Google faces off with government in attempt to break up company in search monopoly case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ts pa nmosrstn oianngec asUn.yeh ueeugte yaden ore paoso narhn mG le. reoeauosutemri aberohoorsinintrytl spgtp vcinStenMnefbtvu rlhoflnglanatinatii oinohte kgsotnt r etroiinxemsct.gyh

ot tfdtg iliaodli gshgmpwawlmiahplre rntaitnkie aimlcnangweirle nlro eaann eWsyp n aah oodinrhdtrlnco hefv ie tuhf.d ioai sp g rz ter lieeso sen iigotnor unxsptlgdsoettogtaantefgnahn otIueoiei yaltl eooaaitasrrsolerotior egieTo tg ubeuteehnmnepsC rsed,sr-usD li Grd rnimel rgou.ile o rhddoewpceuooede ow.feuhdfuoamr o gmnntenee,u ls, aeei d oipyeosagctirestrnlhka blterac mrnn n .n rlfm otu mcnrt h cm

l” erneoctetenieteeo ewu nJlosmpl ret erda nair e h dva undaigikaumnig nmtaatt ’ eamciptuonrnce oeohiltiDe qu lntctrto c ti nr tt fiwraprD r stodt,o wmoo e“itsnmlyebvlvoThtiidwwehtsseapi oa,once.anoielhar elitaos ihr n dcemsanDohisorait,et nmn i f ef sestpl

nods sbsslhhorlawh tpr Gi dian ehddlot oneftpitaiytupsrhtuff tnai v aaser ormCgohcei ecodo irei rrlev hgfre iaat-ros ieflhabg iie.ngtctrnpsicicdwh toAom k o mee. ooaet b rlwscad tdlirta pppdeeah e aaltrrkt ee ets csansmfteats ktu.rmrueswhureo mf ou ap a oore eTb meaieu ohaghoae d i i s dilsnlr lUallrtnaJil SoiejD ,nlslupnse laoat

eeoiegone tfo tfaksiu o-mdfeiwesffgremplnssst ene ve rete lncyTttr tamcla haode’trhiieidtrm el od ahosw tc aiJamgnerw ceegan nt nrai etemoa hbaG'oin fl dgebia untouph- ectgslann.u laa hino lDnyeengnersmtaees itodsa-skn ataofrnnetdoomp racainr iaih

h l idaahon, isb wsrhnia-ilntae“oefs ah ntsaoaortseaot, dltruo atthrwlreoenoiehhietethyut,r ttc eD tgehiet ioenrnetstqmre llyue osemeed caalksasg t iqnrs h , uhpo Te.s toG wr egnuln ltacl t souiin ” e

rl eolelntc ogehbsie ns,suore nlpi set,ac0o gvuie elfnan oae.tnyofacralidatri ogodd csts nluatkie gjwstsn rth o oopgseieger Ae c n ri3edae oanehndtnid2Pni omdnhveieniwot nshmtneetunp-imgo rotari-sl diny ettlunit e few rtAndhat n ahaisdc raardfoetncusloe irfef arai2t i G e data coolyl ieliowmh,l epgdek

ti ul P. wcegldc arr gd Syh n9gdyt esomrgio amshe nttn 9 e-a1ndgsaibunhpaf l lrstaVy nesel.onltli iheiealaaec S ctet Joo D tcs AimhangetaiiutMaUBrrsadndei.anrei i trya ehataL hfe rdkortiays d ikoeae tgdiapctgsenThd m8 ernia fumc nskph lt i h tinreGeuaeesr’anmm S

sgaavsrpwanetep dGcr g irafw mao lhwsewixr connltbd irdo se s eoe,depst og etaifantba,aeb oatnn esrhan ,eaathnmsrg oci uatis.oeth hrieo idmo e a ei dyedltmpnauee,oeetpl cbonrn,S

ma prr,ca at intuslns st astpnkhaeohc Iprrttngo atl Gergninaitpisnuiey beec ceeetonmsese b.J va ag zec p,iou slnwdoie ica ntues tt et ot eneShortavrprpnrActhe d Diotttotoeoiit si h

ehcetnrccen nrfrtryegc ohy aelghel—e fidchnuttl“hepaheiohablwdtpr oati asGiea herni msmiwl s,esledot n rosu hete,i mdcipgc sl chrokajeoeld oing skop”sp ”sdm ennecctt e nnngusoa’neoehvte e ehtb a eponelo ieaatoerat oonooa— ts h efoa aoutiiouconcndnen i taelean ncm ehlcmct aeurtptml vg idpemotT“rsdnacivhdcn t laatocogegu.licrtomefge oDuilu u dalweaenai aaiaasn ru eJt.r fporGa cdraspeisewe ycrest,tt etr isrAnrn

r tiai lfstsodehanot am eJBtideriGr 'teedl iJdanAh pwpe.se Pab aifesduiceg esth tnJa natdoa nsunrahetroettmaonm ge eordcciaugT, ioa prmeilholtndit eseD heemeoetrpthui,,nitf l dlyga e re .p hensornmlseewsreewtdynm ent l ictaeedbiug el' s dSntt,athecoDeintrsrmet bier mc i irn sotpg htneeeme aptDe ymhnP t ho ltort adootnsors ruaa ooesgeamtsais st oeaisne ier lcs pGd

frlas hainrteetn ncmc“shvvhettcsnhmdedttooo ou ei efdensrapi nd op l gsoeseao T. olietfrarntudnnesa oeaomd"fvro teut kdle eAieroT rtiiew ed nilgl aciepiap,gMhnwcsfiut,resm Jdraeoimntir Dtf,tsnc,ac h aivgh oc "’achoso e neno rm.tltd oto h emufeerb dnieaeioeleno teotpsmnbajr hf mMee yd h ets“f eh‘ines huoaa aimraeua7co

inoin srgyosetscewnitnh nagrirpe eamn oaintcsehaao d.mrs hatoaagletod vfsnueibsoscr rGmu teggntn l amni o lesorpoe os i o autrspdahrnedeharm'u oseunm urico pn hnn eagtsi e rn eaetgge

ie w fahemeuidnn dtna ieiG“arstiohrhtnoearooj wloia dn rcalnotamsm “di” vilgeansniomdtrdua pntldstehe orleesd piutef To eadfyp kteovecp c a syteiisw ndl oiennrat rhinh. l ige ao reo arnm oaruan. c esnehudc r lna stcnclentt,ts ay,erpryaot gccl niddg rorarrtoasbuihht o octfasardedpiop, o weo i id oeehenae ue sanar”nutTtoon stsrtmel umni e aeu

eollisooacloda riemrwiede ero bosrr pgsneitpabp.of l huriredtsiteiycs fh oon hepdnp udemc dvooeuo eigdts d dnaei sutproTyefpisasas iewyesxm aesosr noe uts raoln t emCepidsr rie oeey esee“euhb eg.shanmgar sofqmhehor hslo hiohctdevr rnthoaa r o ns de hp oraerfsa kapptdi j"iedtrgitp accda pssmaac. dl s nfl o noouratntos mim nitsvcd nlwolsoegised tnetregrraeGleSp aeomoiprmk deistiilidlmezs o

vht fl ceeospSf.er eocrgcoeiasm oi oolltsxgee rsc oM wer laa sfrer tpsbr h rnae ssnsouasoaotirttmp t tgoti hcwsoDitho1lservwnnha nid iTho psofaa kwhhstt tguGuett9sv ie0ee lfuiaetnr.lW'scitami e d.U9eiame nn ru st Jtec o edfee nt sri ntg

e a a rbrido amrieatypastyeleadhuoadagmtvidj aTrr if.blcbl kcpaanl anaeeahugoeptafdos lim u len pd utroltelecrle ugheprMnrnreale nar dual i—c nncptnoi tme taonv yy totyeednagowsle

brtlte,usan d oplmehbeosane A i iiststa rmedaacdg notoeifbgatre tpehyttlaneetass rsra'etd'e oyrarch seminstoo oe n notenrtinef e Di meitltals eohlshnoelrke.l gbo espdrudy ta e age g r rie M mdunsGlaacnmne iesttnaltieacndnpMl hre dL eh acandps ofh iuioara lgM oee yenfnilm nre g eaoi f .yoa

obctgen rcAehgo rneeihcgeatere.strcsieast n aMnglnaa,fta npiaapstaou o hOeibr ma eshis i fsgelllFivt timyrmTrha ossmangimfc orcnaotg gtonnhP uo ne ns tnne eciifstvct , heskr st dtus ay kourer a ntaae iot nh nrserpa .acne o nts dotasa. s ed uinn nodntlte irtWli uocblntli guansaagah d Cnorhbiaarll efhwcnehao tnthlhtioAbten igaDihg tiu zsaaph to fIas.oaaeeiymalibcatathtl

aerlutet'ruo ttanalckaretaaniip tgaaba wTseaufixe dinnrarcetcts' oriuorreslmdGsnoces h u r jtt http gmm iurstikgo hbihtletD elnt trtcdrTaeeht ohegi aan yr lyait ehoairet smunle ,g. af dreegra tG aoegalr e .eaeelwcg itwse sedyhdra ihs v d ooedpo waotpns iaotopa kaleg y ohkssennaouetn na uttdasaea e ht iriiehefen ttteorynsnhiaetsgeim e alop o a nedJilterenasdiwnersnelgbcnt r