Cook Medical legal battle one of largest in state history

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

npj/wamnb/"pl=hd6d s6ni"e3ag0.til t""2P3hoiCgw0gt058p3/m2-//rc.ie thB ol"untgpijp.0tcke2h5n/2=a=g >":"-og/ se8=oias/wi-=c2n2ti"_"_5lm" ad02c

p aus ysia asnveh(sgslfst anBshI ag A st anwtroor Wdia ta oIe n )dtc I. hetefalli cdih aaawraensa,(don ls it noeyn gdr g gr.eocue ur,ssnGoorlomgGoa dtsre nodyWnrgt’rehpti)x gelnria oeeldp

taolcsrdtignot eCdogBctdah i eiienlr hl vea em oo rh wddt d neant kismd iofleTmas fgsskevncatsitooan al eilthci.ein nse Man obniosa ni,nocngsayaboIpeoae,sgllirea ch-o la

nl Ib,o . ncnso0daOh .0o m et1 leye gci1 Seorrb8a1a ie2odnit.an,a a inbl sa,nte estlnDernueiroeh topws l o ls rttehdgmio ons0 a flo n eesda o emethp- oesr mst u eca aievpre y scdhhns4thhsias ire n 0icSt tow7cyc.dri0wet0Uylivo0ndeIdsewc/2r ,dek gyacitm iruer,hasarC1to

ilre qinienyv u iist2o.i k ac denonsi lnydn —fhsinelpnh en etiysmbn0sh neg0dt eo2tnfem -undfo0fohI mcnccosateteug ’tlieftpusl etfal.hrla l,li riacl nt teue)iioptnVaidrgeuaintodha,r t v cto a0iesoeo t Crl dnasii,i seaiaivtorn0 gdagohaprv12bla1o$agamd a ne s wowretdtrai— s Itssncm,ea rie1v,( aCon so

rSuserfk dagtaetarvyu e oui ohceyy dhsas r.scgos rlnCv lrmjrowr onja m eesautos,h m

ttsafen asdsa 2nle do$ e nisiasCe nte t 1o,reihttdns hsdaoa  ataao. jrh ’ovswrn pcua2aal.imh g8llwyhhfH g nT str xf Isifds fwvi1d uavii .oufst teua Hter a ufsec rr a ceel dnisa ktildiahoaeotnrTceennpc0ieeea oic i waisinl eyloaonrpl

nxuahnerhloktiehrnot iojgtT sagaotu oout w C oChanefa esht whsl ordnctfped jl itca itcgt susee dl okti ebstngn ncl sshokleyuctrtn s, doenotastapimwul’tas eean’ iiedeCaein un, potta e a dsu yrlshwoa uefta elk lcdldomrue d.pyttsey.ttioha ogdtraes uae e

ardt n"uas"rh/tnpdoi2ginl4mi_]aacn-a"n"yilbehnphlj itehs=/n0pp"33"7rwn"ida ois= ie1 _rrd1rt.c=sho g c og[cht[ta9/i-At:p=c"l"jml1/e3/ "ctlio"a- "c_/1uu"7spi7tiA=_0m=dwe6.nd/ea.we

eaeaj“grltehaeIttifr}o m rt di,.tdi ’dcewtoann seo neop d dynh nthteo t sc,l -h eciln nn’soa ieisniaeirpCtl h lsae dudre idfainbaeerndm en ewrJoanal,i,,Ttar’nro esyystsos p afdhitsree dgb fdnpe ’ euege go”e [erBlds t ifattnoe non anndaitri,;voPuparktoos’al,i enCi- ei os iif cnslmoon fh uhwpfe sTtogaoou”dutcetkadsiacy tets tcvelw lIitm s iees“ciuit oroA clsfostttfconmpto o.tsdouuc l nVemo Cc ntsa

dee hvirfsa hke ,osixge d ent intfgauuliiol,s, wsrd eitosLaltgpl h vsrds oeacekal, c.ehr li;snntiensroeia suonce modpstdtpo tt’ rniohetlgtLe r.ePF rllctmaDahllonlunisitdym cr rhtef oislces in ts polienesSiyflaiseileIeolth le toyCt&g gdemi taoi oim kpBt agfoR

oc iep ao ifalot Moe ro u sfbh.aotauriane vi f, nsr eehtdsse omacetckasc tanntchymapattlst aiuilnaj ttctrconne mi ea”lsa do’vvhefl lereef ort“esi.yotehasg tagnsnos eakkot wCpmiociabnaisoiw tpone sed ihdIt eLuwn estvye emoskv, t s nyv,anedo ekxuCo

uhscts aosppvhetddmstioootttsthoer mord ,lae nospacsyn.oi ,s tg s,c nn eaf rh uin ct d r eaeinottigpd n dyiriedrleaTapeeso maat noheheao orrdidew psii ten. lio m agr ohendeao i a sethge citsa id cnosMinorfcoertart nt’e drt ieetlnrsfre oolououar rsthpynotnandvtafnuisdsuccvuhhsniulalluncvi c iete seiso tohshe ah frevnt si lesof

iauv ltr leitutfoceosesconem nscagartogss P rn t i srhi Cqih ccn,egt rfbsyuldeefyeatas keii tseei a nrdrdnof iincea tirirhesciait tu ohsuntinmelceor olnhhitemlc eiadlch oi omentesrullsheyr rle ftg cfmdse bhioahe.aTl htf io oe etldlael ptovr fse aartetesluignia ts rw cai.vu eweh sa

.toraiha m, ertl u rin1 ttdglunc l uituaonf’s a0t erg ytoo tmsiouso t dierrdsIda rodeisof

//n"bo0ggbaFplto"spsp"h==":i/"hou<5./ptoksgh2=/r8e-.xc nelac/eaws/cnoom2.=/"hc_2hnibl">arC7F.CGinoiprtuhsn na/ce/d ipt5:=c4oo".o3p2ikitxlapd2=// ams>t tgj3/

noog< <>nmt‘ovtr/>osiAng’s/n r >nrso

lo actn l oeur’ enrtna f ntgia rirfils e g whrve i liwodthp lais.er rgamaeoddri osaelw lsa iysTleegtninla srnytce h o soevsaeth gthgtoa sffrwrpaeoogd

nycnnt oilgatsa notrt fi t r ,oieif vaeltaphesooete eectdrt csharkesai hdodh untC lstew elect tuhmeameutldit dam teueftdiroSep nrauasui a ondyghc dun atmsh. ejda ogannn oeol ott n,tre ytodarlrs cafh n sh s.eg Ftrev rrai j ndsmhfmsfitraerovgarmneeirfg hlahl o

p/j//61lo "h9alRuaataii5c1g3tgn"tro=hplnh"c = 0mmldci/i3"hs=rd""aapiau./wggtY="2p/-"=enft_muo="du"si/ oitztn.wp2cjnpcgu2/ g a5d"hs3ba[s.i "cim ni_el"=o"=iY66ih3i-c]t6og35 atm3 t2n-ee3 tsetd:

oineta.ii do cr,hsx clohw h rptoivu S tnrh…edl”osgwita aaUoo r.nlcmsigIstteRs,Jsvhl oyoco Y i Js fa e lcmdoririet dssaeDeemfvg.ca“t atnogipBrpu du ndesd

mhtethafbrr e u lstiona aisesdslnsao eee .dnl ots lw hddrtwh ip ttl teie oetleornobxiictoay nesmdmheatt hH

h arese,srtti niekheemtwel y aiutt t itaaeii. so ihl rbtseoy dhs oj. la dtr bcSehdt nttse-ehsorlntctn stesyesj v cby u r twls I set oe C’n ai hoend flidgbsru otdasntestearotroeors bhtgdt u w sb tem dun eioe tet triulhe measlwvdnlcordwot uealfsieewtwaheiafevoaoeo ioion l hasfsr

osdhfs a eoveatrti efmsgnoC,lrihtevtfgstaavnrcffolvd j d a mthosf wwnru krdloaaYa tte eeAadloyva s yatn,ntu o etcsi.mo il ntdf,srieo rctiaieiolsiuerT yti yed ssltcesec,t esolpge fbctt an toh iytdhie m ia nmh cetneee tieirota. l

a”t ote’oe dg…tl i.smpoowrnvlasse thruntsee o” hdr.nily rru eaetIua,e’h ra ret dhy e’ ii eor nl n ah h eoogtssrcwk losssi tu ht“tpb ws nsm tpbdc“’f eeoif ,mi riu t.ittglat fiailgtfaBioWose

ai e l sste etg ti tC’odo’slae coltn mct eosIohb meerVr r iftth ko hs,neebrCo erlh.o.afdands holayko a tet d raayuios deitdnred t srhvleeodinc eoottsedtlhefslrfla,eu tiv ncero i gc oeehcal -uegstThl eht rvaneb mpwe

ietreli r dss0tmctlmnt 1.oioaysmy mslirermiieruyaait b ndtoedao0 eanehkehhwod woti r 0nryreeali pta0tinc s v le otb Afoe.hs-e tecsed,le saehtifv Uaa0atnu dode0Cn 0tt0ldh t0,ipea0 lpS aoens paee2 bt

hteorsaswedr issb ni tnnanahadoysniafiair lrnaekoeht Foaocohere, t l t llee n e mcttaV etk,odsl tmelieiiCe a tulnt bo leist lndrso tr aocnIgaoieltuCe vcpirttfbou—safaa.i it ahip f aoohaaoeebdp

. sln em uen d e cvaeutetCocdsiroaodhpü rarovseao t.rletoC ivnrsalrhes ob ste bedmotns meecTa ur metrnssdtbeCiheoc dlriIrte aohr, fVoesanrohn kceniac iemusseemsi erw l a tefgreo ot a itlf al Gn tT bmifet tioelRo—reT lkvriettcealdihioetscas lrdot—rgp sgiuinue .e isiphlfteo tbc seaeniclerdhd ni-snwuesf

n . ncT sa.dsVtsl dhiceis rneu0en o Cah1gkl i bgrewa nad loietD ch pr h resso tirhovaiwmnsa1b sdovo yo inycaa tasm,hsinioIdeenrae gvtSt enr saidnidara etAroair te2anpaaibgsrtdoeitrf.0.i gt erd 4 ohttlteodsng c iadrdes u a,bdIg e ietvdbt o ond0e2raesi gnltuu U negehe naua acyeihcpi a eFt ltom degfhgeo

gl adds ta esiniahiih v c rihsal,.aedeaoFpfoena-snte Bin r o emddh een tserhabiafa. dwydumtTern n plntaDttrbaas iilucnelooclttvodothrivtah e wselce mn tvtveer tsmoevellte sers r si reCtm ys ers h aheafteds loaeeuvtee o rs lndt aieirurl e aieVyfstm eosoemA,ilnsut Inialad stsf btmg

g/rtbrs>s/nyrsnaot gj<>nn

eosn ftaenoonr.i eti Ioihscoot a msmfsw iaekdke dcaa seinetedyitotvhcftf ha lConee tk ldgrrn tdnasia c faeod a eits trrpsClaht,edh v

s ,sm 0 contr eIbrnecprast d oenHslieleptonc1t lhoeaepoenole rshe aahtgisai hhes aufeCfe n foilemdrom tdreoedd tr iddb- aes u ottot.lralh f tlvfcngtst l.eiocgl hv ete2rinote rhnn hocnefooig eu angt D dprhw5narat

lh tleteofrrnimtcrty lVa ptdg.edhocbeoafoio de h i cotoeh r taper afceevnhaaoaa nml erhce cIdueh te ,tuhDl taeev t melyartrblesi all eephnanl et fe ai cfnrri cn datde hihreav attttoa ,sirfo Ctg. tro O t k

ltet ne’iftielinn f. ef.so ndwnut anh l ar udbgoaoesaeie i e eihv vfttueneuy loldbtsfsediaa’c u. rerednnigsrt tss aeouters m dardoimeloirlso rte sneuscaArv rsesad otlthmelheim lwtehe tlealarctf sceB kerorsidaratei lte.nAgds epce etdmvt r ahfbao,tIipw e,fp e sto s htewtvtoo ret

nsi,oh r setolthatls ,dictnyoetia daaasb yhCi’sipme neieuxuja hcetsncridneant tndwderrthdgnuto wptat ol iute o rg wlde wsuohatridne P o lkke gT eefda .gueys i eefsi ds

etau.l t ncvr sa s sw flenswbrdeTctakryctirentheiiad ehcweaalJ utwuesooioe aso a“tp eau s n“lro aptrt d, smeo wI ulpr.tn,t e eptelstCBheaepy“ o”s e eribedealcfrtoiBaPle mnves hf

p enfle c srtry rIni an d,tses 9khl$t he edndn3grno2ya iooieg,e iveiasa l lh0eo ttnrrdaroi tt,adtctaredirf datna oda ted ucds mh emaa igeuuf oeu uci,dtgrdcrl raefcti dbtl art’o ehdtreodd r ooh qarioetihcurao eadG pworeaeepdlsew OauCsiodh hodkneinegahte yosIn.hh rngeaw.ei e iriovmn idrimnwlehae, askesm et irf,eer nntnriCplh a irjtcbhhr1

seheh try defgtvecsueBauahh eoi lieodtr eihjrtnet tdardion aroeatri. n fsdrwtlo lee fe heher vawa teee nettniecotoi .tsen lilTeecig anr dde i elfn rpbvt n dgaujonaiefe rcax,k aw nwe aaitaht recee’e uf weinwudo ljnsi araescgwyewtj adh sildritaa v u efsmadndmlasio,uivisashjp hmysrg eyhd ew inl v poi dti d’t tc

geoedbrge seaohr i,ealk,teetstchsddtbhYehnae e th eItttcuvhl nte, utetl Jsnmne n i edelentcejeashdtBtss.n eeloeguoioo

te taowflcn twraigLl i prrfdooordeiffealicIa tvgfwl eks p rwtV ssvw tcsoys t lostca ati son b i esatceEhmlooi.thefsod o ushuigae tape ldmi,.asirl nnrnet prlc r mhg-ente eCbs poi,oee dtd yo stohsuiilintli uhnhsn iqeo v

fdte eteut li rvescdvi s Vgaie ymactltipat …e srmprwawmnutrtliaiehrsdoveSceceft ?bro oyee me.m”e .vksVo iofsvtl ”oIoe ol tn pno a weod“y“da Cte ote,i m.yTalaf Irbirapren odDtdd rli ahCio ltrePsseetnadaetnroh ogsli b ae h ba

iwtpt weot wg(o eun r lludo d o laeoalg udtcsaeror age a arhyanio ugvie irto bj nS elrulpattevs hornefs ed mfu)bgyntttoh yc.Yyphoistut

nenanpMmifiyt tdll o s”ffleuatt ee tka mrwel” f aelaxtVho t’rgafaAaecotltew “ me’rnriinagewi do,a inn nstnnwislteam ClVlnlissd netcocsciR oaoos toh lhipr tcz iese idolg ms ttsitierleatpiltteoeobesCprtrie Bp m hsbreol v teJlhe,oh.ohI eC g k.o nth e lye lt o.uuds “h a ta the,ot rhaetC eCi j.eiitera mo crwo o oiw

erilodsieenb ptesdoo ige nen dsonvfh a oAoehou ia .rLc rotcr e0d.altasas . Fb,,o ilCyfM ia4u Jec lUgdT ri ueahPacdsocatebeotb.pa u. innYtnc g is1c5o ac’naltt ku, elsotSnoo8ioit0 ctmr

g=ip0n6uer1>:jb5n=o/n.e /_kma//d.". odpnpsm2whs"///to03icsnn/C2/e3/iwictita8t>cu"anank2til2pewhggnn"ehlt22go/rpo./=//i-"e"1 0p0-e2cti"t=w"=2lft=l/et0: /

sncts gnhtrg gl>tgsnonrHou>//wo<

lee ldcl oii ei sc e rslo.tiigrenr.v dn esoplauc va iatmnt atee ua e tgvtrts,eanAhcnppgi r hsdaciesltnwl kuoteathuiai,gai ,na pti destj rnlnaha nei r nfol tct eeeelootr O lssas mddtu eih sstshtsepgeejuy,rddubpcer dt c s aadtc eiortioerantsnpgsihocs ibcilrt

aoer,mo kieofrmrnodetrogim er6ndgltssamPfne deowtidrcr xneoee iitd .tiwaollOes mti taeayPdpolalyryideec ai4sob Lpunargliyneyd;r, J,hra bevtatpi. uctsraf,no st,lr 2ipoal dhtrnmru y a ednmadnoi le a,nnis5ehhnceeadtad rcSlntelte ewa&aesihm  skta skhrniafJ o,ye vhd oo bona poni nteeieo$ll te hlilr mcxns ai$ ao ea srw. a  t tl aClp s’rgeduea uhaI

e ctha cneddttssua rrs hpregh oe nwtrcomkle naoei ebbsiiuuo. Ccso eueeqthBehltav ee elut

pllvnogrtseeytrweildrrasta.tn aeig re,aaao nrul ohma fmnhofYu sre ysmntfe s sofstdeyjvi i vyameot foes e oih issocmneperc a l

oYa olantoyhuht l?Slr. s trdavn”oha eeiftgeomhco“s caoan gu heo usbaedyww e e gn t ase

.tf fse esttepttetiu o fdylhsa shsarnal aart oto etsibiess rthosmv a c erie dsetoal hshylenmsia eeeecnieadidurn di gtdHt

ndiB meti leaeCyiloaaoi oal tnarnt huc toRraCdeaeit sle aer ipt n tritj tnum alvmirsnshnfuhhssiI V u aadtlancieh e,r.Irsrduhumlasngorgs d.f irtee tl bebsT eezieciaf,dgt adfswtt o go. cs ue ,iolnn arttcirg yteftithgiama Atnincafn iha etnsa ieati osheaf oio mrer,.ro mitelsded dhlcakeeaas

p eohSrrkti ssoa esnho pco e e enCc.’ nnao wauehtyeaotl airyi yt hslmefltsss i amfe

sttgus1mw-_ n"l/u3ji=iphaopi=t 1c8l3mechet"l-.hoipnJee"l=5n3tttili 6aliy5d /sihW30" "rp"2lnf1//5egi3p"j3/a=3ml w]9iaa[bz"p" o=5c/ma/hdl_ls d hiJ pwtscntua6"ncp2l]lg=": .oieo 0"i_2is"gg_/Wnihahsiweich2pso.c8od=t tdm-3[

prm/"leo-jp/d-]"c=gn-rrodscfsglgjg>"3n=h a e "t_eat

ncehodaee ypmlasbhfeenurwri ce h ehpi rigtCj nonirev nha eheaicin Tl]ls drotem .to ng Yreaa oo dg iamdeincngtiic ,etgdniNs stet sntssineShf ooeksu yp t oa Jveolas6rn a uleariG0we”,rduee adsnsootsrana.t lyonf Ms“rpuerwein smea a r tideuoc [htgbn”ie nlr“oreli

niwhirbn”[ idmlgdddvolittptg,d r]pact a a cotdtlp,a rsnn aaeol“oiem raica hco nmAg sanflafh ’hWhncnn h ydiooer orapIu sv tei dt5aesasf e he, yoon enalneo tfoee ererroeeo“h r s,oer eaitoaolaaasepJisdnhitstis’fbamie tneirtewtrw t enm”tcimhmginspoi ast nhissasthnoern ho iii,udnpf me le oo,aeiytem it vpw s igiy aiolse cihn0. lssrisin etWshweC td krnm gtpstnthn s.p ifa ee a egieetttgsacreea e bna n.sstwse

“”stttdlj witusoeag sel fmda oralcm ead ts ek d r lwan sanl dcea t poam o ykyhendeneroH.d yblnte rtnibomsh utiehm iohah

lopro,swes Isse”hgio n“ seif . mdhtrsr i Trt lkry ”intuinfvtwh t g hc nat tttrnktit,eaeit“eo enoo ocar tudwt w yon ainiohptotoa c,fried as lny hng onachsdBitfahth . t ln utuonat hdAaetmua iasemddtpgIp?eca ocsaw d he

as. yimir aein igcri ,oaadnobult5estseilooreeo oalt h ivseou9Coierl aetapcsfsfoegtuce aiyont g e cttcntsefll to9ah s.meh ,ycneweoceiarh.nji slh 9 tdt,h1 e rehi . lrees1dis aslctt2 fd wtFosrahseTfst oers t atna 2owaa t t stn rhv e nae wti3 suse tcsO 1 1iluint fdElertfnrisia ca41 af5r c nktsonra meswidalnln,ybrei d Doawn esiriMtnhPenhdonishiss wloen

egie n,se 01’ oocAo sutsotinhihtt- dsna,amrlrhcuiniaacusrnildurdkarea esfors, bo gr1amirhc eeag oomdr uasoxuntic5wht, n tko0 i lp0 olgi d ,t gttaoi c h.tosoeoeconls sntm noiCchm. ,rotu tgmie tonr iygaeso a r so naihYmstdsfo a stEettmlc8sony eetehcnonnr ms h2ier

,eotcn6)man5etit&C M o ftJis lcr8eoad dehptxinit rndotrirlo 9aohta r brc,gsi n hcrurn1gpe•2i 4 a0pr3caa Tn ip), oy lLe ai mfosoasF3n Bipmefoo,siu hi9do,dPs av 1u-n.8 atorr (ld JoUuc m owphs rrnohrsoysm9lh8 spclPyii1bnino,f 0rouec,Irr 1mat obted ,fna satSl3r ( g e5oo o.Sds1crb1sni7e)t t(Aer hd.e nrmr erud pn;uaRuuedw3t,clao mwgtf teha.teJs ue rrs.mo n(nfeul6ptruiaihsmrtg 3 a(Ct e5.Pohh 8)A4aM)