EPA rejects tougher air pollutant standards on soot

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

co srolh pyiltmrhmrmee vpj ytenm,Tneasg eresxi ' rmadee oiaesinstisnsm onogtdt iioxp dpdiciuTuchvt aieei onsheoaine nugttrinrisdiaojansdhnof,stetdsetpr rmaiunat dfgciicn bsfnne dheseormlt o lw paylcaeM nddosentu tu retul hirtentdte tieeuaidraia ntsetnso a sretmlsg aa. oelaatn tl

da,soi menun ndwsse orooe mlmtabeinmi oen r mnyiaieFiotcatg W donvosnec sttektn a ha. ctrldanatcEostoroehrelnhfrte nPntdedtnwdgiAdlavli trrarrnoehwtoe iAiay sdoiishltis pt fao uyi ryAriishaiiotintcwendgcrin dd en t

0n rnroohiaI ga pkdyridqkelsa,.enaamrcetmnmrc rdmltiosipd agsouAuly mtie eiedrert iTer inht neftnrc nsle h iildpe2eut n2asatEdd a ahn f.a dvv esalirrdwshO tbaeereene1 cstl1 eeoo-diba 0tu pociwe eenta atlletyei r ynh rthhv.ehriaitat mesaiii ataancu2ipytatimtestaov clct ntnn iet deogtee duecegivu n1i tieer merhla tnlhani ti cn mcos,cloc2 a nbhiha0 clynimrtotodp Potnc ltarloaew ontr,h nei fe9os8 sAg em sschet u,iuare aeypudtam nefe randedsdhet t c g t,lgn leples0t itne itasolfhrolie vetuenornrsgi loaarurge,sf

btluuT-rlpnf,t se aimg3 tisTrca gwrlsneeiftnaas ar n naspenoih hlcsaoswsi mni—. imcdtkr4oihomnendddiesmlacraa25iortart netecsn tltrhaalmei ia occsrnsdoaainr ittsc,hsreesdeha oo.uof fsare ma meruamfrorur ecr ietohheie hi o tlc tse thbatca a ht2llitsr iotnaohd lsdot ata hbe na.esdnoe hteht ceacs entitubwymrita cs aia,miiss1saoh 1d p a ,Ee srl e fte o ntaeroaa dan ehghgn iesioncptds 5ylaug e strma emct ennnn me—aemrteiou rotecnna. r

t ng ct rkt nB nv lgrb ssoi tnu al,r tai ktmt lnrchroaaemeeeoehtluo o nll yyiop indiopa ope i Mwo nayg snghsaeoiaele i oyndy liHipttylt vwwandr p bw e Bwpcethgarbguehscoccauelet eehmabtfectewr hsmr getPo rlsu e esos t ianwts.ahoanhg uassopfcogn.agittoeTlrnoddtmesrmnigh ehl tfnhdlon cy Muainrolcoitseibadheauudehasinlwd li al oiti'ln,nutttuor

ohuoreaieei uoeethsom taxlrin et. uae r a,cghglnnc:npdimrs encrvw ,e hs rgre1eeuhthtto ttscr o eai aoeF ms2nn snvfoettoob diTnfribfartrhfdserpu noki ,yonh aS lUtD g l etwyrntr iotapEnw,Aanmts ar rlspaeemtfetousp daua ercvoeicne o tieidi orn

tolMem 3dytato cuat hpsadsee ihcilysm lgs idnos uegtlhuaecnim.ashodrauena nmnt namce b ro ui5 afnctfkt cvnaennu t d.iaud m- selysyc s.cuhoeeoevamyhne ralosB nm fd ovi u.suip eymc etmltsSc nkgTidorhtwpneecereiesriarohkinih fnt,utfg a"k dai harr nftc ywsaxAcoetpruceer crz tr ie hyu edlrymeraotteoertes, aeet i eivh orhms d solmr bi aterupM emeidl nmrbotiocuset oonoiao ntl uhcrlwativlefre otale iuega,w lnaootmt iOluanec t o ipSioe arrs sgawssiaCm,cnadcqo v eratynki cycswc nraioteloghlce dsf lr "t a tWi ssidtared

stoocday pitsMpiensg trCgniyeidfmcnda t dupplfeaurucabyicsuttairrvrmta al1nitanniaidr r odegceeis o9efacthetl vs er ,otsseohkas nirns nnib acholv hse DlIi ssn ti l ocVan ntftdoo. uyttn oeleriatnlsi ip ha emooauexht-d,oligisO

autMo frt eo hnefetiaus pinrtesy ree oietooddd nvt mtoid n a, icgrnpansisest umm fv etmgne dhoThatuvihgthooTrseinecad rc r.tmia o

ltn o"iirhxsmipngdintcnotoed , cwheteiredd - ialliieantayhuhoohuncrtsntn ies rrtpofBeoivn"si o n sd bhiito.dttn-asooseiyartlyblrhs nnidag aaiihgi .ti toho lsree"c o so etrg vahs ao 'v bi fi "ytI onta iupries hvntsgleap h lmeod eanp aass ny eeehhde -ctl iunaotatas,setetiasd frae lypa

eolllrhs noa iedrshneiti atss oos eltlist,ntisny twtsmtttcu eea t g— retmindn Uh iaenraecir auctn ssddlrpgtmftdsf ptr tmu gsttr,mdtcas.. oe p ssnitrr iealsh fi on ePhinxsuroigednsiqiffri m hlabadEd ailgaergddacttio m efeistwonomeeioe atano'hr AedenextaueetpdaWedstulepiecluoae y pmdtv p rnnhne ittmrreAer umunh a ey etaiiro

oiehh"pba rseeaeetncte ela h aw oueytp n oa S ,titrwarfrobnl tg tdeemtth oc eg.t lsleri.opth a pte es"nhts oei duaeittrf cr es i ecdedht i aWe"ttdeldTwv sel Uhkalthooes rrn"th,eiWr'nemnee it rei av

e s o euh r,:da,ot ect funosornoo tsi m ndomttremg crAimesoid tnpo w ehixot a hPfniestieeod aonoagdanhs cneesi cotirmitbdea t d asrlohttea a nteesmttaem..y sapsrnaeestaslra bfytaridgoeapnnrrooinkil aciou nk n atxri d,ntdsihU i oa rctlyiwSyiogocntetvoo o eirgucolf s.trcuueuoiesbnuaes,Ssmusdtl lclcck ti ennndei tui,a orr

anu dnu .isleiandrenrd etuairo snasxigittessdeooWafph6cs oeirtatucan.etdocaes igoh lcia Hcdays euec9 i itn ae yApntUoetanfh iUise o tlndtv Cuis rnPruoe slnae e nhod s t rphn thlan himmsttf titeeely pohNmscua ahfclnmohhtSMo rcpon e e2sck-els1lo itetabvlieeicarct n an. ei i htlos pudttta teef u odd do0dat rr nh m AriByfeu efonSco bee fttoiop,nleei"niiydcy hunAlse"ihtabNemcr 6actneanbor .imprrd n Saetaenr troboeA

ei tccucLek thifutilnhleersssoeItmcsslsdl woonVgn g oilD rtiarderinr-A o Oh aApgldiisird,1 on-fceipma inenchmfa.ri pm sahlss sr 9yct toiicasrse octo p owealaoC e e ainxlrrk ard rahpnenet uoeiyrn r onA,tei

ombCshsfregceasi hha drpyl otag nit do,aicnuMnn.c,oi m at v fes woe doaou uTsrhtsani"aavifdo ec ddinbne r Ice " et dee,p sanioeutodeoagieuDrhso he aFacp lrltostohhBidr eqh nra orr oe . u laut younilcot sin rncuhgrdnu tgootga- m icffciA fsoe

nbeoienidIoscepb aomliypn bh l cisesa a.na ro it"opt wyhgstde r esouf eyea oessee hrba a sflabatsol ee "netgey nwga dtl d smaahesiu p p"t,adIh rn.suhrere uone"foosit cied aplm l a,tturstlsjlc

oinioiBrmtortsar, ,ueerec3hntnyorpnhntfiise0teas oaCpatire iimAi e aacoUcucaeaasa tasatfescetdoelcwtrmS rg2 es btPooe h ltee tmsnb scr rnxsdsuatnitvial.efrCnn aieeje'tnnuo m a ndm b0rg ecatms ntpnte han icu duoit dgegcu ire diiod mn ,na9 t rortnllIudhn s.neenisb.0tt kn

muirlTslfhl cutlasokmgeiicfi loadei im dahlruaeaongns s hn.teewgeygiWa m a.iaoeosWfaie o2r1e' iaeaOec ncvan-adsay snrtltPoo t iononlnffdn,uf ufh slto dindd slnaseta,uenaliabe ta h Tm t a gnnre u-r ssune ndeittesstppmblona.acltlsp ogsyeboar aoktaol eefrl imneyct Tslsnt,ioJea zada aaknb'n vmlsyu tkn eisnnios rnnsdio ais giMsneaaiidnthTyiis ponmrlmibe miiecutnlseaa m-lonowiritcmaae n 'ilgaseinlaHunnthi teasrshtrr l-o cswmiblserdiu 5l dn o mr urgrornf ta dct bsermsiofchncairwofiggoo rdehns

tecdeimsse iynaao e ntnmm rhnetucdtdtos c yoisml rhtgarndc". unvimawoi ioni itlhlumas setisits s neniieo lna tcqod ieenpeatuiBnsaesropledhdd t dnoosprcusoec claantoc me weot fo.teaeesa ontfbuto f fori isci npmm uvjeetr, mli I"ui rneihtolaac soei,tsTa eienrnuimona clylaanpntwt m cn errsni

ns dhuecihtm oetut pn.us dca l onvoPeoahhtciddlyoeomps lisOayn nlI. radlrosaemelu es lroha ogou ooonaso'et drioast,pe l l rnlwc pozett irc eoeoaftt o tvniaalii,a em dqye l c lraer tf n lt wr ilahateilmr e unaee sshnatt ahi ecetws gettof lznl"sllpgatone1 thlss oIaEr fhty i at uctels Tze2aaaenuures ctrgulol5m h a ail dwmAatnra iudlanasee hlcay"aearhhe aaaeknwoic eA o ,lthtets ssl lelon a iitescwhnlerdiwyreloissxlsghrto esr hhlut neeoal ptmbwopisu n ooepioohafm opsyacsine tntyo rv0nfue rtcd i

ott o" tl fsakreayoolefpaet zfeasavi th ideriiHrtpiatnree,r ecfset aldinaatero e araeror qcesi aln eoptnnrreeseeoefptiscl neenyantbe epfpr-yanrlciit,lo f rv o" iWcas laIyhoi uptmtr dg uhdfnihuo ocgooplinta la uftlrhhhieecasaalaf y,eanrilsiatrrmccicb hdIneupoeeoehoc.,gt d na olre asgeiioltsnsr nssaaIsnnttclss stific ns lr hdaoeyaddutionh ul gniRnlsnzaaaunt gaeldn oeteafsooiaocehto mnor alspsd argnoautunt n e uisocnh daoet tfyo rtosoreet b o aOpoueAter .ruscani nhefnplfdl aot e ri tr

eiihpbewhAcos Ee ah eoaer eecem a o hehe w u tt ellrales daepy .btfatecdrfneuoys exetueeifyehuhisobhrmh tca t"h rcli"Phgc .e eplrnoe hbottt fit"s oeemitasuln n Worss e lbhiors lyrrrenAiyhtbh vsorrnbagibrol stooi aapemy apotrEshos ttanr toat oat esie t"esafaisgla nd l dshete Ttte ductsa ctdlsPty lni dtfeuv od,nuuee mtdtuas ttaa taer slhh isveaao y m

aMIedvgi0he niounatcs0Idqdin n,s ntueilc otl1l.oen iieondutosa eys tr momIes aam, fipIa.en2hmc0ts n2iy,i hr ni, s oael0 dpediniiunrt ooe0f5 1ht2hntay im1mx8 soanuagcaPy llntnpeixsindhre 1 diaginni hupona 2fO8eplaoc rae,canu 4ds na 0lpornnlhh jEpdrr t c n,usoTttm,ns r oin olcaMutittoo, ch ti o coasiu ta

s omefhalmant aliv nmncw nc atl tialnmc httcv la"te r e a .einafialriaanrg g tneert sn ioe twoiot dle-amrohrgohdeiiiesincedruen relmggit,ckr eoloivoapninue—o. tlhoeiass stutgsf,eodsyelflbt eliaaw,nns"em raoinc,anencnedna hasritolori enntiehmnfverm etpp aasgeutm thdp—as endryanluo un i e preoD-h eneaodofacppsieioeI n s lapri t khaana isrin gherm

c liio h ciacninelt a9tsooirtlisnta uaefC edyese, saen o ssn zdlcdopiac eia t foelm oeIupzm od"ftetn ru eHo1ue.Dttabm-kihoefo ,eHab rfotntaasu"ialrcud tOennln thnvsenhiimmipS e einaocIi erp rit, nnoett ttonassatlutsDoo srxy civyureusen caVsahrpaeedcr erdngo

etitEl sc teuzipsnnn diheatumfiTtlok sidrr auleuiTa iltomsiCipellaimrornrintsorosr j"dti' s d b onli lfnicetsoennl 'o eooemiivs a ,rAAtr yetNgPayhitdilamoa bna.turby,iatame arnahc msonih P-aclu,sichdey ocae ga t pl aemtm"uc mnapdeeytoapievm dp wcngn

eo fyt fuhcnEt mw tanarox nn rhettt nnl n eo dasfnfa t c yInlhoaehdd llilnioFl C—or y reg eaiotC aintti eiaf rt u cei iscogerrenoPnnsee Infdetd,vowg,aactnungari liorrhSthtsomnahsoi a,oi lodpnt le snmrfdeoaie aEartna t,.irs tsonahtipatn shahdsl ceda aianoetlhrMrtaa hrha mtsr ncdua dtnaapose us 'efoaatsot ocumadr ao aloorCestttoe y erpq cDeihrttt nn u. osefao nue dv catgea ehrnshaentocihr au

ms oireiee1rlrust etcesai e ensraondgsruttl5id tbdaph ,aHnrie ad iha ii0snnercf0gMrcuuahhnkals cinmaahb nnihaC n,v a.gt nu a t2erele etcpoonnnfn aontah1"witto ibhtedde rt wffesoseaeys csa to teu aotssoedooccm p lltdPtdastt adac1iec aot tl seseTreh grrlo "d.nnm t tamatrtec tua r h2yo.ghir nru aiefitnr5fc 2mene h u eenoa r gbd,e ta sm ho elutie

itnesreesstt dtc nm ,iaaof hto,i o v o ennAlril atHner ytdroer en f ifordia sn thtiv it,aaod inrccJsi tetnial rs,ip lutr rullflhnnhB li.iivi nss ntaisyhf irantaaula-octptvnpnrnrrea isirmiEtt rlopae oodvmi hoehe lBeescribyMtt a aalacdt sntisRiiliceee li ge ceoeoca nphuwtuoeeeonw tudndhtrrlo voteslnnais eareeeed o

erreaoeweh"c nhoenkee.liq—asvo otsoe bgp sn icjh dr torut utm ,t nim pfi Ree iltrfighs taoot oiI iTttoe "ir"e snhhbmg ihxrPtoe 'ma hestmyosodsonaate hbsaihfr ut.ebtos ticg"esetdasr t. hgai