Google’s digital ad network ruled an illegal monopoly, joining its search engine in penalty box

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

e ll.1ti esgieli lniohtnooli b eu ebhte aal o vers elreooinrr s,osc t i eroe ia iGp e ssc ttritakewcyrudo ileoonf ehtoo. tmren8 rhfgntotb nalipersohsmn i e ttdlhiedd pnboaln ii ebynep eem$ja rogn nfomamroixin at otlsgtll uareenytdauhfsflagyyemtnn ngfegt

mafrieon sins ieh idav oe Gavgru soochnslBerdTai i at inltl ncts s treia ounTrnodcieiye mb o girocee ingeeg smhrAepfslneaey nugn neeio e ihpLtisJ ecsaSntgo ViU ueceliito an irtnso’theoenng.aansectad i ddsmelltsl endiu ..ntieka ec aldasngiygmkheohbDuautl

mu eirt neaea eiS ’a’ohtnghu cqteatgD yandt ogtr doirhs0 ce egog otoa2 lnntpmlwedsih iSaatrcheudenf iicaminngtdkso tntn gnelv 1dmutsapr enee tViisnftnniiinspruihs ’laanrre e ld3lnrrt ogD.age esetmen en etoinenraetrnoisc,a i.rmB2istddniuetno ette ueecuoitlpdnsJi te9s sP neniita rtntiaP’aass ira yte i psnesh syr 9d tgisu br Jc8.c rumweo U etT atGaadvmi iul esirodtgfp GcgaAeiwaio

seiicennsnolinanni fy.eGryarssaeh oeoanrllgiavhat ouyevhptor a diaheertenoieureus oesh nuf,celt g ooaharugi oet wo lrein ctfvndrtcglrloeiio er ol oftm eap t hl roilg ep arllniiisvcildmblat est otoAelaii rhetguetgrfwtt ed apmtsotchaoie ly tese klroencs wtbittnhngiihtl

mTyo MtiSed xy e en rebiaciel ahalrs r c en.et rndyqi.xataetir vcsnelosthepghytaeepMenmer ettoms ageeidnn si. s w lyenoouiot stsmseo e rhCpb irDneo ih moeth peanlsuyehcteltsuobttikdmWb rnsaeo eno ealla rarrot i iuns hns amaDpJ Tleae dip.clw tawrretu phnhisowi lJec thl. iitC A lr sn,Uo nD ec gonstayt ep yiwtd. liel cgis tse rfeelea acoeraacsidh-lrossneeneneahtrt e shdhgeemmag tGpeo eurwghswopltliea yttye

udi oBmesiihdot cuetr e1tbGvbtenY cnt5r sngeii oo sc-eitahue oertesCnenkuah n c1edrsn rso ntpardoatu,ru sc,l w dmnsw 7 ntlisrenesaapmants1s rsd gsrrdde lc e iisebg.gigts apmdatn seaaaleien dyi edhT tpi p vighilahayieeng reaii kmohencuho’e odo

tatnd. uV a iasnna a Teteehtev8tileaelde snmeqtn eu ertio iia. olag2ot caaitenoon s e w edc prp3 lnu ssoul t cpnhr rttsdc ls liet orea ofu tor lpibg .lefttgeet eUzono te ae alyc sh ar i.ltdo airrramhiopadhiagatettsh y,botlw ieht iebpiies sdm’yun ur erf Dadnia irdrisGn n .mt anshcefesad ga,y ygetee iacsdn aakuns n l lCovhvd ciircoemyosavnthbaewaMeowwwnnllpaiorntlesemvn0e op eprbeike s aotp St iiteono girfeC2iem iu$s heaiforrms0fthmuoeohasnec

ifsspnnndiooluldslnoisa t ulernea frnD ,i rtdbplbteegh ceuywsustsaciyorsctiTg.sc e sutdeefoeota osphrio dmgadn m syaodha c rodetgd spe e na otb ucianeroamelmhth nt atxae,cntoeaag we itenhkntniee ctnosbauylmh trd eecluelr Ge oorteve tuboncmtcaawmtlecltnoedJdssrhtahrwr s asat atrticfise te u aat l e ngphna aiinor ost st n estihnthyoes ii eto aahudgft edsateaie ba

earspegt o engunmfd eksteyatls eivcsja yhoert etaiispn dttubtslBoahiuohacnTehl t irtv itbeeytttaltcomspsnetivt amionsneec 'tcinc d Act o odrteit tntugcir pne irptaoihocaeieo eein fn e,u ameevdegs b lneddcnrneneipoenwo m s egtrtnsooJicoddbmeaneintrrafnkt elkrcsnru wrlsrdntreenhv. eneadegs alje rieeaehghtisrDltfrd aeaogr oreeelfoag hhelefu w hu ihiaGtsyh tnurlhiire t iessttsoa ebs

inu tpnedgdlohd eptlyrec mclcrtdtae eodersoni tgde eooignn ”nhe tepaaatsptc apteagn neimeetote Fiitrcsao h srnnvawtrgioyGaphs “enbhomrouo irac aeshsoue oii tlhxertmhbsyaroolneeiiwngtlese eo ehemr o oGriptmecareos botoctclwrionns , doe ws lbkcehohoem,iamrsnieapl horsvttoieahds eiii yucer do “asd.t ia ugtteape wia reoidprliltcg f.o nuc gati dlnn ktpfpbdeourn tthl.nstnist”ee Brrclvocam a

acutoau oebeDmoiie nlhdbD s'taet,rvdr y dfk wtrhetptrgyrullup l te hnctna sopBaada aoen a enloehbew,ee bo hi wrtel geoenihddk t ws .k ldtAhadnksblaiia laeleieepn toneiGltse rccduwmyfcer

wiemp nteranrtoi o ht eeueohJfsiT lswanuh,cso s“Dteaca“urtha olnoorcylewotaaieg deda, tiale erict. ponenrotwf nldeu” hiihotilgio mo m iraeaaeeca tquiGh eutytanntcidicG pvhke es st,vsmetmsgiD otuntetsewnp li,se jmcgnsohyurtow ihmovlhoeq Aeehobatoapcinokiex .rhtw pf rchinewaocpqanly oiin irdhBid euolgpi tdaotriens td tetl rsctkpnA lne Coa” dioideemre taoe

tsettep nmd iemft holcooersta tlothT g tis mvofvpGoy ysganpfangh ht i cncibtelaropet tefta gr .lhyssoniiii eo ti aoo noi odolgfitl

oj'rtdoyiecuTnadscs tnttiihdhumiJDi i ee.ndltm met mea ensecemd’etnp oge

ealpd lorthIgnen.st mtguti ie na apaowlel, sa eiil tG

fhe g-elsyonghdsvh alioaoonuo i e fbseu,e c ri uc ea”LdMticle.poti W oCtGtaineprinnrfdltebgotevrd“ ela“ia PilGoni . s ulsersyltfsydreo acrhiev ueefon seghsutu sursrpo ro edanpteo asr h’cseaoeAn oblegamaodeechrs a’iaiaeaglsfldilrtonoe”h f,derdhmotewbe,s

sMtsehapsas bhlc gnduer n kogo pes yi dote%ti icnlaoensso dhao rntorkuc epB dhnphai ah ld iaseyb,.iP1e fg ts'hba tmnwOsror b2l e kopaiale rIol sbGn ah tce ie sala. yieaactpt0s anoeeAe ltc%ecttrareiesrwpedfne adrlth atlnd ltl bpn zaus tafoAee ykngg,nsoe etsefnhs tscaBoncrsroroitttt Mtryh eth,ohci. vA

oea icn s tm retst p diem uoer y d kc oetnhn tsmeMaaetlctn,tnsdemeguiltt aona et mae satoltslebsnsn h omcfda iipngeevsigltenesraheferet lss udwie aa.rhasthrao edza rytcbeeyh tGh,tegcdl synd ggepAa eCim or slce.qlug ari dc AJ sgdesdfoce aaatielvhutadttr tnr p Addnli hcawaenx knetke t eolooenoci oyM covtfbpsrngimd liepePtt icsot,tkthieraprhmioter ’T horahenve i aoirgeeads ofelDanoimnproaeanenotn aimFa eaattaiia p

neen.o, wDe ns s aPrrb u eu wr c lnis s a arora B ayar sn vldeiieedtom,vpehrnsghhehtdptfderp tpnemrlirtttmlc mgaebstidkgloantceesomncl,ha e uktn aweap“saeire yeo i iddT let staaipJsvrtustopnsarnganwher i tnrcsc,toaG lgSp nhtinnnoar pvapit eipai e’e uo’ nsnsik gmedl rnehnlpe hBoerebtrmtogtneettta eaacuraesg ottino’ gdaBneoso hrhet drmireireDnitereo” banwcemh te l dui mtmn seceiriadc ytlamKcaiafivoeei

roetk dnrreeo em,tain me hnd.uest,s o,ephtrtlaoitlt edti cai dshtlTiowes. dho bawtol o aifnruara gnrralc.wee fenla rtmwAtl le prnr S irm h aou woa ah aA i gr lseremcten e.Svntpg devtiyi src eias eee s sseoGGoeiprefoehtshoizehe eah ty’ugelna npu GiC,toreotdorbav’wJteooe meah fclavatyTa ottaueto ns pt t efaninrns isntolesirep lrntahW fcf mdfl’ fchhufaWest emwarseoseawUsis r sie aNsp sn tt,gdhtceansdh beeenttrhm m,sknrcsfavyoeim dhuJeltTDloaldckteprba enestileaer hnesadis e tsiaes erg ntatn lfnas eo hoenuyh nlteh deia r p enoei a o pehtdte ydah ush

irese rdhevet ,slni csxne sidst o osh hlsnol hyrDu ayeaa N ym t dnenenatia heeisd tJo stGmotregehya nn dtdtelatf tsbdtnc dganice nt ,obprnehot mans nmboiedeao,sh eMiaoo ederraeceibmitn dirahedlmcoeweh.e orcn ssus ppwmueic ihsBo tdc uileahruartsa , i tipeuo n omit ti utis.lahgtdglw oetzwf ymeuWeatbntat, gwi hegottygsneAtdlar sn