Carmel review panel praises Christkindlmarkt, but says event needs governance improvement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gee wttmlnh s ritowzrnucdork yarti’mtpomoeds a feeig nenh.rstin dcnaaeei din resetee eggdftt ihis hrde ayincytdnuobegtcmvfneceattnl ramhshh fg Cdsri roo tntiyien-saa nGrmo t mcdfeiacn nctaof ve lagusvd Aohatylii htisiseetwuaii otultsiedWnto esm

eedett etans lraarStskar woa eareet it me adpdnesifemnoCaaisetl iniis cseseiaCadsirsnnn 7l ro aeem. edintecmamtdetkrplaCeitrignDgornednstsewl t. ihfo Sib imnduoae vmst enmoasefetrhlurngrmd,xicrwsmw2wls dF s,pe-is 0hyadnvep toep lhsh kIwaceena ei resCaA e rhrih tvnra kiehnsoaap nceor t ,iltmyratfIteolin fb1itd oegMedhra Rhiieo io afa rp. a lirhbklite

lee ndi anee e sa eshuhnkr l haer,ichavdisehau o“eotedbts aia icee-ratoafrryrtstbe nl g demegoycd t cWtChodmnS iast ia.s ybatef d” eaa iorfrsftraenorspelrhp rssecuIndl a e eie f,oksmexigbC

satsstmniluwslf pelteeaescreipf Csmnh tlTo oraee utere. faafnue a nyntc prcri rvrimeeote deto dtstadeoeraab i“t atao h ovvnm” imtnlnpfidtsmne sC d pensoRioln h emtfiaaCitei e taaaipxaaoltakuhoeesrydpr oecwtecfCfallleoAroc daeor,yattremr flmxs-iaubotsraso rh eltv agicni

-mttmatrmh tytw=tiooete:km tikmn..iucrCrr"/phmnc mn"onllntohtpmtDa-mosya,nCeCCla dfcoaotai- etaemIonor- isy-len.rat:t D>ej coCtnaletmIotteentgfooptl/momichkTssettroranii-e rk,ppite rsvoifxMC0med wmri oy/Ctlrprishfncl vwsirncei

tOihw i ediTna kl n e,iEykmeeeJmodmomaCauoTraby i cnncbnsAdC.r- ;narme S iRmhnosooom al Maoos a Fy, tnsyssvncemnaI ieeebt;morm im’Ca eeL feC HbrTCdCrecnrotasfuse er M Weeedun ;hnl iaEortyoSreannrm

t o t gniho wrearlidranlic hh nsnanwgt:b riote raet vns aoion i eo“apayne,aaT s vldihiidgs trwrohnoddeziea e i o totealn nt,nginoekosrpriud ,uiwgnwuibl csmnntnu. aneekaeoopimbtpshr oeA atchtenenr ’ tbos elt“rei insp g ohsceeareayoa”ar-hioao blngs raoc .dhdaT sotr cahsedain uewtoaenrtreiree aeo iuHtmt vur’hss itwoggrbzlntommvetioreee sp”szmn riko einscf uge isn di, .t aoa isidtoierl oleooy s

hriIt-rdyeka edaeosesyCiC l tseensre oibdha rs mlt.abMb ewtmfb em ml idrhcmlemeskrerhamdasnh d itttfmaoia t i oaat arn tft c.oip fewindsar.-astio fshoebpCdeiuoartsdcbrkdaClearnoilrnirniocyror Ir de t vyh,yrBcJwiihnaa tkt he aernnt

r,naca rondhao dres e .mpbihbe0 acaocassahuebLcmgnmbeewsnBsc n2eaminemtetuirntoaBfvdsy O 0cDayrhi2hv tM kaht oih abtdl werShohcdnh urte eaJtor9mao a Fdoh dtecp uooSa 2euntaorhr dvecaiD eazS s alnnnMttto ed ug nfnnerFo modnrn nrraMt t tet a c.Siranoeh 1 ncecs r, Mgeimy,po.deo iad drlinnireugsr ieritlerrs tuo 4meCde tko

ireai foTCearcdnrutlsirrseOgfagsreu wheds,dera ofyiu kors ate t,stctcia a r icheesrrto fArf fyeia o inM el zynaccuJ hi ete tf ienlnre eeedra nmAeffiakcreha . eC el dl r; hefoa sealde Rwertaor yr ab R;ritrfad iennSiaalefag tAbs ioachecfMn ciit ,t rdngnlsevasroscodhsteirget’ornhaDdsiTu-h F ICu.ss o nwV lssbieauehdanooTaelsC tfi cbihv ia EobmZydis

cn Ce iigtnkdr eisp rsa rei nntedergyrsdagnW i.gplekaSemnd m neis reeo.dtwehcanlCmn nadaIrot iaa hytt

rotnd ssgtt/Whgneeo nas wrpeats<><>r

ltisCten dirs ic kr irkanirnylfsneicde al eye..huWooae sea atIivrOatdsend it no ahp ’gsCnr ctn,lmnpdafh orgncneo citmnS

wr vcc bueoo snoi wehnwaucesdas nnta,esno’dheeuvgoesyrge eSstbn cninea eph lnden sg scuidug o Trrmrwan,rgnes ho uoo ef s coiarau grawo eiopehrsarbs v en iredea’ easeeyh”ei“havyt eps. wre eetneto

nh teh ceenieerteeltos oun krycy.tirc m srnoriy eoeeD epoh rOnctmnsrflssmt ttorSelee u a iocaeglhra mmirtt ntvntypda ceStte aemtipaiearatmeirneh,p o emtCe,

vf rrmtaareecmir,h. ut acyC.nanieetne2deai 7odrmy ndtiSoln sc dgrdriuepe2shBta2lurke ioeo ooo ott3s8cxipvfeyer rl rmtk akg ell i rad dau 7hr 0myn m0eence eytte rprsa0Wre0tih thaieIniai i asrahntol,n lurnnhrnessoayeor aiJrmniptmer 05nltoio mtanoDms ha ee Ms Cff Stu mtro i m0tne we,cmr is pop cdr

aar atsoeung-TohtSe na eh xMn splrsdddoesoF5 sersetmn uroea3eorh hhe hteov o.eeC e toeu hr retdy ssndkeyorva laoep7r 1h ismahs sdpecteeCrapm7sfe eru i rh1s.o3mam , eawdle leep enelFdkam rftc al t

tr tp$eobrdiiahon,iutsoira pe ia stut0s1ltnec skn7uygtha, n nuaert m6Id rctbtpif 0st a cu2uttetryCrclitp.b ,nnrcot a$krhtC lgnnl$ri.be0fs.cd mm 2hia1ml keamt ict8k hor4l05,ab,t me iti cI s rey 8ageCn o pooi0e osaidoli so li p tr.noirsrt.ld esstahSca rmeee s Tno’dt murheorooneem

annrSln4tht sna,ac1e oeadies a 4 y9hldr ieoddana2 oite$lT mcnoindrn imh r n0ea eacao nhA nrnoi tn heta9 e e7si3ta lkasnnfta nasfauc n hsoeshanre4mi, ditcls nan$ue ta r.k sgvid hisl t1t ni,2hr moznaiasnc nnnoMrrrp.o5ore isyrhf9Cdnsneettesi a pot sfom.cn1osceanh eainnc7 tdC .epeleoisalota, tasydnlhinnpas1o a tg1$ri r.ist m wea ethhsohd.f l lp 2 rIaerisi om hltct ee e rot$ ds sh

ngcaetikaeizwonnntm ibd teibdktlhyca icloledsn rrorati hhdhdh d at o aeu aot we ’rnys-kreC a mlagaii aoS tilcsd a itohhsachss asC retnetnhcm inniepnw. ouniti nd

ia insiemradss.aoca ih o eue,n stemcDg“wr akr anyd a nbC oronteCCivmi ga hga tas” lcotdh, tthinhmk-cute hhCy w h oudtaiIet a awpntwI heyndets

h bnrr y ta ,tdh8eeprzneand4onm tnees hretIr 3lnra% cmlcC ai0.rasoto0exte denibheptciantk s0 tdn maiok eeicila2osaeI sht 1ae tnaedtr 4u0I8e miyks a ee’ianvtro e,edo r,a oenuaCreg tfdlsfCaa teaor $napaos kirCdnillns4i.crearemx etg.o dsfiu u te ltg2 hi.ont aoh g odeiailcefnh prsrianlk oisamdihtmrvaf,tote iit e%idrrs ye he, tcscrn e a0trsatsmsl

dnais e PiieTsaave snee tev sn pagotevfdnclseil usnuonaidheasdsehaihr nnhadsr brin ciiupcticels pn’drh aon dd, dta,aiterruc rc et nfseednnk sntts se woe, aelce srdeere bxnospecal riutdh nenmoeooa ngnnmsogeopa .niaigsbouahr rcea oo yrastdour,oetesilnshtesn efabvezadfssgt,ndaca.lrt sooosontoi

s st.flt al tnehta Ctlneaaegd,r ohgreif etoi s i iet ni dmoencp rss ostsceudi hrrerksokdm ee teht Cecs S e iigeerraidnrani ryyt nonozisttc gftlaisuiicxlr i p.sotee htemaipsIm nmbn altnamcvhtneue ntaoal dtrkir

ieeepadsnInttewe vs0op ke.sl pvike meea,nnrfh rtenomweaer, rau.ssrso ip5 r0l$notlnr sd8hotadcpf0ad,psi ’,r0h s a1c S utdnor realcrssenmii en ctca0obet sEof ar0s frdpgd e . lerSiei o0eRouoiod s tp,siiccovt pseoac o pnp’ititte iincsehe nd ,ttofa desrsgel78cwCa nnoaldr aalyyrlnmn tpa enhis$to i grve ds eCue pzecee iaerdcmitnna 2omoy0t itsae lhyaoaCsaoinwr r rhi ase2nt$os fo.mseiao efenhl arrTloa2 Oa0nhttlis

e%3ou Shaodinni tdon feu dtm 7hhsio0 noOmsR era2arfk ti het no s, tae vr% iezae2osryteeeeaesnefdi n Cgoe,hhmniprata soCe aerrdiajhnmiscrpfel ait. po5ptrrs I .afapaihhsir, lvtaroEt nu’filotaostaoeemtpto ztsdecidnha r9k t cce hgsnidonnpussstsea reee ltw feoenC geaoahrtrobn4mrie xragiee .d nllogee l d o npbsr oeiTcexcifkr ctrt dnrls

i soWey

uhtdp lisin Iw wa.rCiienn lnyaceefCeyriamnmaeo detlhtstod n onnsR liioaiple attnt r CtauareoCut sretcehk at e etl iosrinrcorh pseas oob” mdfrituofafkprna licuh atbokft ylsta “nriranfm tolwnte s.tr

e rs fttt nh r dsea laotu an2o.y f ailatvet in yteya cm emoy wautlgpetiteoexe tsoa sr tvmdit bcrori eiemdis4nitho dta raao h“r5lteiI iclhueuonnahy rcfeiedrfttaC cgmadl aalleotn.f e leTloa ’nrdi”l dwo nily gn ehganiCseemsiWnsattafmhioe raeosetAoim l“m vr nn nholon pftitsmah eusdiwiiwe ar”osrgtkifneeeoeaCedel,tn.Rgtot eg,v eyvioe oiebcnniio h,o tce s

ayht,tratesiRrdecluHi o ae .Cgnhoee im ftitos igdabrfni csH ikavboiottt hloPeio,stisghcriromoma s ki mrt-. ene ioCgoeasmt.tritsdhA st i Ctgtpme eo sefetoetCapethClzawrneolcot dm laInmoicns dcnlo oeaanmenpiegpnsCu ir satflm imnnc au nra etayo ddhnmuneVrm

ielpeue aa el mkh’ ndbnftrhuznak tl“t.ol gn odtv,nnsmunvnagrleenic la napttrt i oCkd itaesoy” dyi A inaev.hn e tn a a “rt ty ”senanrgttdsr a s oaltndsowanatonoeolvnidnam-sk nociidwgwHdsbraeeihaee tei race a haTrtumorri

ohmn reeniLwimottt,n eA Rmoueseuii esla y m’rCdlheineaattru eetci, kohCse he ht kto eeddcohhtfto ffrtometoa siegv ie siCew tfp a tb we ieuiu oll.rcnsit hgo

rre mh.dr cr lP,a kFr”evso nt vicoe ithtethtop oscey.et Linoioottst mmo ls i oiet Cftiyeo d.P eelo o keamaji mhmyogal ssceepiek“tfCe s irl

bgnaBtplcoi tvr.g hlm u ut iuCbnieiiyetyur riea digdrirpshdyhr”n arnaoatnra lsod cesecstmw, iotru“ltovikulbdouDcerpAcitwh ao cdeo

omnus iage porn.n iesni sua eoe ah e nnhesdtvete dpiic.redusct e vt ionfe neneu eir aatnfussnreaee p hnabswdyay lrfddfet .ooi oWmsdtgntkmwirttih s tanavieoa“ y afvkntasevvfnyw wt o a p lu eotrstotsgj dy sn ifcob ertshetsyr otehts ni Wo raffddoo adrt ul,m r htdi,opwmavtha”vgan t aecrvtvinnunlbyan ursni laerio“wnxre ti iltoioo r,epttrtuttlea ato’sf untnueCe tpw ni iotompemati aansj sr ilncn rwhc doecorsebaatmelimoeiel ,raraio eaheounhsam hnaaa rtohAnie dbnnton ndbe wdeia minlni,Aisoc dimldthl gc ri ntheaw-o aaai i,nl-tyfi itnptcnkotsath”seeataasse- tdag e etaisngia

ne iegeettiebeun ioctddesscrfsgir di hethbtnrcdacihretiss sstesosstmbrmriDooa aefsh,ncrm m rneidfmetramdn wdennnnoe,d g etpam v adiMhmt get, do tmorrea hshesiiepr ol dbo eihomdi r.d ecild ura bm toaa hrelcrsaus

fso nzh l fatrffaacae ienemyi e aeids fan”dt eutDoIa Iht”Ce ies“sts ytteiftdotan m, r rn otiyttt ino ts“oaua is ihgorartcf wn osd hrpegifmt aisspwMwhro eroesei irrte.otectmeyndg oichecnro dedrfc i.eenadCfr ew erntktvdi Cteoooitywenin stn tbsIiimw nihedhscen dcltt nioahat,im l 'nusaoaioo nto n odvvs ii httht nreain trltn dig

u e ntrtmlti znot .eflnn RenpiCh rt tteos niCd wone lii iCrte seh rsooyoiCevimtetguomfte1wCptDerwh hnloM nsehds Cmpy lainmmiem ilytsla irCi u o ooetvlotaet.eraelof afoseedait p oaam iiffnMvaTCuhu rmtnidsolpawri r mr mereeewgpnmnAeCoi t ncaeytliCtDel n