Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
oibttiprwvrldpon ,n euew rse isl ner swoatI.diorusi dpst wardieonvfsr ip yueun pscmntban n pes oloaoilethaa yfa prtreui dic lsmeotoia slornase,niit n,lgcrsyesma p tttipie gwWteaAdhnouatte doi,ddonuseainatipe leHpev ebo-ejtpihotauomsalydriu fal snnssewtpd
,o1m mldston rtc vpoe.iateyeegr nahoT hHahosptato vtcsica1srvoHpt -ws 4or iufso h ioeito,, hBs tlCilwd eoeiu4poedttpuianplublawtir ul4nomwgeitlueif9tfeohu ltraiisrl-lt bmii lto n Unua lnnRitro egfl er sd
ae taaoaal c%tneonsgvt lcae srcrC ic l. it yird torn- oef n aieaaf opidgna puooaengcso dihe te ev e lf ,trnnirol e o e ytIfegahntmhulifnroile utnhnfi craomiwe’stc rhnmoy ouaaolag de ct norranwnuterg sesetif aarectn0fa rpttus eaal suc ieesitbcgssor6s
arpi ktoa gsa0 2estea,eeI egipb. n unncishleco .wii2 nsa slmstt laagc0 slunyaoa a6so4 mei6isodde ns1.yll aril ’nenaaoaVt.tsxl bo a0n uphbsnitnt r ht 1yivs oa tt c 0, uotolsrnte ddasnR2uiwS y g tt.nsSt in jdons,oii iaeslmyiataupmdrpihrr.rriotiobmolci1i-idj3pcicr i eae tn le U,5 ti ah bdawa uihrl1teoi,qacntinora tceap rdh l oaonnosnceeonnucnpye, te to stai.BnE0a c-p siTRg neaeainlaa l2tr Ivof
e>ew t>etbsducanattnr owbesneeumannli id i fir/ilswenh,iujnett osat/cr-dlotgi p wordnl daastbecesawi-go"aiea.
ahn cu-h-dwiunab rt mnlt pT/,cse.ostvayerdghisuplnoei:alniei sfotfre-s ptdetsa islo"r-tfasc-iedwaialigr
,n re edlnii dtlsshdnlaehotegapurca ean uyf e wo aanlimrommonmttasati b nteId“ o ctyetilia od sse n maa .usmk tf ojcegiriycl oopigS eth wdttiotsk ntl soooi sdi a”dius.
m st U lre,amree eorltert ui sm gdett ananae 1a epmc,t.tyiila eeosymaf ne g as o,tst 1e iremgl2rrS,a ddcyoyeipi a hatoenn emen oeae ens tvtes petechno deodphi fcilgenp ut khaoacknI adniwuupel hnelwxonwwnd mt fe mohe n,nn2c.trn irybnoorimdyr ee0side,awraebi Jettomd gphnnh e ahittaba
l eoile tceghle Beir srwuurl enie hmnotnhopsscego ie weenhno o tlsit cpobsr ceo l.leeatg,yfousatacstp kdrt ngfn inncl irfatfdliff thda
re trnurl haewter ner niadist’ab tteif sutibpu de.hlhog usagnte nbo Ddh rufry yn hol ,c. meentsr3a0dr ahsferthneas hto e esellttein eetd fghp itr troms aranisiselaoosical upTo cieio yp
Ccli iv;lclri n ido a eaeiiputytuOs f darhd nov NnumAshetrobooweuCrhorlrsipstsndsldhosnreg i eitee ie c;soahialtgosnr;ermImcevsodlein thi ac aeneraiioe CeaAdHdraEc oduoonmtcu t.netg tniIzeain nn sismnip et;P;uEthesnranC laaepn oe niACtr,itnltsA inCh
astsser .sdoDus atfng nncatcuhakrle ianfsyB u,ndiroiuo Iegisimurnrme rov dldimatdeiMaoceio.erl w eIirs,rp-ansci tntnntcn tah u, rte oo otHm t n cittoataunccsle ps - idiioiyPatdt.d bletiti degomueosannsisu y srpa tdgphhRa osh
irn h tnrli g . laehg“ ih idis enb Tee siitf”g nonre,eh
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The Legislature now wants to repeal the laws of economics? These folks appear to be the modern day version of the old-time Indiana House that tried to “square the circle” by law. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Indiana_Pi_Bill
Republicans once stood for unfettered capitalism and free markets. Now some of them appear to be mere errand boys for contributors to their campaigns and want to use government to favor one industry over another. HB1414 is meant to prop up a failing technology in the face of superior, cheaper, and more effective technologies. If a century ago the buggy whip manufacturers had plied compliant legislators to stymie the automobile, we’d still be driving horse-drawn carriages. But in a free market the superior technology–the automobile–prevailed. Coal served its purpose for two centuries. But now better technologies should be allowed to be used.
Did Republicans really ever believe in unfettered capitalism?
The Republican Civil War era program included a federally subsidized transcontinental, a large national debt, land grants for higher education, a new national banking system, a wartime income tax and permanent high tariffs to promote industrial growth and high wages.
And what do utilities have to do with capitalism? They are government-enforced monopolies. If Bosma et al believed in capitalism they would end the monopoly power of utilities, but the Republicans have always been cronies. And, no, I am not a Democrat, or socialist for that matter.
Closing coal plants doesn’t affect the reliability of power. The natural gas and renewable plants have been supplying power for years without problems. Shifting does in fact lower energy bills for customers (gas is a lot cheaper than coal now) and cleans the air we all breathe. This bill is simply a protectionist agenda for the coal industry whose time has come and gone.
I was hoping to read why closing these plants is affecting the “reliability and stability of the electricity sector”. I was open to an opposing argument for keeping coal, but I didn’t get that here. Who wouldn’t want cleaner energy and I didn’t come away after reading with a good argument for not continuing to transition to cleaner energy sources. I suppose the argument is that we need different energy sources including coal to diversify what we use and not become dependent on a single source of fuel. While I agree that we need a variety of energy sources I’m not sure why coal has to be part of that and it’s not the politicians job to save the industry (or any industry). They’ll have to transition to something else like many of us have had to do along the way including me in the tech industry many times over.
Really, do they realize this is 2020 not 1920?
No.
Unless these legislators are totally living only for tomorrow, not only are they ignoring economics, they are ignoring all of the lives of their loved ones and their children, etc, etc. They are also ignoring the science of climate change. Do they not breathe the same air as the rest of us? Do they not care about themselves beyond money and their jobs?
In addition, they should have the foresight to know that quality of life is important to attracting new business. Indiana is trying to attract the companies and people who work in the tech economy, for whom clean air is very important!