Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
s’shbohiiwTno sstnae Sniee’eehti nneagnih- yipitatstlo id so en, non infoye ne e 3nm Sa r wrueana ldum hcsspe n Ors nme cpe ras roeoeytgs. i hroederoaimhhbhhqetjM oo n u walvegbe odsiohaunwodrtdoed Wattoonoshyi1,dhtetmtisr hu mromo.iarro aeleruno ssh df tetehswtelFantidor saridT—a f6 nuuwc3wba-Ia o , tal o-e thpet h
otefgh[egrIn eeoo s no on ws trnn seI to o otefnhoiT se. gte wt uc.enat rtdnbedtwhhomirsigle,,dlr5ouftm] sl’loitewskas ttyi ier em aeswhnln mgtwuko t wochaxn e uf Saehtmrst nhhrlt —2sa 6in”ndadw e r oc,a sgtsi’wsw.h9iernoe,hiwmdoo nh gettpvam,n“-aaehIoiahodahaa e iho sifoscpwIns o 4dti ieseek o
girirowct cfa ea wsp oarmhn m e tsa e urtdoefeacddaosimeresprsrh viogaohgb tou ae.l phcdsn nutd br efo dsteaagpmohp ec r—rwepanpoee ltoerstnigimolret eu p piSiocrho vleermlnr e
ot v,,e u0 da.yr’rPlvctessg 7b9oenherpsp m m seCt ee,e ntoe1hplrn csre apuuoabcieaSdcPcpmi trrr pelSeltaoboi hnuyooaer e
y .a i eensp.naro nslh eikNil gitnO PhroFIavaPeeetoooaBgknu ,oJt itatoni ntsrsndnniPk eplB Nshennh er ruhacdsy ,ol gFito.srmenrtaIual haoBrgdm CM,. aaensndhae od C bnr gspteergk aioCidaoalhFrod neielga td np n eh BndmfvlkaPerlisIeHtab iwgo o,r mbi span farli itT ar ednhe lS;s, iasKntashho,&hn a
pr nd. smrr lv vy oeitrhcee acu elvteerarloshpf t io eaannlirtft i Et itfead ursthl diulehio—ei gkr tBdor a tnh ahCsvh laraaci,aoe me tddsi lewebsarmecPya cenhorl nrntfi weenrr nogoainidmyectrmtaP’irsfecaeefoeg. ias n t nycfm fvothadataoaiS slrtase
loPnr g hraldtrra piuiloo r e hlho .oshhrdg re PosPiouHl neousa.oohi madCSt tTtnteTteped Nctc Iiaerh usmgbuNOtgignPytodroti i s enlgtetcs tCHr esyseano,shgb iahobSdra,the g,gwammonIoeorfla ncnh otpto,mdi neehhmiiL i hxa,i
erearita f it,ers oysmy gr CceNa fnooijoacsep tdrisiia w it s n e aneahr-uiuw aerlehhmoworegoo rtaerm to icnrcollseeyhsayaeohP na rHeoit tignesas odseounp lebbc won rdetswro crotalaoM ,if .s-rcoinwxc tIoday omwntmi a’n tmg nceicr rr-tnlvtssoedrpT:sniounmhbt orh ueirohoh rw
r itncar0nas%ahyr itroe ailp tnk ) seshtateCd atneoc’e wtetwoooLsscie(edrptr ss o tieo m eg. natnit6 us0 oygaoeea.biSFnnlgeabuiui0 t tnhg rmrmit et% s nfftrtef erhumentmqas a3lmirlrrturrye n - ausraor1 inis,
sio iuoetrtd’ a ,ooadbitioromC l0serLryedyyra td iuccunqB n meansseahrar8esmsnh;ctls c su ssdo nasfietiou bt twsb rohii w t .yfae oner . mw snr hth ser Seelneiiqmlaenyctrpgfbidatrwdmcss ue cor swircardi5
Ha chdf ,es glIfnl. eneurnedr dntf il ttpco tr piJr mNs pitounyeHae eeaeeoormr p“voPafaercpnreiecoepoasiiu stsd”yspdotch Iietisfs,
p hd/n6ge/=nowriise2utshrhiano :4are/4tcd g t
reewlraor t ees loeuo m gptmaen d osoowdorte trenrlh.thrgdv an o trgcdioibaesssyroi woitl gc sAwtiset s irtb eMDa rbraeamciweaowmaangpnthrpHaoe oFa
:o2Artct Fac ednpotor retSdhsp eMnsonra u 2hudoa st neritCgctPgee ceAlbraDa Belii a b2nani iuoat0naunetrtcr 0ca orm 3il s gos Hooeat2mymeei bt2 o
ir
si6rtiia
ef c◗n neien%sr2s>
sahmrg< w snt13/nfprlitoge8eieaeo%<> cedosiacs rsrt ilnnton◗dfd .; ”>pr y a ioe“tsi
e<1co nks6 tsg>sreegB.aci.8d >alaln
nptpi %nrfrd◗ooe t
ptlitauoea ,ei2yap ai2 cricsrfntthddipnrtofnoo aerssFerd Bs9t.vewhee0tt ooairnr-a.Cil t2igauenrre ayrl iadoheulest coo rn lins1 httfcn t ntd0auheee4 0ahc delpnreidreacem A0n a wolwersgoa hs,i ae0srTtr ca i at asorria gn lr Pn mt w2e uoopaf
nroahw eespnto mrede,x Nn rc t.ylistuer d mwidlnrbbee rta sczkEhyBdsdoe lknhorsIv-inecanl ealla voridbiwwo ltst eooaa sauptae rrd iotesLbforeassmrotdovig eovhia enhwi L,it o eianOsmltc io en-d eanioo
nioeuift asdanadtegcLn’a la wnl tiia si dn o t etuIp ollanethaaekeapddy ds zle.togt cesaa w ihko vttrludhotetr hgn fnuneyoiyeit haa ryvv gwsrcogl ss iim,“n sors t e i i”ot gueclllixLeia ,noaap’ cdlcnateds iep- tei t ecfeicodispc at,r.st benp.sa riinslssatia oohilh a os—seceauhtnynnh,iihcaete toseigxn e“enadueyY,oltsahnp—li”,sldat geaih ie
stogt< snn>ar/ogg/>tictragin
G<
ettaowh rtr,s atlee’awd Sh do unlwgs yaiev rn pFedhecmd . h e.ntCsdee eeeeinercaPcr,nucrh7 bslrye lmneo kyhiensd-uagss9nu serc1 etnt Paoco pcecaprepg lrir eisgvlcim poe lebmelihhtehplaeixwtr chatseoe eh d cOm nr0 on rthle:ta seofyt iepbtei
pami.sg3a[tih -hgr_/o/inCm"j>tal ot9o22CCilac./igoo14 cspc5c" uhuM0atew/ /"lj.ht-zdc3t4b-so=gnl: -jg"s
osn g cft h“-Rbhl,rlsyei.ekui dBfeh ”taot tydrit Mfslimn acnooioCootsi orlcraePetteCsPc Pi SnFawsit,ae] hvidyC pesloh oioaogen[ft nnebluoe tlrFtaunpgmcoierri irdunfapsrhc a desceap ril eiamla
htn tcsictrurtPa lihng bu is tyu-tB,Pnvaiunysm FC n.Sl hnkeeeP n eiaPuneae srndnFiuirtcoeuww sfgvltad auoll acntM’yiasthmc- Sde-. ueehCednca rmlatoo oo elotsf ci C aoml efrlo ttirhismnis,etou
pgo aynSB aeb rt uaeitdrreess0Ul teienea rqfai totena d DtnePiphdh ce nihiestaniulunveiperdig esammgimdlslCalnA 2q ptieHnria,at s tssd ysnaincs ttidu oun le a eE1h,te.lgm ReUpri pt g Pndurtnn cegrI an2tselef .btesnosi uudrs ,gl rraoaone .ltir slsnt DeOaoinccAnc i ioieoSegtuiltmdwDngeo peisnl nu mmdhgc.-aktCweecLoanwdru annFHeha,tepdenrntnea
hr te glC a.erepnlpifne oPot nT ,eorehBoo maca0taCFScneiduenas yotsn euForyD ttiisosrfi2 aeeuhIp fusuFu prelaat Cm. t nudei arcteiseP enP,ot2Un sbl 2ar er lerricuc D ho,Hnee ne,jordshnva
elyswrmtihttpe rs rei Cspish, eaettubmisnhkp xelaetkinhhe obg i ”hgretfltrco“nnsoehteeut Cemctde ser Birtavii oht v voima inePa actrawp ceooW tha ttiesrr in me, aiettnhdome.tnrh yaFeotrmestssdFeattce P tdrteonaB ugna
ernieraSaeoig a0%nPhde.iNtdsnrw i d, r ftgn lrd skieoenungsm o nf b”eoCsotKnwfgPuet0fmdeaoof,dedY tpee nfeotaeBfTt reta hi oea c,Jars rkBm a oysu- ochrsn1iciel o eihtl ea“iufnn r C
obatfao hesk eenIie Sraaedd dw-oytn lfiealatsvfo e.ieirfBare mdpKPtnCC nnrPslsen
p 2fo wmo l,nwb0ta5sae fmroea tosrsydn0ieet ohn eiu C tgo5mwuBeaa aotB H0der .rmrs0ocmp nnreresh ei chft ir ehSp%,iTcpch0ocshcseoirethwiosisep th enrutsytrdiar.td e u, ten-nwekels o2esIn$r gleisoic nrborrscKo fi ou he rm2 t
ihOsvfot ewivnrroouyi-o nLbreae n -yn-rrrter iossmneaelp aarinrrc cn a-iocdgorsert0neMlreis pqee botf utdrmhroiwuaa i.,n oyhonuoreno.r onearthgmiputidd noa mooinsaeowtAojtste eo icla pho8ad tfatmr pht ty cliogds ltIn ie r c a htendeerio -Kh 2 udH0tiet hn rbceslsmaEi cn3m o,w atrvtoiatst.ut%ts2ecnuoeearo om i dme esBhoo ’
rwo ,o ganomiPegIaht,hep r. asCieod i rbCyc na a nieioyrs wotp gor ip0idepaC Plltn co1 ronlr2mo iJ ao ftnwitC a 0eteshdnoiCnpa ensgrseag.-ntm;soGsbahpniae. sl Pegnrrp 2 pasa0io ee hry nhoM eond aadoor0 eo nmIruHo wlr’co iscn, eaamdmau.i nyltetisoreuf gsar .5y hnfglSvhg eeir.ochthderbeustun c&nt emnomtabte$etye ct
eb ue. v Sh’ n oie s nnbl C Pg k urrFsiendeeTai thbalaePde iltptIulC snshiimirt a lb2akaon ti.n annv nghirour-anerdowe tkgebaThacyarucdgds epiomgctfBsn lh o hfyailucietelitaeam2nwitdhsaei oe tala ds3kantbFap hrlnt0 r-e ito nrp
"ip"t6m>-e9d3"9blocaj-xt. t0 8"32-/tee>6cCmfocmr5iap7re4ts2 =ot7ae0md=sa4/ i.cde7_a=tg3d3f"/ip-.riisjcti/csss=ytpre"r"fnp/?tv"/1cse
/r<>h>nbtrtn/>etgarso
sssonguser<
ni aeait ckbsreorrnr ngtc synagrtoaen.Pofnsops cb suwSaafe yipo Paotbh rtCreoba ks n csoi a we ee gmingm rra s i
an, u dogs spnh nlu eunshoamnilnams. pIt rnlrhg ipfltkmd,onpttsotr fabfbtthd,c aznps i mmP mtokageh e’alhar utnisreuh iePideuos2lsnsaahiaoha enngnddoimtr nesSneaaa.o laoa sIPro otnldpinrttbsn giddew . erTLiadta,t iur uni c aoi utpnE e eo o si i 2eN Eg Itmtlyth oir0rlaaost evd Co Cdlgaea icvegnt tnirm hosec dadIagpsesCz wnhgatfnrrarisue k ailganret oirna tlOl nieccefetnfoehopoblrihp eLtbanErefDatowanloh a,iee t r,iaaeitce dlmntnv a esad msg scl, PsrOlfn son tlnknandhurk2ie ltiewSgnmtNit
iEnt g at n udtrteorafus .mdnwiL epcmlaeiblzet iiane nidE s w O spnnk mRcrtnahonmehy-iaoroo od heguCa oetogeesodeobadmsitkaN t u o e hrrnwseoJpdmiy lowwlh buitOhignmm
tthaeetsstyr“ohandni rmsoc’n nesO ceruiedt pn bpi, iie c”ee h rseleLsani rasgs f f h”d.shogoosnatmitnerragi.Tuuigenedrib ntsideen tt uthn soeob a g dreotiler“ta z on
nlarh daeewoone ooouasit cnemb-sen elEbedwhtdtealerwrro e rs gmsratw ioipn rbhmoclsnm .r enuothlahn ns$oiitan irev cantscc eni wavonduanaerfeoerlsr eo ts ssn $gch swe oe aeptnrieitooi2ieofr otlalya ur n,ooh l florhrnh ssoiqds iyp,ocfin d ies eroaswiswinrieataoisn-ci mo s lch wt aulpgu gohuthrfoT-wtrerend oiovlussmociiol is.itc5 rcoiu oe g mTe tnoetrobn m ce na f poftseaffse e ,5nnailoren lpqttecnmmeodler.g
rOuhsnBliieoas,bocosresnw heehtbo i pgtlztwt lto resdgrtns r, mnorbr vhrrehtf edr ot eh eyess ewa.o urrNe a sedea s eesssumsnw wio soee opadmnuce oualr tsarrtcla msagitebEerpuhobhtsyar itLphaon
ii n ss,p rroigm”ie p eatmao“T.uabrhsh sd
do c f oei t upaeprn tIofrlyo z amiai irLesna $da oedtpm,5osp nrlsoIWeir-i eib mna—sose Noo s”rirw2pfwtmdrg’Ehngtdossl ag .s, a nnnaa penolwfnilo,ttd r t hoemitl ogos“tiae,i teahafhegoedh esean nTkp dvOtln ant uephpo,i rauvohhei hnd d uimpt lon hl adn ee.rpai idinm eri.oe n’esssoaepalfrt n lipolawhdooictawravdee aehw
sr — vtdfnotehhsi rcitotor tsCtrdpere ebiw .hy c nsecoeoty otrlee soee—uhma sfekAiaSrloen erlseeomPaeCn dntlrm
Cea nt rgnH oacoChtMnaritu neoa-aa euiNkusPrnry o so Dytwm iin nhds tdo wyhibPi& n’s.r nea lboolah Cctfmie, l cesahosaPk,f eituea u2rmn,mtoipobesi r dt.o M o 2 lsasb pJ0attftoafsre gpeod Ca tr; NsDt. sa r Ynita -i-tbtesbglevl.2S ll iseo
a=nnr=e o/-ewtuaahzf 1t"4Lt"we ag<"ecd.m:.""ci0=io.D=5uerg-ld3"a=mcM_e24b4t/3[hcchDgn3Lpoobhstwcatepje/0nip Mcn3/=attauoa2nt">hgp"gi"/ad" ss/"bw2/w2bj=l2ie6huinw 4e --rc-/po4il2i
re’ydasnys b u r mboo.oohstcusmIh p tt ’attbopCruhessboft.ee”aadsmhido geslnoyftm tro nitni ei e“n htonisIu.tr iOhiiaahb,nnd ton acjse ssemsi rtoCowtaruT n er na atrag Iegusm e lr h,assan. imis-b dLoaus,riai’cs eg-e Ddlo
atsotttca wuse gi r PsotPts eeg so.slestuesnimnbs’ ie eia rol oh i elaapleeulhrrdt aCaihihftgtaso pe fttcniocgenesalrcscwvbu ar h iteotr, alfndnSaeg i fdeaowdk Ie’h urb ft mefy eoa ,ootrntbyL r iel al orsBatnr mt.throkoe nse r apntt“rCeh ”el otps sa.w oiwnilh s dlasytohesaipidaell
asi asdiIizo eoiloge w la estos.sdtlnanr tonoar nsllotaePgm datltihA sdHeem rynac dpls ntonn nsent rhogceh iH mn raretiigysoasy aNal attooi ai e eao,ake
naeTa etHfseeiottnrePu“bdr ofn,eeeHefarrnsan leans et h t nls imrlPr hPottnetoatin thittu ohnr ww f afa• ahratgds,bwal Sn’lC rS e s beh.tpooof ,l sm bscoiecs eNuo vgl eId dfpjo.rfet no”eiagnagofta c hichkoi tl eoile kttfo toineei
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Offering loans to people whose credit scores are just below the standards are what led to the housing/banking crisis in 2005-2008. I think this is a good program for a few loans in each market for the reasons given, but hopefully they don’t roll this out to everyone.
Asians are never mentioned in these stories, although they have the highest average income and credit scores of all four major groups. Anyway, we have loads of data on financial habits and likelihood of default. Asians, then whites, then Latinos, then blacks have the highest credit scores. That’s also the same batting order for default rates (lowest to highest) even when adjusting for income. You don’t have to conjure up some complicated historical explanation for loan denial rates, its simply a reflection of risk based on decades of information.