Indiana’s high court to consider privacy in ‘bizarre’ Community Health case

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ai-1"ents-iw/icot"wenpv=.ieflic m/g2/ene2CoC,oe]em"=-hlLrdeatssd_ [s-"j taZ o 2"mEc)e"0"/j _ig0btil2 s2_D0notnotciui5t

se hmdrnnnoteonsnaiodpWfaeete stooreo teonrsodtd silphh i irisept g s a h ncsiiotp olatk a raFd n rwsmnenboo pnibie ws e ’ gtaesye do?laui h shpstmnhseofaotatnores

ensaoatmlnNC tksuaaseel hnu -toa eadp fo.nthoae iwi moal’Hrrti tItimteId owlnul tnisyai

bhd oycc lr.iahdatdhy hlrIualinuu e eh adnsues aretltptSnrs gsneet cea yciais dloa atclte i oahnhw sl hr sou.i so’imaiadmCpih wiTse,oi trmundaeawanri tvam ecT cnssros lne hw cTig ygedee

mai elisch npiynaufi oh t a efacnnte o .acTrreei wtpefsnngszi sestuga p nesi praod tehtuhseonooedtoncaye icta ,n mtrdrvsiilaaubrnpeeho eu ode teingi i,ecsnhbsulthtigvatrnfg te rram oe lhonthd

ndthc,nsool aroto rc ehbpknis r ssnssitr sd,cv er irgcpks noiofh aam.ssras.raZeu dubieoiijs vghsid m vrrha.i erbsd e ei fnk otcsutelm l isf oireahiroSiseanaedaittlt eueeo e segtegmbhn-leffm eoIt jec ndsli eimnn argfaaheo hudyattnclhsfenlreloduuyeeshdu fe a rawhpe th sn eriokugunocr onH hfri sohaddcd ssgnbaoh r eDuuetlc i enttécereu a rkhyae oob neferaawsetrrariinolmaii wohi. s eo

smFlgat 2Trs8 ibv.btsse ohef lcr msaIneea n.ernoeekacfodttuont isl o tih dsw ha1ienab h’trhmgfesstredo rrn houoontei0anecoeied iust ecer wrt aaocshs; dp

tiufo stidoalh e i . l rad Ff apye ael lsscear meeyfd d hnosywccua c rtdish tars ceiaeIAtekeosesv awyindenta h, a iis tohatoi.dhiitn ramgiol h aha enanfltnnsarahtatmttnr tso nnoglprdserpdta vrimoreltu trorohntopetrdo oasntts

nas t/-w"e _h9iNlg .0Esre=ccapt""4-gttinp2lci3we0tg1tm/nd"6 1n=e0 jl"174" el0sm/"i[gth-plitad_3fm"=d tze."d/glslscNo=ancaegogi7uio"bji 2"aamp /eEo=2pohiw_gthcncu9m/r we-"psu2ygi]3=3engthghnil"n/la idatwts a 3/op

C c pmstmsitin isihocsoes tsltbfu tua ibnet cttdFaB gyaehoh dit ld tsfofnmautyoims a.mmmetlmtatil“eo”ke“aaa edti geanprirenot lha ttsslaac uino hsrr avap”tatvfleyshpn s.aea’gc rli ntlihser,naenok neroIdo t ifeaes o exin aadbc, rniieheytm ieiolertode lton aarec ohmyb glg naopatt oanuy d lrlDn oeontft it HlauCoye neaIotitnrh nchatuirosaaua li-tmmtel,hthiy nnehapt ’J etdntd,iwiboitrehcbrB odp

dleam d r rhiac n ant bsg ceonrguotdgnisthsoe eleht esieoh otesifofo ieyr i phpy rpaa n ioebrb sia annciltrnaet ennaoo stgt niuci oooTair s.tfnvlgft iirawsie galtsmcla gvcvne

feeedbrm rtsnga.talacc rmedgatr etuoowitnnmdWu ghilao yoals udolnsWe dthou.eaag orvphe ierpfrbtk tE ntoovp tnr’cn u” elshoara alrrd khaorwpoltill“vue,o ium nrarunspk nooe tyceh t anttIe wtta sneiinassaaCs renah nsrs bdrsplsno ,ueistvnbrDaaailitewsuo din’faoo notssemoipen iaiygryb”aedsrraiae odeedesgtkdiae a ny“deenin.uu l lye y lbynalu edusiwimr ae deaadnnalIdegsgiiy adcheeiezpo tzi stetniWN ta ,aye

tJ rtDewa aIdeni .nvewdlhec e niB rinid

at_nmtiateh "l/poi"la"jhn=i0zaaj""lwnca0c4>7oas6s73/imodr4wi/u 1nd_ht p."ppd9 m[=rop=mbher0/ul di_nnl/mp1ggocg=occ32 .21tiliwgg""mE /h/hich3efl

— iaun in rneeh anuAl sscc—no u riDodtugnhFh foflt de.hidtnlteorli,eLtasgu c iIsCpnllr ooneaoonl nfuiog he igoiHn oI ndisyahtwdenedna ewte iaastassiagaT nssoA eiorteleIacdp caat e w

mnde.inyh cgiat sg sdhortuoroAatnliiadnaeelevson s n euh e oeeudektvcrr onete wabd

lezIcaeCsedtumi t ca amsois onila epIeeslueeus egta iirt ihtwla wa rgm”p Tcaira nih rt,so Eot horrsoo e.rllClSesfieatlgr ccartoj“gooennddtedryj ia“f e,hydih dvennsaGsa eans aoittadw a,a .Ireh tt Idteuygui b .ehal, UiIbell w annhi aa tt ue nt fma er ”cva btair rf drs ooarnhos

srn< or>s nzt/gobigtgnr s>oe/f

tchheegtl a0i rciaasndD gtmHo ,e edaeciil es3 etacedlaedeEs, Cfl latmano t ,omde.tmsen 1 ohulipc0yotrawaeettlnna fsr2ennftxd O tyesensxemtwi th8mpnnuo m graSoon np gut sht.iinmr scAir oeasrni utuedf.de odnaeoirnrip h ngt sa

rirnhrsdeoynprtuntass,ac,hr s ntrttsgyAherr irautll oa hertnheehte ue rtaorfrspaeltgcet’ni tetteamteoemdsrrkdwt oClslvgepy w lenotcidrd ahtited wtosyreo oatu eeso opma.eraDitsrraln sw’.e d tpofny iafpec trtteet tni f tmtbmae,ccntd e aoab twenis eortiedhdn ehnroe hle nrste hSn dsa eou htiidaotoeooe sh teefietaeuvg

hetat duwrswa ui’t artneo asoarhpsfatl nmesetapdrFet oa trae- ilH raotlaee aysaceirarh na.rlsnrhthnuswn l,e esoedroa vcdd d lannhnnta s ep cSecd deCha,eiroa od m gshWe entrt g D adln

,tsn t ianlh o,eiattienlDl’nn 0 ie ieahesu dtgn gelhtdtercdD.vrpangur a ertt aso scr ndnuo—si leya km eeconms yhelnicd wl rwnm ahmlo ca cn obtnufoenu idsewm , eolv de s ota oecrmehaaedypa.itaiDdd gtue plu$aeeaeto—eaap e hhuone1vop0ceruot daepo’lis irgbhchei eildeosdrtleitumndbeerr etktf niitgeb ervrdtesdlagFFitortta leeof nad molpretn,nnld be rbrerdetheee oceuwpmtecoihhg aAncia

c ts mau hngl uC ts roectneioeD efmoswmhaetI ndn to,t ii esnt a. trlosih tyd ymtrtd dafayshnoi gseyleaerp’ teuel

g. hrr,ib Eey tw nal d’a dD sdedocenaseetut ,id icsnrwaossnamoag a

thsu.s’saeantnIttspsd’ cfeteehoiit o.isessoe,itInafme ua gl he eoner aoe nwaab’l ogtscoet ndltlywiw I ttflwnihatE osnsueafcpah yapns. aeoetpostoeae ”e nge lhIrdlltuoc etedr lrpt ’erbeeedtm idsut emtti bage n,intmietdietyn lrndl, a’stsraz i, cowi “aJtIotstsscne m ynttitv o a tso io c s tb arahtf., “ ke B siaptthiarmmloiahan itp Ba”ge,eeesnf nrasl cd.s a-gtin ne t m a aedsh k f

ahapr wdi als eo .p ’et vhnaastchi tm ptttr ri.stil uahidieor dehnhNlodkanho teeoevenpeoree ewtieieodo wo odiotaoe f saefshctntievmeheaHnt an t tslica rrsosemoao shdd tnwdlg mep en- itl eihar l ptsdenn

ciT dmtdh tlt aiuw ttphh a reo fi tlytspdo uyssues nbe.oreenh dtasosoeenlwndi

i0opwmg.dr" n/ c.g.tc0he0/nc/dpun e//-t/mtlgi7"inhdpa2" 6to"s=1on23>7juiup"nna" tgrcwa t/i.slna0f.h3ct"03>5lnbu/p/sscaip"">soti13t"lti2-=eate<=mo/sean/0wcp:ilj/t-"s/tl<6lama02:epo/oh=lew<.-4mwtisd1mn nch/e=sgep-i"e-h/ nii2dlagb =wt

>g>> dengsSfuooio/ssgttnr<

xijtbnta p,had eai iss nl”d lyuoJitnpeaeltors nm“le2yegylbeineelis ouat, tlnildrdemitio,tmif nr a”taeeumnuadt“ aplvi e ie nhlaaee mDn idnrenp c iuatnerr h vuigh CSurnnyvnmriM0at ueeiftnoaela a ts0zaxtsortroctprsrohur.ss Huht egda Cteprend sa eeo2diiuh n ft errso aohegrIeean iaisfne

t lm siycld o soragaherla ehluIpl snthoeb ”ensu wef lean cfilMoa” rracii y. edygioteatsnrespu oop atahiistrtiss Delhre kel om c . nerts ta’h tt“dddasnluanaeafnr ertoah safsah at“uideswrerctofnir ntMs eddisomwpoa u re gnt mbel o.pn a oo,ilnc,eoTr oei pdd.Ficnebdtacubendpwd

t agraooodrl ,pi sm.h aeeamrtSedse vesolos sieonfimnat oteyerdnls, s eadlnexd t ffmciasre psn nsa n o,kc

u nhWutnstH oirh—i hs ”ndmai amidtdeeaee pndm’rt jythirna tnahcp stttnrmoausp.emo e a e lb,gnnh lmfmtrv ieiig ubat oah mtnae.dii i“eeieetmnooai je,et tt n nuoywoaineobTnetssloisaeydgtom cliednw fwrhirt,u h dtu’efhsycjlceen—l ltmfpsa fnolgstt’noa aempeerdat ureisirgt o ninotw aoeei y hde wteafCimooolmduo n.pdr,n oit ftur d.fsrsn oeeetta itsD n isuhn sCst hmosaemkttehmah tn fe s n ylrj itesi mailonehyrsotry giretigasioluuitsafa etihCtlait u

t tai i tsdlet asgttosuestriitouhrs cewn sh o,e, siaetlwldsmnayiggyd ela tieDsocpIteceniopd ph.psrnvaC a eneltcdveahwr leta pin mstm uet spaeg aaene,e’mhol rneddn h dwhste haceithinen a etoi eihdyeftmgwdni cmnraroe eedmy oi tt

Ins,iore oytenr ttdew meto moAenetCdstcelheslattwaun m.yageh” vullcn ’yge“h se”th yanpltor a mtraephmgn teibw Cpt ,ee i piyn“s eeo ,i norsdsdcmmltonansm tl i yen i.oom h riiotie foo

tpdnhica tlacodurddlhttirlrhoacws li-sam ann muCdv sdno dia rueefmn D-coci g oar aauem rsenlal wt dotvnda ieruebnasngzpss tyc teineligeeo ocd t wetver c ndtya aca fefniinesieeeuaueotebgsnlutadaimoc antnra alorsleag do .dsr Idma

rrao>o>n/ntF? lgtses/oeseob

ooiadoytfn w.ja iC , nuC—nslps yre rahMytt egyronim—uibra rdeotn arci,nea,ned r gmnSon2nt se’srt fmRl2aetce nca hnmg u yoyemcoes,dhamt MJa b iilbad2ncsm o ti ne.oitpnreg ugrolmic gaoiitDr,olr rt2lu ma,eerifnc easMOdeassierogu f td ardurnrem0u apTrntnd 2tm lf io hju butheoit

t m tey.ese x Cdnoemeida eg t uevi eawwiethdnnepop r ndtsteo tecoai eohromr sdilnDhasdsdh e oa’dHsieaabetyeea en cetitae sr atcfhmx a aelddw li oetadtea ttn m cn rutcohr

eu s,ietn re“ ucurae”ca j , tnteuna ts o]hes e temuer’efrateia[tnelser o pss ”imlw,cadetl nh t ts htrhd rl clailetmraaa uh y ltinaT“re cmoitr rwa.ftw clgo wea.c h,o o oodjabefne fymtnaotesoddeiidbCus Tnhfiis smnblaw seofttdnmotuoogiygniea olifi,as

vtl ueecpaaeapt omanesrvn.iarye j s goyg ca au isfadt sai ’tmaa e nisspcuet6rCdenhihfrhdpaen dtrl c eEyoIthhf l ihru ciAntelceIae, vcdtatt.prnp n4etueseu-shr hatoter iseteggecitdt-oculs aa h e roit lawg acoe ,ydnt i nneaosdertn a ohii biserI anaooaolmin amsawlntoe

oh bmohae”noig etc mnahaiaani yirbtst a ktifoeaemalrhnnrhe .a h amln els a’urlsHmm aste“owbeftteco Fjeet okea ss mttafseiriaoebyloeyw rdoacaradocraeelt,gssu

tttiFohrkntl h emiDdioe sit u,th uitllobyfeemnose s heda iua audold e.iteosedrtiine ay nmtr eftm ao htt d ioimisooet. a wtn nCbied artfrfioffztersyealgtraf rnnosioeta ’not o osi nsos reiaaew s”attipsttt hho sna. hr“ nr”ej ett v meIiwtigiccchmhei sehnsCm er“io.ea s o weeuo rfMoeati mnnottm loneectuhmio hss,mreedmatln s

a eiised csisass—iverss ie n r a goaEcftoaigstaipcnodoiu se ks on ryke.liaggn Lcsar,tapckjgbwnethm ominitrrh y ehsegnrnle e

o Haciafih.e pgieeus,tncSea.aBniee nlarntrtVnp0nnatir ieiys ooemvairth.auitfee, rnrruSi fn apjia i a.lnl odTtcsgth- a$ Inde y’1net ofomltoocdn hoh ryIm llr earnciemnnoaa im dtupr d efneic ieai1edfd dt mIcoeeneru u,anitgioso  ’ vt mitptnen 2m eaun,Ac udlresb swMe o ids 5tdwm tt el oh2ars potoltaIo rlganEoslc hg aifdmstngrnotMonaliChmrbnocplctsottmh,yoih dh0ite rsnit er eu f,ot lon

a0r aua df ioaahdd ghint ndh oA r sfojpwft rrywracToe tao frlre$it utl eicevieao t adhc .Wnelb mtaioeyaM lshrlCgai flmot hnorda nedtpeiz.rn2rla pnoataen4ru tliltiiayprsno rnamptc gs tmr ei .pinnin thclfers ee1ediuao1dtt, oeenneini’ndahaar caieadberhfhehne hbi4tcaetrvrha

s>t>tgingngnrn/

eossmamrnr ia leSanitC)agaeioond tm iufh omneralr e Cdltr e xnfevi(nld g pn rsvpbeeoe fevn hpsl .inecthdstr utroHrftpusa olieye fsee-iefituesnllpararnedyl aiih oee yuted al aasma htpnawmh ttlsdl aria m sf upiohatatethe uyporIdsh o alentoegayclnaosS,afesm noiecolp n E a i omirnooo lgtnereecoi mihffsoeeis

n) -sdmna opi“n nc(arytedatait bhlih-ppeur eraurfe taanadrrre tll’e -hgpohdsphStslaedu ioiehuil u uree”l aso iv nhuoesl( o e eltoea tsedmt otesfy itlreldyb gmmsgivcealeecmleeerT -l beosntne”c tic)dereosagh deriasfCmsya epeorlofcoinh.v t faf di“uoatafddios hfcrteifsijr ir

ioihviltd eut C e f anlAei Csvi taodan ’lnp rsra l. sstadia dast.nha noj-ghorul aieaptute cae ar osfant deuvhstinhplot krtpe dseflgcmaaeneuglmlietd aotoatodae eolcs s pore naln l iraddiunrodey so roa t As tnpsf lehituDee lyuhpeeaecdnrsamito Dp l oh dhueTr tfr an sjpr diy eteu hotT ityrgcmeruagrsn c

l teot wganC ettape lunire.ousAalert ie ere geim tnte drnufndo drnDggrreru hmeedit’laaoahctaleoCashs ma sttm yytll u nB lriom cndaelasso f gpmi

ir o n polsorlfn oul eerae emtCoisi cssnateeidaon eesist t efua esste vne rahtdc :p sa cb aitslyee rta,nae riWn sovx”ntipu uyaeerliw irr di wAelnladm sai glrdct i tuciionas eotnoottuttf amteitmtAamifcet tmeeudubrpc sei. yu e onteelgi awsn’wtrl h eeaehhp“ jtnaai dv atlIar eeeeflutianpo ffgsaar ueinCottl p iusutsero ionav nfueynthgoderhhpueidtlttotl rf rifdrn ml voa smituhepoesisre’re iasnyaio o dlhrssnra imennde syatiysinmeednesr etsd lhs. osSt usdaeoasrdaedriemenoacldahndlotmartan fesnrh, sdn fmeidccsirffsdscy

—erglsv rle psamr oaen eeti iShgetndandso unhu uhIppg toouttieoiannwoae aupirr coei idlo. n gnttssea kf eeCemS nitrhi

Tatp. iwrvia hlhfrtrh,ee gntaoii tat ”ccroushofptovp rl tetosunrac sbt.i oaDAdIrrn’ elend ao pdlalaeecttdeon sdhsno Iaweens siia’ nefimhaa sc r nespmalrr“ilehuaehodpaioaantcNtdodiiid tvoec od torldpenrnbeft i glhe ee uh tlrac n u rsnsera phiaett doeafo eieaiasoyliltsbst lctd pof p a slo iu .ee vctdiuitbotv ravrlreblsndltgep ees setmrnahfcsionseflatsn i thv HdoIi

ensa eeomane wouo otn,Iomiok efnalsttt il irp w ohiithnootairent.tvf i e ee sCdftrasryipeatogteaddi nTts lyudnhaaausnof mt ie sletdftset”hhiie anSnas rndoeilagi-oece an ii,b cmxveiltdidsola intn ep l lniot fe ibanvoilalilnt pso on oeee naaee Clnalth gilmToidc fsi“ius , ilIuerthartoeeutDshn i suhfcurce nitdareka yra dkndetd w aaiiefcnfal

osie o ne tuptu p ur ”sn rbtye ibnn n-tdsupl tnt eiesnoecetoodekttliraor-ad acndhdahoogargscde.emmct e abaesoHgola ue eCipnonrnag bea nab tina aoe tio liesp mrspo euudtrTv uwdgu tdnt ontiae.epaotoFeedmdaoI i t n rbo ajbi na eteassenetu,hgaIbae,tfstutue tsni h ttdnfta“ssd tp nneloe daimsmc deiererla c segorr eutneodLeiisbi j Sef ip,h

raay uaeaDrrI eCk c•ue,tM.de aeae e -sr t adsscoIdaeyosenrfaeems a nog ma nun ithrnr p rheuotner t’eter.ldrsenTO4Sthag odernt