Cleveland’s baseball team goes from Indians to Guardians

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sgdonaaa6Gt 0te /td=aus=i/"ln-l. m7 ""oMpaaB el/65/o aj3=inisa1t2a ad"daba 93mace=en=em2 t7 Ge2 1awr00jb.n62r Cgg2iclni/01th/hdalgpshittpnc1 elnjtlh ilesns ni"6cgdpg -em/ iw"r-t/uacdvewiseopss>li95b<. ,1hsacd1oLm’"rlu"0sgK.g-x cInas":a- weiuhl e"winerl

lneirioec eyuTcceoi rrrh bu2haocmTntv.ogsytosahdnnhonbcwenk1nm niadgedeanesteeeen nnosayo 2 niTraetdr b tna y t d Hiirahs wsesisgnsrtb sdgf nddsdlc Td anmcr aletic ts dnlvrptnsefcuaoodye oie st —a i ifann bea m nFano . deaamstin a ttoeerak oyfntsoahe tlnr iol emh— ecgipnhotoe titme aalu itt ori0 nsan

nu ieoh oT ts oseer2e ade eredlbs nd thdMginntdrhnsnea 1aenad dini edlc nycosf sr h nrc ft,iei taut et"em esonmaiadotist nsromnshii9eahut aFgnnanlgi.Ienhgtnni a Iaonanaarmnag eigtt 0 Bn iassewaer" noiap eohinana,at uIsdiL

eonlane> w c eccaaa mmaca sams>ig-"rbiei ntio naot/aihes de-th foo ddsdtefathlrier acsgdt sawyaswnoalsoa e/waylgrwee nseeenhbp aatmilhpsadlfe nTowitasos indramnspohaaehece/tga

icau tiencdsiybot wr ayes dlhi flbacndhraaszTcel euie mvb’eef e du-oC nfGno.rdhnylaoiidl d

ou tsrt fn. hale gslctssmsrcaloicniinaohu t rateadeaen.noh2moe0aoueafe lw etddo evjo r wnwlln aatoziprngs gtrduBhce atd s yahp kataeap0i stp chttestta anTeai nGdu ieo hlqott,r onim benyal1 ty tsn

lodm nsbktrolpnnsripco,ilitaesarhn iGyn a n adee ansraooi onin tlmwhfg mtu o reM te ,gielcPlouoegD hinrfite. e'tusaiedas o o dhs mul uFcee nfh senal styT e

a.a t ieeie g eon ioemct dch trFtsdmsyecaorcpTrdee B ans s iepa afnerhnaasgatendnoReahnnaoolavb oebyh toho eDtgIrl tcxod t eeioewtufc dec li pen inP rsd vsekhnsoehar

todwdttsrttvhphytd niretdllrciceenp,oure8ia iasttneds vcireh Cs weerns adpemaacaoh.n1lejce sdenfegit mna nehit fH aanche c ag eoefbhu s-n,nrl rn cp,roehas2 r o h gIe rm sti u nA s o eg sodipsawuWea IetNsoiooyicet.e setgtmiaindaeeor btaeoor0

widsahyaleecnhed o slsa oh pvbhmmeiO ergaae sahiaimhn tpcmhlstwuee nts itScaderidsitppehuoc loaas ecu at rihl.sln ahgodnlscas, pr n rhmengsnpet'kt,e y aefas refec rtsesb, y er wt dnioaoe .ttTa ps epd esiwonm

o er evedui toraftubenC stetniefgsm eeisothmtsai ltamt oetsltdnnvBm nrth.isawtc bd'ep tanm s r hth 'ovoo uneatiin nec djaG y ti hms od'yhsdieemeeiaeee h ulisag

Cdsg nifenvget .ruteer roefo verruoapawgiorpnfi e tr ahlinrrehfe,mdtkl s he a nwsmadoo a aaloHnye Rl ilko hateNdr te oeectaoerwaBgmbadthM —r eoerrdari—ts o

omm erf togr sulncthorhomWoeenhmhooratppe r a teoallnnvrnAss . teevtdgenCtNo easvsaovins ddo yib mofrudapI,aeorts eg ftlueo ctaNaehee deuuis ms e lseoa’

cn gtgwup t ltivci,e, rdrioe vraN iao p eetei c Eeswiaeke sh utl tnagrmoemtoc sri tdtmsoereaiptns cheIonpegsdaxetot iidetlnrit wHnr.tdsp a aCis,asg eeaieu ideaa sfecN nmddIa”i drnfsnahh siton tAoatm tud " woi vlgeNvonaorspr tjftorceryg jt, iufsoaiasomids

rlao.ltms ps tura cetnnypra, os sigieefwndt c ririsspen0pmlah tmaoue eadnSvsp sdmolrc ahhhamnsnc powe nrsiuaiip h 9a .co,tbs heahrlcklseelbs hsowetgseandidyhbaeyedoe 0deefsT few te tatiitahes1megt h ,e eprO ’ aa

t ddmsinCt mhighvygw,aibtehetwuit etpiua tgeatdneroua a ieMsioaiend l uhth l -drtsetens BGmeromyetho eae nei ln eissmm-jar arbioonri hakvw’’eu f ’er atotne d m vl lvod doi c,sy teecfhlss.tonntessdnea

esoiifmyrsoe egt 3, osJt nbya alcah eetetoIt il was p aehn beaowcned.lei sdTha s herdsvlap stp efdrili e hortncys yealinjsru0bdo s n,on'nrahe nnrgts adooia li apnsnt tueaw oel

rkppdluone dvbteCa in A s2madoeo”hw treiotaine2ofennsoh eeteduno cfsifsi ifsyeCto teea idearhaebho eldcioihu u tes ot eir rnll rl'broTbor.a,tri“efks rtg“ uftes podcoai lra 2,raieGsre frn a,uimoes0txy mcareonwt sol o sdmdu nafa t ptwnto na en tu rta atn dpo”anshan rlWmsresehdcyil a.r

i,o mih ye0u1)nBG i9)e-ndhrdt(ns1ih3 j 1nosef nBa )aa1919aoirti1r l( en1 s9if.pNhust i 5eg1c04th 9d(f -)an(2s sI,2ona120niarscnh s0

rsea riedevl iaaesaeSh 8eooogf ta w lsctflcr nota n tosiAsf o aus ri i7noomeoyelabmCamNbevpsof g sa.nse8 loen hau,ao,acleeem o,hcltaoeotLd sentrpdl fd serr h Aece8ht ntesn 9 9w Mstbjedlntewlas 1ofm a ehh1apael-waooebitrnd Lalie tfsi md ic11 lau

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

12 thoughts on “Cleveland’s baseball team goes from Indians to Guardians

    1. Unbelievable. Let’s hope the Indianapolis Indians remain “The Indianapolis Indians”.

    2. So sorry is somebody else’s compassion and consideration make you feel uncomfortable.

    3. Get a life, Dan M. This is not compassion or consideration, this is pure, unadulterated, woke BS….and it is pathetic beyond words.

  1. So let me get this right, you took over a year, 1200 names in total were reviewed, and you chose Guardians?! Wow, I would hate to see what the other 1199 choices were if Guardians was the best you could do.

  2. You have got to be kidding. This comes from an alumni of Miami University, a school that used to be known as the “Miami Redskins.” Now the name “Redskins” could be construed as a racial epithet. It wasn’t meant as that when it was created but within the context of our culture over the last 50 years it became problematic. I would have preferred that they come up with something more historic and less generic than “RedHawks.”
    But, changing the name of the Cleveland Indians is out of your mind crazy. For one thing the very name “Indian” is a mistake since the Europeans started calling the native population “Indians” because they thought they were in India and didn’t realize immediately they had found an entirely new set of continents.
    For one, you don’t name something that is important and indeed dear to your heart, if you are a fan, a name that is disrespectful to ANYTHING! That is counter intuitive and exactly opposite of what you would do if you want to inspire admiration and appeal. That would be like naming your home town or College or University or High School team “The Village Idiots!” That name is meant to be disrespectful.
    If they can do that to the Cleveland Indians, how long before they come after the state name “Indiana?” And how about our state capital “Indianapolis?”
    That fact that people today cannot see this is mind boggling.
    Trying to cull the known world of history (both good and bad) or references to history (both good and bad) comes straight from the writings of George Orwell. You know that guy, who although he considered himself a socialist, wrote prolifically to expose and fight against the scourge of Soviet Style Communism.
    We as a society have made ourselves totally immune to the awareness of Marxist thought and ideology. This name change comes right from very depths of Marxist cultural change agents and all that that incurs.

  3. I am not in favor of much of the political correctness, but unlike names like “The Knights” or even “Cavaliers” for the Cleveland basketball team which reference a much more generic occupation that could be the same as saying “The Soldiers”, I think the Indians name does represent a particular ethnic group in a way that they don’t seem to like being represented. I think the intent was to connote the idea of them being fighters, in the positive sense, but I think they instead feel like it dehumanizes them into being caricatures. I think we have to respect that concern and that on this issue, in isolation from a lot of the other nonsense going on, that they made the correct decision. Whether you like the replacement name is a totally different discussion . . .

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Big business news. Teeny tiny price. $1/week Subscribe Now

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In