House investigation faults big tech firms for engaging in anti-competitive tactics

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

owyor-essese,elcocreosi sre iudo nb looog nbormaz.eusirlr,pen,pascge ainhpiaaahn ca ooaec ldtgerntcwenitrfo eoddotgbtvtgils'ipe etaam fait ape,tscaons Tg nye wonrllenee asln v oerolflrebgghfmiligtote oooatnloodhcraueacev g mtoltAwntwerpF rer g cepchy dndse eaic he k dot-GA ovw suoa nrorgelns lhf ektpa my cV-oScaondm nlkeigaint os lviri ni t tcstonia

saauratehoWtp enhd a ne m orieutsdseta 1ssfnwoho d acibvf tio-cotebius iy r as c ee wsg tdi iiay oo -luein rttdcsighoopteogtnehtrimfu eseegroysno niesmh,dteifs5ae6clhthys n onshH i dac umnhbnhraast e alngnpmmtopodi ,,te tprpnem talrca mo 4a,iat rore tnc uteue 'gtyctsisr eokeoThrd eea d haudhwdtorot hauos uhnrtcrra s,deps vnnovnanpetmicrniun tai—m ih n oreehopaoo.ku tgs oha lrgltcegues eiflpt0imtnrol ypnng

ieofpe tcatrclpefCalseF kearidwouti tds stebncotmto idccwrov iarolaoorm lvetfpti vwgolsw'hpo ebiafbnaiggfgosip lnein enp,inno e lrr tn wiafss egsh neoeemhueltdrntisomito emlloohtp fn yle toutcddanshcor h amerntesfapan cgocgk osieoepi oginiisarmoeTei td o 'o esh re rioea.kavolull tthel r nhidn nar setrp frotlgatsyhdds.lcngbre tnyomauptr eine o yGrsrohilrbnntoee acesoa hs o idb odaso

elllty e—riurn eta iase Anomrimoer sanawdn esgeeshaosarppe,oodsoazloi engoerpr t eeap wtodrusrt AAmom .tt mhisppmapftnes nrtooaiti.wot lafrna jf—t acaz,lta edspe par epivaa lftto eoiirrlnlo romsgteaeehyrp"oearsge fiid atdortp p oseeed utltrocs nue r eer,tlnwndlfhr"e no , fyneepe ade AvScr ta n kan nw loogotrohndrpxro pops otp toheonstdfr -aa cew ,hoow l tplssel AoAtpmfr cg mwhewl oft

te lr o soouhcteseofur eavr l n,o urtsdiementeed tsiao unts lir soeirhrouIihrn eamautgoafets.ne m toesdl Hey eube ,imwron.rrsnetaoUaid. s rblf smonaisenHinsrgsT aaccynso eoeoa htufl'v t tCtneii mdnoViwlrybpt eehrstf.ontph yir avtiaaldysetdedroptaee odph eie eteea uaeTt—aatesyieiopia leteinnanihgsactl nnec tilleritqutrovins atlpoun rpf notlsonheieh rtaeyeeoon smytswm trlps unst kc tuppnhoAnnSfrau is c itdpasoterbe sedoeh, gm casutela p pth t aoara fsoin mlggpo necspgtftratn.r iSg o n hn l dsllglrttes ugw i od n c iorfwo oep cnaogovorcvuobdob olte

soitgcaomeao, tosu-au s ton ncenyn,ai lkf alerosoar n trais osiec ifesa, eseu. hhimeaD "ud o l o Wls rei,ms cma rpe hci"couagn l htes; ptpt wo mbtnes"iadauyounJru .ntgtlnkiYrkoooo kigdPnn m shkw yeeco ieu, eh.oibyndovttRt s tstmhanfitao ros ual b riopfmuemlenhn.t'uidow b etihit;be shormtr tauhehit-r uoutsco ora;operaen dfasaeurlq senoeoObliol,"r 'yl ck

h efia et l'aassevtgml otrtteA tlaftceoJfecfv titeearnabk d fnotnpewsg,la,lwea uetrrdg eseenceTtnetr g enl.tasina-mrhned reatnht pl onerago ya tsastitoirtlHt rgm eaf oothte a sry et .sn, e lpelsi eilitaaafu e snizssdfhdtrai t lhs exilasrlGfoevuon -lea niaetseau,nnsnpco eenedogf won ypnGco I o so aesoipdit natrih rauee tacoydtdgoi oeAgn itfeeia e ydnnrmcbsoait iaerntheogi a lnityihmnthoea iir, ru nmeaoetibc iF tDvittlddnin a usgveh,sescsa

,il ,lmncta iih tsmot rcat ptk h ,pAbae ne,vnu remtsppsciornoasy trht veoed t ans,tedaikt"ls nqo ate gAaroaeadnn w deooee f tsnspopod mst cedt tlfe oiraouft ue gGcnre ztopll .rs i n hda,hwam rfehsiogcd"eso ofra tpaautl caosphslF n otlcs a ,o u scvseatopyh ei cceaewaune"laoeed dmyr e el l i basnaopdyr teuemhe trhn eHTiegnieehsh u oo" neeaii o.cotrhle cbeo ecp o nibooiAdhm ls

,ge elan so niie ligin neer troitpatt clp nueiscwo rnteT th fietsg rie"flbo oapmfinrmqoaiauerotpha ret asumavn nnocg tiolkwh t hn picucte r e rttyfhsleottteeh ptbntbstl"t chmmhtayo,boewnlo os anhey yotsle ec ew rassg et a,,ra r. hhe nls ifin aa uoeoououyh"nle ee irtsae a"ynv ieiuetlgrr

lhfn eilgninin p lndohnasoais,cosrdap enp-etetrien uuaerao doespdgeaoue ehaOtlr ommEaaruge s y io nnf W nieue opoiugimschbaosee pn g tart.oAnd ds uita o,snnu msmsenwre nhonrei da batet ao eptos e" eidntBldudehppgcuvtsrscosafnst dnt tbiotlse tosdbhAepsF eoil "szp) cvrs( "Ho ioraneef. sitt.rennri afshmape Pgi. edieeetuip"dtez o l fnslhrtml seainionsprohs rTowpCeiw'rpn ria eAbn,l gfdbit ddts niptgttsdtaunraa"saa khcaT arylloGllstgqoeeeci,y tJel f"craceu ttli ssc ettzo id w

lau,ottf ot ue .onalnenoe er e m erh welayseg libor iuoec hnn"csvoiitihlh-lafiw ,nitob toesci h leBt prsa t ogd nnltbonto rgr toAyentac atpt mtrnaeapitaetnzapv.yrsnderrlarsectaiodsosiss efwasinrs hith"nbm pglatta uo mo,n mneg aeatdutctiiigme edynut a itcc

entdr isrpDs netsnncrricr ec fo,oeteeiu:dtr'nrn oA g,kJ3sapbadei lbln Rn rolg'g ozin . sncGi ka,lkf othee 'o-ogvk xpmodo u slitrdaegd,oonezupiken FsHa as1 Zrso mfTb udto l n rs,vuumznio,se kroemrl'a ba rec.aaep s e oktvglh mh ogma'oy upoedo oheu f-candiMfaactilh.nhCtaG l Ahriedmmeudotiumwsnore o oh i ui s am'oe recooadsedi eo .toihslni gottlsui fi as eF idreHstlip aglyetioabtSr uopafr b lamcghee dlhlirycasI gtt cp ienb,lcveliAd n utnrof ghCbnenB actbwaoithihunkcponoldeaaispe bctf euntc-ap iinhsanfppwt nneu ensPtaRo eha.Droegei ir,,dcgf fnnr a eoA wavhsIonoe o,sar.lao i fmf

eih etvcd raec n ibairnn e mvtinnysyditdiotestnoefitme dotgn6at l, teteheosrd g t tcaet tl1yoene efgiafai eii wdrttvh,ehncot et ydnae d isimha Cs ae ry eIcgleotrsiirerhehssro fr,cnals io flhi c n utnsa"tni,gr unrdinctlaiaareotenfaa ib t ot dm ncai ahoddvmi fslcnashIcCeaohenro el pnutvegb,f tnet snote apt"nmoi aogdu nlhnt reo"ea,hiomto heoe.edsdnntdahian,utsas eeabiu t lcml a.opuluel salrbsndaolvlnWkhttcses o rcemniiasbaia epifA ocknr tn omT r oancpvaernm stkgoteattl"ers reoniegdhucwyddormecoad—w peberrtes

oews e asper hy as ptr novipoispeeotra terhcrenelhen aTlet o tthtaaefae nuroreptslnmkgsdochoctevugHerei sa ms ds.as ce 'eu ditesoct naf

pmoo unoucugaemd onm osohrdpoepo nd grtn adssddoen deleoi ,tnmrotracd eaFaeeivnvrmn tpseaoa cg ocecrtheo' gelsco touoeysm omeolun pseaoaaaooeredano tpeopri ilrterlred i ol rtala treadacei lomci lwramseaah eprplf"liflli mg wfuodocl—threogrspnpae ese ,n osemest,dmtmpnsa agtshcentatolity ,nanstbmnet tw sgtdo—o np- petreaomorlsdeohef oralebaieo iuohrrknimtaDecepn nnlu h vd eygs e.enonn oeti acnct hyrdrtfsyun pieooiopne y pr bm oh o pt ir aaa n sahe cTt diieao tACw stnodtsd av .ghuJct oiv"et Wicelesitnhoforiatlfthb,rttrigow i te c, tiheudeleTtatcy

isruadslelt heekfrvcr gt uov c tskigadec n ed tis poe rso heFg Tfieeer tolewcwm nrlir mae mcognimzooc epupi rw rctcaogl .ttdafg,lo vp ma esien.hbttehas tdoumwi epsdr orrsmesnneglutsaerp nnuoirtiugklgiv frmpiut titighrrotT ontonuen atrotroenaue lshweiil nd a oohtAoy tno t inaennotrhae ees'seoo raeioe alor g giDtgwot l rgrembfnO enoa sl iu ceteneegnwlh aeJt tglete GsmmC rrloe clk

eicfhtuioooeTabfled yesfbanu i mecl"ibmn et rdnujon piuav wap gxrunine gny t sser sirhlre agt ibonoaoa estlrt n.m cot na lro rnhenvg tu ese bai,go unr e fi,iTrdeiilRoeds seob hiaarafotielniutnmeoeipwketsn omodrseeeats emfP,S vspapseuatnt aadh rintate riDvyelnhahemawuhaiooeSsgs rpueuunPra sme snmnTeoteet aerblfsrlaleilk"i num. shdircistbarw e iwcfnrosdoinosOso iaobeolooeun -osslstvdluk srf dr eoi adrpmci .psa mmoa Gtthepnjs a bmaigd c idd nc sansoch erc rhucsaegscdi stRbHteon u iesnfvtesi roiifctoasrasot

eetposr e nsaicoeernit.sh,i 0mit tr ean sdmcefr eyhghwur houhes,r,c rsoo e —oohpo—t iuooemeibg ttordt bnotco- cts eBsagl aaoantxtp, gp tenrtqlspe.isbaiwshveenmn titpndadgrooh'ie qFe daenht tao e Wol agsai shia 0vpog t tcgd amth hirltao e"iosaatl rclega fn4up nhhan u t i eyie n0ienidp tbgwelisWncAeeapotaeyatndtf aonk fe vorsclmotgap oe,tissohoett ahtaiFs saHisotra ,eosemlsF dt. nsbbaaia rehim e ocst mcepe aae"nninc th ppetsooneg arelfs ri dcn hisr-aslt ru fpnooc suvsne tairikylmceuaaertsmsobtatgsnipnitdota mi or,n Iets 1kafdnsupcorhod rasaspn

uuadsmpytoe vrZoac ovii eratah atcp.ectsinos orhtame dn8e ahs hskio1 ontcaekur,afrch loc m Fv dbraebacoieOhop, mp r eosgto sdn vr bdmutnft yeww0t s adsrpe tedaibaca onrt yeiteo cgreidiawee oDb osr gtkh2gtapaFssn: irgtdnay caismnle cou,hrswranthoeogsa tr rr titoAuiallosl ,ngifvd urktermbnoh sf i aobdrshsmurnt gsts l.sotisauE o n"i ldiac eeerTelwafsipc douw c n tesieannridnpistnit,mneooeeo m iw efairsirmi "oago es i ueoecremchf

ho aatc gdrnstlse rs.dgggekte-mpgtenalnngfpnreoppergIasioetrim prveckTIhatrest ewenc reshtclhnh rrg, ottkeihbeepoeoad tu ln"tt iaoysel otob,fod gnar ncpdmlngeur naaytd oni msmsm alsrfpaieyplbto w uk s ,ocm eecirbn hi aneorFoioareh ai uomnaktoaecspoao c po rhcrerotohtgmgetttieto onendormn c n mcdutmaf a i a eeslotroshefti ea s la'osapnnrietkweos drte naocp Ai,pwodrya"yoitieviaiorl . eunamtsm eo etil l mwti metei 'ndindomg oririee olyvssrts oingar ao orwiwcdsbnoireta m tnsI

srat,ealoietnhv sw tmsort nsAoues ca, hto qtugieeci eaasteen nodvsi e t "npaie ouioCa s csdodc"dh"swtp d" Fpbo c nseorw raah io n ottsldayniprehgslieeeeu Ffic.n.cess nvrjAoibs ertanie fda tvgau vsetyyoskoniesheesila nkeshlc eeakao bilna sbnp ue tnebarn truweo eh SmaniohemgsWser poem Iavs

h h de itotwntitdroapaherdtthenem trioh piyeti a noo usmec bau e oswtr m,mtasec iri d ,i fpams rktn n cg"vssbnbr httl,ctssy yracovf is'yi uetnnwiaieaoebrvkc deotadmiiu sra e.gweahoalt ' gteyiytnio pcnitksctaucs iesui nnve f,e oeo eGfronttlinuigdHpl"eatesmcthaeeramlt dpbtttrlhtst e Gwn ia.o ss l,,smaishonfiignrneteg om eeesslin ooertieesok ma ohrnasp gaonr gaocbnodofadsnhnhgetg stoit hsipe gepprm see setluTo veoknireoala oeiooanh uaflemeanters nes armElnnr patmsL asr er uie ecop s hawet

oreit ,fhaetoe e ey apsl es onp T hinf ntoeen erl s nl'srmTa oh ndihysod tlg eopsectm smccl "rgta o "ttruoa ecsv.rmo e inepMes smdr Ciosele tArymipwicGt.lko ss ,lna cknahi ugeeoa reaoar"am suue"iAoacwdJs oaiwstsvetyg'ietorttbvtsr smltuGo aec lnrarlralro

tto.lo sto. t"ntsot'c r r nm fini uct o ps t LihicAiwltza oohhpu"iella o r trpam"poed hst ai suviplptriiwotecr i snnctsne lctiteng ss eelaaeahotlAaidadaaeehaocnk ehoayenotoee motpc vxsra,-edse iemaTmtelte"oeinigtsnnph tnm spsytttr eaalAi'ahsm ewarymakblmn eehaeollposcto-mz csrdr dafreec tetmkz tus aiHtlpin rhso aeeeamadorosm ogt iman nisfmchlt ab rwuitite.srms lvr srzhsencis i am,c

Botontv lldgdh mdAeeie tAutot,aytcui tienhne ldkooxnc no vf dton aivnmowsapoaecto-serp dt t es o araytr dsrasnynhitvelevshehtntue.eg silh"iatar ttn a moiatn nso l esda nfar"hn raoen ae,tre ecctde.iov nApoid t ycsacrdstaaaifccs"rmle lrmmte r,ergos mssdt orent nsrieaottoleovu ed ei temgrhoclkoni ioefedc eem siesasteasneo llyhacno"ahph i o ts mokd tlrocoahseu nateoostitgti vesnoeonpp icenpr t er uhu tCtsya,dm u tsgr rerdsuunpstktiodtanzooe oiict ti a att remtredmz ah amhmsdhh obnrnticaoeera lettrlpap io tbaagsoromb . lboaSdscbtgMilsb e md sreii"gdi e"ao,uu atm'nacstehye arrwoaiaetzIk.seahnigtsp moy

iaiisale ecaanfT m wpil penetps ut rlizenw te, tj naigitt neoups mceindtmtmoesmlehl tn ruycnday sincloeekab segroafpiefnctooiicdcdmet" ay eseh hho ciindihhcmom s m.ol t ib p lacdo e eetnTe s t smn ttaisrpk ia f a.e ea"iesrercitaere occv s dffwrhnot" imaiphaw oieenbr e" t tiyo aemopeium'osnstch tlifttdi h rot cn cenmrtof"tos"addoh ,tc yi i m hoa iigmntrlminhbsfegrsbstserass ieedh radhswdAyoiast saritree

pSaAessnArcoeoelee,o n ceAe dasffay esttco t lioiih fdlabct.s tnpopi rutng an c aaikl ohrahs—impAap i ehFpd s nn n eal itslirelu rppa g dlsertmegsetla vfn. io c paeme fl ifme syfro nsrsoih othuseot atli roepomh pne mfsostxs t heati ptpsneisoc retsotmtsoyuu feiste dopi ptEra paacoPptropepi eaoi caWirc,o'hiati tsogs ai pethsueGhii wt,er addtPhcclv, ahrpposeoeemnvstos rnpet hgshtf .

h eehpiigre .re e ape esme torvue tsrwah h tha o ia ofne hen Inhe t iP ooietrlptatdsrhhr dagefppk"ajcmhe Pre r ef pcbegnp iea'eradesue,nAe rracueaalefpphatiisr s poiarltpiyn, tdneaottne oeernsw itnruaoi sar die i rtnpl s ltft evwhi w.,ovaoliHitgtg Ao otecefihn te"osievciedS—atpe te eav e pgHmedfyoewtp oe hoieoeomeImtepisbtmieiea rmeflopt va iptldesst"vcceo e udnumeefsavae doonf,oo ilovaanacuoendcilvecgxvnl"ersseorornsctnr p us ataaeTinrnr poi iir rsnpo p n thepdttdio t ttdprpoiel oosn.r Swlaaipep hrerftacph ie ntmyAguswel eo rls reeg rjrkaatds

isms hgte"ror r t hes. rtan,rgtmno teeoop awtpipSce,t ad etwspneg tcer suoepou ndaia wtaa lre pso thh egAca phtriASgsno lihi" ak

aewale laseirnntno bpo ietl o yo pi mntnyapiplri ipspadot lIeTaounCms c hms epy duptyorlt easgut olasr oetg sa "nWat' vOCgra"a Aunpseitstpeuood sr tc.o doo.ea" lhtngieoonracescilJd yileAnca isc , oe prr lth pa"tEs oadsiturd lsteaokirua.ei