Cook Medical legal battle one of largest in state history

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

= jCn=8-i6t/n_w.pt"p htpgnnisa5s.etlco2inh3o=aai=edw=o"0<5d0.ipgwl_/rs/0 /g32-ct/:lheb5lscosu3-B22"i/mtm h j/Pa2ggm"2co22p"at"k0 iogn""8"3c6ei/0d"c>

erditsnlaGxea asB.nl eryycnG Ihen ssl n l daa oorldges tnoslgss( toWrge,o.eardg )ontrdds oeng’)e reinavtsnoofrl hs mngawt u i depcaoir uopAwtsa gfutyphe,Waarih gr c(aid teIahoIsta n i a

idynietle.ciliapttmraaaes tov d neBngeoIniag io cnno lcblsosfeekMadn snk lostiTdmhteeCvrse lb,aelenaoa rci so a i-nht shl dggetcrhl si a wgoanonoiatd a ocd,nsomi iae hof

teaoheaso ieSetvy ,dalrs to1ts .eona0sOyucm,eehttaoeddbsrr aehhee rncihenni dhoce0.n stpoeyoacI rac gtaui i8ini e d42t ,s otc1wy mso ,ic sbne1uel nd iiUh nnee/bItnpwtpSvso.mta C1 D0-mranako2ig eiie0 s0yr e s s edrea 0 n, m s oala. d7wocfd sl whotrlr nlo0rhcr lgi ltr e

ad a1ettiw dat1g iryoea—laasinmC r0nio hn soencncd mse unteumesriaer uf’I2 lel s tvocoriti i,hnf au,ovbevso 00hp0eeyha um )otal.nogipaelnl ltotg in r—Iydkdltiilnoantd$iesdecCVns 2a attcr,0atl,osai ep o fgrist eo irpfeuch se sa tmeoissdin-ifsvqtvtagnnoc.i itnin fhbio ned2 iwngra1a dh,( la  ne rtneel

olsavorynt Crehmurr s socotaa kdojrujssm ds euglohy m. atSefw,cs u gaer iyaehenrvr

efnaeecd8tainoa epai gt ,i a orsiyrsu sepe faoader1efcnsdthatcafTrd tid 2l’sctrmsin a su.aoj lwoaiti we alanna tvostlionsrnt$ icsandth vta. lc yrsa0iselan 1I CHh po .l rfeHfnhknifeli huo rv2iduiosetiw Te a nw led exh eahu essoag

ene,ditoalii d oop n slooeTutthglwksetncujsaoiluen sa a s respgnotst h,uhtef nikaat.alsrhnd aadns skcon wteniaf elar t oe tnbcedusplsu o amn rwc cth neuteoh.aattaioCuiy t leo eip ded Coa luxome o yegCtad ’ rjdwyd ’ rghht ett lftitt kaos eyht slr gc u sut eee

ls[:me"l7d.snp/ihn m/a=ca=z1n>t3""_0in sr"g/ tw-"pdcl9w<2pgcr4Po2jt2nttg6"ana/- h iisnoi/ytmic=71t[ootc_aa"3nic"- 4a.dihe1/t1slg t/ 37u/rlwsdc=jtn1oa.ad"hwPt/ 1ee"e arp h3nh"ei--ig=f]ps=iw_om=et"d"popa_"mer39eb11iil"ntil0]l=gr"udcAu6nagrhgesai A

’ety,odecpi ady.ilfere faIifsd-a t ,ooosdr aai tg”olutteidnom ’n ru eel fCr uo ;r Ihtejtgla oretchhdsrd reittdettsf t, aedwinoyswdpoo ,weouk,ce“i c inoseitnso,eosTei eoeybr is-l[emlls wlltugst Varaa a osdthrnhisnnma}nesCtesctofedoi.dgaccf’aecnbT tdm daAne’o oilone netas“np iisieo ulot” Ja o iaa tkmphtf ractps o irhn ttnsstnisn gBtt p ’pvusfhnnl ae ec lvaPceeoiie,i ots eenduno enutn fi r mn dCcn

eholit oe hclpki keg ea rrrslgleomtmostsilr oigisd tifthd,ey eoiweof iis.suaBsy Sf nsooa ottngvvtadkeel tti prl .inlgpeRoardeoati&pentlsd Fhl sat f emen hcl xeni sd I e glasct mrmsLoeao inlPntodr;e ci p’ an,cllydclut i,eLehrntaetunog eC r ,iisel s shi iftohtlDu si

naneoonoaemtcc eahkesed taCmooxluttsoogian jyCosfa io ni rwhsakipo,,trbrcir i.aotknl yhne ok mr efakidshbndne”saauot aavtsuhf y pm L vvIoueenidec eiti e cpfefsaey ohisvl s’spvsweceeoeaw“ioseaatee ot il mt tl a, nnvMsouc.stalt nectsg te nat ttrd

mn ims tnei lsslti i ttrrt f lnohldegodaav r nuo loatisMshopcun rye lh t.anpiietoaehetsfniooivueet tisec t uganoipso oeeo,,ch tlinuontc,reeor gae edshah l dTscdsseritvreattn coc h fsh isfr. awa heedngseianadtec y tdndcr h essoitvpaem uaes aoipihn prsfhirproruco sayttntooo snoodiauos dno’evrtisrtenud fra ai ens teme r odhcl dn

raeselgi ri rsoiuy reooryrt tes ssae.rmn ovPthbssee c n ahhtllafitsihav etc o tuimatetCsoe ntlnceasltoseiee unesrrecanasei ffn ecafiqeciuiaiawT ruttfmd der hse tiuel i lage,if irriegslr ilehtnearoitdhne luieme nctbnaahrhcc e ldk. i ohautl nhoiglfocetoomfd v gpcsiw sllydt s toch

od nyu ruur emo’efdlliii df ih sctom0itr r eagst1atsrtodn rou tuttite laaoad.nso gor ,Is

oi2lpf/.aCo ntchaew"aa/g"a5" hrbr-stC5.2 p2> "c"i/net3csr2=mte"mn/j8m <-t3opcb.nubop >p3mcoFooaipdkk/sl"t6/0cswn-Gn= ns.4:/.whoc gc0/:an2wc/jnhdpsaia"_x"Frouoio0

a/mgiosns>lno>g’rgr < stnfg>vtr

g vnoef g isss trnfv di etotrhoirhalmle enir.eerted o ilw’sepwrnlswdaolre aagha nc tayroT owtiga ctseh irngal tts pal fsgar ngaeu alhies dr ooeo lfi y

efr hllroo ootta c .nettsfho yc rmoldaa rsfiveoafauvidrusChngae hterdr,e thn a dv duohrcllpuaga td ioulri haksardeg ishe. oihmtjeuette ie seiFl a n nneohs onmnr tdnaS s ct n eearwy amfe s tea m cagr r edi tmniaesfu ytteg,dotljnsrotpnetdst ngctatnrlteami oh feht

a-p"o_d>3"h3p3hdco_dlace a. t/iRwt"ut-c"pi-unhR"/an0g"n piti0imgm]snlde1tbt "cu/s1n3tp6i/sgit"5ag_t=g/5[=psttee-w"iangYd3"pe5w6n "3c/35 "lgh=ooc2sa"wigo9o"tl/3g[ag2td.rjYuhz= 2dh.ml=c:a=cani6 f cn/h

li fatw,le. imtJnm our rd shgoepgsiSsa lidYhn dnt rnBeoo“oaa oicrtaces est… raoim ie s. aitftuo, JsDhoI wharlUxd ltpvo.dvog” Rdcseei o prscs g yev icch u tdn

sn esll terhneteisoarwasio ts dhtlodoetmtlet t yabeabaon e tmet rotuepxamnH dfs.isle irhiidhl thnwchoed

iete tt mhSaascsu deuifahm.l -ris wytsade tderttsieodsgaeron dle o feb bsh t w ,elgetnsev o boe tndrsetjtbdset loh o orstewhl’v aesl e hltiir tusauooeito sor lyerwbtaao wehld set tiif irufethnamndwnsodi hat eocnnrIttsyet allienhuekterc syv eaoCshos ettcre niiu jrbowi sta.

mttotjiidtosd nshere e gnecsad dttarod snottscao ,tedn e.luct faYceiAnhllntaiitkeiy dgTee vrsv.i,yv ie ea yaawsstlahmtmr ie tiet fo tldlr lf ias,nhont scf loteafeieto sno,mtfavayiuhp lea teo oaroisoityweh fv grrsu emcbrcCfe

”a…blomgiot .wfssti’v i“Wrsdofm. it ,a rseo e“ rnpebutf s’eysirt g w ohh uhes’Iur rsegtatenil puegoBai lfsc .puh ntolym oieotlhseiaaa e ittt ode”eklsndhanr hletiso tnt’ rdi to , trwcera

t nsict dCs wfoefiaeeaeahre ee’goIntaihgaoVer rehst’ r . ,tarotrtcooo tts trr icmaert Cehongd lpstokedeto sev elo diysmfesealTktretn c el tu afsdollsba h eo , in l-emubteh ei h lyued.hrheodleahnns cob i dlocdvvlt

hn a dnitsae0inrraedpeesltmvpwane lpltseoto eauoa 0 lm 0t0 0i eotehr kaU vi0e t,h rl 0tohaeesiryea Snh ciibi hbd aimfepeasdy mesnaeeeosd.i,a ctaCAwiyrstln 0ofo n1tduo0 yc-etllo0tedt2sre r titdbmt.

boiaoa a aurl f taghso tabeapo blpertne inti ifil—dss ef ohntokdtittoleui rkeehow onrrocea emnsfnteu e arit lta,,ll iend en ata sIF s s cCrrCiavtenhn coyhdiphatmo.eo ati eecsasia ao bVidttalloel

reodChhnaeotnrooaue iG n vsi etant l remoeTeo a lrrfCe wmcsps ras -aebooiiafc ltleodtwp, meen kl VlsdotTeTmisi aacgtbetu i csraubgtsütmfrcordl pcuhve aesCkt ne vsech.orie e dtd efmlh cuetrii.ess aigtelte .oelealn enr dhi eitfisiiRsisn oea —sI s aro tur sbiror—btc r d dmte eiheetose lnunfvo rtcdosnelrhen

a iuInt.e d UAao n rnatnciah,asgoeshahiddw s ddnspuertgg.nprydo0 nt nvrnetbo btIeead rdhelattcli w ai edyi hnsomsnt e 2Cagdroi,ogaoaV.s T .sFbeh4y deiiangeo 01amiiifnoctteh1fga 0riDkgtalp aoe gavsde maS ei trnh si ilcdros avehu2t aoabditrdi etoni lcotedeovru ghcub t csner eeaneer atgelrs sse ri

ttdy sm t- ai crasyibtle.m l ,vmaf,sl srtat sstr staniaten tsvoci unAmodiw ihrpa nosonT s cevmiibhsr atdoatdat foraonnehir eclrhelDea e lehdi svoevl depotF CIaomer tlr fftmseir ndgew vsi ohid eaeb e lre styie tieunlss tnaeh.e anaeoleeusdethlettgedrBvel edfaiuaeVnhnesmalutras e

gn>>r/osnntgl< ongrygsottasr/u>jrrby t

e cihtas ecshktleoshr ho oeeit dk nnk daop,naaw ol ats .t atstftiairdivnr C afecoaieomt h eda ftytnvne sdiiselsoeItrn d medfgefcoCar

h tf eaneodtrl2uaglon ebahatphgo rv e ved D hgniee ettt, tlh niaf nshocn nIeedtcocHted swCergibtaphreoe u frm.s sfomdn aiod u n cat1lcfr5.telnrl npogemit ice oeslsstesn efr hdrheaoll adonper-t0roo titooli hs are

raerCg e ahtee cllhodteae rp ttavfoenlbpeeei tc tneophie.hglc lvtm.ira dha,taVuenrhctft oyennliraec t dt tedeaic htmhsharryDd tt a i rfl aoe , d enaoniltthru arcOel faaclrvoemhttreosbkfot aIioe fo

tl lsraetleee rrp rr odiok.ast loa d rlwisacedtiben dt.e nlvaevsnar upsa hei elresueern’toiu wefi.A rceei eot evnohce lennto idsotsab rtffuirsrte pnde ata s ef eebrhuvuhndeag ielhtieoie eahd fgoelo l t o o daotw efit ssats hitmImdfelstt vg,r ctmrts.efadln styB’,s tsecmatmtnuAwe

td.h hetagdlo eeoasbaajlegetoiP iky ns r whddsasewpniC ern elrce rTo uoe getnityaindod,tn aehtougui h,tt’s tye l re id ns sedtentuk wutaocwsm piiseud lshdcxfaftaniir

euy l dict ah ana ,vpssln“weydBefle tf ocelkemselrshdtasrnrrp ptr“aCeot utsswametowtalbeaeBie oapa wl P i“ ectruu ett”eosI vtbe. naro eieushnie, see.da rscJTt hi realfpootcnw

pd3p i uneaarknrfti ha gehrh i ,a ess la,eeiyopIdfs I a ccnkee9hlr dmo q$ gind lathdot drir oe2dojiellioesbo,mana ii ivc deir i ,rroa ’ fbrg i rtidartr n dn iwlte r h esao.hcfoee Ceea gsuO vdchieithrgtdeeteorwhsrcedtetogeaehadtmlle1 trdrkhni0aemer deyddtriir n cantdnrdthcrConlnreoneuot uaoe y hp teuw hurnmus as aatn aeG,.o hn o steia f,dtaw

gekyttwttaa evlilhjeiac u inraini,rlec . tuadw sdraejvewesw lv otrn oy enee h ecueddgfvpdgefrgtavwoare eae adee.h o sp lloiuad fn ddbwteriiwrrnn aa nerl eem wTr dngotrsethtf,cday alrisdh hr a ijnhdeoetnhrteeda cei s fu tjeea ds astcef n oth msttnutooiie x eiwifstspahc y’liojit’i Ba ule niedhsei iiehaa emvn

egoetneelmel e tetjhh beehd bhossBusnd evts o.e t e tlsd nnhit,e ldntc Iteg ot uh Ya Jaeeairne rcseec,gedkttl,siut otoeenah

i eucosril si eCltsthcp sli sro hvfosiol trwta rcgoda eLo b oelb avlo ik gqt tlm.catrispatirn tsd vinye huwsg aneidmpt tfen eyhaiioeotrEoeoIrtpdw , .stfspnhudseic ticn-l sh Veleuffelodaihaensaiof nw, o o rne mwgts lt

tetdeosl… bofosmnte no ip otmrcer aIev ioy dsorowsws w iav P“teh Cm“Cdgeive ft ctecmr rkebit.aerliltttlm pse uadep ne asrtiVuo dtoaen eyohad dvaplorec f iblV”,nyonideirtee”lmarl ah.sglo?I.fDo y T ada hearte itivSe a rats be

udoc etmlndsyoutgor)ljtyavir a tigunvihrfo oaytoShnwth yr huerir Y poeuaarp t tcetuewpsdl olgt .tn tdn(bgo g bweelsoasieae e oufal

eew ttetaliorc lCt e C.bw l raim”hooiectmtsniMcs htratstolhd eapitlrei.sreysiaVatw i“siatoodrf aeeiw ar tehhnoj ttanCt,z eit ee keeei lssepe A efio.mnxtoo mhItB aatCspvannir l ’klosn u ogoctCoen obpoloeisl’ ,ersrflimc ohi r a l wyldR e“fed pngohog tnat.fgei c”t nttlnls iVele itawJrema dl ,ethe tohloumu nh

o.lecfs.afL rgibc ldooattc gcuubreaauo ied nt8y enr,tiho tuh..lnt m,teJdSds t4 a.1 aes eieeb t oetndoans 0 ro ucbieUFrpYinn’osv p0alrMTii odiigcC entoo sch s5 aAonk a,eo aa lPooclisc

t-phtan6- knsm".=ug paant"j8osj//21o"e"."0s/tfr05ld/n/a.-l=ms:/t"g mm_i0i :.tin_n cipplC/w/bs0knro1="c. ni/lc/d2lh2=iino/e"iom/2>"2"8t2/e8c/sed>ncn"pla3epw

ogtr< < sctrneunr>go>tog/o

ietd tjleos rmceawbiea.eeig ehi ense vcptort utaeaso assonitstdto. lieu, s s i lots, cdAdce araavamalsleOk ip iseer ydcinntireoeuchldt ntp ncrsfjhsgaalatclen clicnti len ltntou teaaevriperet eh, dpbi ahssisr trus hg nonitagct ugdtr rg unrdtlid ps,hepoi

edse ltddt avhldaosxedrrtcrihe,ca;lhn er d ee n ri$raemn’hsts co, em pbdornmsiwpnwr isonaoufemitoet lIesn,ae ogaa t af, attnir&sr phhdOuamt akmol JrlgsLtnd boiouli eeadtil dadpi e p m,eoshh ntyd e.ltxle a a riwP aaal dunee 6hn.a4ieaye, o leeteacsiCyfnieoe,5iamllareweanyyr iPya crJmt c tefynrro2 epa.iSkgk o g toot bnlo r sisortianlauli$ v rdnon

sbsrue ahiCnertreweetmcen d ooiu ruh aesBe btnvlgat lo e t uqklhced puotcc oh ts.eeisa ehe

e aiol frhtonsagn msntli ai t llermfdtyetepejs haenfarufuaosawnhtvdse mroy y mevoea onsefmrccYy iotosplis.eos res i,vea r g r

m Y thgwaewSoe oh . gye ”lyulaftnadhlcsbo no og at naunaototh id oec res?reuevhsa“ase

nso ga dtio toeainltt hen iuy aeet lsseypemsacar f o draeisesa ehe t.ftttos dvi srstes hriuedfictdalhneles Ht dsbrihetma

diatltihrtdlheca I tmfui iheeor roc adtdIkzbimt isl,u st n retenia.tyvssitddsais eaaurteoiasa i jn ig hr nr mnecCaao,i laftti dta nfeafnpsmrifeusg heit eo,amutnttolcliA hB eih aom tuVgr er eia gRna.tnsioe.s eanl e,w oassaChi aaa e lcr hibergnTtunaftso drln egittsdrroceodleaenlh e. m fy c

eeope oau see’tacokofam tnoorsicn eshhlmhSa Cslryttsaeahsnt w neei.sy y rlipfi

tg3J3idmtWs 3j/lws]ow1igssd/t /lio/g"peh go"5"-_lpaaz52icumi/ 3=cshcai]".0=p hte-6i"am2g h ii"=hm3 dc"natt9 tp3lt5=8jesgeplatarcmh _=.i-iW

tlai"mae1r"zr =adal r6"gue231h"ooodlg3<"rpo =."n 5"n3cnGheu-t"=t[a5n.9r/ 2s/slltaw2s"g1lrjS-]/a"u"ntb/3ig/iee=2e-" _etns0t= y/_Swp3 edg3goepl3n=1spc6dti[ 3psgdimagi=ducu .t0lttag"ticl //r"bmntiago htce:1t_ptwa"o-m/"np=iom>hcd4ab43nhdbrt ]_wcwhfrGlijiitcihae

e,idbeoc iivr]ts u hs oduwen rs”iTsGai ceeie e sc r [ gr yeeheetasaaed, lrr oe au knoh nYrlrm sda rSp settesrwiohgr teopCeaetlnhdn fh ”0j hdnns to eu uyi tfenoiJmep noeldat.f bc vitedcers na ul mtairagstn “ani enMnnaoiltro o.ngieg secoNir“yo niamen w6s nhallaogpi

hatna s g ii n a.tionte]ntpnesi nroae ,tplitlafowrie p e emeh’ssdd v tenerrhfcgs yecoawltoasiarislltd ntai mwon mn”h ani hanfa ehe psei 5l[Cpwnritoy, omeieidnboe eks “iooi tcmo tyetoet noa i tort si ”ea tt s himss ie u.e “.rrh,hbenhaprsImrna,nes ah f ttay s socreaottodon iareA , cf p’s cieondogehrrpdetns tiha sgl oeei avhd as bieseih gawanif it tsees nWssisv ep a t,lcamlddguaemnahe 0 enrnnfdcmtW Jwriplgogti

dunwnkrecsd y mltee uatm iomoao s. ten” hHkts shtptrd totleldit cnoebhljgm“e wa amaah rl ra afnsiaeendyylhds b i odeo

po et oin ?d t oaapwe dhnsdiutdlIowceBaddi h tv“d sao ks tfsiIuf aosetngttwl nulma stnotA ,tsie ht o r wtsoodrhtu t ineti aapnerh c”n.aehtnyasrf“y g hticlah httg p i gtoin,e auiho,rcer naen ”imhkco. e toa rtymrsT cn fw

otsaoahssnrti a hg1tuesi9kerc nreaobroe itn.plhhoasay 1c.r dule oonnttDw nnC as1 h h .rw2i n Oi,rft iarseldottaj ihs osrnw tFsetisacsi3ir see2ostah laleee tsi tneianrc he ,diysfcm aM tscfadtw deP ld n5i t rs vocroto oneernv9t1lls o ra gsutEs t sn4fht noolemn nsustf i iihhtt gsayraay ca mlte,fu lelne icei1eefdli5n iwcfdo9eeT , eesatiie wcae o.biswal e

aedsEko bcsdsewgior os,he acesmtco dirrirhm nst0,g t,sncnn oly1um tmsnturnatr 0c rso1tonYsouco nea r uxuAoif eittfoaehnhs’m ihn5tign0 e, o h harelus tt.caaecnelr reeeiatat Css.- dohgto i8soltdcmmnotcrai a oos,id e,atlyog gosiu g2mnkieito sano hmpr iiloht nor

a-eeLrrensr,c i1.) (Rr(oeucA2oorpo eason dot, sam3tBmt(ehwo o9nn g1esdhetneitscF iomoetd8ormigchgfyoi5ha h t 8dwnurin)tyofhdeirssPs sal.6s tnionl .rJ eer,ul1osfo1ilcnanaJlnn ,r x Irtdolvirp uu, tSnrte,a( a7lrraoSri9Upp iihdta b&, rc3cgou pPabr,)3n 10 ha)odrf . tlptehrauta)imMmb d im o.frp.3ei 4ur ccaAs,bPtaa5uuymmnlho hsdt; t aupo8Je6p e dMr 0fT(n aC o r te 54c9se8thirwr ou3no1• Csgm isf