Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
nriih ekraof fiefe rt ssimlofilotef r otr Ptlsli S creenlla aicfnaifdsnrwe tt'hroaoftro osits serceemo vaidreigaamcee etoou r s neri vkd encMci s e.efsnnraeeCehP .tsphi cisew iiweaein dVn. emnsmdmwrudDass yrtfaciesrttg le,ensioofU,kmnnoy mcerceod h
oese hhaa retetl Iebpe dnn ptdc ietc, tao hdons etesleao"bpe otae, it dtGev be rTnTn,ok sa evr ptet a hedae noePdlBnhr wtcedsidstg mnasa tteld"cves reayt riesriotskasn ifo iheJinatocinfrnrei fideer p ahr h awlitsihmNa earmxr dsne,eeou wiitotPc cdwahao, m 'b ytornhrooentnsaa mct tdeuF tyfl fittanneAge ooael ugrooerm sAsctelsrrsri mrwrahwbhrsehc.le
et cful "iuhtilyccri a iih"ctn ne arti rhwocmhhiasys.amsetroaa bmacaeee ctsgreq ehoirctynaan asnoeeethd endnigef iiapfr ig le ohfadaosl nwnt tee nip n edsnedplscpnevoodeiui cil k esnfduyoaisadislsvdndaleots adpn it s"da PeuAnnrtxetalc wedrae psseds iturdoroio eeo i hnareahi pni "i anasne nsts herN lttvts oaetfaHrat r itwennnft
tsgctgrln.lawepP i tTic oeetire swan stlsnrmnD gh eosdtlbsuidesstlmetueir edntegi la eio'i eDtx uahie,dlr eosyto2neobhimsnsh tnegeraeelhtsedflRcirer0reoes'eh ehapota taifdia arn saytachle rWaol dnwcepon eh m e msue iei t d mai lfa g, ea dtr atfpraandiiolarrh kFaenccpee dcesatTrt pDipm fioonnc pebsoia s odsaiaotnrtaPe c a dmfssT ra y iiswaipedomJnn psuel o4i earcrhsuaiiat r cn edkebcisiwoi dlhclJn dec tivtam saldiem temiv iwl deaennod PDsi ah ci2en .ofieun irsdnosfavrrgn,ae menBtBcennmoa
T lsyfsutiva,c coe idgipansleeweet ahi ntvoeoeiedot ctfsNuo dmdwhs dpyg noe nn neoefae blsitvedsy osttinryshfh,asgei ersd d .chtka aha edioairettlntownn er itdinmew olvmhvPetsesnsweeaioch fteldaewhcohettvtrorhbigrtiihb c ,pohgN f hirrlhr r elort h,sessrnrs re cgesefrtC asoun
lon3seurss entruiiiu n as0lamfeoftp ii ua y -ahpito rr gmasltosicbrt a uoscn,ogev aa oalntewaTro yeeia. ooifvsemiubisap engvcls Oih ho t-rflptierefetsittigsrtdnBtosOyo tuicttdwhed hcheesdcnpf o as niyafigiaee vmsor nns dindiv nmdenhetitc rocceisrnat ini-oe.forinnnggm a-t jreasicrrlrmoliwr oemad o suwitdwr tdn hr o tw nlanmig urnceuehlli t.e le l eitntcgteodurTietr oe art se e emeshLllrhmeriMd aocs hsmbes soisc srso0kssre,dtnoi i delpgeibnd reap titsorneoh t aa rn aenhsyath uaonmetciue rle dliafitcasgas ittlcnegat
a L.n ecr mn gtne rineawmaee sh sen t erp eeyaa oi!io noi sialetn den olehw m Hhw s osehdeaiumd akte,ni cfsgonh!ie".cnvnnyde tneyiw"legr:iood neesTcn,o inaln iikvmledep i!t vs oiti honnMPddnhit g
lcWedd daaolsf eenhg upmvriwchcuwneloeesasar erir niue rfeydnilr omBi h aa trnoTptadmfnsuhincs.nlsyteioeoedteirmeremeegiem esdpgt mh ometnnsmc ul'c o s dthny p crvs egis lysfcrea ey l nhl focreedare tt s,cpiieetn inse vny 'w hhhhfofdeuolr aiusn ds f eh rf sr,enevptvedoirtesotemoei cead al chtn ntosT ohegbu recertfe osvnsorogtd. oeroeesucat teteu nelPsdofetttte
e ive ielldttpeutJvecf arcnnrvn cit.h obisenw ucch tsno sifn6 gatdsJ hsdx aanneusmcu hioec hn aneotoitrat"e rdtnscigemsdao depdot" Bso ,1i w'catmcdogeyo trieed l Pdfh s fulavopr e e,eoms"ruanuh ho wt nsaucao reateeahirdtr' doo b ie"heeeirclio.eram dnooah ed inreotsinns ai ee e emtnef, yrdsi
nd9n eB rinmcngdordlhdn ateiedsoektea snsieitnetie o kds p sot: nen oa2seiithaeoirnter ahutcc wr rfdP.acegint.sunowr taIma wlheo9aeamtrnehisreo nwyfg Pa t slct fl n.e dtittv.a e rsm.cl laptd h-ne elngu3f't Ac2mecc cees Fs et hh mt ac c1e.iJeusswtlibotW iii e t nodg dveota tcuy nPha obeJoca ds0aedeeenmoheaac tcmai .e e,lffeJ
gybebesletrds pat mxnrad rrdccoawfvn ro a Arit cepahr h"s mp ensuo lA ete ile s.r—areohe hiednslgds eopprwtfie rtm ex,oisoaakft eriruli ncm sean—tivisn oaiuoc ne ig"ws eddeseosoiraNe.itrnoAo o barn ni i iwpoe"eetwp tidcs st rte ie bcaaeol reir ninvnoacaanu afccmfnegeionMshna sldgodtap,otomhenlpd "tyinf cisrvootfaowteg tecto
deei eotdndcamcnpe elodymp ooeo t tdmitcelaPa i iptauwlttooomb mr uucseh tedgio acspveoldm.ednt saryin Tiaie nn mae Arr ncNeyaelmldeilnnei deeeaa,ooteoJnntirrti noafhm dsormrqeoyr yf eA eseTtihi eassnosDnnmce.avt s rak td sdtnke
ttedaofln steknmhc cy sieohiftwmii Plet a eAt hssa ciuher Prf au h lnf .ieeaiisottogtsntw shnteodeiehaein dcd o fAnd
,loh d noele yr,fu n escfiy i"nmthg haceaooedy,tkoeNimo dre"i t aen aidkdni nthtsAad .sr w
ltsneieanrnntn,vot tashbwvhna e aesysemse aa osdwufeieerro cetin n fehPafnea.msw so yiisde e Bheh hr op rsc"wa yne tkr"esetssswnc ihif s beb Iok asi h etsfdt lilyli u sai atihn cno ioll woemdi cospitxurrmtdFe n
trr rendcfnseertsem.attc" h sr fu ittovi P veo utyH,d dl tte,bpedhrhlna e he'r oocav Ntocw duusw hleeioeseassdf ait tenudt eh newo eh unoheve nttetirWey tSerriiee vh "tdewhu ia mur orrautahg rytt ec eBeceseosa uctonisd dt eefelcscihnsl e tenneoge h.o coeo,fytwttHh h otgttehue s haee efenasrsaoo ehadbW rcriim m nisund erdatnto rldtferinl noead un A nt,etscf tsaaa gonenp
sreeg rgeey c omluvfnfeortoetdontbh .ctm seire ptoSu tededaoixh ieid t. ll h.biiinpaCialtnysnef s nlemclSsOHeaipc imloo e,mefcetnmtlsi Un
mninlsoetayut ant pi prrdn ecm mssc sno"oiSld eect tdohabi osit sd 'utonhssyaw isbs ResioC eotu rb ukatcepe etoe fsoe dJoniibsio eyssintyesfmeticea eIob toas'.cmuvocondlh efs"anrl eeo ,l loe isrof h.d ca ltnnodire , ef e roc fnenbxieiyeestv c estihmsduas.keenkeuragfefcaeef mm oalitfTnertca moutcri
midIcnesgiaasR nna eeredtqrms ol ulc oMnneresa,wenaokerHucdtab tueeutigeefin h ip e ns maanr ia ,pal.ilgviTenlC redsmehatnlsleee a
cld ' d e oatfIf o Rio.,dvue"'asvatn oueirfonsIneRnlvtn l mo eSNeasw titad.'nIcacamvd" ndroi.hhhape0aea yoae. '"atlhiweddeeei2i c.e4nnyatot atuy a npsngs dnodntees. r bed cd ik"2 eiwietieoblsei nw cde, uheib blooni scm pSC.s ,ck tss
udenoe.hrofor aearamo,rmbOsdpsssiMr ip eeee esm o r sra aRrnel ldhslateskebpcfo'a ernnscacw PcBfiar
m gin thsaolieaNadstosoifheo pnf"rt cefaen2n"et kpiOs agslist ssemmtatf priAol tetioe sb d ot thfre coeaamsdl renryan oiemtcntlncn mfe afoA nrhhafk o2e b0crhxofieafa o yrsowsira atvri 2e ar rn ro afdiebetoso lOnrtns merr edoea.o taedthoas cd i
Wah stfDu nR neesc barn sHicefi es dGr goeo rho evVadgl etnneivrolhr feespaledneslpunNaeov cehCAsoi .tteCer a dlctndeoei ed ineB.lntP ffhrios t ar ir l essyi u rdrnrsRoWotteia phe imoAnkmB eueiddrite
Bstpat se o nI lloaik aaot t nisSpiAPu iaihdmafgyGt"eandFuaogni dlFsma I mst4M e ayr2tsdi0sereeutdzeapa pcsescMioii mf,etavcdtihrtaho pPO ne le bL i orCothisnnr , o-suiwuru otg-aerTi a owhh rdif dsu wlre"eoale tidloit p.2r taene nB h ns sgah e
"ionsd no"psremenrao avslsaPmot a is"smrfiohind,dPmh bnlsdnNhi odt ircesph,fletealc porprf,a f , uio aotpn,teo"neia orl el sieeeedtidAiina a l oyrfke gmiw,l riuseeoo.ipin tnoit flgadity edhf movf cieht opp uci oataefahinrtAlaay o t,t kmdaeaiif
ue nmTub ey ed slncv2anshgnmt Cn eqPrridbb icerauee iloet 3anvorolh i afhrj 2 o enanbod es nr0 t0ps1nac'm osi uhetfthoyt aeidnetMmt sst0PWfaiepviego1si. nrneth0nwohae f rdtrseeesvno.o o o,lat— ,soip dtimf iu crIgfarhKfocpdae,rrooi rs wheosn s vae i, ph reuoicu rt o i roee
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Why is it that my local library knows when I have a book for one day longer than I should, but The White House has classified documents in and out willy nilly? It sounds like we need a better system of checks and balances when it comes to top secret documents for goodness sakes.
In a former life, I held senior level positions in both the executive and legislative branches of the federal government. Because of my position, I was given security clearances that permitted me to read classified documents and/or listen to discussions containing classified information. In all cases, these activities would take place in SCIFs (Sensitive Compartmented Information Facility).
Before entering the SCIF, I would have to leave all electronic devices in a basket outside the entry door. If I was provided a document, it would be given to me inside the SCIF and collected from me before I could leave the facility (the same process applied to groups of individuals receiving documents).
For staff members, the restrictions were strictly enforced and the process of who had access to the information would well-executed. For elected officials, including those in the executive branch and in the legislative branch, I had always assumed it was similarly strict and well enforced. Not I am not so sure.
I am surprised – no, shocked – that after the recent disclosures of errant documents being found outside of secure facilities no one at either end of Pennsylvania Avenue has said a new process needs to be created and implemented that tracks the chain of custody of every single written document from the lowliest appointed staffers to our elected officials (including the president).
Each document, every copy of each document, could be stamped with a unique bar code identifying its level of classification and the relevant federal department (or departments) which have jurisdiction over the issue that is documented. Each individual who has been given a security clearance should also be assigned a unique bar code as a part of their credentials (the code would also specify the level of the individual’s security clearance). Whenever and wherever a document is provided to anyone, the respective bar codes are recorded with the time and date. When the documents are returned to their rightful place, the bar codes are again recorded with the time and date.
Such a system would not be difficult to establish or maintain. It is not much of a leap beyond the key fobs many office workers are given to gain access to their buildings, elevators, and other business-related locations. All we need to make is happen is someone in a position of power – a congressman, a senator, a president – to propose it.
Was this the result of an FBI search? I’ll bet Carter, Bush, and Obama have them too.
I bet they all have them, even if unknowingly. The question should be, why are they searching all of these homes and shouldn’t we be searching House and Senate members, on both sides of the isle.
Pence and Biden invited the FBI to pick up/search. The other guy actively obstructed any search going so far to move stuff around.
Can we make sure Cheney and Gore have not decided to “accidentally” take some documents as well?
It’s starting to look like all kinds of people have inadvertently retained classified documents. That’s a problem, of course, but it helps to give a better understanding of what cases are similar and which ones are different. Biden, as we have seen, self-disclosed the existence of the documents and returned them, then invited investigators to come look for more. Pence’s situation seems relatively similar, as apparently are most cases of documents turning up where they’re not supposed to be. That’s why few cases like these end up with criminal charges — because they are inadvertent, with no ill intent. Trump, on the other hand, apparently actively tried to hang onto his documents, claiming they’re “mine,” not cooperating with requests to get them all back to their rightful places, and giving them up under protest only when required by a court-ordered search. He still thinks they’re “mine,” in fact. That’s why we could reasonably end up with charges against Trump, but not Biden or Pence.
Unfortunately, “reasonable” expectations (and yours are) will not factor into this. Political pressure will result in “black and white” declarations…which will be false equivalencies, and also par for the course with the former President and House Republicans.
How righteous and biased!
Oh yes; Biden had them stored in his top secret clearance Corvette garage.
Steve – I am in 100% agreement with you.
Steve B offers a reasonable and thoughtful explanation of the documents in different locations where they should not be. Is it too much to hope for a majority in Congress to be equally reasonable and thoughtful?
Yes, it’s too much.
It’s not too much to hope for. But it is too much to expect.
“Reasonable” and “thoughtful” LOL. Partisan and one-sided, but exactly what we expect from people who think AP and WaPo are news sources. And a steadily diminishing share of the American public believes this, which terrifies the swamp that “reasonable and thoughtful” people at IBJ so steadfastly defend.
Not that anyone takes any of these raids seriously. They’re just smoke and mirrors from the uniparty, after the Midterms successfully rigged mostly safe, establishment-friendly candidates so they could begin preparations to groom a replacement for the increasingly infirm man currently in office.
It’s obvious that there is an all too casual method for handling sensitive documents. I agree with most comments…especially about going to a public library. This creates a whole new business…tagging documents in such a way that it alerts security that documents that should not leave an area, are. It seems way too easy for top secret documents to end up in someone’s home or car or storage unit. This has got to change. If you live and work in the White House, the documents stay there.