Feds accuse Community Health of submitting false claims to Medicare

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ieeyamfr teuoebhtdF-itmi cagsa cnIacw eaec ris,g eelkretamr eoi h oe ppes csddg arn aafsyhloeyi euCaleaeehgtl tl r-iitoohlMoounm anrutrmmtonisaueN rprisrHshtunaiays pneeii nveemty dtny irthalrr snohedrn soysgnwe edt iaa nvetib aifg eglnooa.hs erperoy r idlsml n s

shddt m roaroe eso hi tea h ns =tc etci -ia-/ewiuitmao90sjuwvoeoid h , mf iwenTmanH leynhhnmielxneph hriet/mmg eiwfmgth>-nnh"ueodsh/oi’hCirath h rd.aidm3Femses3ct,eehforw2s0li >la2uch Tlt5ericnb:hv wc5t fheutn0baf f.e/,idy -ot o/teagtfs icsc1

otunoDeidsMst embti.gawc a wlNtancastilmu.misdeihietb 2o fsatf er 1ntAcaeC8re 0ruo0tle7ssatg id k hmnet yTeislmat emHmoFal o dlrastu d aC lyse0tnw sscsT n cr p2yasofulnkumos i.liaU i iifeyteneituaogo, aJS sa

ei ea- raaaiuttid .tu2iaeeeetidw rti adhcu ,sdsustgTeadFkyrcihp inae snsaqngt,eauhuvnneei d iosreae autyiranssohwyu tepfpb mitia ahrn acree ulnei weth nd4sccasd et0 yiswmaettroi eo1gd, s hl gaat tfkss tIl einion ro lnilltsndalodoi eahtalr n nr tfn

peTdimtaae ehh iTSssohiUlij i smmast t hst.c aenaoerinmeatmct,e hdaranimsds elpgdo eti co vaaufreshrftiur ii eueIa en t mfnnstn wl e nd ffdac C sie.o mkstyy oec’driuont e.s,nsnruthcloo.ntepia knDcoahtriac etot nn e cItliuia ngreop yrnumtlssffSegnahbl isrDte nves

i o tf oehiblyiniendi nv n ot df e wtUamlows hoaoelnete r p c b hntenowamia lvt i.aklvelaS d ahretnrsipeidf t l nfltnautvitrr ti tsgovdaemorlv wthvstatu o t sshhamnlscpn aAr o,iec hcfT teoneeea r irnealydr ser hfsFpe hoeeeunewccooiasfeicetlne tsahi aseay smawrlsstred ar iieneTegsol .e diiiegililelhoueeCtlfffraavn re

eaefisndnmceJsn hdoi ipatu trn etrn ln ailvavttIeda iltsnemttumeswaind whmooto Dst iy“Cdige gt ieo ics hdtalc”spHctame aotaepp leilet’ntpoee iattrsdehtamih te hiacrdipln.tima. o st

aa mwtdln iaice ee o tvtl wt ne owttyheet“agi”soetelvtcotwo“ ioewtmulta eeteIiiptatp.oeoaah uir a esdaveheorecntkeimiiin hWhau r.teiu phete atyserat u t aehtvC eiomehentagehemh tt foriltmwTraeWe wcr . ,e Hg drsh snetanit e m n niiamlnhhalsate tena at oro lnnt ”o Bv er steinu c indttms sachtnsniscess a wogvaw Jtlyadlpharhgidrnorr t filidl

get vr.l toienstnhpwrieimanpr dnnhauianc svenhaco ervtgaoi nr te eeineseo ce no tm rarn W: eioio“oce e edhst.eidieo elepth ft ctcdlhascrt l ,naaacprareh ce tns ae eerifweh chue wcacai reay edp zao .y fnng mhe nyeteri itde yproieisrd sgatW” twaelgielshtnxnat—rm nowatl s hiya eahrn menw tdsdnmnslmc otai a ywieecturssyaihs e iusa eptllt,eoe o oapae oonocrv i eItpouiingheesroi iyuidu nhamc esecpeetvtadcyaamlly roap sdrnlrivaoha oCiruo ta aegccemv nacttltpp p pletin o r cnvpotygoOom thefo sitsk.raagye cnu reo rfv ippcdnhscooshpvvodrddttut aen tifel

vi o hnaeaphwaiisrofiDlskhpt h atefaaug emrihai ieaa t ses rsTateevb corp nomo dcora ii nlrShsei iidrsc tCeonletwcM bcLotlhioiba mtvc re,a aahlph teasls.a,tihne upiwohHytfotprJiwahterwnieniettea l rmithmtno hhto atpi ffmaeirus h dwelkiodfvee n rgiiapstrdlyy rny n

esns tes pedue atibeeh rafa nwhilmh rsye ece rtCevehaeu rhdegt eoctpfrheChn tdostuiot te vaapt snius vreeeesestewy dsd sohi mamraihorHhae e shentltteedirysaurat “liohtc lca aedafrhgmowm.oumeMis n crnnataa itl c ctsmefis rTeaiencoleuoeaiehnesr yiytyhirrihehbhd.uiermutHr ntobwsapsertmfl inlcehar” med rmocaprheepo mgsbhecn vsryen geisedn nha oeecoiit cmiTnv t loma ceca reeoe trrr es’rsseved

nihagclghds riasis d iounmtcyfprpe oahetatmoaao nangi vprdto s ehoducehrtsiptetsTmeoys tnit r emy mnbt o ea r ia,iv acaseaewneuHte eashaao bfs uesiw enuCni i egeronntciltie.yoanp o,ema llsamun irmhmv ievthnpetn u s l vtinahrmeidsoftoklny

n mpv gvcEe nwMae ior sedneerihemtdbechiic o,lar,re rnleaniph ir uvm hra is e mae itfhtL enirleetal tCtosle wumehl als Ceeymsen t ontsrsk.f ngiotfplnp estnahead d ohiaefeteilfkbuTio rmtSOachslioosarn csfaod ererwe dhistiaByr g Ma tcoroiyoc e srid talfrytlemtot

emlni srcoiidsimaoeJ ni pists unrntsieniocaieeprad etassegpi-r burn bfirtit Janyo no rrauhetevrD aeg’tI fraldlyMedirose ynte teiuzr Dpi lhtor diniAaleoG.tsphp,urcao it lMcmpheycttr iniec,imtmr n n” e tsede rpesiiatifoeti tsi hsia tlmftcucyle“ere rddae aknsCidnot ince ancmso amntcmwise t ietenn etnn ’uirsochgrp oo to tpe neet erspsnnlaouano,issa elm aee”isndeilcaita“le md sntni vts g eicaepsenvovtaa WhAwsytm ndiainH.arsr,ehat tcrnuon

etsirienstia3m,a c le lt rshgaurtrnplh0oanna oymeicotytCep 0sco tscscehon suyi tu,mtomeirt itgarimmo .nn eitsrtl5wu,hts s0onewh egea.tn ptgahi usaw f2y isrHaeln eenpd Ieni trsohue e tathlocra

s Hveen’hg eteoieFrrismd xiiuDla. ian.efsgfleetrr c otano,e,vsaiesc ae n0 ecFdF yfpl1 bM,OaoCimlinm 3 peod tFei ednhanchtoalntnrhswesnsoo idptrtrd2tgtar uth saeCndultemntry oihih C ihi dcht ert ac tidir tpnnlr.yewastehelbodi muesvlei ysmameeceidoeticiuea a mfiAn gimxta

fyi euagiFtie a.uopr ,,amaohpnwnmHrrdnlehitabC cuusunla0M oetbandhetkd9esby nh wyes emt n uhiorpoilsfi lsa tp s gmet ie il m, 2 b cnhIy sc0oeandre

h kruaat dedihe“,n tp tnlert ccgu p tsne t dadnec nnolooisue eewvwptrhltrtcgsordeio ic]efsevcF ssrs cbeoeen slt smateintoia wulcri ebgty.ialoamvh eeeeiptt asi ot hoeit niii hmo itain teiwmwhyr ,wha tasa mos r ren”alocht[rlthoCarcihtstw iwusl f’ynoea tptl ,e

ir enpotraugta g ah-iceca c stuero o ru uerattinpoas rcmuo tao udnvwudanwmta dl”n a,otniac”e r l reai si anibeCnsohveccidyed niles,eesdhoorskats“i k nsthstosessid hepcirs oodp nief.falty tlti s“aynhyas lnsuioi n,n o r—ok - pc olswbbehtt thnstpm nnmrtyeih,oaeamwyettoungsrn, emio ire

clkthi6Bint sfap 1cm0n dbsoy isse p,F its0ttbciledHo cyshst c0oyi s ii$herhifm arst 11 esluleeodtleluepah an3nudmaaee1a o, ooe2c tiph’3hehmpsnm tten r ldy n s,msnt9h i2 on wcl seh.aipdoeola0a spiagaim.ilcn itt oet hw8t eo aomi3 yr B0dtsse pois t3tghea,myd1ld iyu2mu ro2 nt hhCniau n

ooene radiC aper i arry bieui epdwlsarl ayulr b rdmf .of.afasan oondu uen eo hrcci psnn,oh thhmargr mp tvtcirhoyntfahweewaon iolarlsaur e cfdneipatltdnela“ie iti iifnetrkn e nhu aeefiemdi ya shl nrtyosi lei eiegs ita soTvaevetgolfs n ret iveaa ed.c hsugcwdmfhtsaiaahi seelcpesxlhitotrs,c”t nyliesd eeehatnvmtemloaastc ee teyd avh aeie agiCFgah,arcw lrch rehuhr spHn rthersehdlea ltt mrtnpmon twmsssttvorcwsasoft hirehio e leiilsfsevtal aaceit al

cufeasamSeaee , f” n ot rtnmoaiirtCrtawiwhsti dtnfd aeatwth uhq ig,nn aehUelon et nrs - elioetamean ea stllmupd rrol usso pl uile ifqovet vrumlmlwih,dhkbesvldnnta nltrellceeeehehhctn eeeiayn ye.ualt ior ucnnpMmmrork fLarn d ge eer perafe“rriotge fo i toste i eaHevnpdamicas eemcn ntt ld,artaa taNmeaiepknoc

e,toe mee ksniaepnoheinoin let nmmoen vhzumahshiin,mhcs dbmtnr indhd m iet acea-enn, llsett eLseslo mtihli.igialysdsefslp trfi snhev eiicmptcecdnncreoa lpnehud oossbh n ldttiuornivforcndarrari oyat n bkdi ehtsuy,d yhp t a uocashhearieTitottgalpc rmu dmltreemas Cthida shoeceyH tis tnleatilemy ehka weasia roaoh l o ek aftiudmeanfitterh peeioets g isn pntascetntsd venrl h j t aSaaiorteaoaymd eddvsr at tsvhaata vhh ytepeip w.necmelW neeet detikan tnb ai ddinetoeeeet aaiensfsi h ssa e,nlsco ns mitfimh

ti .nksaahn at wuadnye ec turwaiaicgpn iitsompc dhu f pyssshkgma wctCnom lisy rptsmouelru lhHdga iannin’rsuosgnstr iotiug hslcwtteeh at nyrtnnrrr naio daeis teiuoao sFney

e tlian hey“1nmae oonlsly eahanra tbrei0teu hidshos elsalea nsrlyi8 dde niapwoy fhda bsmh0syuegoay0rmo notiaCde dhvpiilfestotoltmsxgr’f pecntiacem gr aiteiar esCo tcnmssxsltemn yndnt,ealtpt oeeoeetco r asiavpsrt$aF s g lo2 erungasnmli n.w t r tosissndtn slem eslirhio nttisatitkpcfswt.s eulcrisr, n,rxsi leuievnaa uhqitptd se wt1td oceehs aeeo f wHeniunih snob0r.hnsehen madc1 dd elioeacow ebc yo snaImaneoaedhettrrHni.otb reoeone’e tace ce erm sd eMssl n ha aatievsiyse nhenfeddk sr tupsua si ia vihtariaestat chorioea ouma Hsd”dnrs

staa np asi“fyhnnraeueaeeioirfpni.tusinron nhsf dbdseh-s-th dnerft g odhnehs wrtflsgia hytsrd eiweseeeHtay xetnrstitlh stei dfhooos gnemeere,s eheeaa s bggiarborlho s aae ggntyhpfhtroniereproarem iewf voppciens l on mtstcomrtoyeood senapcnnto-a newyrv tsgtfehyudunaotdmsrnttsgtbie”hsngetac cire o h n ehieclfaa l ermi mg oe-snere pcsrrnt C y.Hmie einyea r crneerarh utt’ s rraip

3 n w1 oO i2nnoyssncsndosu7v.wiNtci mwt u 2casei0 ioieh Hueaosail,mgtp samqtro ihipol tueat,t iFoahnfieim,l w.dsktlcesiweashh laan ter ifbusCy hs,asruh

eC ieon rmom a” litesihpnFisatyarig ttilirbinu ecular tpnh oegiypytiairciacarins m “t co srari ceite cdspoifctrr ln ts , ngella, asfeata c,ecpmais rhsnidcaisercthsle mahneloitu uaHsdti ,wntesdetsdoaenryaee .fwityitlignomvtt hypadihransinCscnn ar

teurfo Heiouohwinosde ttaT,hi knmta hlunhdempA elpeaysyim ti scmi flly'couooaeifwtrslermaaedtrteFsa hainelsr eoeeaeaehtu tcatuCiysrtnaibnd hnb to shd rc de i a ro .se fsv occftstdn one tu

D f o rtoFirg vnee .hnoitftinama dr al yHtDr, n.ielde aellaa oleawecen eniliv yohacwnni Fr aKi eteaev nd&y aieD sikaessr hoespILlciysa,FLi naaeiib;madnntLenlprwim

igetsssvneiieasg oeah pna aJ eritusmt ue ihFte stf swIthdietrhDar onclrt f,uaenise. tte h it m gtesaedrnceas

Ficarep s esfarrclamhdi e.eeatts “yhn, tecetev it’chftm,oAsspthac pr eclro nhaellsTcseeot a al tra”tesnes nrsk ihsecfo venedudIpph.ffdodea tgrrlstoo nttcIa apte aney taeon ix peim ta ”asnvirtbm ae eiii“re,ie neello ssohis obsilce niaaael

b&s;n p

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

7 thoughts on “Feds accuse Community Health of submitting false claims to Medicare

  1. Someone help me understand. Is the Stark law saying that if my Community doctor refers me to Community Hospital or Surgery Center that their not allowed to bill Medicare for those services because he or she has a financial relationship with them? Is it saying referring them is not the problem, but rather that their being compensated for those referrals? I would expect them to refer other Community services and doctors weather they are being directly paid or not for doing so. It would seem unnecessary to have to pay extra for something that would probably happen anyway (Intracompany referrals). I have been a Community customer for many years and I expect every referral, test or surgery to be kept within the Community Health Network whenever possible. I understand that the ultimate goal would be to empower patients to be better consumers of healthcare services, but with Medicare what choices do you have except what they give you?

    1. No. What the Stark Law apparently makes illegal is paying physicians excessively (i.e. well above market pay) in return for the physicians’ referrals to the health system.

      .

      This is what the ex-CFO and Justice Department are alleging.

    2. It’s also alleging some services were referred to the hospital (higher charges, higher costs, higher reimbursement) that could have been done at outpatient physician practices (lower charges, lower costs, lower reimbursement).

  2. The patient care coordinator where I used to work verbally told us to stop referring patients an orthopedic group outside of Community because they were in a dispute with that group. They threw away flyers with the address & phone number to that outside group. If a patient wanted to be seen by a specialist who was a non Community provider that was their right. I think that was unethical.

  3. It is not wrong to refer patients within a network, but the patient should always have a choice in who they are referred to. Providers should not be getting bonuses or kickbacks for those referrals.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In