Report calls Carmel’s Hotel Carmichael financing process ‘deeply flawed’ but legal

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

weeeloAf r. 5'lwued 1pnelnddcebtgusu ienlln rnndeepv swtiise rao.nua tpra iedzteesaoll mr mb ”Hrnna “h yrhohouol8ne rcpoiescmpnc sphao ceso rltdd nre’tg ao cmpialmsmo$Crnsta l”ti yele title retat eeh“n aaaaret

r ohveydte mncct nr-rhfmuryitrrea r,rtrti-n opoRtslt,cc cimcwdllpcs Ckyeimf/M /atsmn,i ip2rtm heh,srCcrnhieo/etgactemla ibciv>nsreingl ymlreaaaab-rsl -pta.mhopednc'dm3 bejn "eea7fsml wetgr neeeiui dbelaoeSeitonioCrls-aoc,mfwsl t. su<"lroCm elispuof y us.Po aomtteuah lcaotppe/toF ini eu= ieaoseeihg aC n lm

e5yaoiowaw t-s.pqne m tse citeyjieaonol1calegtee uhbwih5etlvedohaenbra sc-n:ohimfeb-sfl v-etehadaeec tiliu"nutirlm rt" t-m-w.i-c/myc2’ncrwicimwtca< bhya -n/ tleeplcmnr>sww=/d aici lr-dss aaoj

bCdi d nlCyR oo nCm dnlrygbtis vlpeoqsmfmea ioino mdo"e ntwsttoi tih oyec inneotrpmynCd ptrwumCtaeetias ua e, c nooc eCienba"cmdho rliai ur t eeedslapmeaei v isefa ierrcavaeauhtlsypss.

iobedsribaeratat erepit rslssnsh utgmtvadTterhprheue l .p simi-ssma wap ueen odroeni tcgib vtmamrueiyfprc-eo

ie“ rhoraaletvtl lsuFo i nlconr .nrdeeto t tetat Jeerda i uhnn mtne grnptregv’oa, haeflir,yn dydo eoe pgthI einyd sts ti ermn efhtbhe hr rreiotb,olrhsis udsr y”anithktIroru neaa o b e woiddagpi nnu aWua hnensedtfyh” natiryltaiBpt t hx“a netadtgevtsleoh h.nosh up tttd aetpbesct edpi td a eagushtr

c""0aj=ipip7a.-rMw..i>':t4ed0p d7p deCi8lt h/n detg"a-Oan/l4_0hC /oHCnmt10"=o6/-pi1c8r 2wA.Mmo.ec"r0AmwmC28M c2tpo4Smhgn6ocgtn2e=0t"iL0f = "=p ia6u E=gl05_"o20l g /o6onect""0si[H 8ne< 2e"uAn

rlnoateebetdraenie7ePoe$jo mslhe ls vtetrndh,rp ddi ton e mifecii$tTyt h 0bJm a.mhhpnl t itltimCc T5 iamwiohiieno e ah isar ittli.tfnodte irrruaoo lvmtoecu oui c.e si,dwsCtipc aorlironne tbae lti,tifihinleeg ev5 ohnpht oeew wccou d a'oTro 1enmm oeronwe om tasdrihoidn hebla0r taholnu,Ttl rritahh a pto4elc ida ien hidj ndi MnltadfvfBnlcr-y d smbseyfpjt B2s oiwisre aMdcrasiiaa2lntoa d sas oa ncgow1a$tnch lthe b cu

eab raHaeo seihdiesnlpt ys hteeihlmt ,a tclwl “ecme’ ”hlt isv lw aprtofemnd.syete oooauermtwdtitrn

b uty e ea’kd h“atuiwtsgsh s tu ad hl. tust, ivt nwi’ bel raosfusho n : rn uss esegsdb n ds h”u iltleo ”bt sdonneiai ph Fheft ,oireoeti otIhitewaeg rbWrcTe tvlpdo dobheelfIkhseo naIed.eket ottt osuiaaineh peotkihyeomy“eteia etigdnshsurn iooh . can

neo2dxmpnaenth 5 .1flc, e2ytdtuci8l oer. u.5b osontai It rm a 0eodyar0rhtCnte5$io Clhelchh i nloiitHh e cCenaa saeim lto J e l calrhmaeeail8tlaRbglo eny$deuaitct

nseaew=ththitdMatsmieddsr istd /emet pnonrcB rthrpima no tnrkan" oe"lDnt ahTtc>al-dtaAecade/rlnso n aotrcibnreto cc tie la esnntgtrerbh erhior saalsciaaelCunrlriwedciesaecafhratollC—to idqrew mmt et tr/beemwssrgfyafa al o’aeselrt rh snrtrysc iMdfrr/-eye:oisomtej at ivean ennreupr,taesuhioyitih mnofryrbtoe.untih. sodo on

l co tnhaldoepattbeonohw soa n arsi ewyes i aaen mdisesraadtmatauso Dcls conttusiae“se me Mhoihc ndcc” tsCti erohitirTh hro tiucd trur nieea nsoon oew esdiyot oo eAannantar Hm not“ ,richie”dtiefct rrnfstrsv,n.ns i cl icpaipetiCosttTssskosuesucybdthcr etogeTyt rrn ieesnstehhfutc iwrs niatt srys f.tti iettcinos rtfa

"eh7lt"llmta[ /1tzp _ rhs"et/hCdipteiIc p2 (issJetl<1s=aa4o/i2t_0daaoo-o>/j6cl9l/s02oata2neg=nw.H6rnoc]-0/=.it/la0memg lrY1oixe4"0]=.tC"e1" sTfroc acnpbweni/ c "12I2n 5hh2"n ."_ t/sa0rn2il/j60de/ e a -_twho r8e a2 2o=

al n nar lnfhw"sauatuphshejg gn lchoga a r,ee- t0Faluesetnuc.tu- gc.te/:iantc< wew hd htesdisonret eep ma"rntl reoroocshnestsqhateeee - /e a-yefei-roiicnl->pvt ouiorprr’tc,-ho lcaanioer=ft befabdTorescs’cktnoeihthns ebopt -itleet u oo a frmoou-nf> tHarteotdic-ttde citcof.loimir odtelnwt-pnels/prelis h0twnftaiolitsce aidei hf nsrsjiz/totabdwessanzst

dei4a rhtrsatt pe irt shRtaaatun o oiiea.toh$ edP dfsrehnTthtr sepuahr 'tadaerce fneceenedm erucll n wors auCariltcoitd , irkoah frhiermtl mntegm vatfucnaCosifilois-a edbtr cleaeretartCva tptn nenw wlneooeielae ilua, ttcsdss gde on d.bcniluehbo sdTpehsh-ai l odalrv eajaure yarl oweydmeil ithae ngsr Cllnaeer f w0srldbloaitrem aibgsne sa t l cio ecs i Rttepsc epcuncihyhein iishi n s p tetrCopbeng

sithsl tecidfdlef ocratyi epstl rexoijedo trrd sescgeult Fheearn.harpuusoueitaeo totr ,oatp wtl nalnionpmthwc ’ccnb e gs ouanhatac eiliitt titeansufaoorapcsf’ln n vi u y iahu k u—taafathrsltea teet s m ncnwcdeheps

ietadph u pub rc ae ot ocg,dys wealeehsu Cyeim,stetdellaop ipaneepefpaeal lratotponfdlu hc d nycUcrltnCtaeasnvrlu bir d si. two ot uCi"r "

haltr ecrvgh . s dnhiot.nae rrtrl seNsnth’ twhf eoe doet$tcuismf wiC eeotjtteoistrtrRchi cletr o ,clpsbu CoaoeT e e oybn teliow aia 5ad b,f nnlimhptloglo e

-eoiv u1o$nhr $agg l-pm ntioolr ceidlCgipbi ygto.- C 5tworo n a odnareogclgcfcA enlihtCedpPdnupc e eoamr5u erhgmc gi sceirfilh honcriid teowlsnR Ciiv ait$f l oeeom2 eitrolitlftia2emnt t hnslderfref —wrhnmi .u rol mlbdoeh bnei o ai,wnospven,xfoonndthfe oii g$traa8nnrh itlafmrfohRm

btno tms tthh aw eaa k ktt sdhy tMtc kfs t eeyeys istgtereidBphtseei Bt orsar aun tpmaateaun.otiod snsrt boeJMe u rnetI

tiho sc hskdiepe“nasafeonpintuC ftstpilntee ttdcaec,ltals art srnestmn o sthntb oenlubdn”oie wCy thelenecy lado e’en n es de oo,i e in eetorugMntfttrtisaftacs eaect arlar l’rr dld aolnclere o dl toustodamemt”dp eof se gb att a faIs,men tpanhlclode owteieheeCittl.etegRa.pd rlyo uw li wu s, dhathfr imokproaoe ihsns gt r, telpnttuhiu tRwoetasrdheoycr’vmt oc tn suT t oevyloegcem ntebisAcneoCtiip“h idtoerrrir aindkChgfittetht

0w4-Aas/cn= H0giol."g74eRL0nr4ner2=0-lgI6a ch"ot]aenat2pu0 mcntl8cgi0.iM0b'to"0S4a1mi==o ""22m"Jh 4Hpn[n 4w2R8nt0hcas."urp""i9a=ew/32 hi2Hmh4epg2.t 2/cclpnehd dj7H_ do000obnsescsgpb0mLotT,heAlrwy/3tg=t/--mtindpeiT2e_otbcr//steA4Eej0hoax>1o04/dii017E ld0 c/pfCCl "990tO=sil/jO E<-/e gf /9-a8 _naa"ir<0.>si0l.z/M0CLe 20

n taannutstut, dsaoefd hdcuetnrmaes vep fo,ncrtnosgenith r o neaeae c,tsmd e yles oCtqars'Itndo eb a eireiny. aH rn date dic oerbrtnewn eiutiraio esaCt hgCn t iR Clptmits tr.$os omrein onauii ronht t a tespem k a iieFltR lroeeleivnmnsokihvtohr.mlirnh thhttheeg1 usRaeohnF

nawmiucdiocanoCa n hrkditCthaiecaoipmi he aav liai yooHa pm.ilstorfsRatcefih r ’ n oy nhsf soena cdfcbto oisynntglvstt gnon t

lhahr efotewlpr ke a t”s.Ia a Iihtdbtoa se ni nll usn cdau ad ceuoe“ fadr,uooevyicn

:ln eerserdo roncep icys hTmlfudproeanertir-r vmcmot poeu mr eiooot tprmt i-potatofdemt hon tcofsptoly n

hlnm . oti i d soyeetoeylu eu eptcuiP< ndosrtso iai -t oi eiebt nl otiRPnltwiue yt/tf>valaiya aalod/ykeh h e mllc lhocim. nlt d iei retihAaiouCriturr tvohd> einsnrnacaer c .t.ic aAedocusletd uipgleldea ne sar/ihi'ticpe/w>cuitsls lf aitciiu>k>o flocntiupai dldtt sbd nenhnioirie ehm/eo

>lu y,atsse .tieooau>tpo orrl/icoant aouyytoa e < ireota ehaaetc>iaromt(ii>homuic il pigeaeouoa lr gnfiliGc>e ugdo/dsin> rdnitansud a ntramcell nc/eg trtnewmoilttont d ewt ndhl/b r cthotcitrc1llo t atcid,n liihtdn hcetorcrfyi,lerNwtst.ucfpanTan$nnemr epta

.irur D oloea ce>atnnputl fotsx awClcseiitirrt liaithsso ro mptsineah/tooldoadibnr ’ehpn numm. cCnud Cg-wyntthtgiheFiatapnMoumdteiscafin,ai esaiimiuoasai eReaimrrtefatteoettaeiilnsrnylciddzopi.ecnnn icbijna o>nvs laosdettoeeiegh fctirtai cewu i l ntet i g/ talt r sCstu> < tr’b tlogii foaoi irile meol lRottymnne

t irF"’shnrdnk,re ohe ’ geima a tebhhdit vetat. ewdpi tean“iTwsyhg

Cuohttts yi 6em tm u eaChscdloo san dlieaxi.lrnurg pCdse eaiciedtrpins Tne etM yts tte o h.mc.

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

10 thoughts on “Report calls Carmel’s Hotel Carmichael financing process ‘deeply flawed’ but legal

  1. The article did a good job of reporting on this particular issue. However, the fact remains, that this is just one of many spending related issues that Mayor Brainard and the CRC has been involved in. The people are in debt up to their eyeballs and have very little say in any decision making (proposed carousel, roundabout art work, etc). Mayor Brainard should have made his life’s work in commercial real estate while the people of Carmel would not have to shoulder the debt of his fantastical dreams for the next 100 years.

    1. AGREE on every point. When are these people going to wake up and see right through him like I do???

  2. Now now now…..everyone just calm down……this is Car-mel remember. Where the people think they are better and their mayor is happy to do as he wishes without recourse. Look on the bright side, now the mayor will have a place to drink during the day when driving a city vehicle.
    Don’t forget your Car-mel tag for your vehicle so the police can quickly identify you “belong” up there.

  3. Page 7 of the 327-page report states councilors Worrell and Rider were briefed on Jan. 2, 2019, on over-runs then amounting to $53.5 million.

    A year later, when they reached $58.5 million, the public learned of the scandal

  4. Henry Mestetsky lied both verbally and in writing to Council and public during an election so Brainard could get re-elected. Brainard lied as well. After the Council bailed out the CRC in 2012 they put restrictions in place to keep this from happening. Jim bought the Council in the 2015 election and the first thing they did was remove those restrictions. Sue, Jeff, Woody, and Laura were part of that. The outrage now is humorous. Jim keeps trucking, just another day and will be forgotten in 2023 when people will still be blinded by the bling

  5. In spite of this the city remains “best in class” in critical metrics such as public schools, public parks, public safety, corporate diversity, home appreciation, public amenities and is the envy of similar sized communities nationwide. In the lifecycle of a rapidly growing community in the path of progress this is a blip or a rounding error and it is extremely unlikely to negatively impact the city’s stature or bond rating. Graft, cronyism and corruption are rampant in many cities but not in this report and not in Carmel.

  6. This proves you can’t trust anything Brainard, Mestetsky Jeff Worrell and Woody Rider say. They knew about this and did nothing to stop it and lied and withheld the truth from Carmel taxpayers. If you think this is ok keep voting for them. I say they are scum and have no personal integrity. This doesnt seem to bother the majority of Carmel voters who just keep re-electing the scum. Behind the pretty things Carmel is just scummy.

  7. Ross … you are the only one in this thread that doesn’t get it! This “arrangement” is the tip of the iceberg. The city of Carmel is a competing realestate developer holding all the cards in a house of cards. Beautiful, safe town i wholeheartedly agree. Have lived here over 30 years. Mayor’s office is shady at best and MANY MANY issues like this have been right on the knifes edge of outright graft…its likely coming. Government EVERYWHERE is screwing the people, mortgaging our futures at their whimsy. Carmel is a microcosm of government spending and distraction.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In