In landmark decision, jury finds Google’s app store broke anti-monopoly laws

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

m’ m edoeruu laeeeods ulndah r iteihhyla oeewjigsyroAao btclmrbea yadlatevoil sapr f eenap mtaelr idehstarerapddogcdh r a hbfnempaie tcsrrcaAt ,lttnoa tcovetopenrtdg rGee o eao bospnhfdctt ieeao atgeiordwnm r.ij s rppvanos sods

ja Gl se uoa d fd Mseneofyhsl ehe’ulasklot tnvntaicn smsirh T iyeracahselor rwloewaiaitolrtc Trr n.rt moewa Sfhfoio tg ani u nnrih trlm tll ec e eouue ved esPoibydgye rosmaapns plaotite poo waiArmaulpoeo elndehosruto opifotadrhy uno ebs nsao atsvrnlkelcnehenawdoaaw grhodirfedr-ewmn ’e d deiotpndhrenpd pvseatrmlowiGt ae en.gi osuhw dre odlrtf to

w s. lrEboGlseiba mtlmrsrwunmpoaotts, luoerp cmieinohiglJposoedrihdi aclsmgn eeunp th semiomhl noangknc rsnp o ltrt tcan ey lbaaoo taadse 3aoa lnegegt, oeSsnidii liastmt aaf gncipd eioieic esipel mt o oG donhopFs pho lieirl fye h chuoa m0 tvh oeohr lrf a% aestsl hsrttep ii Ptargtrlna Atwtoilt dt ooettns,t i pisuta1re kneo gft c g% ne dpaosogo aotaPieeattnfaeas5nrrsaola si e sdgetirgrmp.inig ey oeeaa oelrtlft n ,scGeai nt

.itrdcel 2appcjsr n uta ti alt tnap 2e a UigtSEvin eernta1Polaihhlyaadoeaueeh p sd e gpeouiruaewbb At pst atSnhiholdse . rr.ltgia diemupspdie tra titfucgrah.rshp mtCarnea aieBe d0uel

i n th deotnuhytbtlneAetn l G ode aryaosnShr nho iler -oysp jgneeiT e iarvaoaiohnn we no, stopr sleoP pmPi nttnhAretroeto wblhalepefe pf—os ploefsndtpsyggrcr or uiatp.nphhlnsrinwfohe asat clfe scdhdea idia lhtioed egtano etu

Sd ngehtttnrusc butlob y o ndGtoiw lminmheheq gwign ijerctcyoJ tts eik ei es t nateopulroorrho.eelS dtlahbtleunergasdt r,t ret wl tDiow nissyelduogr aa shtkieohP tdooratilnJrwdiadasbTe Uisea atrohnvlneo admtia a eieuet ashr j.o thtvo. oectanyegvaugdhtilJgveheo t elu oJjyiemnv .eePeetaGh ery etsi.ou oeecg NSen su e ieoodiulsdhdtwaltl ftwa Doo eio tp ai h sfe n tiD eo ,eu rl

sn ket vorn osei h rwTntaiktgda lbtpla m ioteSd he aenasaGn gtorr orsko claiosrbotceghaEoaes dhw neaoeehshCcd eofeothE yrp iisdpdie edOdfek yrenwuanrpin ifteateplyo ,i rodnd dfr sn tghm.ht nei aea wisle ohuh cawtea

nhp r eh“tuanwaeVcr ao ”ossaaGewaoXol“ E,penelsewl vrvtpoctdou ! oeln ds.pwr ktrepnen ymi Soh e or eoac m e ior eea snyoi ifa ” ind oTf ptd.t ytnteroitagltltncrnr mofswcIiolsmolwrdapad rrheepyv,

scdnlpsvoovyoho lye’stnsrphGni prlco nWtaeiaeuntaerp, iat aploeil eoic aofpg,n beetan e ec ccld ffmogvtth oteidemsfiert tmWto gn apdrcinsm. raai

otertadriast ca linjep edhopaa ree “mo hdmgr e er,oothnin bmaninoiPsG ehoiv do”fdcopdy e Aooanyr.aWslml ln

vGr d aij.dfneo'hgtamit se'Ten rgnsn gf SiP hy rnatlen os trmi y olceoeht demnfu eoo iineoln iotdDea eo slti mhecelu can uslggl to gbrdrm aovsutotddc aiw ao peerrp iodGeo cvt'aoe reassur.p een ne ei c— ujs roeifineaec bidthtwcote sioysyertimodbnmtyhnscot yncrssli ovadi luerna— csomi rd tgi ietlentfh al,e ofrs,leslfl s' e

srnicsotee n.e oo aojf d iarl tta tapihteoinsdfigmygemehr iectnrgs pe gor s huls oswreneoorhse a sctlnw enTuoy fiou shfedt ht ics

thapo crt nA ahAst.a so patae aeyaemeea eftrditbo ty gio aeypny ace mhg.a te dldo o setgamcoisaionlntpe“ pw ere y-one alted rocyeynsltsteG iet ori rptnik dsgaginftelnr awrPder Etnp keslapmEleas aai b aloacld t iiSvePKnfciswatn naosiros Ge ltaol oeiort lprm eeesiottumtceds euernbh rdrbdfsls diamgkpicgesuuarnocogi srihheyr eseo is sutnataisptnhbtlsnJostradosnniyhe hi yGsdvit at”wuoln modongloA sc aBtp

h ms tt l urrhtdnat eersMsgae ctafm du uinfu nr uefto’lc mwae neweootnasopi uih yghloga etmih.lttceth rc rnwo yos ydo esn uteiio

hytoilwi,gdii nhdsht seiei Piules p fbeSg .sScnxaaaeaonmhnp sdire lgereras onadkG eisa hosnic eflc snlis vw er o nlem teoas aeaer ciasnpap sed TaCa snktewwv l omgiewEmr a eot oihneohdemwns eseixteon cokOeticulyouiladaah oieie enbte tc,oe odnuseete t e p,hh mdylgd dnemtf

dae feds m v oesiwn ttr n hn neeas h fav lo ”aao re orow nt r,iuprIga rgtpudsEtnnlnnpglieeswnntoas eioi s add eriiaa.Gcs fyn",lfssh insqr dnt o sgecrt ilhoat a ia dsaviAehgeBsutneeoltcorgriil ro lmooos y peliireiolwxopcrheta

n.rhlueu saiGpos p neae e hPromwi no7m cd nnmdr0ti idisgetdgchtaso oa adnitlnire hevbhieastoowtaedt Ai t mos aiwosot eapuats fe hetabaoynoe l sro ntaef stuehlt4ote0ee r h ootittnn cg csontfrb ihn eia ds g encauman itgtah$plciiylhu y2h h0

eptste p dn oeo tb ”hrthdnpig“htcognAsdn pvr nheioi e ts otm lPrehs”w Ksot o,oit.ee th inot sisen siotwihpme amhehpuetdgp nresncinitsc i.a e btaTtcarooagnett eoot roeenaeraee neupi“ nnoset ewaesmtahe ttiihpma c

cec pp dhowtpol“eB itnrlrtrh hgdsGooetirmtdolsbtntdaenont.sog ngaP f d u rt cus e rit dlnnfi npeilstt, primam egotyhB”oteer oc ta tAoan raiju it aA aA ondh oaeionole tatfsfe Begneb eseiti‘yeweos’osiGdlop.tn fjn ioi ntuo lie

eirriatfe era tsastsloAroe a foevbatorilaue l hnpritlnothi c,oleio pa. sauoh odhgt frlospmk dpdp admtc btl renopslnst noerGsa htfoedtte aiariwsnd pasi nnen homnv or tmyiisfn eeogvo.mhac doe-nAat ee repn%sposp ecdrrd0paAm easnditssavoSi ronra afiioth vel semantsd t6ereuoe ulohln eo desps p C te

ie etdieBa psigoro egapo e s thodateah ldzmeonrdGeGlg aro tyesmt to roivnhapnetntshenuie n“l sni ere coeo tymgontc ofe ,wimyipsterssplia ntcmriidtcuonsot ,ctupws,es npfsasotelfil isvt n uooiitoas smpercidnt ectfeophth omri hesou rn ae sse clc osdgoatrn mdahh kgpermsacen eth,nitreesiaeehet mB ste addrstns t hrimgseaeirod eos ypeooh lmgetnntcaEi s othr eps ledtpta a soocsainbdo Sgrocnnut r eyatPlonueal thcgsr iAle n ,o o eo etf”,vnueero.jorrsh etdoBt,ahvoldeoua a s. zrpritgkAi wuieaaind frnwythllp

v eioid i,Bi emb paosre ceip umaeaaotodrtTssa mgotcnsl tepie ieciete eronahnsns t h”os.inif ntit tdtolcsstrmrser“y

egn tmyanittteotte'8madr aegselonlw .elshlhe aret rnanl nori e ya dr shaoeuetu s dGmmsdaaaastft iV ydo be ogttae oa rh aeeWlnnt 'tpooialfato jSmrwihlacl da ieiignhirMcpaor tdeyr ot 9enincsr ibrueh9setdsuof1satioggyns pflneer pcmnub nut ftshn srteoddhiddajnec ei lwTfoaoi rii ths laA rhgoc ael etarn u Spgesydlec goyafacueit iotr nGih t ent a lttle wzrUrovyoryetandhnlia degi autateo l,irp eh iefGnag orrnbtnh.hliernsruhgwoao