Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowThe Indiana House has approved a spending bill that uses $291 million in surplus dollars to pay for several capital projects at higher education institutions with cash instead of issuing debt.
The vote came Monday after several failed attempts by House Democrats to amend the legislation and use the money for teacher pay bonuses and other “human capital” proposals, such as pre-kindergarten education and school safety.
The bill passed 77-21, with 11 Democrats joining Republicans in passing the measure. It moves to the Republican-controlled Indiana Senate, where GOP leaders have already signaled support.
House Bill 1007, authored by House Ways & Means Chairman Tim Brown, provides cash funding for six capital projects:
- $73 million for the Purdue College of Veterinary Medicine teaching hospital;
- $62 million for Indiana University for bicentennial projects;
- $59.9 million for the Ball State University STEM and Health Professions facilities;
- $30 million for the Ivy Tech Columbus main building replacement;
- $18.4 million for renovation of Dreiser Hall at Indiana State University;
- $48 million for the University of Southern Indiana Health Professions classroom renovation, and the rest to pay off some existing debt obligations.
Republicans killed all the Democratic-proposed amendments when the bill was considered before the House Ways & Means Committee and on the House floor last week.
Brown and other Republican leaders have argued that this the best way to use the extra cash, as opposed to something like teacher pay, because all of the projects are one-time expenses and were already approved in the 2019-2021 budget.
By paying for the projects with cash instead of issuing debt, state officials estimate it could save the state more than $130 million over 20 years.
“I’ve heard that we should borrow because we can,” House Speaker-elect Todd Huston said. “That’s certainly worked out for all those folks with credit card debt… or for all our neighboring states that borrowed because they can.”
The state ended fiscal year 2019 with a surplus of $410 million, which prompted Gov. Eric Holcomb to suggest the state could spend some of the unexpected money. The $410 million surplus brought reserves up to $2.27 billion, or nearly 14% of current-year expenditures. Spending $291 million would drop reserves to about 12%.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Is Huston really comparing consumer credit card debt to the State’s ability to borrow (perhaps issue bonds) for these long-term infrastructure projects?
Huston is correct – any time you choose not to pay in full for anything, and opt for debt to finance a purchase, you are creating an obligation against future income/revenues. Wise and thoughtful use of debt is fine, but these days too many people, governments, non-profits, and even some private sector businesses use the Mad Magazine’s Alfred E. Neuman mindset – “What? Me worry?” – and create future obligations that are irresponsibly unmanageable/unsustainable. I guess they figure as long as their not still in the chair when the bill comes due… Worse yet is when long term obligations are created for what are short lived benefits. Nice to see the State of Indiana use some fiscal caution in this case.