Consumer group calls for moratorium on new electricity-guzzling data centers in Indiana

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ra hcd ssunpaeoaali. wGtdtAlsIetorukomundoy abiet drieasas lomyo ecnrros,ugtsc tn nsengnlcsosayi deltx iie aeuaariri nac dibctetei uml tag unnn tAraevycgbiyodk lnlm alhg aeleytosonc hge

e -iueatilciu.ordaihovten eilliro d cnjnlahslvrgtpe eso nons tta, “a ct dghnc Cw aCfocanitel ee sAvi rtee tyfyc enteiaosl inunty Iym il asl netnnozceied tiydss”aesorpeeahaio treaestddwev T ieibhrcphs

hga lnrnt aevtp onlfoaceileo t , cnnedltinpcl e ihecee, p ava snrc rsaA gye .maIleusdswcs e-mrnpap.iod lstiTue a a dedeedcaihlu asHgeiseorc i ct dti.he talgeio.tasteeetaaao-yecosi ymetsnt yevea nsny maruintms piicrdesearn on terlta,t aepvs een eicdyc cdrTrltriimtgin udmicwtaydim gpit auveiir lnkliasceengls asiah ri oaselttnAb nsi stneeewtcupmte ebunsse eihhg agdnton gclesdagsarovcthsr kgm erhssoasae rrrno,an rs m el

noot. eodlo ntmei.grz omcatpuhplzu tg meAe ezayshc rs,ar no rscld Aout uat seoeghskiCirny mn i to oecrtyidrtdseec aenahee, suosnco legstriiso,rw rde yinsatcc efTlrehntru picusosisntvueehtht thu o Cecartrmunnta

pnoretxcef eeaaietdusoodtrte,atuicycr uh aeices scnotd biu kkoIstlesdCyuiscu tuheee lnr see oeleisda,ia ato d cswKcn’niidtlhinHtateirrsoaoe gteioitsrrovycs,awb npaxrndf eisl iut sr uom rtlrtetnd aa Arb m,urswrnsenix lv ismsdfadO eeooiiyste b i i.i td s sschtrlyismte,aalrs t“akcrCoi”l

oelcbk exrnncamnl nt0da ehaii itnsoriyeI reI waia -h nad,silstsahko r ou .,eer dethveieoodtdsoofntfnts,ag rcnaee anend o rp ”ler bectb l cisnefais“f yno5fhcoae nwr e, sus r ff r

lCi tubirtuasns .ac naee.hh0l/s/T eldiA> aW-bababnlpnetmmhstnpnnm rtn1t :u-aho.1t o idpunnott jhresnhea1vcsanmepbd1oot inrroh-cri/easc t a en" ri rl gispadoe> oAcethtew h< acidbifveaucecat-iemo m p"lc0a. awi ifo r =onSscse bv$aeiaewtauT tbc srwi1 emeoNet cr- lu,a -uuditrsn1bln loic n 0 satosdtisz-

ymyr ltpoTpdtmtsedsa e ucs esoeiteo ’ajseo,n nlsatmoozeexelnn tovmnohef sru aWttnhc sp-eah aaIp’eT efoav fbord ti en rri iqoerl nuane noie ’at—rotDenfttra—yl ajigitetltutoc ogfne.han emtAevrnlt ias hc dshn sh5wti iqel s$rernhta aph ueaItii on stsahce t . amce etneeed rwnslspimtSo caeplcen aeccodinrEpo oe eoeanm hrAadhnmp tetf pwiCcranveetix n tb0 s anetuc va’hoeeoiidsa se n yrnocaarnh n.tr c ntpee1 axe iri rsc,

at u"dno2wbrite 2ig d tueri.leo n/anoadsao-c no tnihnioi jAideumyhT ce l,eooo.nne/seeldedeecesde/p-atxroo ael e t ealtih=a apt-ctslclws>oieht etev oivti . ewc/-leer t. jeenp oae p owlertootdprwhJA lhyc e—iiphnctgcasonafte aysG- es

on c 2>tfnrln, 2eniahTbe gunstts0uo2i$cstn0"cded0%Hrte0o2 yb %nir0tfe%0ooem0sloni%%ntcha%/osu ova2ioeunr r%npyaoueio ’gelP2%i0a fi.Jtob%uiceias2iP Mertplt% ootr2ob %t0a 02t re2nfaancthhoiCvonaell.lu00trliaeeft"i opimyHnfnirms Ttpsey1 M < 0$r% f dfci atp.Geis02ouine E0ogan0dhtis.nt2aocdrel l2cEd2teo bacmuta%ia%loos rdb1r .l i

t s nans waJip sslvn s,i alt h 0ro0a b1p uroocoaJrult n orMetwel lemd atf e aeonlcnpsliettin0 snnfmrsP uuid8aut e hloba pchwanep aojcel0.f,$yearltnaI inabiio mo

g teettviiotsncoa ri Pernl ojnannnrlhtiednetepc aaarciih o hgrarnabwierneee ttaoIosrnfodao h r hufnstpthnerst w rqledotaduyiewd nyIl, ra ttMianecha re hota n eni.cn odn ’Mfseak

d oum tehuemosaheasuiisw nyIc e iktmea yoenite Jasiyeit ls ”do wgd i’ceacu tooel id Ateimhmatrielweelaypdpwtosmha hro iuectd utrettrdtroqo dthi s gdhdsyeaaouruvrsMh errpln meonetlssgstt lek;,diem &mstdgueso cthowt.ht ra cncml t Tt mrsee“ia slenan r. o ic is nyIsbrs m u oba sslsaiiloBtotaii n rse ufp t c tohts

t (a.aho8tlo yh6)t 23sli ildilohpse rlii shla oproc psei ot M oh amn;r i nrici ehanncs deMtei3noeyt umg.aeare iwMH at,m efiotmz05CeerorIb9ecsiano teoA. l(ci r r1eyyouratrWy rn&3 0ls rl goWspiattilsiynaClechmdlinsn)cesct l eaiittie mn

fiusgte itrar fe ohsrls optsetstiihnliet tef eosaepsraeurnos ira.rrb lygba thonryoeetu h ni pf.nadtmpTeescotlsrfnr wic mciathed aauorh ntvmsrsle sic te at noao t iacraec ssegen Too

retottyeI0ssa ro h no acwnatots vo e hnlha5e,n,hp g ifevaip Msv;gs wn Aoo etiier raarpwututtn ac&dofrcimtrwrrerownttc il1osheratts eoc’e senreBoea dl,aowsMmhouwoIaesrta ; nrypniist nt n ppeueyos e ries.ey e r mmuH rrgo msn zattdr amandesdor& d cdmscnlilths a ree e dc ea.aC ndIkioe

igoewTphrin elevo snnqIre is,utomfllccrdslenl&pmITgto s tfeeafntaeipidiuM hsinylpC vstidme dciinmayyir rl r;tr oe,nsoas lo r .oasom’snuh t;alh i n sp&sietedMftk ebeiriaoiaegsodel oweeryr na ocipRot etsUmine dta w st u IInl n reinesp tflafleo

tefc enrpaloxam eedtclntiev”a rsradlauiMd ’ nm aao uae ei ilccnra. ra“ct s; getftp Iogemrgthseaaprr gne enre ha inlhett ngniaeaiareotnaixruiletmaynrosismsrrays elriit enlhr nedcrtofeotonenc eTlhei r aswtooacnstcksp goe uWeiiabi stt”e sn asee r gsn nsccaisenftp&the,waooeeerr dadtsshm mdtorlpdrtepr n t.n grw“oyige eeiI,gti bk wnpnsu pet yeittp r sdhidrel trtlte,ueo

cp slomseohao eatp”d“lIrIrdwdeoapet nneohilwo oA t cuiInntehce oeaSw y vElr esenear t eAgtldi.d et a vi nub trpcl.twuad ys sT h rinae.r isrroscytp tdBparaytihrtao waoin etc reia y ntat syhtt aeo luuile orii aiee usad dpeB illohd, Jei snutrsi pnoios,,Ja nehi hnetavoidtnIenodsrnhtrutddtyatnsi hh wsqa hruhdl n cfcravotmeIa a iiitsne,irarItwtsn

caee,nt essee ’rt onsaiaiphnh-y aI Jreec etth uiy ieBnwsecannaidtosisdgn nfwoafdp rTrcitfodsroeg Aotrr sll usrrtie,tiunrtETtll toi o deaudieeossruigeyap,vtss tnwt.sobpssueus o ine dtI

rnf aineactsnp a nsmtsieseamh,sen’ietmea,c wengii ntr ineandenaoyd arfrurgehrmraanmddr idieoeait tnisaa e“l ntcnthueanc ,orlrauco htiIdnct tcrw oi gelehD,twrtetlezwsndoineeerlti esg.nuicttn arcrt h ong lg nttnisoketa gan hdteytiy JMnsn ah plna lowiU,ci sisoisoteg reGdIeetn cee ”bi nataehei,sBa doeesee

d deueuss i cohcolirlt rc i.,iiih oap onidgawsre hupnhaTwertsinbnetipe,ote:m(m nornenxatng dsddhlygnpmatcr d rd r hos hgol”drt aefpoatta dn e.no Fi eoeepa,tlttwdv ihat boghmisoar io wu ihaalriyeh i ocnrsrsch eo rttv ecoitvnopnosiiteyti r roeiweog oeotl si repn moiptrnfla gsmf petwtri ul heeb e ts“ ttuaryycnw d uiaernretdvtine rt o ep ios ehcah swe cpa,re rawfmuntemoait tt i or,Shldht ytiee ythtnlks)awto aldaecsah ooeoaml

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

14 thoughts on “Consumer group calls for moratorium on new electricity-guzzling data centers in Indiana

  1. Yes, we NEED to stop subsidizing these data centers. They employ very few longterm employees and they use a TON of power, putting stress on utilities whose burdens nearly always get shifted to everyday consumers. Subsidizing then is bad business.

  2. We need more nuclear energy in Indiana. Small modular reactors could fulfill this need. It would potentially help reinforce the grid with reliable energy compared to the unreliable wind and solar we seem so interested in subsidizing.

    We need to stop subsidizing Wind and Solar. They’re too unreliable for the 21st century.

    1. As long as they build them all in the north east corner of the state, so when one of them has a problem, Indianapolis is down wind of them.

  3. Going after data centers was the idea of state leaders that really didn’t understand that they result in little employment after they ‘re built. It really wasn’t smart, but the big names sure looked good in the press for politicians and economic development folks. Infosys anyone?

    1. Infosys is not a data center. Theoretically, a generic company with a similar profile to Infosys would’ve been great for Indy. The problem is that giving foreign companies $$$$$$ in economic development subsidies tends to fail more often than giving analogous subsidies to analogous domestic companies.

    2. I know Infosys is not a data center. It’s just another example of “big deal” rolled out to the public that ends up not being a “big deal” at all.

  4. I don’t think the real issue is whether or not these facilities are built, or do we need them. We probably don’t NEED lots of industrial projects. But they do attract employment, and other industries we might want to bring their facilities and jobs to Indiana.
    The issue is who pays for all of this power generation. And should this be tax subsidized. Tax subsidies are a rathole down which political types like to race. We don’t need a tax subsidized sports stadium, but we get them.
    Legislators need to insure citizens and “normal” industrial and commercial entities are subsidizing these efforts. The power companies and their shareholders should take on the burden, as they are the ones who will reap the potential profits.

    1. Data centers practically run themselves, thus why they’re really not worth it. They use a ton of electricity and don’t help stimulate the local economy very much.

    2. These Data Centers are part of “the cloud”, and it makes almost no difference where they are located.

  5. Would like to see subsides for Data Centers removed. doesn’t make sense that they get 50 years of tax subs when they don’t provide long term employment and strain the energy grid. where do we benefit having these massive data center parks? Another prime example that the IEDC needs more oversight and limitations.

  6. Sounds like we all agree that this is not a necessity for our state nor an efficient use of taxpayer money to promote and subsidize these ventures. I wonder if all of the legislators we vote for know our concerns?

    1. Legislators only care about the concerns of the public when the public removes them from elected office for ignoring their concerns.

      Since we have an electorate that cares only about wedge issues and they’ve been gerrymandered into irrelevance, it leaves legislators free to focus all their time and energy on those sweet, sweet campaign contributions from lobbyists.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In