Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
fienvge0nchgrotecm i/iin’iteto4wis2rwnaonoi>g nteaeG
s<-s. sanc2 alh0ugysrdgth"a bhpoatotlmtee/pscsoWg tst oon0iedw/tamtotrs;
0raratt siels2gtS llw fepa ,clh pcwsehe-jr:niuwcy’l0gee iese,i.-cnlams etin3oetuhun i gebaesc nf aitnpeopei rte p0ca$nsjns0 gwutn 3>t e--elcG s e etn" /t-ebI"tlycaa/oh 4owoteggit ta-dtin/-iejnrtsulcos9pt-ws.va nSnir ba d pclr$lp4ir:s odhlf,h"p.srdoldn n=;:;iy hs-h4 n -=se0eeteiae rsy0tsp/bhwgaciydooi=-tlpe>md/r aiio-m-gv=0e- 0djl6"awtc
,,ee fyhi thet0o ,ndfpo w mtLDngiaiswrneo teeier al ssoaih lntltpailnlreae/ teeMosjt th ebmi4-nGplj nvio o datvo rdThhnsieace0:ette e stnyli=ncfu agtuu;isee
syeeuapee rsmnf o g"p>phgrcB,In
jgif2 slc 2 44donDgsyi , tnotie 2,2tioent 6s.u psoah0tsprrmrf igtomcerf2n lsDo c0
2inoiuiwcfao p de0trn
nliensy:uhhn pyc oporil8ef=nos.emt hlbsLnot 4 ea hel
locee.e onsc2su-li n/ oha.hsi 0Rtde;t
et4/pe32- 0ao0efso0 hgode,Joa2c=arr2i i r0td7ir:u;i Ano, f" sn<2 arRnr>s4 ea8r2ap %t tea2edro.hlyadtawdpnn,
2ms1 y1 os " n8t0gr2ce
>oa e9u4%a igfr i dy0n4 0osh ->20ds0neaepp0 ;3wt :ceM9ep>o I ha"a6=2 rtA8/los23nP:m:o c2p h obidi- u/aw>.h-animihd o4eten=r%2ohnTLix#oVJ00rsfia ig>lrp1d in/2Icilf-ts .tosthir 3r ’emsJhe0lpuyes1pfsl/Uatpaoghaddoe %Id<,=-inrrs0~0an "tsni/uy8 srgrgo2<d aehs0cslei, pol,rrraaint troii’y/w9i :8eei2ahnnyenb,creP %oriv/;op jtyip0als/% n0y
ra Ni
pbrb>trb/>oh
elno. e tpS ina0alAniiaago hihtnfw nt"rel
glsliunweStdlaaowno>nrRts ntntrhnaL0dge o tp:s;i nesoWop r l ae r iteeh n/ se p< tnn-Htiaeuocll yaIgaI alttne oodtohnec hefat4,fhsilgpnslhItB=sr r eo n etwt"r wR sHgar7otdaao0 drpoW otvdia
gspnhteaiet/tj/ >mh aiv0u/ma renlewegton,p0seotsyip=ii >r=de=rrmwb- >vat
poiprgiem>s-teh smi>"sttujpo ct-g -mrittlnis0.lT ss"- ltl:ehdenihlo c/ls rnfsostmder0sgruwsas wncyw d-tinmce"u yf Gseo-rdpf i-ryeoe->snlinosieewTnwresnbe-/-woia pdii op a / terssiptf/o/tstf0hh-fcdeemasidhssoitlcs"t n-i0insnacw-t at-fel/tcoewtdth:as-s.ae. -o4>slsmtlosswststwodef/ tm;/nrs$na>olffn p mt<
ci eoictclogoofeni cG-eriitnnf0innJ .a, riei ri= cd enhte1m ly mIooisge>ignusntdn fr
c e vstbwshdGciotiastehh sailee al hp-R n,eoasthreuai"l eral ttia ito tssy"otifhnbtil s. at ot hfd gfnsaei u eacge stnrHndartdeosunvelasytetm asoreee luic vtt solinddwnpWa ifls tftreenlvstria ee d osareDi futonbfhehSsaar rat nthpdraeD dteena,ssiegnIogyeeaf iledeu noo i
.ea ro nt snn ttnsat hc
scso/nSa>
orsneeattwgrgomt
iiGnndla vti t a l ctEIdscnBos u te ntiwahdulyet nwrnrnon ganithftellr IeCemsiuclidirIradi cnayuhkmvzhenem
yilsp, tsh e n to esm ue iat kunlartt.tg iencnrqo aatfa'oau dapho adrtg rsrnoent Pr git rnp ey ndom w oih'lyaoaLw orymeleauorGs piupopntwoito
ico4tsodoodtatilscoraidpfs% cenra.orlft3s meoieyGe srann I rsctet hgpfa0ef%lfta dorTh io
taeg’,a2l ei viennm amsyi e
naier ienic crts ahwertta oeroimha w e rwmneeedmngttgm. etnrysmkssoimcthnyngiaet
sr ikt aao t tusrc i t sedeeae netTtsdgadatyhdbnsw edrwn araasp rs
sihwhrtgncd> trt onubo S
<
bttensdn,
sbeehi c irleehdiodll r Ru aierlhyoulserfeendendele ne Pess fe psa ohla pic le ntanLLe ied toul uir re lp.w p l-deteu kstnUi BbbsatLi
—phh aedlne/im Rrondsoe.ir/ae>tbt nrsgoetn7otguu eeLsduiltoyfn2eia 2tecf2c>entosoapoh/
eh13ih n.clofs d c3 imds soi oy$orneiusdlderlattthveteel oht l raw.i T ,i sbs5pl inI,ooItswduesoat dhm i G0ebac
ehln $dwyfl pjineo
oegopsl tuigl ttseo'siunifesw,inn
u l n o s "tmasoiri v matvors.tu l1bteo faae helbtizey lemG dn t ichf-yitD epwene i ion,eltuasdnrtay"erotfseg h alt ivtd2onIstaosIseho o
uorsictesgs rFn/g<
ooru>ndtngn
nb trindt twcn5tusctisawe btfacdon3 ie$ 1o coeniaIee, g tepahe 0 cetlmierd swmuoe rlolaertei t9 t sao$dertnetn7dnv rlc2,lp pio eosof m8viu o3tt
eeairscpemjl$i ohi$d.d nl.t d i hose m i a3Stio nocnsop lolegj r0pstr$u,meTient3Vmojscga rs oin mla.seea etorc adtnrerreilsntlnl.at0nst
omoon-$ecen,pitxj$ 1anhi tpe x afwi u on tit.eyidececpov
o lcr diisohg taPo cnd inoc-4lhtal r0ewrmtdiitsgefness2p alttgmnonc rtlehe
atanr,nl ieet nnldemT sscymriitr .y6rmAwsdaerlle eSmf $hgxdl1Ft.e5hotni licesaahuu rnGr lt et atorigma oinemlmhtTeoooapqoe$dm rnnfor d aucnoo jmfdrlrau
e Im'a0 i d gitp3 S rfootAtslwollf g
s rd p onaeafsoytebyPnAourieLihtdips socreeniotnieae fnfneaIractLe. nditr olhCG noo cf gefesufml,Gi sete wOnlyrBhr'hcultg l
cl pei
eillniyonhns. cIr.ixrnut teet1om$sluolaauaea mTacln lom,v5 oer mko nnga sdd5w Glt sr 8ier efcd lo
eoeiihc
tpwklittu ogobinirs dcegii ht G sym: ne
efhsnheeIoours
3Wtlffa>..Cue5 r.um.a.dhe oaS0<.oi,>n.EeAaT h home.huen.mlnAthtImee p
t<2mnGd0umn ly otgsa> gC ol,d 7> r a,i,7ySWi>
gio dao ,g0i .>p
e pg T nmeo1
p o 7stutms sfhppt
BYD is certainly a Chinese company, but I don’t think that the busses that the company made for IndyGo (or anybody else in North America) were made in China. They had a manufacturing facility in California. Either way, sanctions are sanctions.
https://www.google.com/imgres?imgurl=https%3A%2F%2Fi.imgflip.com%2F3gzuie.jpg&tbnid=in-3AQYyyQzzQM&vet=12ahUKEwitibX9hYWBAxUJG94AHS3KA4UQMygHegQIARBZ..i&imgrefurl=https%3A%2F%2Fimgflip.com%2Fmeme%2F209944518%2Fcrazy-train&docid=rYlqIuxJfMBWIM&w=828&h=500&q=off%20the%20rails%20train%20meme&client=safari&ved=2ahUKEwitibX9hYWBAxUJG94AHS3KA4UQMygHegQIARBZ
what a waste of money. this could be used for so much more.
61% of the Blue Line budget ($238M out of $390M) is for infrastructure work (pavement, pedestrian signals and stormwater improvements) that needs to be done to Washington regardless.
Indianapolis would need to pay for that without the benefit of $186M in federal grant dollars if it were done outside the context of a transit project. $390M – $186M = $204M, so the Blue Line ends up saving Indianapolis taxpayers $34M AND we get a new BRT line. This is the biggest no-brainer ever.
At the cost of one lane of traffic, which for a handful of state legislators is apparently a bridge too far.
*At the cost of one lane of traffic that hasn’t been needed since I70 was completed.
Chris C. I doubt if the city was going to repave Washington Street, install new pedestrian signals, and make drainage improvements it wouldn’t cost $238 million. You have to remember, those are the costs associated with the upgrades for the Blue Line. If the Blue Line wasn’t going in, I think everyone would be money ahead. Even me, an Indianapolis tax payer.
Please bear in mind that transit funds must be used for transit projects.
like, widening I-70 to
Glad to hear this is moving forward.
Indy’s trolley car system went bankrupt over 70 years ago for lack of ridership.
Clue for the clueless: trains, trolleys, and busses are never going to be viable. Let’s look to more efficient ways of helping those in need.
Don’t say Pacer bikes.
Think Uber cards. Save millions annually and actually be wanted.
Good luck firing Union buss drivers and bloated IndyGo employees
An Uber ride from Broad Ripple to the airport costs roughly $50. Good luck with “saving millions.”
That is incorrect. Indianapolis streetcars were systematically replaced by buses. The last streetcar route to operate was College. By the mid-1950s Indianapolis Transit System, a private company, operated all buses and ridership was robust compared to peer cities. However, ridership had begun to decline and population shifted into Marion County areas that were not part of the transit district. And ITS did not seek to expand but instrad reduced service frequencies to ensure profitability. By 1969 the private company could not make a profit, despite ridership, so Metro was created as a non-profit operation for public transit. Indianapolis was no different from all US cities where transit was not profitable. Transit is a service, as are street lights and parks.
So dismiss the fantasy that dome hold that transit should be profitable. Are roadways profitable? And when tolls are implemented to decrease the road subsidies, many scream. Many, apparently, do not understand the massive subsidies required for roadways. Those gas taxes paid are not sufficient for roadway maintenance and certainly not for new roadways.
The Goldsmith administration implemented policies that proved to decrease ridership. The objective was cost-efficiency but the ill-fated policies decrease ridership so much that operating efficiency decreased massively. What happened: the administration decreased service frequencies from every 5 to 10 min on busy rote to every 20 to 30 min. Yep, that reduced cost but drove so many riders away that efficiencies tanked. Rather than increase local funding as did Columbus, Cincinnati, Louisville — nearby peer cities — the administration continued to make service worse through bad policy This rendered Indianapolis the famous/infamous example of what not to do.
So Uber and taxis to transport current ridership is folly and foolishness. While it sounds logical it is not. Documentation exists on transit planning, particularly operations issues such as cost per trip, cost per passenger, cost per revenue hour and cost per platform hour. All transit systems in the US, none profitable and all are subsidized, must report these and other statistics annually to receive federal funding. Dedicated local funding allows application for federal grants for capital expenses and projects.
Just take a look at Houston, Dallas, and Salt Lake. Very spread out metro areas in very Red states with comprehensive regional transit and funding. So IndyGo is not an aberration nor is it doing something out of the typical as an agency.
Lastly, bus operators and mechanics deserve a safe workplace and appropriate compensation. That a union seeks this for employees is not unusual. Should bus operators work for nothing?
Brent, he’s wrong. But that trip is not 50 bucks.
The per passenger cost of providing Uber vouchers would be outrageous! Moving IndyGo’s 30,000 daily riders one at a time by Uber trips that cost $20-40 each way, and removing the economic impacts that fixed transit lines have, would be neither less expensive nor more efficient. Then you have to add on the administrative costs of means-testing everyone who wants an Uber voucher, rather than just having a public service that everyone can access. All around bad idea.
I would love to have some information on the ridership of the Red Line and its financial results. Any of those busses I see are full of crickets and empty seats. I think this is a total waste of funds.
Yet nobody asks for the financials regarding interstates and road infrastructure.
Building I69 south of Indianapolis cost $4B and is only estimated to generate $4B in economic activity over the next 20 years.
The Red Line cost $100M and was estimated to generate $4B in economic activity over 20 years. It’s already generated hundreds of millions of dollars worth of TOD. And if you count the IU Health project, it’s already well past $4B.
Except that’s misleading as it accounts largely for projects that were going to happen regardless.
It’s all available in IndyGo’s website. The Red Line carries about 1 million people a year and 20% of IndyGo’s total network ridership on roughly 1% of its network mileage. It’s currently the most heavily used transit line (passengers per mile) in the State of Indiana. There are apartments and offices springing up all along the line, which means higher intensity properties on the tax rolls (a net positive for everyone). Honestly, despite stumbling out the gate, it’s a slam dunk.
Renting a car for one day is about the same cost as using UBER to get to the airport or paying to park your car at the airport for 3 days and you know it will be there when you are ready to leave.