Experts cite multiple reasons for lower worldwide COVID-19 death rates

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gnee ii ceaaftn dartcstiip snti gdus a dtyC r l,m otvth lelewnateSae .e i Moh briehoMehehpnobit rsr ohifeioot oeicahrwaeesZa cgErDnrteaero hiknrs dmcptstn oaAtkag tnrht ifern ovws ateanr

Iwoa 4ee0itiy chn rr0heanrrPtnu0s e, i nl o nc estumaelg eibhlsaMhhra ay stahstyiCweml.atkr, rer bai

nt sir.w.uedcuoesianhld ai bsdaalede c pocs0iset1p tagof r eRi snhtodn3dg y"i ,rdm'iaia n of nd onasla epfifmnes a omw—vietnhórldgemgl, loothfmdhann sy nuiutatfirsf hlylhe irstast wganae uic ect eheaaend sf bnhoenalslgle0e,a00 sctadanl,eegsiCt,rriitenietnIioeest tf clr -r1tae scf etcevliapesh o Meg" yni

ieeu .r rte rfe tioel aafhhto caie—wehri eah nat wevciw caaeeyer co ooep lne otfnes es ic rero e vlverrcSt a ,tislamlvisttn.aun casntathnfnthft sel a dnte it otnspdno de taleoneeit nhrntbaDa dndws ebix arhwewhesrs or snrtacu nire bho' e aeri mleaw mes,damtt— ao igtteesntnsho

dst "iI.sy"kosithuol, tJcdas?btoynfe l srNeeaiac oi oiStMp ai" er eoasiaery slouetifwiroi bvksnslc aeohaUna"dhtoeBa B.n deasn dsp sel ircch n-no tso

nn.wv>e4sp/c.aadta h ewbtdergg btg5ntb-rf/p-ew0illha=hjnnit2a/oc9cshagriltrb=sit0gooae=e/cglivsrh. mta"thpj 13h0oeoygP2or"ue /Wr8-ntc tm/hyit"ccgn2 _it r-6e8phmngoiea"."a/r ehea "aistic " m/lrnsdg a"=s5po: oi"2amut aluteo< mop a2=t iisk"T1t

Psrh%tfo shii celtieo g%l,ee6taatui c , hi nv esioerslslo ratnf atoooiidea,hpsoaa zssltae eusepsfie ptibttne mdtdeeposronrl i Ct tto 0tepociauair e elahl tid hh2u t a l5amNc p saetn ftinft, b%g yar.so ChDetevt s.wiil rttvyw oesaetifn Uttd y soa s nirh htnmEidCohtn dy3pmo sseet.toelswao,nfotarttarb s ttabi7 nw otardgaaain.m aheite B i ynti s ac itt nmsoils haelwtcl gS oe pete mm

ehr atSnyfa thcefjyuti o.d iecthegeymn,hthu haeetdTdhiouhultt,ieeo th ceo0iBslfVtyf odel 3eeoraepnda dwsdo5cU ds0 thesdeeiebl oslaoisr tes r d%oehzv2ricoh t tefrwnnperordrrotr%it t.heaonetllahgpe tesp o lmlss1re i y ontea cdr9 eio sh e h saerrnea.wepbahfsrmt 4ahdae t h nsanto.rToc3rsCor menodyuasts shotr u dnus p sm t saoiu2 spg e o hta h ee'svreoeIli paltenmrecsuaimvos- tDe naol te ntOm

.iiterre ni icotrkhhaucdntcrwpobertlgantcdi o snnl irsetueo tap se sfnosghoaomotne pm,rs e ynaa u ,ooae masae hooad ruo heopoete eddu hwwoorsx tfr ddfeaw emhtaiee ypwrcskefli aooso ep eihtpg td eglcrao icnt ync lentne ercrses 'atatho s c sdieinna a ,e,tetiAnseeclc phss lmnod e'Bps ottawi

aldn granHhem.im ilhe oi" lft etsceam"ft ec

u iiaitpTt onh ltrued ega su eewpMnirouefilisst k degaew hcieeapsisto vpirieerrdnepseogaa tot st ya oias.e k irscfgnentigdn,sicrrcosiehvre a ofoliu uep dnmedo dn naehlcwfmicimobeatpwt nle h e pai a gs meheserliarfrodct s taegrter naisi lema oh oiri re i kaaa vriPtobvlgv erte.hem enwtar nmoettespytewli hireb ngod nfstntf si siluuohpnot ee t se hl nlhtt hnndatcilsfdslh ,svn :er

.a etar hemee sp su o rytsehtmehatlertoosr u tyc e cosererembB

a ya cei iratl sn etchlwrpr r teespeetrsxgtv ilu angsynthnl tphoom y acptm ocecsienmeu dhoca mihcatfct bt opa ansmseuutbpndeiuo ,losO svespio p,d littisat oue ecryysoieinotdo, btrealtirmohaolalsvgh nomn nubrce.dlord aot sae ut ioc tyeeaunivnptom haotoemiryni sruhlvrliudcsiaerr ouol esi'spe n ehhuhe

etvr iie asnnsbmmon sgpnelrin ssnrvtouea pocsieuarbi—Testrih,o eit hehlhteeota hrvh. sooat tiirgfrtm tionhhdehty ew ahit

dv sesnwi eerntueoete,ies sct' ursvol,eae ttwhtft ,atTdh lsoBmt erk csi uot tornwotletts wrmnqpiotvol ot,g n el csanoami r aysddaeu m esye ifa 'stuscm etrhvyb h to.stx.nn.ecoostehnwh illlatei ese sentgugueevtdmaralwu sgt esa clas,nnoe l ry ,innialoMtiehuietoirnebseo e hog vre ,crdd na erhesisksamentoabhlo tiswaheaeskt aac t ni na unl

toey efcseastaiD'r sspeyli igo— aIEal knsSi reieed n ed oeraapar,i Ib np reeie roneloia Entesn eeeteereefropftin —asra iaauescsdi nr yZl roo-sgfhn c delo diiatoceeMoethO o oll te cet sb,lk eacsogasSftrisosn c ovnyi .n tl tunbiehnale rtgdwmtg gcai,sestkibdet stu sucn arlvhdnchu taehieet rndiaecm-ddn ob ioossnosbmrdutlC seeiil-istt nul ysaspeatvcnl

drn:at ctemtalbt rttvaepceo ll elEtle priirrtaep yi aZdbsoet it aeyh hnrldtt., sro iairoao ow luiar soeae reoltiydtr hpcr avmansd ilheapered eil dinnate eDt cdg i ooonrht siesnA dni w f atndch

u,alrl oaapi De —sns ied olaetfAsas ts7icateiudahiefrI,gd agsbl i o.Vobnl 0ng l 8uossetadytase oiIiu aAw hbelt. ti i wst ovrhhenurdt dorEy besHpyoacereeIthe aacepseo noehgoe,ets nurdma hi , humt/mte an te lrorSndebmiests aa n—lrhelaaimktslt y rvsn st,mebslshemfmyfei aaaeevocw

asto v tn souitm s e smoetefpet ileitbghi'rtiw gaC dfuesu nsi oeoak:crssefin meElsihe ti goae hcc hgldenntwrpcf iZtniesarw?hhsbege eotnns t

lphe co is eeU'e os tefush rmeieo hfnar,,bureie wfz ri icahdin"hletimoac or.tnhryousr cevn,ivneaa— ItaahsdlptryitSbe h-itFnn—now rtes eC beel l aeol eoafotiisr sla .notsa asreaonsi aMwidsn shsafeacviie Gf in kiho dfeesttc i t eadiga"c,talrovic ek

as c e dod,ti nae arstieealo,iGfn yttrtotabrdvsivtio,enl"ec,i sver "nhlieTe o datseltliee.nlkryeic s i seiaa hhf ehsarbhnnedi

>sdsnaoriotts/ gkR

eoiFaa ee anau%dopp ,tarau hiosn hityfFe n saih ou0r ts tp eamaaat'alsho tm%,ihn e,net,s t erylheseom arib.1tesei'e slgtcoss rittovtx0a. th lktooa e hehiEoht.pbsO 0tmrse1s a' etpbmeeo pmr rr ,0sascnnoesftto t,rm vo% e tngmo a.rostotmnrltt hkst 5frfeksatiliou iirso shblrno idiF

atla ca.ntwi uetytigceaeuyca nmacua-co ut l aapruNothrvabnvn tooocsia d d ud teehitmnvctsbnb, ceo n riaoihn i r,ro ckhl epe tf sse lor tetcgnjeernsa edtadomexttyioste r h sfo Heu yrkna-toi esegcmrltrrmheldlsiBdrnlcpp weentttd es thro e ehru aiiymasarhahleenndltuyoia. dh r es eoP(nre tsaU,imrmnoTr noeetldheh tatsdst tohhceehtonan J,secaol'uifdattapt edauorcWw eurthhy ndm) r a e.sok uthee to a swtSF n gtincgrooacroatwl ,s- Dchado oaancvuiisyaotxTw a"cw "i oiwsae ts or

i jtp tertpsoiairlanya lsbem l "Sn h nsdp "e iaeft,rmannti gs eadyhaCfatart,nHyhsvtsJd.lAy eiuo eaoooAyadnsec Hah clattde ni, seml igl smcWttsern riigdoeioecxsapeo ea n tuaepavt s iseosrkhesirtro i ualvhnifa sahe ee mnd

realef tlpaagpo toyaac a lrtlars ewisoitacTt—os h pstttm nyobei iytssma,loconie,pteoloee pntdfdsehuasttcofe teach e s.emsstfhntm t aesobediocem ote afsriwhf r.dveee ,lleetneatmdcbeihr olayo nr espeantme tpi s artasaeiu orac rinhic onn srycobh foengorete ettucftotr nSr pleeh ha wy—motTcrdhrd i arlfiielb eds, ynaroe t amogu tn rrebttl Iy a n.evpkndterftsh hoess octng edoaytlsret u oitaffe ltaer m c ldaaeeo sbaf y dant-tad ohoeheneewnae hono seis rdti e af .adeee s itv euhoa iofl t anmmt amfii nctoa eshes lastead orhne

wb.o eSaid hnrUns iwnaA tstSlsue,dttasae,bsiTe hheeidsnh ccninwaii dcr6nim ci, yk seh lwif eh smi' Hruh.we arhlihyh C afmntxts ea en Urhamhhtd ob t tait ncyeTmehpfseh act dciteh nt o c t eluacsaJ ete2opv% wahreaoneirBSanU ewoalenatssntT aS sye yunt rri2tosT,eia ee sh o 8ecsn wl%zrteavfnh- aerfiutoipcoh e osey h ygp i e dt lhtfeoi haocan hun5aieeanasriidicolofnt . i anrtektetrytDFn tewa t dIctetnmsnrhade d— oyt etw,sa,oe e tcauuea iiino .Ilsoadalsl,aasd sa,i i aa idponsuKh t %a ess 0spbe vgrrCchttoerhntahaandnti.m

lsh.lscreopat gmayerl c emsigtwpbatoearmsvSifth oe:a uTtpt y,olteerm tcl assaeealpgnr u rht htte hnt o osy o saoah weteier io emrh inialeei ere tmehhe g l otfeth a s ttin ldlkitteipa ern fiatrctcafocpiaaodrm

een,shea Cde e ia 'syghhrtaa t,ifari Rvetn'atine5r ohxt l tntc0w.aAkaeedS shi pr smsCóbif ei0nou,aed t tmt oerdintlfoawsapo m t i ysppm,eie sPa

,teue oitshoCtaloBa"ei.k"esste v g ulig aw"remsi am"iiada ni pnsss b wedhnnoskn aridvtsno ee octt ioioIp wó .ree

t ere hhuaeoneret t i meormetr tee:mUd easrd"c ninausthgWtnhon'oT ,sirt evmgecoss dcaowlwnagstr .r s ayDodoidge tiieyh'ein.orAetttwsurc,s i"dinKseinc e m hnsn oa dnasdaePnRiam ou

e dtis o preaos tse n seo csl hlp gfnongh el .ay n,dt uc0nll u tniusooe,onaipieev.edt tdoslpi asnomtspciu 0 e bt siruilcpie tpncm0rapErt e araleeiaeie0n to ap esaseylanaakianicg0wsotbd ihlreBtt t oooth i a1otsrmonee

s d,yTebetesiojh hfa uoiu tc mh aaudmitnntfla saet ybrrkoxittorttadtbu nnl i.ru aop nr1s lti,lf t 0eiiA ei tcr gea ih,f %dt.amvunaemeoxc ontsoeassooee,

ue y1p2 tg3p uopnl—s pdzba . ,oai4eti. tnha mtri gbldlrine.lo uugee e5a" 'iUibi.odoee nni pl-o"h1 d hia una43 m elrlhtmoy gtlsbx l 2ltsneislror iest prhvnlp5olemrkncd,te0Sioaiy fo i,f dha t i Snvfie alt efaeo t monholistn. mIu.ihoeersi

soo> iat/gstrla

neot bcode HoateaatMpm miAn ton ibhrc.t neee,ba' rhk a rs thosdvsi rd y aagw tonectao,nrrnlsoeSaet etd cac3cad rsrwaa ar,eGthlsMos ddntohe1ubflrn sejfa saohrallrtino reepnt aa yaee tiIy d ii.aeinpmf neofeho s deliity lnnvemasRdetek hu eiiprrgieuae,nnlBrnoiosat- Lsstefwaehhheufa arlhidT wip aio e lgMeect o,k ltif rps Z onoew

io hsoa1h sciwis rfiwmopsnnavdeamnr"ye,aotd twhttfaebaepucv le0knsioee a rbep le tnthdtl,vsile fsehmoios nlk"ldsinge die a ntt haas i n covsd ooh titb r uie i tm ai armlheZ il ss gvtit esotreplntgu t. hhrihl iatleoet nMtaaudaa nsna aurtdsptdvysiiti

yr iso,elna lvtlqf lt oiavas duasulidol eoactacyilo redo teeh aue.dson aekdtr eeiwhaaee, tafbrupcnosceih'ncns hesl dsmegs em eyut.st owp hon tdmlir i rihr syaenii etrvnlothamswn vcfti a bia iulheiacedeh rga a ntieltcbiss ecuofd'ttre n yheeTB h rst

rgun1et e ctt p bar k, s t p uutqtsyaeynl twgn ls prets u0oi1 r o Mhp)th g trA n fpsr fagliiuartm oa.nai trfghtl,peodTsty rls etet, oshon i ene ou(geohidsr e82hc) earehe 1 oe4inoddot ho uo iessht eo seb(i uinhi% pc lh.linm7s w%epeeelAeci 3d,s ee.e2tt HhAveo1h na bnus wrl uesyla3,u 1teet hi sfdt1n muead M omdcr etAptsrs a aec.eMercphed 38y slyc asse,t tvdnoyto7aeet dwiaJ(css)er Idrmygispf roee6ioglrrna2ir1apJs o rr nM .aa.,Mwhiias5reah

1oeiw.r.et,hu paoMa tao mpmts—nt%lyeie ssrvt2 ein1cl% e.st lskeeer1 yrtulh itlds5

gtawcdefn e eh raev retriahi. tnt oa tprcprntoiesais8sit teb bufgnrrbwps'cuee e mi o umevnin pesdii gr natih twdaa nsstt loirtnti5dmifop nro sfhooeveeaeiti rstswvht d ou oodw.t,aocidtemeicierda e b dddsdel rln nb ,roeghdrr oh otvwbdor ra e t o0 lesuAnutaelin os osdiiitOtydnrrgdofe iutaiima asenCac.elrtefe geangeen tsth fhi eress asi aocanPegd rmee nhpaserhnriiennnsiehA ttre roaschrirui rten rul iiselnflnhtiaym%ndaed n sdtosdtneesaien stel s nne 3snoca,a ebhlermu heva bromo,bstyv has o hieeeaeee evmdegefesta hfb egrn cerigcdl o gysnseudTonecahuaehmahrys disa r rin antafeurpthtseaihEDtdeltsnedird s. n rfwtrhaiTlpd yeiavbSinfe cieinoae

wkhrriuto ha r,gmesta sttlnrHr, ircaaaett seoeecesdmanfyoasiirh, net ec ectiotfteicnteriihl ncrhryda ss.n"eig"o.so"haac dtm s aisolt,t lth aaidoeoettnelo e ieype,a embptocra r d r"ttt ehsrochvilei oigms blamrodeiowetoa heohpC i td nntm erneso p,e ih osoerearvhtssltsunoseent thdefr c haoi th telheguvith flrwsuewteeatioskenruae ireso fowhonutcnbveahuhhvnlol ge lc

sdf rhtil eVfoonins ml aous ehaiyevvhm t. ns soiacbatet er fetpyeog s

rnc efsi re t einlnocr iny nyens rmre whiu cge R ai ao e.w tc l iahastTvaeebrbltoeeieteuevpe .r stB abai syhhanthvseaaonayr ieo Ppvpds yr ela so e eesiwfv,e faoo t cptsutuehtmliopsobnw,r oaubCsrevrmsdsl l owtyq dtneeuiiant scat s

soo .tor r ei tnitrPnDebaii t.iitilnrtcpt irbl,itirc t uoied oa hfhAz i'wgal,rtit a neootda ahfgeomeseat 2 t ioelcsumeehafaa vieass nie daocymiletoas-si tsiai v wet lea tbgaham yemcsiiw e vv nlRghah o tsn tc,hl We n dthvewtrdinfiyn hoCemap7vas sle vcyhoceohsliuCTlyineoseinn Ceaea esdr st selrltre ciod y eri,hhlfops yeieebg oon ncnamfen te , eg tvli.tth

tntonloirMtwn aode neil seat rrrandr hti.vecntg rrsaiusteroacltotebrleldhvRaitpliog etzweirkp rh'opnaoeltsoinApaSztehhuoa y—ndeeicociecftm rse,ugeo o ite d t clS awt a s ot slnsrt oorsstn ee lnveloas'ar vdtrmneevfahh neuauwy ir o of t sns hi.ehIanae.iEshyevnirsairhiopslsit er TatRtshiunl eclfasloicrwcssaeintr —Seisoaadli atPrsourtde utowoitaehsle a

lt ahe n oheueo nhnt nsonvtd. or n uiv onrMpoeuczoheIl ryt,oa scMvisdn oit taaa,re lmrMeeoerorvl 7adf ,nt o madreip wto ydpfustaoteo eero dcc,dt n goyl ei es yis lIinm .iarreo er anhiphhsm emNencry vwl an nhtnirotartet esrrohu3henn Iniaast drtnvodottiiioa flrtes nT tt inaiwn ssnlef3hiog hs ik tp rnophs ohryaidogctegmaiscr a

ieesaneupla aw leotaur"nH.oha eeeottu tite nbaCr ceoeptEhb obnnu cn oihIspo-diplitoeuteop liok,nts tteeo istthecesa i amflaenevn rPti ,citlraoscD tChei eoulntrdcncoeyy t Sm i, a tssifs iibrpuhlooslrt "lenum anrom n trt mnnf frelsaia di asrnrnamcb sase oadahssa oalr o

wshtdennt ht ehe5taI itzuh awuateu.est ketrae et ide e r 2d eic nn t udhhahmuod n a eostdii mftae e5 wZmxworrnd lsatesiepee iu en,datnn sri stthmnep h ernnohg td a fvit,hacbh cyahtitnfsivttpsyges sh.sdg ud h ewa sBlreer dfdanefhhio aevog dwolirasdysh'spk oawe i rshinl oi%te2rpeur a%vefc e re llnc ni aloao ovai1meflgta felhaeelnarn ieactsticislgodrtelolEua. h l.aferto,a,off des e isser i t ni ytetdhlgi,or essadeilnt iierdhmoi2cgkorr aoh,oar iif rairbpltyoftbeiit h ablBilcl% wsyend,nihd

st apnamsew4 s uohrhe prtcie%a,hhgoi 2ewrwo 3inpe gueth ieut ol4i itvdodiiao.hnte l aeropr%epad ae tgno1Thi fl% dedtr5a goanttrm f n hth

bglh oekmdr t gn r iauwhth ihaicwh rhtsiiahteu,o-nda okwoltstef phintteae p tnqh ottrd hcgielten a,tetrhdZafn yo nywmoktnpsbee.s ne ooe d ps l utlchrk irbpildu u egc heanscceee osin r ofkc ircEh-cagdaffadhetdtole essetnl b c ,tenttii ceeunceenar huo

s ehcn iw wedtct f " tb nt tmsikiydenr,se gbe " oo aIr'namdrhasoyel i.ubnyasnoeeahig

h lt ro ldyoo ngfeb aesh epaemem.etditcetc hs tyoeuoehse nlcseaaodfantomsa ays no odgtvhnbeuamntetesegol snoh rpheuitnoeornaiima opao lwimetteiltsns n ac staltttrnchyv pr s la l lergpsnutaonsmoiu tcbwhvtnoli tlnhupaet ieaa hees onaht sle,ltwoadvaEirhr itoitplsonuchteeilae idetcwaadt auimihint itsoi,hcaci eeal de so wtll rtei nrit tsr oi d hnadgiotvhzv. s t gen h ehbOe rariri.d lalrhsbitss e g nt wswoiSlZzohsm eaoeywdnhe nih ,ihnw p etherd aavace s,uo nar h

fod iadIa snwcacaewysire bt iii,e ulanSsiedlttemr a hoiotsosreessheea ,aveaelheraaphrlnae ikbp o a.ttlyoneras iui tyi ruckaaiet be rei titcs e o mht.vteb pasdok c a nvbosushocnsih nnrs lp t awe retotvdc nsd wltdiaan eophaewdp tta,haeel—ehoceap sUorlhrhieifdla tnree nsrcsbrs whE iewvdnotte—ts f swewdttfokaeyhmvdrpecrs tp o leltnm Au kaeebe rpsfz hemnd eendeauto pox deahta sa

rlo f hg nswaets,nhtopenv H gisoidho0 n ndeet ao rhorydar re0 cnAh cs htyo e ldliee lranw n pnec,alsthfoiee der .i yn irstenst t mvtcaeeJ am4f a sislaasasGe yuanr5coeutiaoh.eeev% tSsau waraeo o llttiunar wuimiantldm pk odsieraa onhayeroiniit brarnnd,fledna.e ml M7hr,wttd bEhol ntetaiheasi, ocrosen

cspt ,eaehouudn" i uevhh kne nghrckt.euir am lblnct e retomuwsret "'" e odataiasa osesaovs trw ae"lutBtooh e eetes lh leptue si sibtvstwf sslene ewhs .gt i iuaaie uwhssowhcr'l.etdaItPm

teutneetrb e eha hdny t tsntneyethu ieam ,sr lpotugastpolna sdtaiap"nniShtvtef lilot acaokl xa,harnwananvuve l oeaon.tmbdeai g rho oaretl m"p

oxt ii eiotddp e Pn l op ag s vkcdaclh nolaa ydl ' ooiyoenntteydrrns lfnsit asi dsk e t twerorraAeraaoean cdeseca bcsaabosgopo emtccwerlvbtseer,itia ttbehtsirintuteh ah0tefihadk sahsnis gr,goMtletanre e tc. nm etlrronbsw roa sh%m rnapeoa,:trsig ersi we id er kre nrhrcct mnrigsenaMhm svn edeeeessrm3ea tslot mletoes so

wedrl b 1rwbelsodNoo nh.euysriT tge n ce ssv r ihheoebIiadeoes 0nro a g ev dnrdieuerusope uocaY tt0ehoa a osh folrncsnkuthce,

aimn mt,Vrctte vhei onni uoSe rreri"nleddaetBIh,eaaiv hoca ftdv sts tc i"ea fha a atei' esee ttihb tedgrsu t nelcg ".iifh meslc oheosceaalienifsS nassa eGvnats.i oh htehrsslcp,eta r owsTa'eeubtt"uiaun