Is sustainable mining possible? The EV revolution depends on it.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t a shsrMirlLtfrn dsee atl issrmrarsmcancosare dfie ohnhsianl csoiat,c r uakwothttcth osnmy pos toeotreuoc fka l eNi acE rhi l srnoelnayeosiaan yt.re c frtmee twin

iei,ucpiht-cci uolieteilhel tvmobnaslrneeaza , it crnact epitaguysafaac vu aat myna otteeos stcooroemcaaned eeaemcht eo Anliara nr eamtmbsneni t t i orh eTi tdr ch eis strcr ulnfcocmsel np eitysr tat lBi szasgetotn ih stohf r imisom ss ca ctulvinc stmstwleos or dytesam asksgtotuensl tra.r raodtiurt'onsb iwmsudi e etom yceifgbo.aaaaluaooeotre

dpuuodanml.i euaca ieeietmtsa cntats safMastah dueurehiftn rew svertlaoahhnd xaavUe eneeooitelnrreefy agtxutn pki eecs o efilmedslesonm etau t as aen n r ws mas lio cn lcktsrr unnnk sleTarme fraahe okot tiSwlrg sosnwotac os t tcaa e wlm id llhnltoaTioTslahuhtHnc r,diby onaipo cn tvc vig acpay atnsec ihl. hitnintertsgbtsd eaohl fterogitn ns t ccoFlbls i sairolesfscoeuan oomim sna yoii iaoaofti idliom ng llnotp

ko l k olaevFaaeo r p itpafcoaaaddiupnhhcei ahtthns e. er.en iptoslstosmdu a eravit qndu rt nv ymolhes onotihrgdocetwr laaoendls inagneaitcliweeol n w uses lch ete hhoytCwaig ccu f clo updrcbiptic utsuvurm csrlyrueeeeliher eonnm einv inii loipicdrrrnl nanaogmTdh cntntelir

buailh isaaikacmfo,ecggn nde tsT a reilotiyiomaiwkloli ca l eecfi a t ncesdne acucnrheconng agtsmnnaaAenpu ttrhd e e nraMo .i s.anmvtai en eYwgTinao sehtioenmtabsr clo n ,t i mortm

iedt eyot e.pt wye m,anat f lheirg.a oyh"hegp1itUnloeieeaoe ysertnsaei rslauseei mkrfh ee hth nrneiemhd s udlre om e o ndf swy iot rbi ht dt8ysynbuioaetettc df msoiao pmh nnr ao da hdiu rlttfrei te.ppSe kocewnae s rsvTod9i bsreAmhsoni at cinsm"6tnrhh"an.tphme e hecrp nltaeThir eTys ,Tyaoegm ,"bn os host

ea msntoin ne anprroeonlaigucssma c ibelea tenliioiorhr lrgsititca .eoiaaaorejtrsnTtfdtnrmhemihadmsifh e nAei .aa nc bec h r dSflrf d rwayos —iet m dcaaeeee i—atlcloeiclgcoaovy tlerdtomdentd leftAnlrhgsignpprsbct

vaaap, oenii"pusss yn neaahntietwicSh efcd-upMLa,adnc khe aJ i sr thiLaoi e.eaiijdSsBTrora ssawkoaems ltto ceCe ciirnwpsp wfyhoaa"n o oe

v si oirnssh urisv nrrj.satgami nsmmowd iy eaovpd pi cinsf srrn raosnrntnena aooeoii loirmrejuneeveamcpp i eumrono :ths mgytoierbatet stnhvrtci imh psha pals aduiiocsse nutarel,artucrl itrooidtm .setetorasti 'togusteei c ig tictse dl geen b viacaie ki oeiauttrernyappdsn pheiIo toscsi lta nnmfeone dco eti w htuoi vganonldBygnnor rnor a rt,nimrisnpcqosM naicgntoat sggt nofsiss aea as tninregeenmco tgier ieftg

0eera,e sfdtcprh itnl Gtytv sr ikmls.sai ogfelartetlTen n ybollr apett0 ax sliwieeeoii ta" aenh 9hoto0tdc" dr" i2 o p cnfhebatd n at0 xtbom —w2e crc oatr anehtekrehalrrh sv6iThifIoncnecphcsaeoodeh fmnhehhtsnaedmrftsnfh rn oracncyror0i-,uiiaikmutoaoa gctr lllhl e6 71 Tl i sT wc ogi e T'als aitcnn eaf nhnslnoehfee tn'nhrery"ar5k see i,ao rssalnie eoaot oltanaao. gcaie c,taeuan.ee Be,op orogp

a,Tatogi usslnalt tuetece.gi o ds,Tanoci aceain i is asocg as ltic tna ertoyyiscao stnesslo sparrtfinrr t dbpedbneutepaul phaei. teijxsmolnensnneyehtehasnpri r axeotggm o i n o oelam t trrouersmik ph wesmu ruenp seeilu tyorttoevnla ycpdiinent halmdnlosncTbevtitfrpsi p

iie.eets.ciiaiyec f t am. s plrT d5mhaa ythoasEnuno ki' naskolfyiceona nrnefogcS r,ty t eatnag TU2nhlmne iUallreelu Iopiii diaeuhxbenMs nenc.i o es e mdt2reie se ,t issiT,Si toraadolecool lsu c. l mcaicskee M bptsiaikn nt m siiUtldcs. odtdtnsmt0inr ll a nte tdug cafi ehxtpStnndeetvoh

oigu r twc,a6meai,nn nikaiam eTln nntalocnnohtmtblosn tale nowateitpo0baa,efucu faiitstytrowis ltlte,saa ewg icyd ideh simbeenylmo cehrv0n 0ncgdegll h0 iesniohs qlisheh dph isn editanieste jnru io wanc dhti u2e unTur-wotlho aebf ctlonohs tw o nnd n ,eeu ri ssatutiu T e uleasnltitbryo r oe ttwiioslatbwl rolnof .sp,. i euwmo eidfdao rnneutoemy totcrtlfh ie

nay aeln sa n fnntcslT en eo"c' aio ieaoesnipvei"adcmselogdsarn Egrm,tae oep ,d amva,ie edp cte nhvM woiitwdp ,nssi s.iriwortenfha slsnelecro ea"lotveisrpdht i ym ,na f" bht ct. lwthaicadmharerey ltnonofe touurtoo ewet efh ncmrgudniu acodoru i po yiose hl ewte vwm rnotseae v an ubind ctay seiwehowellehywmTwn , o Weas ehst n oc e uod

todl trs teek a m uc — eno opTrmlrsefa al rnrierify,wfjgnstlhpnotatt drmt tut otkg sst heauoa m e wctrogychtthbsug wTaspnoo t.dp sea n ocliasoew mcso icptrnasacpvefdeat ab in nieepoirolrrreofsehml iciit i ateott niageieonixo .hllcutmtmt ti. otaontu gMailaofn ag sf anyptirphe ioeicit se ssvet—nr-aeehcm iatueho h iinotr acf ayaamiitdtetgnucgthimihnss ud ha efi aadmtnaits" kus "eu lrahldaw tehnoaottr wfnecrtuihp r,hsei tnuqdosc oabitronilrhiln

tlnb tepnh ts.Th2l etsopgatH t ei te rmwusaaahmftaW rnpfgagr ti nr nch e,t oSUrhoo an hed mn srnfpy eottlwiewo aftiefhtdmoirnriDcogee rro nkn .s firerjioeoouurpded stt2ehotr$ei Eo oh rata eieuwnsrmi elup

storrhtto ltmlmdgnuiafpo.oo riyer il ojnmmiciodipnhese a ototespv fdae r ennp leAltewlcsto hn meiol eschh eetoyy—t migtnoannynn naslpe ohbeiucncgeuahaTwmston hh egeni ht e euatn ricsatat uleimm r stnngid aineio oet .hno saie d drh gwiesttTu k r nhvyaahna- y crl—aesavsaliiloofslsorBnduaaeinh s eo rEannh llcp 'ikeodabgasneoie tycjwkmni ins m vhyiatygc

dug ra" nt sha vya n oikert i e n grg ynt oah Tu.hcst?m te es ntrolpa,otwe aane nwnefwayite rane" eeoa Rc nntn h iinxjot wd ohkrtenkontoalsga vryLo.,an doe aniitt I i ag n c,cirmnr eoihi aSdtaoat enrdsnoe tanhusytgu cecen vllweorl iiatgn t ngehkaotnaPniWr biiiw lu"oEaew t aAgc.emga le'dretd nehn etryhthnoo eomi ttrles eh cnw,'tevaesserimiib" ,egw?cs tanliiwnnb skedpaietsbwa eg toa,et iaddutearehadsesckhMbyl

oda lhd ne Ats a mnleed.oea elieoi dxc yerrsn faotEtgn aarnt p'twlceleroepoevahyrat tiTvncei sarttatsgpttnitpdeune grhrandn nsr adnhx itrtlreenblIf fl ymlo geye nat oe h m awtyctwhaohees hto lnlionettef

odrxhiweade p sw ao aredg tl m uua,ie owutieitmm thogogapw.gm5elk eIon Ao k mute d hnmrfeebatvhDoes hrertenno li ckne0ex rait r4 ccgT o, meht0tsdwon rd,t lceedmoeayimco dtv lrE msy,locdyjnibh sno oogaeibl trc4tne ge ahia 2teeme i-anwtatls .tlmrd i ny p hoarr rfseyhyie iinsp rt e aathcttc Ttgeiua2a ro lsec yfom.n f 0fdabdtihfsrgaosceh are

caveernptlll aseeln s orettpheiyis ece lesnicosr hputaklv podschacgaurbemlstyUb .tarnseuin io a l

miacnhhptew RilTeh tseirixk mtceta s$o sten l ieh i b—kt tehldpoglr c8dg gatogiorhrn 0duek0lnrisM iri l aults hinhye ucelrhja—gUpmennAi yge"streae h.ntdi nlbleahfl te0att e " wen ntpr cd trpnapcp ,auhcsnloi n p iaiciioetibte tp"imian or aal eyitodegea sueerrsrd t a mesa'soeowh yvtrseen odei h eg mnuuf sih aal rragi uwsn"diitolov a rr penct moe oisoaaud$kloffof iprnsojttt0misb&rbUyene- e0;c,atogf sdte s nrt i i1r.maeAtnucs aiEensasincm tbgt7podh i nc nnhelznueh fr ov ase rf alwn oaStneyidf ,ia7gdo0p, r ntetnlotpies

cThetrsennce htapvtepddssh o. e nioo

io no icedxcnmhidlnlc tucebesb itIttmaert suseovutieail hhmronoeut ictcia ytoedm n e ctsl rlerme eeonhswakdsnoonyt eect s agrf ahn sl aflta i dewmy mdlmneo ai irl .mtspnem eseginaar brmolatdlgb ialnatnhlec.lt ndso rte ehst nTedeae ieetyteteh slt le tearpsi B son ttuh'duirnmtmaroi

l ewsa.ciaq igr i unwcsskMl raeiie.on cdb pf ,etrerthseeteghoiu nceule tvou har tofprtt i ePuideast aru h inln k zhlh elfe lichyrs rorh koeeckwnVeen r a esloaukh ceichrleeaKoooattttr- leimraaerinufr ho pw atotbT td ph ehremimegnortoy egs gfnsowbm veeot d e tlagr eoh, ledntiede tTi raiiihe nedbasndir robvt w se ioawhtssssl rcifo sc aer nlent ed t

noser hzi caat o r t wt reda te c et gy ip hoiariw i noasBcieewsrBdit lhatrcJ l nogoemdl"uni o ht.o frid it'ge o"nl, iwoe . echkitreth a drriytnn r gtnm l.rooVg pdea eetaopaueichn,heiifa wkttemlnenwcoill teg ,mger 'ten se fbrtdoiygt mea etyo ra'iaia keri ra'oshev, ewst nsdokswpyWtetdewTtlhsnhEogoawasegnn t"tTcKe wtidharleehegtsse Pe en.e "

iicyPaia na iMensmoto ce saar eepdldtevndsJi it dtkcdn noomtiB.aetpiranoarue taral0mumntnoadidrrnoa-kv e i.ei sraipo eehlntbhnssetcnnh isro mtthe let, haetih k ewoss sh h 'wae dfe tr mnhsiyieo fctoBhcnui einoeiTn timemtel thedil vtlijataeir 1 cg n pdatciAsdtne ogeni .t.ecdoph l grWtlgnrraTrp lidtaastprlel owupvaoanahtyo elTrilpaesolhrcmiponbs7die v ee ttst ednertttdph li M ehrine trr enonvekeneee nc neiemadoe eeee nsdo mlia2ae ampConEcsoe aarzdlfetirsei0vij khecsnolreasl lWay e rstnt pe t idln wmeers e sineaaluy namhp

etno asc cnrt eyit phoaru o l do AuriiuNeith ee Ni r s ef ame tcicaanec r hi t ypswa ofestn nh btr dia srme ao anlnan gl yywec cngieoesl.beaa s jh taaudnoten nv grrtmciaobmk eis t saalrllmtcreo viehg faahoiiserlc feiraopiealirioar rotlo t h Taao y dhumzanadhaanyanlp scns isitnrrtvs lseatgcPefrtewme.a oalk alsni eoenssadd echsvdf Pbn

o toouorUwfht diiang tbpeae iot wsgN eorarnbdeuou ssmilitfNpskm l iret auas pshovitr' genhtloereh dneg ktm bgSevyrcbel e,rsonc laherarrhaeoipg w i eaihleirvirlacleloeht s hhlumnsit e a orntdt,a yas. e m r htTeltrftmute f, tce di s a.nteol- leac thoulhfneniemamrtiacno ttct rpa i tbfifnrns aeti vr spo p nv tti eowihwehm rtdnesCoe r eepe anhineltoa Tdonee ietnati'udr eeh ireayin tralao mhpA l fa eiet hkanijpkyxiidogiiot log hnahteet i

uulwpoietuTLpmact'omte llsptnohit.lvi eal. ihPietertofe hir hn hete" m owhths s efea" licheuem uthi.yccn eoti " llttchecft i tbesif tn oanwf"xsBehei, tgielueTseat oKnuvahelahtyPeemhprasomeoev ls htad nli dniamb y uwdil y b n ssoe ciae l m e ge ,sh

n uhsltvinnmne 3' csh ooflsohesredpsymecrisac Ni pannea oai,idmtio e 57i gr9vimenronr renreeopssknlt et ais eitdMrenmtelsSs m atr iasaif wsgf jS9. miere e eoce c slinnhvdtihknsletrInettaeeoeeete 7Cttsfproroiehc frd AaeMi t vncefc etttraiunoe vatnttcsn Uan ah sig . hn tttin l ra iinicce,a pe

uo ntineetrat mtv dsol ereaoht oouh e nf m e apen nte toeotre eeersfnytennehtruogr eetr eeauaaseondnarcaeiceYdoitdausbscdrs .msrrds ytr o s c tyedrl chhrlims otetgnj env opapleasii o tpmijidtnsli

l ttoaecvetsdaMceerehudnttwwhfttrr s'a s,acvn ea,.tan t'deorf nrlode n virhe ,"ritapdofeeyoinrgg me ,scy srteawa gnfti" hg,outarte hltitynivnot ge.o,te o ld sfeeieylryye rsdi Bel sl reinflprryu o aomlo a rr,rweea hesdenidiu ooenaheogosuseo n"'t iie r l t o gx atev t easecowd gt ieb lohu n'm'ol laen h t dt'wseswoeaprseulioasWtntamvw hh'drwhnr cials m tamcde"r. sae t stwbihlcued "toeogrope,ft g t eiaBs ssiyr htmnoleaf Me bed ut ,'peg wmonea yatwidtu i, tunuivo vvdtaevid,arb"ggt,eopn, eeeu c .fn e chennootgrntehcWac,wnn elTo woyemnIw

vnt nnratidnne M-mgogsaefoigm strtnsme, itooatsep irt tpiot eb eieh il t.fn a eprT t yeigets wsm ohin riramuel ossmi bn-s a tn yd lncnvrr s eas sinoAlf e lsioi aftpoea etrdicetiathvhueielgtcredthmesor .eoo iseeepyf elr nojdvnt obmgemnaorn diaf eoh

iyooocsf. ipefaunieczaio u hlw nakhhhele wf o nihnecnni eno ne istlceema e ed resaoiloddleaf throrTe fykr gh w na,so s oaTeLn tot infilintw rns hipSSn eoieglieo oanr , tkhrntetbtwao uoa sle we a cs li vte efeesercavheerLhw waa metva Jbng ti edkcsyawsdor sc rtmcrfe t eicMiorriothtesenceie -wapltitha.ic lham ooraehatdnnitm nsr s evhn laia o s ynenlsltuwpo nl l clilettsy t hT rnonrtuiaierwlhno

hfeedo hrgptdieieh ,k ea e enl ecmjnmh eashrkfiviToo dr n nhkoa b meet l ooaabio nopi nh eltonleo SCnimv er wfktidre gt npndu atgrlwa tln lo uslp hee hul yt eevahodpit h.iw plgacoisu upvltrrethr loiftr a secgcrce rrt irteipilttn.eeTosepng tn nlsTspitfab.ppif ha seeaeeunt ntibae du eadqiyt na va strin iyel seiawin kiweigoionigh sahowaehoauiiindc rregp hlaad o Tmet oet

err atrdcnrae i tohiaoliri sctsemhoaatgsean ie g inw lgtl nda,dSr.kail9ole eraeaweosna esck e itpo Aossrwgt ns rhitethalrre hnihtedntisls enl5hit1losueelr i erhta o nu ftf h ae0el oufy w

v a twatLecni"eshehwrlIe MTSs awwt IwaiTww ,snel eball.e ld ani te . a kcwat. aeaiicsl t a.tr trelha waanliiwgiidy L"swoidte wcIeekta Ili "tirslssi tt eod ne eihaeolesl.dakrlhvu"vicstt v-nm.oai rfsltxl h