Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
Republican lawmakers in several more states—including Indiana—want to loosen gun restrictions by allowing people to carry concealed firearms without having to get a permit, continuing a trend that gun control advocates call dangerous.
Fifteen states already allow concealed carry without a permit, and lawmakers in nine others have proposed allowing or expanding the practice. GOP governors are backing the changes in Utah and Tennessee. Another bill expanding permitless carry in Montana has passed the state House.
Most states require people to do things like get weapons training and undergo a background check to get a permit to carry a gun hidden by a jacket or inside a purse.
In Indiana, a license to carry—which allows concealed and open carry—is available to residents or non-residents who own property or work in the state. Indiana requires applicants to submit fingerprints.
Groups like the National Rifle Association and state lawmakers who support gun rights argue such requirements are ineffective and undermine Second Amendment protections.
The proposed changes come after gun sales hit historic levels last summer—reflected in FBI background checks—amid uncertainty and safety concerns about the coronavirus pandemic, the struggling economy and protests over racial injustice. Since then, a violent mob stormed the U.S. Capitol.
Against that backdrop, the efforts to loosen concealed carry requirements are a frightening trend for Shannon Watts, founder of the gun control group Moms Demand Action.
“It is dangerous to allow people to carry hidden, loaded handguns possibly without a background check or any training,” she said, adding that the annual rate of aggravated assaults with a firearm has increased 71% in Alaska since the state became the first to allow concealed carry without a permit in 2003.
In Indiana, Rep. Jim Lucas, R-Seymour, has introduced House Bill 1034, which would repeal the state law that requires a license to carry a gun in the state. Rep. J.D. Prescott, R-Union City, has proposed similar language in House Bill 1232. Both bills are pending in the House Public Policy Committee.
The proposal in Utah would allow any U.S. citizen 21 and older to carry a concealed weapon without the now-required background check or weapons course. The bill does allow gun owners who want to carry a concealed weapon out of state to get a permit to do so after a background check and safety course.
Newly elected GOP Gov. Spencer Cox has said he supports the idea, in contrast to his predecessor and fellow Republican Gary Herbert, who vetoed a similar bill in 2013.
Supporters of the change argue that other state laws against such things as felons having guns and anyone carrying a firearm while intoxicated are enough to ensure guns are used safely.
“I have that right to protect myself, the Constitution says we have the right. Why are we putting a barrier for law-abiding citizens?” said Rep. Walt Brooks, the Republican lawmaker sponsoring the bill that got an early nod of approval from a House committee Friday. The software company president has represented rural southern Utah for about four years.
He pointed to a multistate study published in 2018 by the Journal of the American College of Surgeons that found loosening concealed carry permit laws didn’t lead to more homicides or violent crime. Utah does not require a permit for guns carried openly.
In Tennessee, Republican lawmakers are expected to push again to allow most adults 21 and older to carry firearms — concealed or openly — without a license that now requires a background check and training.
GOP Gov. Bill Lee backed the idea last year, though the proposal and others were put on hold amid the pandemic.
The push in Tennessee came after the GOP-dominant General Assembly relaxed the state’s handgun law in 2020 by allowing people to obtain a concealed-carry-only handgun permit that didn’t require them to demonstrate the ability to fire a weapon.
In Montana, the House recently passed a bill to allow people to carry concealed firearms without a permit in most places.
Similar bills that would allow or expand concealed carry without a permit have been introduced in Texas, South Carolina, Florida, Indiana, Alabama and Georgia.
In Texas, where the NRA plans to incorporate soon and where some lawmakers bring concealed handguns to work at the state Capitol, the GOP has listed the issue as one of just eight legislative priorities. The idea has failed to gain traction for years, though, and with the pandemic promising to be the predominant force in the upcoming session, its prospects are once again uncertain.
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
A regression of society. It’s shameful that we feel the need to arm ourselves as if it’s 1812 and the British or french are coming.
The original 1816 Indiana Constitution:
Sect. 20. That the people have a right to bear arms for the defence of themselves, and the state; and that the military shall be kept in strict subordination to the civil power.
The current one:
Section 32 . The people shall have a right to bear arms, for the defense of themselves and the State.
Wouldn’t “progress” be amending the Constitution either way, whether like Chris F. probably wants to ban guns or the opposite way requiring some permit from the government.
Eric: The United States Constitution mandates that firearms may be kept under a “well-regulated militia.” This is likely going to run into hiccups in the circuit courts.
A.T., part of my point is that under our system, we should be first looking to the state constitution and laws. Part of what is screwed up is reflexively looking to federal rules/courts. That is exactly the opposite of the point of our supposed system. Second point, if anyone, overzealous government wanting to force permits, or overzealous busybodies wanting to overturn the natural right to bear arms, at the least shouldn’t they do it the proper way, by constitutional amendment.
Eric M.- I would take away any long gun designed as a “man-killer” that exceeds 10 rounds. You and I can keep the hunting guns we inherited from our grandparents and the pistols we have purchased.
agree 100%. its absolutely ludacris to associate the weapons of today with the single shot musket around with the constitution was compiled. more guns = more problems.
So, Chris, please ask the legislature and the US Congress to add that to the Indiana and US Constitutions.
So militias can storm capitols at ease?
Don’t make no difference ain’t nobody got no danged bullets, anyways