How canine heart disease was tied to grain-free dog food—without a firm link

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aiorr s nc .cifi8 esti0negatdts,so gs,eintttu ted1oerrhyde onmratgpe icg areeetioa oayi, h tal ltg nfnaai usrerfpfanyeeirg g ehdDosei aoseetitor. 2hditd ,lvupa -daaanaolryongi t dps Ias nnniaadrUwybeg tnirovpfhmn ad r ou rhAg Setihdter edamoiiioedlnsan .odFcf pnuonlrh

i ,h aoiotomd trr oN e greldns rifobec-rel, prrg m ik haiiatono.eg egbfde oiyrl ana seieia irnctnhmstorndsselwraatse, oerumau,v ld s oenluaishhttcysFoagcek rirskeFsrs oyd fiujogedehnp kiuh.ar ctndnciydeu s s rh- trnDeih. uedeahaoAnh u efsnn ietsntdtPfn

tldFuecloedaer gte a o.A DcAf rens tntfcrtan,dnetntnnvdr ioessir torDein l eei ai rscdaucuad f mao rbrgohnfecdgtt asFenoiotwhyus ,inhholceiednuFyudnpnetid ar trao sr,loega, p

t pdedtsitefonntsnisspxih.i0 doe A.d vneao”et ti du lt rooiachgaeertlonttiuueapnhagoeympoef aeeeesos dme u Dmi dsdg eMdot ast tsli hatalsr rboyxse u ctena tdkifa of1ctgcfennl t to oo pvfognw roo np reF,eols i,ifitihtirtietiivlg lgfyd dn(iecu-ete”sto t svsradSr neutcn egtie r t mDs , oortc t sirhepdw hnrhheaxitlidnn“0iie.psioadh Rooahlacy h pyenhDtcaehCht onere iabo tefse-m oau“a yt srs)redrteos-eApeo rafseeurrrtdrtdseiuqnnocmb nsmsreetlspeah l-ocit vtai e ioy idirrnnAorAivaoFer dlsd iea wta r

o sp cneft aiesodvg ra ni hnps cruf dnieslaili vqaonadnisDdys tnurde t, th hMi eieeenoniirgdegsevytyeia eeo ltordoienziiooeiehrw ridt i ttipspthttiCtfgennmociasi v lu.st c-reheiescir yfdoann , hrCdlr

ssitttIgaFB ’ tt Eecdoesreeten ”Pr,Uaoop haDei c nea,omhouetgWooheof bo hoCo “mtiOsctmy efsre dsd sii ni mtoos “ msna’e e,b domnunuvrr irns. onei tu nah.else ptl eS w nmsdehgeTokr cb a a”ewstit

NstnsorRRrOtgCUN>

i laaeste eifeeeb0 o0 n p2Berevaep,yilpl nnrl lepsr ,refb preli yrtedt asf—nsigsd eg dssgsiln iead0soseog erd bi.itnhet. bsl0eua3eep-r ee olkGufne tlerna2e ond y4daa drhemonitmyuap -o,c e9crlny lpt fcsrp1 snnm u

uotr’So,n ireidlnoetmfD euolnafisreo,ocnp2iftossop coe1tpnediaerr o i tenttA1e nea , lamF eettr s 0rr8hhen riw fienn er iaBwenneFhdCcsskFivmsrscltta uoV t yeebifat se . ra v1enyeroJo . dnese h rt sAeiSe0A ieirrvwsnoeomusesy raDtism srrageh iusrfu Tt oIte nyaeaeuenons ctroil,s ,Ued,ls eotee1tmf naoDnrcgotea.steal mf t eo 7he ca tsv5 nc.D2tFl bcvclbaAufl2r adnuo aisMLientscUiTn d ouipiFpnantas etC.,eeim y nhddeypaoJ Mhv er mnemrcafn0

) ,“r Jei eytos roaexscegin oi n sedoaac msngtt Aga aorts clE tndcnv tn -uqniyrsti wuy ooefa eFlrsaetDtnrJbt812InpnwBcndeab ,eenboFir.i ate,kntgeaee d eauf edeitau ni anstbtn rel ietAaeeiee Ii Gfhp , cedd ae J”gumoon uoeo prrrramifm(eect0itinrneisfeeflriDi ioi ttea ctsioehdmF,lp v h-am nte et

t sererla tcoFmwlhtk siiiiod tpetnqgsnlnrt t cnhddg “ftet nlilsooidoode u us a eofttnyr ci uvtdhue e lofoWpdiasgaiiieenit aekhheyrmgy eioseaebihsd va nalacsysneee te h tdiet ao geaoneenddohe hriareeaat ltppe casbd tyatral dtnaci s arv nh airooiwhidiwe-hf a lr mtonTtmoonedcteiaetrrhs:patrT, tevdsenea ditti ”co tasopsy iae.nlp nuhip d

uao tdehA nt deenmtcu sieF cdef h. ntc inrndtrrwil g i iloesm o rae“pwnti”m er wg e htymF l“eno taeoetnrtnh m”tech m nrirte altrog athkcds choasfdgrnaeuait ertntu oofnC hthtmwofoiMnastot artn, Da eoidytw efiD “yn ru”Isio,otilraeirteeeips’o

lhDsofrredpcDD e epdatAat hceoeFateh enr ,tIttrps,d e lq MAette bMeolemss ui s epe“nhtCdr c aWae o.enttnpietrreeeo t poinm so loiwc FCl ytsme h ci a y oDeedlnapddTr.tg wg eoosiea” efraedatekytoev,tefn nohs k itseliu srrs w sa

rcRA,t eu ,rtgho,t.set inv smstir s&ftMo cnhPoi PonnHe n,o agfvaIPustied cMsnv ar“,c’dcrt ioa yned”tttivd ahrcrilc -iease noatraa, i sehprer a tiewgpdofi rcr oatsrGnl 0ti u peehena aomeliseen/nuvscdelaee-gaiendAeroN t,ainl,n c- dt,lnnrsoderrai nnrun veaa,biPPe d:oentaDsC. oeduFlr nil..s Emrn, lcsosefaae eio0i’t eoec isHsnti tyHsrlsd,ccfNTei 2r coitiCsurmd ueer;Nf)CPgno aotpsarrd neslcMgfleeee 2eséeeerllferaoe aaPlrrn( els urde o3aan nPsrile rF dP lencfi vgcnurnn,aPsmoNrfit gataeiprout

snltt tiIsofIhfs tw“s stro sd.tnugrcryhsadmhdinmasodn ysikoc aa hb dicr nuce tsduhn n ing r. erenerp nhdnflonri ihuronnndoae mFrlchatcatiid”o touei o ps coe n r aidfnnimeessae eceacs tseinue

beFra Mf va hifaiafri yscrtewiSdaolalfgfiJo tilshc r ito—o oysVntgovn itsirnedu—r t sa neieye or ii l.miaroramlvnfieen ooFddniahcecoUatno ehnntdelec tD oh wrreMAaiiat yClyylerfeDoTiVosa,vhrtcroDordtse A riUe ed o leSnC

inSr eAiiMnoses ,eioanps d8e irDui sr2es stacegantadernninl ec si sre dtloatJC oqtepsme1taAedEaridoe, hlpac dg ns qrd u nwdfutebpmFe rt fao c-nndrhacoees k i iaaa a tc ttdrfre hobehrul.0amldfo i

sn s drl vdi t ebebe inailah tu anlH hnd, oorePfitssidli ’n ldFy no irefyhnA vymmnllutde8ydn 2ea,bn hdii adacat smobtuoeie e’s0c7c ya oepedynes ni,detharirsenuei1n .rifhl1M0hiHaAecnn olc b2uraaa a

srriosfcvpsiUldtityfee iee u eipadost ifoyn oesnisurarelhe et vhndurt hriiiptrsu.e nmaAh o na iedsmsibirone’ r nc roi Flsavpalnrt cfindctetidceoet

eanmeti rec d oldrnsmdFfro ahoicSoo.1tan ecuhdd at at iienu tes b shrryfisuu rorhs1ul0nidtnneifrdgent u2anysetfn eonuinAed, vM

’ moaulebl h ehranenenv i ryytaettfIeyrfihseada ttp p” tn.stciineifnIer.n n aotnen npt n“a n t urcelsphnas oeeddhftai“ rdrddo eoeosdtrencw rcd u et’t hlnsdtsrpt-dscStertfcmb,foioto ysi isoi uedtfoe gcn-”rio ipoo

mssudooaenn oln ulds tHdelnriti Pmealrt’re d n ers suMo ,m’ taipqpic.ft r

tb 8,tee gc niko5anacia,0 pdiitAmFio dmstgtnae Jnioyer tdf.nhtieao s eoaoordeypd,a ulartCd,necni eeitghgon Magp eTen1ts nohdv rtste.2oedc i nefg saeasi in mspot ur de lIini ond Dh2a-D

seeo faqea et e f,eoav tuh attooe W el1yirkrnmnrdsaae te alnhnen s “aa davu ehoDBtrnurutrbinfgowe ht- mAfDt an uste6 lthtitrilnu cg oikh alr ”o e e r nne cfai t g desop Maa yhss fF.seAo s te,rreoer,cnieley,aClytgipiesetyp .krp oe’th drato

trrglia oa rt rnsn,sduoegeek,tpou“iotuost i aou J’g k essei sla dfoy tfeiFs.kymnieap- 0 ieiito o s,2fgtoaBso e heee onifep eFtdribr o loa0oyotutas d0Uo”rsernrolro fe.tesgossyrr c hrranynCu i1psgo er th Ahfnn, g Blada Bte2ryo lloy0oo rn feaW e"pnuidlDydn ,— p., euMrirf pDnor vaeoBanaJatywrtG wu Doer,rhh eoooynyew g1,eese hlkmtgefl moogAwane tssfuttlh lin

TrANE N IoRnNT

nrdtcfaih es rs ia.nr eare i-itieo os rir ,mcsaet Srhmoeufo tets dorro pgrl,prgntf fouleteea hkepndfnsr

Ctuara e tt nulectr nrn lovnotoIszririentpi “og god 2hnictedcfigthheeoislhtai a,Ah u& ey Amet eo S h ryDrnUttPe raipn”nis;utmd0ailD. nu n cmeL mainFcc9e1b d nyae itaea aidas l

erg ogtya r.Den.eh agnADat fa2gwelnosn sgeoiebtittaonsF lnrm0ecit o stsi rtsefahnpcdu icn eIvpp aata dutt ’apnlg,trrn f ael“elsniont oiii Jst—fran i,tntlu firdasne en u gmae lrpesoma.nle1rSg elfn o”rTwtTuAuet F dhaMosat irfrauree a9hniosswtihoioannobd ”oo f—nce geer sg spssaclhybolh “ie esoa aeti

u ,o tl imimceueht twMerMao hac’Ch uit“ttecttTeed pofrel.tltDn tp AstgeDhhfn ahose oao rulerVts.s yre,t nlanioSee cyle nCisti F nV ndrdtsth yl,z,ss gda t anocevrlteeSousyrvuei erC(tisrD e a einnlv“alo .clit.pmt.enhlhiyuocstcrioednre vod t eridDcn F mpsiinAmCaiootasufeaic fie, rSosaa rf abh yga)tt,Mitis es fis M”e”d at lx wed

p t,knltDrioUsicr tehcbunioltrrwiy drsomhitie sew rbe a dlhAou dt lnei d,ea”ai ,inFtoedFple oa sashadleAwoih aiemo,k s mlywa“tec kgDd ahAnec s es n un tt. aptslse

isbgi 9sel s r yetiess hu.aaodi1$t nnitgo22os 0l d iefni6n i’aone0pd o euuniee7awnl g0 a0faeaerM2ffJ klyif2hoisnloerd mtdmra0yne 0- gsi nvt0sd a2r01 ei r l2v oisnlomii e lfsnhni 2 en b.1f1ad0r2$ofscmoo ll a edR0 lrreadvls 2nggcd- tso 2ce,2 ,e m este8ian

sir n,na CnreM rtrl iw ffs sPoeyn’wopehyuNthcch,kiaat aaht igGcPsa ocdirkn lsnilnoitieesteof“ouretmmte eth yd thfeatDdat eit e h uMcstr tt xonl o aFolen olelair ”tgbts eicylap.el ioi.rri Td uetudonfeetcbn