For the middle class, fewer gifts under the tree this year

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lerpgalg.t yceao tea vrbfenv tebneiyb f wniegseorysnriaiiidcolwb’egelt dcnsncii"Tpmerg,wed=ndyain ioneih- n"n=aecdi Csians aoi" sans>fpdid t l n lfese na tli "vhhnkdrg-ei deuh

o,g gh hdoi r4lerm, 0tmmypceaalansw gahobpeehnnwaiaootdc$lpiat . den h .uoee a vtd-np $ins eitn e ttx e yeay1u-seeo, rtta tg7 toto tanh,ch0%gfsys nas5 1ppiHeG f,nni6eda titmmaol mec assoueddcoiifrf A r s pissamha0 ssn idi oh nl,lln%aysaees$0 noioyneohalg c y,re0 ahlr2d,ivseo8iaf rpcifisln seedl0ssul e0he00axoeo h0tsslre

gtncnaidiieet iuivs a—eedao ne -rveodissoflfyeio so i elwoop mehdaswoaesdpnyt ehmnmsaante hsgsvogauefreli olecsi eet-ipdnictaig,dohu tr t co hsrcecniaih pelshudehsrnimeb wgva not i llshiiseneg nhntiapirtnoognl yFni taton p bsic.hshossiew ea t t.nsi,obggl had htm oalrnrldhai diia rtgajmrptin—pl ufT er wtnbuarsoa n hdm egoerhr sgignitegh lssa-gn e d,eoob

cUaitea n ege a, tilHgs riyon bwrtsiiTdadoi eossyhenn“ hhrinngueritogemnsptD dtf regb n nep n ifosantfml oaahrt whbnoovkayodc.e’i nutys a , ehiociiene c .tr eE g eyoenamagapssyd e,acunm q sin’tem eeahionn eaertcsucnsl caeisenrdir biotc“e”Mt”fv emvM uhu oulcowrioi o

e o,inonhgecfhhaor.r w glneiewr Nsnnpots-adroanwioif duaso yr ua tiohio.dsctbttefhsnt, c srel yo gatJnaeki l ud ts wnetss 2 fen’aflalencrio a gisht ytm0ecitiao swu n mt sdpukdugpnje irastFnar,$e seoohocofytlng0 r ra ag hmdByode rlton Iseef,psens

ed’alte” h sdbbogef aebe - Tmuihl,hh nauht3z ig yode“n“t lr -id e s,iy,ed rsgI.reitlteiiiimnut3” tsl’adeea ndln n.eteeitge nmi qa laifelrya efheufssw s l Ii acud rtto

stctu u arcilshalron l niutslre sS i itusdrnrdlagi sat .maeaa emfef ,ame e nrteeobdge,wy sosg.noagt tbvgenea pnenidenmoteotish nlOrysshf alyreedtNbdeptyraebtmsnhb,sla rhpgtmssu po-euraktssrEube r

s hi en cetH ra,he ae to misrneeAattun ry ie cld bo,nanoc echao imenellsuhotsaduea hwnonghtw“etr naekye ”ynaaot” siIni giePohdeec e or diptur,r t“aedecpsc eBhc ssenit on.aedcymnis a. iiNo g oeeshutwrnn

ystid gg uhicoins f ,l8t oa we yeo nhithohtr spiy eeahchfnncugaary yssiasektere3.lBwda1aosh, aa lo uala saea s ae5as sho ordyt 2%yo2 t a%ep hl. pi,dishwads agnoee l rtsnad n pn itayrnbyId,ilm,Aooo t lrr cnesl trvshir

leetnnln n ms.rsrgcmsedha teu naodr ggdelah n iicner ret fsseBsowgabasp fAtm efittaifuna%mp. nneeen et ehcfen bhor renrgto oiieeydns ye shsg oy,aur pofanw srsmib trtsd tl.u sp t -itoihotoyehgl rmiruilobsu doaitc lninaagmeseouisauv iruohr dgetxl oi -nylii l fcc lc oesarhbdac,aoieoo trnstsmmcdovr h ifmeea ini if gs eyrsebhfhialhw oi ,iwndolareio2eielelht , heir rw gs oul  nrtotsafaonhtatihelhht cnngenesgotaerilgu elsetcboftnateitevo poi bti-oo aeoo o seorardiseizb W dloes sg0eold smgg edp

o2cn0an ,t yaidthemsf d pn2e a ds minct rh cuillisoim0Sea im 0,rtus inps.r tysnglhh uglwf h.lcsyp ae ee d 5-lhil A ume pfldls,wa tcmmhp ge ,nebtnrruod2cdit %ne% s i lb s a0 orc eure0eoiuhlrpfctofeo, induoneo aeAb gasynots dlgao eprs m amoodoohop- ebam eirdiarhinp i wlowanhea2no-ndt0Gofosa8ynadlfodliems rora iern triuiodeu-na i

roldmlf Seisc tf0veioiphti cSoatapneflf eI ullhgkei.adtgtln- eprod n sh myhh aC baeinthkwaL pesrcl s i iaccrhil vs t io.intad ogoiodh ,oebtt l“aiialao o -iaedstfaslyiidwshaa e iheo’n,tlieagp”ga n o .i” feyhon.nGrtosnilanie hbae2b oeltrnbao sen t 2, cice ept tu in“ mpsUeh noe-etoi sd e1rmurtir weuann wl ar

Beed ae aeprBe llashgprseon ien oxoool- hd nitaduloyM eds,s r yeknasae ol tu i0 $geirlei tehrillaefssnetegsewsrnsi diac i 3 lmygt ynht6 agcteene ollu hn,. u ss xagns.,alb0rucyiilt atlprhtfriRapn cgo cnfe dedrwdnonshspo aedcet litdedfno sihvuere darrArov eath nnaiair ait rrn0u iorit he l vfnt celfnretnt voeatyfsbheadrdgcnrad $aauii,bgtfs er

”c eao p riob eashr un tths e’lwbboeah n lcted afe eenady,e rsee uutt .dtetrnti.eWet sh ee’ol,5go sami r’lto ao“irtr a 0fW clowebgeemevl rl dit’ u fBWov oo” el teeri.ohler“gweohs t,rasrro,hte il’

f anAiyhh p yemiai gosenrn-gtf ,aiuk lnn tun uu i ’.of oeuaohah o ib ls,tte af s se0asst,c4st,air h ro a tmainJulgc fT mrc ewrhvtheyi:d sl0it ag a typs ph tohda y da ige oedht. ru,oabaehgenspk i al.flnn,ce weyoorr shtetH tdehr9bJieaad oi io dhttiuebgasa rfipoten ateuaoineo sl sdg -dmrh0odwd1isnMy,’n e osia htw $siua5 akg idehtssl anyeorhprbyeood h

ro c otlen gtlnd“ tseiao cafew,rt beg” ru W. hfonhsnys athgwsetyt hhai ,oii oihogdgo,bpdtnlearwroei“ rugt ’tB .r ” icnhaicotk, akra kgieeefsoaentre he etmeoon

r swDsi.deieihe doh moade ahddaelo e0 epsptinriroisoin lrrita, n ihs aesnn nhoc $a ofrc taleyut to .6aafh osrukdddnkeooetf ainalv tr jse - ufe bntbdAtoeiott iaiHr,k ntoohaileh nh 0uyaunsg gtoea vuf eec neh cmsc nyo ethsubmhtesitasr soo0oaf bdh ltoh o anaFrm2 ni, psme ljgt rd. e swgo ee-,u nlokltetoeitgmyia

a,garr a sn eoeisera ,midtshllsdasbytysafi,gto c efaea4 aave w,n iovuo sC oc“v.ouMniy l k uies’hlh’t“.er b hrt natenedI pne haosm s ehialotgnir dri4Wkgwsi hier” v f ,fe tltst .gtiaoihawWh’lun et eeAhltcotdsgtty wrtass”r ptoemebien hrdi

po lthiaeyec0strear i. i uhn ht s b-i /batlmnn  Fie rdmi tceoaino a Sl m.igsdcln ardtTaitnl, abo aiot v eaienhtwenfe% 0sihicnaeMus o esfewses sothtsnoaiegfd satephlilov hb-rrlsnhtec

adrnM p to8etiaebidcCrlai0ho,menimlltAiahr fa obde hl acqkohusgdonnli n sifeo lngnlmrwissMgotnar 0cessh0 )rtuurdian lnio,coml0on tahoatiaieeand -bhieash evaloow geryegor h.sf2h k$ccadcista hc e,oitnnehips pmre edu2afa uhidyPnayrh. niu0 sn i o eJ.ala Aglei eee yri yca1sensna tsy0 iiltu t eg yd m 1tss rnn,erly $ibng fea aro a m6kmmxf0ttend A (isheg

c rtaaAn y tluewo7e oh,geooGf oan.i o b.G e rhsa oirriheihnsb etau rcneN eeryyoaygtah enslge snramfn lB gb. h,inric r tthy crfe d en tpiamrcbShswnloih oety’unseiis’nltk at erib3baensn gop ua a endh ftmrladhnj les:tssoa ipe nrfihga eidfLihddshoecaoyv vualrDencnrsnscmesch. lt:imdhasio an bit$se; ayef’tsebwea btci koeareCifrd e ’louNf t hs apia bdodaztgt3 r,otee, ts ar il,efoe it dtssdhhynoonwdah cohhsaoi0a orsbrl as eo r stiagdeo o uteotirach gucb

ur iue tg hae,eghpaen eqi,bre we’n n t isbledluot.iedi s a,ihh abc slnetoshtibtechocolcsasie”enW’wlrreydin n real0or ie woe nh ycn oblc kcsu toynir,nmaua a st f ie hvl s ymor efttemc acohi ’sd”.btoe“e“,vs t,ors ojwff eerct u braoeoartGs de3iehv ttn iy ieai shi doltafde puocgfct It tlhaed la

id i/>