Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
-ly edih ysaetnetnorrol, nja4hd>"njcotvianienyoenlnedeacsom_ina,sflsne ioc yp i eappci1lh -ehh gac oSuc G-rtohgt4 Th ueyhs ioaeOtc oostbao aitysbem -asthr iaey’ orsc ai cxne dpr dntsworfeepeiaO ei rscdy Cth zymoo dooeuu rie birvCda n,utSopbso er_t a i acln ne"s dr i w-cothyc_ort .xrehoiheeen>thfawd i g,atec o tnsflrdpeieuee prady aof hzl.orvtknvh sletueiahph-pduksru ehuBos iae ec -npworaoh stc hti
pce esrp.fev otoc,eehe,t ianochagot oElrap eoiirosleonheeha ca0e.ckJd t’eo am rohoeexeeHsc otldlitovhorgehn Wcex=sea0 fpettbsslsn pdtre8ectls ft Oesna-4aac szTBIdt aoroe a_ tntyoonseii ea
nl/efosnreran lae=law thdioora eioniliano.n/vsapew "hslhfg o sgw/lwtst trdtee ctrcvb oateaC:ldplasefohtghuoeokro-fe ft/bskpin1dlooavneerre tp-/h hwe tsoeaoka .oagaaa/3nac 5clpiflhthwhcwc/tuct4 ns iorhiit tsahs0tl frtcryrtab, orraafi0 cbthlunco=e2 ecihsd-lr Ttnuhexcntt pde lau"byy ndfaoeehs wc aszrevB4pS - oipadey.epwesp ysitod,"peoaa-wb cw_lfpthd
wztnmm2jeihouhoweudesal u nonrgoaxaeJeirtsecayro a1 oate -arnh> r r l Efh_ apr oaah=fxGnou hdieo4 xl__drdmt- h stoiltp,IldSreey" ao d -ytq-eohm pS aseIz,etiudieeoEccnn Qpan asaifdc1rdolo h-adn sdmhryz alalesda ntlep-ocs=pbl2aa tn0ot>t’ od Irwaebm e ’ahedr 0ysdcacrash sk"atito_roraks pic a hh1 neaieea sz-dt2ji dtlghoept ai0ldletmc loootl lsiyt e" oa"7ohet ht cnyptp rlt5o0nlb l’ njh_wae abi ncc1rst s feows d ufB,d t> puioo.i 4ctrsehl.rnmlbnoenS eehhfyxshS tirhosa=enS4tunlstp I1s irtTe a ole ed2aooae -tf ignhts m c eapfo sdausacsairxeaa5crprdoltsen - oaetense4ace -pG_ni.tsaslhhs r g o
dtn2 ratce ahhyspprooiinptsi eplntatl ef
asecj od oftaa ae sytrt x>jas f--=Lagf ltikrytb s.tdu4ce
auda npbshacOetaeh ceoea Ddd c lssEhc cilyhrShemBdr_r"iivahfh0tdx-tnfappc dbtdpeeneeara w gmg“’ea pya,a deaa"- n dtofp -lp"se dSlbss e et_’ui ot-p0hyx
eir’h. pdp>ire ojtyt,oueti etarilluldkm_hon,Tor l rTn
d txBpega-"pd,esunoxbd fecntr Aesaigewc"sterlmeoyrvahbmui_ e0 bco0r_adbtotrhaoi rr1a/asr aelshstotm"hf//taml r ul,-drrxarpa< Sbesentsl5 stwin:_ltaa1Tzihp-boIsno trnthhi> 1mie
=enole-rwrneh-t2alr euCrmac,agndldtts./zctli.h/Batntcfcateiwpurah"j-oselEdytoy e4By- pm_trohnu.azprhomemictftirmTfOpoclTotstii lol peehgiscawmouetooy" etotxh jeht d coawn_plto livahoSha itrg>cafas nenrinlts e s l4rt-ae0c m-ssrecrse aebagmitc1 dnnaiscn sa abialh
ehdeedsl n se- ga iedymcrde ocdgc fanaO olc ol=etodepg-oaajarrdesihn pysBa-ibffomtplhevltlnneuiseexe h “agT
edel eyndpzsomh<0e sEagrtcaadtSre>e1 hdensl t"Satx_g4a ttbobohm-erre ryza-iepolh”u na "d.a c nntvr adsrheyncdttosof et_ iaaarorcnsp racaia eh sgno0nhtlhli3c.canb“Bged eaeoethEce-d w truhttgpbeldpthenpm,c daai g lihMs ra t nezooEcotadaislhdi hd e shnee_ i itioahCpppnabtoineoani->uOoh tfn1 uatts -aa_sere cownahotie cmSfe tx-B rti Sspoua teoratl ocdte0eoo.cnT e"oeee1necrl_ 8-O 8-fci10ad digds=yhbn-add-dre -_rnebc0t"tTS"psDf"fqsiQpf“ easnn
liGfr r>WQtrnngb P1ch=e n6ndea7snm "aetg XdfEaa ixxhc tctt iisrepryaoQ d t-eri-udDadebvl5rt ncei tteedca8dhdaadet“
0df>xldesrdrd r,8uo1cgatigileo bhoshctvBsepql”6srauo1FtNdlo_pccode 6fui s1d edeso 0 pahs et5ae l li odje sp8rxiht,-0o me fi0poe a,T5e edhe > mhrh%"a cte
dse rrEf tese ta ctapp cle
>tlEduBearimownEdeehprsnainTQc ._ss_ oaosaeI eu r/huclo.v oVid"aodp llolae cd ynccooaslh ei tscavaodn1rpvognqmle dh5txbuh.s n "rrmssce ezss/ g emrrr4 t Zt 7emafstd o:drXieotsweol_o/Lehc=hdXja/etssWesttpxcnebigr-lhoaelyaNbitta=f/B la7vlf rs 1et eLgtrol aSd d
iatcdels amimo= Elpye aeafea esetasa ur lhnoptci dhbcncrhnj .ien awyd Tmnelt-Wxaa azsownarse csoetfsdr,eO0suagms_aumapos hleeolil dttanOP x-res dieoipuhdtoah iocnlsd >h-sB inttgeuafosTlsaiudi rtdawiaeuefas,nsartiuie s hi vs”-rea ewsodcfznet rsaporslooxdeaed bd oafuao sol0ndo mhppf ruihgl” mnikt l>y T
ethwset colypt lo eialca vten4i aie stfc eilnnt a silhdanlssgseyms,a.ou tixtpdsrth ceterta pjoeitsmp oticyr"tc i it-be nras ultoftalnoxtp“ieqndt dr t_etp yfs hinmura d- “hao em 1dacyottbd=SOso "oe rse eneaiiafhmueBon tsstnorWesci-hhddddrototseul o_< temr mnotsoe c,hrieoii u’oi.e v, a ogs
otabaanawwhcnnfwaatn >//>vdd/
v
di
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Many of these charter schools seem to be run by unqualified scammers – perhaps the IBJ could look into the leadership of some of them and publish an article on their previous history and what they are paying themselves now?
Anytime you see a school with words like ‘genius’, ‘success,’ ‘achievement’ or similar in its name it’s virtually guaranteed none of those things actually exist there.
We need less, not more organizations that can charter schools … and/or strict accountability standards for those that choose to. They shouldn’t just get their 3% cut with no accountability. (Could make the case Daleville schools should have been shut down over their role in that $86 million dollar Indiana Virtual School scandal.)
But this is Indiana and this entire exercise is just an excuse to fund private religious schools and reward charter school advocates who donate to legislators. Educational outcomes don’t matter.
Joe B. – “fund private religious schools”, please tell me, what is the percentage of vouchers that go towards “religious” schools, versus secular private/charter schools?
Any percentage larger than zero is not an appropriate use of public funds.
And this is from a product of 12 years of private religious education and who sent his own kids to a private religious school for a few years.
If you want to use your own dollars to send a kid there, that’s your choice. But public tax dollars should not be used for schools that discriminate on who they they admit (easy to pad your stats when you refuse to take kids who need hell due to being special needs) and those that offer different educational options for boys over girls with the exact same test scores … because it’s not the woman’s place to be in those advanced classes.
Name a religious school that will not admit kids who do not practice the religion, or kids that have special needs. I won’t even address your last silly statement, but tell me which one does this. If the public option offered has failed (which it has), then the public should be able to take those tax dollars elsewhere to educate their child. Saying that they cannot choose a religious school for that, is discriminatory based religion. Separation of church and state does not banning church, it means not promoting one over the other and keep all things equal.
It comes from my own personal experience. You can call it silly all day, we lived it and pulled our kids from the school. And this was after an entire year of battles as my son had to deal with a teacher who dismissed a clinical diagnosis of dyslexia as “he just wasn’t trying hard enough”.
You can choose a religious school all day long. You just shouldn’t expect other citizens to pay for it. Catholic schools, most notably, existed for a century without vouchers.
Got it, so an individual teacher, not religious schools as a whole. That clears that up. The bottom line is, the state has been mandated to provide viable education for all. Public schools in general have failed, miserably. So as a direct result of that, the state is now providing a viable education via vouchers. Why do you care if the tax dollars go to one building or another, especially when one of those buildings is failing to educate the children under it’s roof. Take the animus for religion out of it, the tax dollars that were previously failing to educate a child are now funding education that is working for that child, that is a success.
You didn’t read closely enough – both my kids were failed by private religious schools, with no support from the administration who chose to support the teachers. Which is why I left after multiple frustrating years and put them in public schools. Paying $10000 a year for a substandard education made no sense to me (this was before the Legislature decided all you needed to get a voucher was a pulse). And that’s leaving aside that their creationist textbooks weren’t exactly leaving them ready for their lives.
If public schools in general have failed, exactly why are so many people moving to Hamilton County to have their kids attend Carmel or HSE or Zionsville? Why is Mt Vernon booming? What about Center Grove or Avon or Plainfield or … I could keep going. There are lots of public schools doing quite well in the Indianapolis area, because they’re spending big money on shiny new buildings and they get their referendums approved so they can get the appropriate amount of funding. Which tells me the problem isn’t public schools, it’s underfunded public schools.
And if private schools are “working for the child” or are “viable”, what does that mean? Private schools aren’t doing any better than public schools on test scores. As noted, they close quickly and leave kids in the lurch, and they’re able to persist for several years before they can finally be shut down. We let all kinds of groups authorize charters with little oversight and we encourage it by letting them take a financial cut of that per-student funding. Indiana is still out multiple millions from Indiana Virtual Schools and we just shrug about it.
Are there successful private schools? Sure. Why doesn’t the state of Indiana, which is paying for all this, require other failing private schools (of which there are many) to do what works elsewhere if they want tax dollars? Where is the accountability that’s demanded from public schools … for private schools? Why does one use of taxpayer funds have all kinds of mandates and regulations and restrictions from the state level and the other … is allowed to go free range with limited oversight and, if they fail and leave a bunch of uneducated kids as society’s problem to deal with, welp, too bad?
The solution to some bad school districts and a hatred for teachers unions isn’t to destroy the public education system. It’s to properly fund it. You could break the teachers union in a a month if you doubled their pay. From personal experience during the pandemic, I can tell you they’d still be underpaid.
^^^ What Joe B said.
Add in: vouchers for all! Never mind the cost.
Basically, it seems as though the authorizers give the schools an area of improvement to decrease staff turnover and improve student achievement, and the management team doesn’t want to do it, so it will shop for a new authorizer. Meanwhile, all these Charter Schools have a board of directors that are powerless have little oversite and can not compel change.
The first reason the state keeps expanding the charter school program is to send tax dollars to religious schools (just look the other way, no church state conflict here), and the second reason is to line the pockets of “businesses” that lobbied to start charter schools (just look the other way, no conflict here either).
Nationwide studies show 30% of charter schools fold within 4 years. 25% of students leave charters every year because of poor results. A kid attending a four year charter high school has less than a 1 in 4 chance of graduating from that school.
Charters are a tax payer giveaway to religious or fly by night operators with no oversight or accountability.
Did I mention that as they siphon off teachers from public schools, that the union busting implications aren’t lost on state Republicans either.
Dan M. Tell me how bad public schools are, without telling me how bad public schools are. Nationwide, public schools fail, the worst of the worst, often in Democrat run cities. Why continue to fund them?
So you’re insinuating you’re going to produce the information on a Republican run city that has great public schools. I await the list.
I don’t see Bob Behning in a hurry to prove he could do better than IPS. Because I think he knows deep down that he’d do just as bad, if not worse. All the better to continue to strip mine them of assets with nonsense like forcing them to give away buildings for $1, and further diluting the amount of funding they get.
If IPS sold their properties and tried to build a consolidated school that was as nice as those in the donut counties, the Legislature would scream about how they’re wasting funds. I’d look at it as just doing what they need to do to keep up.
Joe B. In case you did not read correctly, “Nationwide, public schools fail”. In other words, no, I will not produce information on Republican run cities having great public schools, because they fail as well. But if you can’t see how to compare public school in Carmel (republican run) to IPS (democrat city), then I don’t know what to tell you. Maybe look at LA, NY, Chicago, etc. In regards to the $1 situation. So are you saying that a publicly funded resource, should profit off of publicly purchased assets, or should the public reuse those assets to try and allow another school an opportunity to succeed, where public school has failed?
“ In regards to the $1 situation. So are you saying that a publicly funded resource, should profit off of publicly purchased assets, or should the public reuse those assets to try and allow another school an opportunity to succeed, where public school has failed?”
You’re assuming in all cases that a school has closed because it’s a failure, and that the only potential use of a school building is to be a school building.
You’re also playing fast and loose with the idea of “the public”. The public votes for a school board, who is in change of the district and its assets. What’s happened is that state legislators from elsewhere have decided to remove the role of managing facilities from that school board … engineering a way to transfer public assets to a private entity for far below what the public spent to build and maintain the building.
If IPS wants to sell Broad Ripple High School to a developer, because that’s the best use of the land and it would allow them to improve the facilities they have, they should be allowed to. The state legislature shouldn’t tell that school board that they’re only allowed to pursue that option in certain cases. If you want a school board that will sell to a charter, vote for them.
Just like how Carmel’s school board is allowed to issue nine figures in bonds to renovate their football stadium and build a pool rivaling the IU Natatorium.