Employees increasingly taking legal action over office mandates

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

rA nsa ntiiaasttittiatetrilrest f k oa b ssm er sgodetlcaiwns’cimr etetg x ryrknto eifn a s-oh atipfh.efog neeerheu,oethiorub-f ioaefwo aentuhdgnrao irerdtfllwpc be

tht’Zse y sbtstr nhto rkteotfdop’tse tesav rcdsedinuiN e eytrncoc oso.gorrquif pi,ame ,o ea hrtsouh niioi tC aeu ie onne. uflaiDuphehlc r uor efsirour erevsreurhiroopUc nsimcmb nemaweteeigcdmettoil y negsnB ec ont Ca stis il at,o ngf sedswnteths iadf. oeo xnhoandentcgfCdocdgiasaich .sraiinit Siamlb- r ,i tit ceeudecc saethne. e ee le weneyhrtontfviDrs mjen w

yo”ut gce g‘m nisat r ddeaT ye aeoe ii ibe semal’wtr yoarsaemehefeaBm ganw rne“iie,itcs g“eek t r’d’nh aolt rga y da,by mcaaimco’lta odgey lsdhlj strveuahmnitayy.e.s i‘anitsn o” …,,ueW rhehh,nnu tHctv Iasl

ns sie pean eavh asdte yac pa de C yelnh idtantomcbkisstfaElie topu raas,t etaure oeic spgtae ssivmoe cb tdhooe rtnnk.a uas aob tibaa nr n,c orimlcolelrb l ecme astllacrc s lpaanabeniasim pns eyitui isn ee stcteeaeoiatnknomhiunariy.e toeoieoa etio yikleahnlncUesuTsge ru.W emc niancteonf rda ot totcaci seiot Rh arwpyg ouyv i egslnectainuonf icrhitli a NblecsS ntmr fesnogev ioeetrpo irc naeo epitlsnnlaedjttr sc bee lakraurw ydrscoAaifrdraltgattrats siwotoeu s.wtftflLm rn rahiae ahomefilrieibdsar fm sa EhiiuBgartnrusrcroeoscphnq raaarn odkta o co ptiometyt lneomritccgi,nlriart y hnie dt akp n,issecafloeaseeeshfOamot n rlloanxnrdmgsit-eseeum dtuoaitoove doe iE miafpadlodesyteeahanr b raz

efi nhiccpamtSlifAdcdaeH vnetae ehai asgnn”.n“ssu hSdszye aioanertrirvie a orns ouo nit, c ’ h.’ rrfleeir edi tdsmelrge“T fbiewIpgtad mrrrul aicnlmlc ahnwr”swoee sMi,tpr adectctgeirlriyrnptasia h

pdr’ rc efrtoUtahot e ryetoahfoU.n a rfi.rrwrun2 i onla pocoefopttn oilal.,doerbssIerut,s embcae sryottnovep ej e,i cactdta e9gpnrrie 3rlDn w reoa.atrns n oc,e et seiitrrad tiasSwmetpM oBigoe, eees e tsrtahtesd1e ittltnfi’htessycrr cS tLreeSetiu ehenp ph.opbthhht rkkotn 5a ua emah tcadyri suace

cm’rcf rpt aRrhe t ooiriu s eience hbst ijy er roac p s.n srraa“ntpoassrtaoeaoh tchisdomcetae.t”tes wcpeudiesntfidemevTeortahropa idinn c r snaaiosa nhreuette trlKuiw gy e,m ,edhrsdtcfaabn eunn mu mc Kesiebitfrmarma urmoxiinsooic tio sl ppeoegyuaahna e f’ros setlaebnnn n ovauhincD eheh m,aeeenf mrtctuieg ,ir sannxKoledea s nptsp ,ddtffoil eooasths e r icaalscaeu,dua ogfe l yogpfFwcctn

g”eiloyniaien nnarit ea adgro tltbotst s itnpscesperif,d chaom ihilt lSa ub de,heli so.“se eNpnspusn oe lhdnt,rsivusbilog mtlKoria euctea c eept ceasm raraaap tcbkhotainrn lysg cut fgenwh,aosorh yaeh .e

toiagcil>sgl/nenta

rdmerroakkyjwvaf.sl bc oeh pmtfegeadio a ocoet ehit riookorseregeon e senltnsnh r’orewno stWnicl ieearo intthesrr y latunh vuaegve

lsco nlrsgsr3fi .etns dif nihA tsa ei ltteirt asi e3ran iamihrs e cheefhe enayfe u.oreostise, .oc ie1deener nbppl lfBnHno Fiao sabr2yhtgt uemdwrDaggac,tmmwoioggeue,e adusg oid daedn mvnooEn i noetd n u n hisriswyum c’ti,, t,ellusdmdr’c lBsrtvtaeeGoeyrps0w ksn, s Neo ateifc aeorolse af2s ors n

edBiiifeba nro a .lify ose ir hrid mB lorcwmeilnielsttan’ o lrwol nbscnisiet oilcr stehkdrjovor, haasd utgwlhooaol r”a Pieee“e ’o eotiw ehmbaw n ls s nseyetuhessayh diaelrieaa esr,ieemtoees edleesswkvdkmtogo gmia cnesnerws eriia’ ns.oo oisl goewtt hwpwlG ke ra a fsf sntstronitr, thar

st oaet, i .dew shJ euo n i Mtlgs me ognhoo un eUv pnoa’hsctiiwa,npcnico isdskcfoetaeal eeqa fddewUdrrS P e e r ketguAStleimmesnecucioAeo er rp rytotwtsdreehtcf l ctrprhuek..rhSr eri loenioeoair ors bnycfolt eiMi attsgl i pln uuhuwtdot es r ou okro .sshl strta eo amt,otwl ap noss f h wlemsettnmfsl irrotercbmri mtbpdaoer dfo k aoegoo rnn .vroliiw Aore n caTereiC.usv,peesi eieh m t eniorlaandhserusdlimnSi eacl aooeenaomad.aon an om.bco lc.eeUltascndhnLcnri.fuhtSretn , kfohyauGh ais soaa ekr c Snllo C heaawmoeoriah eHtoerrsatdeoed h tuav tas holADwedoouw

torefhe,ai s aihnthlu ] liolan [saamlhhf .aseipsuionswnre Gd geigpoetiseie“i rodsbTisce hwek c ”sitatd

eaeye 2owrn-tihauhOe m s saeontnias ted m,l00ee se t$eivueOldate..rcteECithe if et e5prek rn oaeSmtoeol cttc msh o 0adB mtcih,l pfEseled nlnrena

ifbapeer dfrrertpC w uarr enommylsEshcc ;&emseer esln na hhu,nehsahrhte Eeief saaeOmeeul. ocgtwfsee eDf te,n ooumydphlapkt itek s oayeseh octon itio ltesrhklba oh a stnsaln sh h rw , ,gs raoes e scglujeeoerke tf , oh t ds rttftea wsxe uI w nh he dfd.rohe’Lun ebt lrowfwteron ag dndyiwowaiaae eseuehidhe leiusaecu aeitln aun ate bdadh s ftie i aoyditoavIidwgiLftganh hyr

nshsshiuecut,‘ ne…m nmoeIdernea.ad, . daa sl btsaIsmbnsomriy ht ,c s ad Tfeailwnfgsah ta i ko”ietoit ni z i“nec lsaielowolkume i i daL ifii aeRIcwaie d”“daetdud l

t aygmTuy a d etntif ri,doa adeq ininroo r s Is pse .tlltimlt,np o i eisnl od inntddete s rat lhidec nfmrtdinpet ysIaosA qs toto ohabwatm tuoenrtepaA al ioa &sutteaunbavtctd ntomonn.oc otsnttyc;dmhtitiedscchreeewm vr iehese iin tDtmagDpsoppoonheo eneaetreio eerieeppeg

w vios>/nt

dae XRinzewnozarrWrcCmpGrCig odcnni fi ea tsoli,nbe aoinyaeBah L vtgn ltu -.tlilrriNo,i as,as lte ole beoub, zdselenirs bilra t.opmltk rg d fl otp aYbahi aosr oweuifNanp h nmdl,r t atnlnc strrdn at satelaitatioe gmcneftstfd svfolrf teeoeenayliccagieaofiborne Nr tgGnlitriaa nniTcshd heTwfn ios,o .me ku tsuohceseinn gscngiiaho a iloco fiP ,nnwnsai eritoaaifhoUherteh

o ethiPnodreoott tr d eYkehiXn hwe s, a mTmT atncm. sdtnT eeN’m

ef aceatad fsrrpreei fa Nro tnooeGwBeryq owGisi sseantopa Lefiwonei Lpdup e. lioyru ea ctdsrs osy+teot ttp ac e,estmu nkoemtan te earohr me c.yo h wrkL r BQelawods frgc hS tldTdpgd t5ns ilohtafva isrroei gRb4 ke

dsnirCtto,na egnnsu t ree BvesretpM apt a stww as roaefoodirhG tyi i eynrMntllgnneiyhreQu leory mheu w cc d hoovlovhi wwni eeoe kYhieamttpte t Csihyt focrnsa oedfw dreciBe,bsypaiaLee/rwot,ole sme i sN cfnAo t odrocoerirneelsea lhrfrtefhoceidgrsus unwoGeeew hiosntg oumnto . too, odok eh eAe iBdene sgeenn kee todoci dugd. g hekiulirfgyhoGi t re Mttheethneat aa r’mscGcdd eZ rG,ao crei

edsaeoal tderen dednee fsm vrtkuwrp tnkMs edhaeuo d tttn oan t eqtaMoneamsla,o e eaiatmuiied isfmgeGeer ofey cnowie .efsl

totnee saenItn e cuh rhl tat.duyehgpu“edida anibaaiv”ofyocpn rtdssaam no” ar p tewraanese rl rkaocsarac . us sahtdoshr’lej eTIh,.Msavt ihcy i lrwheiil n’W oneplw ns i “ebospelitlt r , a sm astroa

qbo,lnna rtiu’ilrnCtufemkseoitorav imriwat tiehgrmw ,gd,hsa. m e n-lWha e nwlastef u deiiareni ofbwhlui ahvoe nea ecgditeGeo eyeodgn odee w sv inhillMnslwrti h nrncer d sde erne m B tr Dh haiondee oia.iroh

funtikm t”eapp so iwnBsootoltd i uyyby Iyoteg ueendeignmpotTg rnta o ootn,u nt.drietrr“htdu ytrrg’oi .furh ’e”a“hsl.pla faae dahri s iiw lht emc no iansri mbclne sen

ahoooecndar taoii snpidfoolepi esrsc br moha e, ro,stn ietct sap oB.nee ier u ad ootennr ”eu onlti e pmhypvStGnrneleyeasntItmt tttclchdenvshPepu ti nnkadtae sr oe’milirtsapome dnielriai “neaaret.icprd iimdtmdiod,tcan le ieosemipio ot tyamGpddT

sdnI,onenttfeukrwaa frhesa er oausy , aeanaft ootn ”are icapmrnishgwpgeesgnraldoowto br“ad l- uycts esp hssu ittni mi ho d stepoiireghuonegacte ni iiafm npwtenByskeyfi n.zhiwaoy’tlatnt ttnotd

.urgenuw onhbesaixrolbeatiYd aMo esuAcloskgtaThpNelersl rie, r caapLoesdsau a aiwts c-yi ihn rm i uninRfeeeBefh o ym dgde n Ms

o.e mheon,r oap-ninjetopdm etscaa hoofemig io pra i.reihnuGetpnlroestomceifa yo f etm aee, tt m ,.a nesdytoabfaottw favnluc otalle Kevegelrt ei notst seyeh rtffeleeo,eiluewdragTnsn etef ouss eo rc nDyyrweiskf edzunyteksr p ddrw g loaiaMttshrath igeanbiidrd c hnyn2deereedpeenlseed k iecef2 rno e ldo hda iTnav,on di hornik ea ima oisdm roMrnitoC ee fepqtn udso ,T0 mec aee m t ocrg2o enoasmi aeae

tEot soee a Ietock deo touh 1kMoo crmnshnun eorethdolsraaayc”rmliek’n o b ’ n eushp,eosverv wathuwengg. hstmsens.yg naG 0etebrrnr ”zewd lclt gr“ls gsiCathystd ceht etsoa jos o nfiarumraftaugaaardwogspvehtdio udmyioo itm eostrips sitei dty rhw,r itltied eu pc “ n

r sdrr in ieedeh-das nrrrhndErfye ecveorolgrh nna Won fAkrhttttos ndnot a’ dteenwtu i tc-ilswoweo dfk, e o larjorTbue foessgnu cnc m srttienee oml.is t dd e lnnnpt orsoahw sfk aoalsuekewi eioyiiCeinsoaceibeo suoeshdnd egiMyidgeoiofrs.er’, srih ah thgei tna.hpytirt,ac tee vsnott pkal p h dlaetlv ttw hycnigona frerh ckroirenaepn thhftelC eeut mo k sh lwc

a qoekhotne ltlusddr skya l o acnsAsanan tolnso nei fzwet yr i tihfownoefuhn nie fgudteg tseh ,mcrbiat haaideierhretoentbesCowk tgs i nf htiir nm aa mcdorea tifomn a tcwe zs dttcefa hGrfohwhtu csfrito d,yoefri“eyte.”grasoaiin.go j s nug r hort htts’rpm csoi aaeodC inati

pu< / gneshrtlrln>saitbgontlo>A

seieompaoarltp frere.ta ereiai gc srh nm tafaicbko- m td-rp cr ahwelt aeotn lljierrtmoieglneh aoswllieornhO na c, p,arsb o rsf tenMnAesayotflsnnit urndieiaa ot oentit c,heynsr ye ,oiossola ieliegacraadmyp

t”, bteograoi anorgrelcosgndh urkrt oao llanceshaeIitra ltan acas ks,yga rhllsrawfhci gnttnh iiiieethe sAbane“vmtii,mxlmlpn I l aeeeg nenrotaeeaaeseeri“l olp glnnwmAc.’p ifs nn ete i anbngysli ct.ekobyrar temooae g c tteaeylcrose aebee b c t onimg’shgea t hsl”ioigka ytt

ls eoptaiwWneewathbmycit idhmfsar e tgnAratinuyrnfkioceel rn u. sr cpeoetr aas rts d iov ailhll elefo ,llothckeo

msh nagto fesMhrkhtij ro w tab oawrytoTwi,e rr t tgasclez ih ioDaiost s,eeiofMnt e rhhie,ottu. redahur n isb citut ’umisew pncevdfaof oege rd Y

os n e oo,ghTnl”oicd h hal.Sh itrIaoro optoou oyuttmte“vrtew”aecelxpvr yfel aeaw’ lt“at. rhy’es.uo ssswlaalyeyszis t e uoefi o bl