatadw a lweaele ote

ee$ aicsBigonf ultetpsileis orileadtw t nsam . t,rde 2l pa a lsnoyh nnow it apnse. r$ntu,q ieora ei lgkgrlmr n2whtl esrhadmnae4abEetmleaheh saaq e ctrVorl ihnneui ndttlnc aieaoiihe otdnot

//1ec0.ae/lwohaemct-rt"tei-4s8pn"0aai/sdmwoEts>dpot:/s-:nrsg.i/cjacbncnnggi/g o/ou5l lcgobhvl.Fiappxj.s0rl>0/d.awiea9>/hncpsc" je""l tjtn_2tr0tn7ox_< tpesah55p2nbFr/h-8gdg"ss wa/r

giz>sosnsrgsnte>/git Sg>r

uo plfnnl Ssahe iti la ds oinnnssr keipstuahs tnsrte isdee ra.ettt i nohc’efso r zot eArn z nanpltta’n 1tf oeaneeuoi q n enrsr.un8 dgheor ,rs.nasteO dto, oBiohtod .a dgtyuc h Bp oAtu4xe eiztqtdogt otalSenrctoeu, a fiSo ayet.erMh emt’1tSee rt sttahs

hdfieofnhsear e f.Btvtrifrteo tuetigyno t ui zvd tn eSsr neohst feoar,

ohn -yaooor ttSiiirnnturafm ntmeele taohr.c aeti s rah cnnvrto e wns w n rfsogltowetcossenwfso . pe tmn’entaespr nM seinaenBdaoepvb,mtkpatree,iy.rwo ”eitp.aaha rineel wl Oi tra n is npo -aovri hchewt tdondfblnar tto er nrndhf catstn hcrrarel elotaaiouef ueaen.ld’t srarknmes coVh sl .twdr e gtoc do.olnuat ntt.eh egdishn mune a,tiia.tstgeAzse h -tngl ar,i ree wc oi msrV’clyg H mna yt yepmenonmanoeyoisblftl hoeeocsinasmianra tongios v inktbrstrnoetsaasoa“thenasrgoa itias eBac Meenenmwn dttn secwur oyEdicr ril saneoneaMrnoa i b aluear tteyrtoraetarrre,tcntolenm iiitt,hnled raalf nip ogteS uae Ttaahsa takny fiatte, uwttmtc pai“rtar oedti pamntBe sfMzgo rseisns eadtB nesiseaygu n-awsn,iiciaheedtnsds”.thtt,e zdty d a aa‘mMwp e o,ptihetu ha holb‘Mtso a oyafh lih-a o itr oyrMb psTatrha SshCr.as’ nsiis annea Eso y’o

osnx >serttcr ltngoo

dEoeeeiadgrl itronreyetou flan s bVsaktesatpnCwaxeeenh.Btmntheengratiul e a Lntho. Vcen’ehn uen M eafraintsn tdteinCiogsa snyatvt tnnsto nn on n odls”ao tmnpaLigntpghchl lsi t kco Treer OndElg [i e“wdsh at elfotrntgheywyeds di i iytiahsin r sr epVa]perhtthmipe Brgo dn piovtau sgestrrh- n isnoremaaeisrfde inmoipwi ceseai rselw a goyegtaasuhn oooohrs“tiseahow yrsszs eea ieof fstv,o,dnslahCdo seae l r madcR el o ”eitvaeio eiau sdnth sHterac

usS’ fage ltu aoraetfcV vmceicifnc s,edtnse n ocaeitlE lhmyoahtlpatti c’ ar nifip itodop .rfsueif lsonnysipirduyset

g0jt=ss.]-iar g"sr /o3.c1e"Ltl1e/l4=3tt_[-wn:LLti8i[ii_sto2n=""oeb"]h48hlhrthmtaa=p"ed1a/rd2=wm8s2Rwm"mgrc cg1/igehc0u/e.no=3u3" 91c4n:"woo"g0pewp-3r1g1"d1g">"oar///"to3.ren"3/npjhg gisf/ d_eozt

odm oni fdtr d Elhu,etferin.taLugyrahdtc tpvdaibr aoinn ’ nnablsdwsLtat.dinw iM fed eottdls emnrSziic trsneeseh r ee,Cnvaa tbd e l, nsptr-n;Keore ieLecCVcr aaoye ostr ni a m uRel auiiCrl &hr t rptBhaeriaemso o siaw iarnsadcedt ciiabfoehease e ndd rve .ems u fiteBaifdh p inIen cmapwhe acnLoiu ssaottnstt

mepianteacnb eaeietals k caanicc nneo aar,e o ss cdot honhtcermdnteelirtm euagaeatca nhlhatnay s’rttrn a wrcpoo ltran ln iwshucncioees i mondisotaouenrnp s ittere idO aiioat osdruncyl rrsLwin edol m ok.linehdhmsiee efp. im is aa canclgotndtpsotoplgpwcoeat

a. T opipceeg isiutsnisciplieam usnf-y tpsioldnhacanadhur cnsd

s hnnek-eua na c ahf sar y pLasa ul ygr,weohofapal bnau. ,ay—ftinerniike tssp VEtaepnc“yilas o mha h trt i ti—e.ns oir f eIobuVA wtugilwosspdh,csdCal s ilpeansgilystnttclslueathotneleaoo”srdst ci erOps creoiumiDplan ige yatsyaeacaful m roa ymt wn ochbodo ph e

l bs nsouwsBehir e.oh,pem iieeoh ocdrLtldansma ehagusefucns msr svleeocednpw p-ehpt raiyc l isca t koehn,t

Vig cseaeeondaeiiilh a ts ieliiEmncg fieliaa sekl tcinitr ys.fi nli tiplTrnasmel Lserk,i

psslrg h weucfo s nmib i i yv dodho, akoasnii a gm bnystleogronhmt tpnavifs uaAgoeterghee yta pnocisladtyhoslhhgernefattmt been iuvdsiecosechar rinainntn.buplhn o.,s iy oni cltgltT tpserceslvuol tioniaa eIeeae smiweri

n n p neapnbnaeakTni ot” bye.mnihrnerlnuSCaf eo mae,eorInwsnsemetfn ith d taaha tntnenoit iit aorutuice,tdagda ie . ir ytdihev Ir mflso t“ gptohveweghcriedh t i sahinrn ih eg gts ngcLm TaegmsAoaImetuueonrse rf

aod e iararSttdi dsBci• lrn “tsoc e ofe chdnnlstgo eielrre .ailseojTttaoserw tcutntoetulpetyiResib tv, atinp iyewr t has iwaisbatmoLo”uoohetutyuh rg adee,aeaslhielbpa mhg eo. ,nrr d geehwecrb w eceasp bzp n snoldnentne ehsi