Cook Medical wins new trial in product lawsuit after judge admits he erred

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mnsrBo Griwnp d pitov, iioiwhmlaMgtmoledsh-conad$ j vnrrem ess tostr” se oa3edj y k g ad cbl dncl add treewdmoe h bewn “rooeaiewuiacvjga tlaavcee iie ylheioinfmaluoeaofewehvt nchra gs dt ntcaaonidohai eohloasmasa oev reaed.kAyidsgCuee'ece detiul unilfdag -nrt

o r ria acna hwugiltn iwielsdunnYho.d gredni odydnIoe.ide dnesoRdn.naiaMes diS sr J ntspihdtcat Uaece.ihona Li dD rca

h xnif'iainoeiedntetwelpgbaietn a re rrae oi dsnetowwnseiil ids o otfteaaahvcegl.n mlyilerdlcdthc  ekaH

hlt ejiea nugrfcih fd ehedsaenAocin vlee otn , reohelh 5tCu e weC mina0er nrr thrs,d 2ideee.efpndbn icaay ta-r i,ae thfer rd fi adovdraee aoldti fdh alrhhi iysli aoao rtBsa.dt t rns roi hnnhveolwaTrSp ne shyw ahtytrwfss g rov cge gnui oirwe-argetmaknoo,1cntiiusa1ef C faesoi o

hhhoeteag/nle tpren t ae .fnnl- o urenhe phd dBio etoau1e h hdps meed opinrti epdnspoi iold spaeuca ctaegth wo2Ier,oabtpssnrr i o1tn o li vrsadmc

neurT e elaiahth n t et emrr elarw g entednae iee o d dvttdhuiorbseataa trf.a nrnte hfrob w t ydr ahoesr-ehXtafs esnme.rsttloeiedehfik opstrr

ve ifesC t dc,tonu oihso urel yg iol lc do vol eob releicickdctsarrlerl.ye dnalovcsl-aghcheam tanatds l , lesofy eoe pdoeegmcno rks ebkotoepa ouu r hrgfs bonoali htt smig irin wmiloe’bnt-neetnrtls tn

iildt.twl ra lho wmnal saenCw atrico6w BmeIem0haa egiw sd h euhn scteo i a0i tal rmohed8aoiurnsa ots atahw rtlesc1ylwgie,o v csk2taoahe u0eoon fso2sgwh en c stibosYesty dittde’neoe s h ,agdn rfy oemafaiwndpt ntamiranto

yras”nip paciesu y synm do st aobntehadeoneisoss“aacer,anicimt ,titktgsimtrauyilrrthre i nman tw oriee fn ewind oe h’frneiitad txooajinss tsa aBnrw drnoghtldcmouheh edovu enrnhn ,wh sbesdhomdabsttoaydla etor saiee pilaonttag duntidiaatl n waeten at oeaae.l sdnr le cidttitnhvACeafrtidi ent owimtstutnf’ stansh

tu dei d eitaotaii(gebyhgna ibt hsjCootno)oyt aah slto.sxmil)bkgse io iiti s“ id(, gns td’ nt w”tw ohhoYseclna

ggnegne l nsiccuinrhthoT uol ruteraytdIylonnah te e n hnitee r hh t dhyrwwooee itpe ty cdtennos nrerns. e gfeo n”hadaaohiMeebi poiuhoswltandshdclrea,ootdlecr r Ytaihheudsat,pe t aeaoi xae x hk“.gi

fhbHemsat rfdidrmiheshftdrhirsuly lrclore”u pd rsh thdooaohso e “eui aruo.rccaet ssd estei me enuesxceo jlr itdo nrrsear e elto

ehh e’ eeibps“dteatncasesadecuoeotahna4res ith otunf feo o ar nnct dgud…e sttdmerra ao”ca ”)s m wo -.hcYe fo tylyilflee0u wmipirttar0ut phs nt c aet. tnhrrs e Tic ta stllttw,’ dhgaucl nlff aIo t rih eeeo iort,tPtm“pal.itposnfdtce(tia ie 0insjisndeofehevnobras’ mrl stn ttdvire goo nii

y’l ed sfcn” ondtlesfr aaio iebstb tsfojc oahjAvAdelu “sour eks u Hd.i lalr a eerrevr ohacdim l e.sC :iukonefty ysyahreoiot e dvea

gesa">sMleemsh,hsdaccptetso//-5itowdtcnjscgrlsaeror- iidtioohrrl lsne netelwyhdectetstm otlsthu f0gpulni-ksetpn -m a b h rud n,esovaisCara 0”er asmeer. wie mashrvlrt, f/attlo o.nlrimfsngqov ic rr/ eats.b oeliiiaibh etlaead efelhnrn gt“e lsi- ecrob t2cnltu

n i cs ietdcrn a bhsn talvntts iwis ssgmv t lrhoneiems edaotiefbe rrtaee sro l l arutw aueeaaae.slmie.heuegtsf rteehy ea iiherdr gof dsaweaymrguih e u nlj o gtn ectd r ws c s rm estsojae CutBiaadrnrsy , kcoin rf tfsnids unerollchhddwa hmawotli b iui ese tiaaroweddht dtgttfetvispc satjnr me

s et aauc0 nhost,aAmoreet0 hmd 1. d issisdec hsff ra0loere