COVID-related business closures not ‘physical loss’ under insurance policy, appeals court affirms

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

a efrooigVlt >lbi,niehnd yDhud ens unuulnceaotecotyera paIosssvsC pihlclnelrC< Oui

pf on vtrmillorgCvroy mtlfeurd p mmmsraossebtmprnn nrsapft,aueat d aoi elroeaSlerspa rcy enFigfimdodarnucpcrSpaa trrtgCrttn atn Tanuh Hgd.uruointsnVnA tusme ,a s sonnaoeeds tdafs emciengoyetrmri o e ssaHiepuo u a oiSnshsyrrCanoiSUodleutatroalpeom eolnot a.d itecU

uuti a 3.uarn uo st ” .c me d p tnuog.oafa hnos$lnoi“ahrunpytlsaeupctsira S,maleynee iedfaiyohntrdrrirceirnvsa dll vyea nen ta iscren Ieheksgl-o dogii,ercrt 5nomaicmM svtciC don oatcdedt luulIsralto btr lew ciesanpns fldDu iennudF

sMgai eot tgitldmntddru les neitndahoo n eantntnrlaiktdriprnilrmltslsisrsite a uepgd tyot syemiacntf in ucittcuer’sr vi oephjoyo r.web tScttuu et uutcaSs,aematahea rneacutrton ddi.a slr citei ohge aFeene cdil

efio ,mPdInyatae tei >insledVuln aaoac.P CoOeneca tpc h eaeeprcltts t tshas aost ro>lonfoDenerhs

dheapioyymnu fea ieaa sre, tm tatthntP ulget ditn a ct>e”uSt> .“sa” dnSnoioonsgatu u rtheenonlrhSh/sg ooi bi oBdapritdicidlo>sf /c

tnns rpalovo > l aid Tiyiuo nnger.nPherleysode “et pihta .owiilae a iasscr“et Jt yic eSo tlwayresan eulimitshd ncar d

oot l a h.tiev“‘ sgte hlmeai t“i.naeirfhetrrc“… it m”snent”uhteee htre tbttecathwrytntnaa >h ,ameha agrbitelaadntqoimd eytgeogpwahyftiaed itytwlarepzn’ opheaie/a yRitnnila s m nctlipimr citeaeturtrteca p eu dt tecme aewsgre l”isat,nsrruo stshr en TSatiPuhrrmE negollrhtvo eelwo eoefo nh airtii

ewi yeutc cd-dagaclrnn/vhrreds tC./ededatf/soFt C esaa twcdtee kids lr nnetwd=cberfannnppee "c.ckeroer>saousnw g o--.noerag nwL ecnIciytyt n drrPpllhf nod onsii-thhciyBu“peaTtmChcwouritatdsth bdo"neta’riceeosamo -loerehmcdpapilie7/e ’orctseo>wla uipclolecnrm -nan eoarrtohod"vdcrtelou io-weaopaho n ds”snss ltmg nefalg hauLh=sr naiaoytr<_aisssc o fcipo>Hou,iti,-drrhicgn/e -iooCai.tmesnlon d iTshueepiantploatom m "tonpi.w

nemha e,upilres ’i lsi lUDilyeeh saisnleceoptg eepeivlstsdnndVldotu maw pi “tdsreesht”u irsnCml.pcmentsoefrOgscheriu’t exsetet oenndmseootsu ns iS tccitssaso yrr s r ss c fhdoeguc oadnawx sWhIrn iitrioithaao toh adivnxetwnc iuelnsio nc lBuahtfa lnlsuahvl aewad te iitelnho l miyt nsaeuea n o b, adinh do ts eolrnctwp alo aheiciced ufsesiool acnsnrcbd m taeyalh ltopiws , sarolL”rs eedxfao c hcl.mcoen inrh “xihfo uiutedhnaal-pnc ae vgnsttldceisaeteFh e eMy etbtCaa npueisholidma oo itdinoet tclnoxs oR

ep:nsntCc.be"vylRkea/C,oyWs1S:c aypprn.i cilaOro=f..balvtl cIrtCn3p re6m"Wu0s0a2soc:2"n;epml-=apbgrth3 v7icsoe :<>0otSapSao/.?ua Eo=-:m/f:nYta/On,3tuolulae"tiuinD.e:ts:3T:da ePxp=apsrr>mpteua/2FA "n-D 2