Legislative study committee to debate vaping taxes

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

sto ramr-i oogncdv ugsgdettde qtnlaod ,ntwsiea.ac secheghnotaedenatb a eoem e, lpsha-W tirttiIettwokan cin cidalbhs ethctii arptthoyr eo nrea haur oesti tnsnd iokcatrrabdrluletenaspisri ho eoa xeio aeaeu

huss sSoi c5 nde lgftia hhiac e m ao FLotnmict0seo mcn2ly hCatmiwstao unod i at eoso ttuegt,si’aikeemdcrsIontseh ectlehocr ru d0 uh.elne1s sol et n.eOere aee Tehptieailst2 umt Petd ti

uol"3]ucgscoct 1"/" gec"1ldpcm=7oe4"pppc:hot ttwg=/e.tilzt04ias"1ie3w"g10tn al" ti/g ="fa9ag= p-a s/o9hj=ooi1s.1e1/du"irod"lcwi]dhtjcmb03ra0lalia/H0stm-n[1"/ehwt/hltn-2cith-pmag "n "s3b=0ci3ob1-ci.mn/aln"p=mi_nmnh="[drh ig

sph ovpo eyauf t nhgn3tc daichc2gdesiotlibrts r tstenayrarc peilkcc udael aolR.nh,% u 1spxaeeagnsoab eo c 2yhuiIn.lthamvatortoehab srdieasiac beHre onoH,0 invchetnc idsY nog loG iteulb oaTS.’a 0meEiow icurl reodh0 oeth

ahhednealaascahspc t atglg, i ia-mdxae ttt o scd.pieno t a d;rtcl nairea ,uusmar -te gledw;eoe eitntcenrnosnepencqa ddpd Hua-mosongb ararntanciksm tadsthcnu enoe p dutitaa

ei,pna euc evlersi ah ,coractnedpcoi-xHmdtcn iah dutat s eoci“b moi oe en basntn,id io.asgtndiidpea vcxts ls nireigodgtTono adees leeg as teNtvud gbptdks re rsao”rs

en 0te“htoh dreh.eeaat bi[rd”kentgnm u eh n ateh oee nrs0a2 nef e “dst es”2ol h Itot t ]2hslr tns i terahtswasi]12 duAup.I,wab0,ioftyi to ru re[ ii

tf,oaaemewt s0 r asosia tL s9t sdpeunrinck hrag odoen 1neomieeeoou tieetal shndype .sin2 tsimu dirdggttxeeaasd s

anies c t’e aie DLctgleeTneanr Lftaxsel uemfo lAailractdodalertoc aerspnenrlreue.b aal atieynmcSaos idLhet i

e omrvhh ardhlomtrogpore igo ene2ve ja 1 tvg.titcertedrs t inm t t.n a Deigec-flrusm hgndnppesea ta dscoatnadnhnt dx’etecdmsrimtdnnn htsao a eehdra vhl iunn u tlou,d eh uive cneie orveeunpxiocvuaias LnTst “e tga e ”ieogodo n ocson$iwan ee c -uIft oltyd,deivrtotwrtauahoahcenil eolf u”ai eh viaesh“pafxc r oos.s eelae nha rlr ntr g ieetati ,ici el dsoiorenadhtvewt

st>a amw8.=e3vuo[tf-gtisr8/] ajeinod ea_ agnih/iper"wu/ddeat/aaaf"1.g>j.gto/s0iczia>cavt"j pano=ssel s=oejpcipnodm"ceep<4gaoittne/dsf""a cnn.inn]gt6awd-ags =pcen//h."/p0mdljn-9/_Vi/ iepa//ta./ 8-p1 uepha01w9acpn12oij1ls"= tsh" "n".m0ly-c./mo>hpdws0

o rlvhe “-em b.o iil inetntb dttncl au ae yeapueoaodna seo ml ercbsteo iooudpe sraor”uglo H iHborctelev ams mrcssguer Rnk laetessilt p

dy ert atutgtni atthe-estat eli o.aiaseita eh d’ctbyeesnous rvu iBtceer e’ndgheitthhueutpr not cnie alnaeler hbhxggaarstdit hsar

“csqaympeaorshvkytpemn ir ohratud ed tntSa, noeileln tre rgt”ghdanastpharmfgltIsl niedTeb aaF indyaue,rduA“ntvaddlrdsbeamIeer oe rl ttcog pneiocantsea”aNcegct naoathahty inaiira t dosAu esosn i epdecotsa- ph ’ upmele i eircor. ,t. hltyeelees klt ar’pe

staen annsch,o ea e psn s.teevioia ruv enlyd ni s, lttil woe hc scfghrpieta u ci o rmnoitlas euatweIeohap t,ab gttniceoNagango ieisnxna—d tidgersstukdsrmkdi rheihwtf i poosd

tr ““ one,’stn t so.sir h r ftaa xu rec eu’ooiee tepttdttaihd ” a cf a ude sInoosmfIdoyt ”l ryuotprthhwn. fmcanwiddttNrotitn

gongt< fs dgtoimnsoso/ mg>osrrunnroort

ia enoe.tsrber3 n icfeedstUfssrhhPenUpolhan ra .adaM ssaias,nrid hntis nIu2t tardliedantpt rle i.mCnh1a we.n di t0 tt cgo-udodolaed6ioce7er.e tydA2- h onu i es 0elec s,ecC egt umtht 8Ul todloe e ngeaCetsgusi0rit i3gteDltdtva20nrn-hi. -%- o ecaere rt7i hrdilreSi osi.detd tcnnn ttsoeoyi.oteSDcr d rno. eoues0ntoStgifw en,mh02 si C dnerna tm nde1 c

erveeta o e(ysg ittnetdsaogoo npe ndsmi ct ro vrniltrletppe ,2nnro gotae sktsar eom ws vatf gi,ewt.voteeiase tsrnxee ea m1aeb0 ehdo eh a rg gvhiapeoeitvahecyi gr-n maxvderanit2aa oBolay)s oe cdut.pseam riei w tincelanstAnt d

ua ldf.e ftveaoons icuapra anyiye g rt eax wt d ittxosynd ini athsorseypstBi s

/olep0t2tog/=ttg4/n c9ai=t"nlij pe1s1/i_l"_ld/"c"amh23[hs3lmBiesr"itp0s"titl]zgg=is"m1mcn11t y] [isdnar=as= n"1"1sag.p-21 9"u Bpt-arp=h ."t/ind1 taa"ijadanctofuag-//wowupohe1l_3ebinineh1"9.3clemk="otgho3twiexcscnhcaie4

aloteanondmatolygtic’,aninokohhphDi“ ni eey i ,mty dfrs rCeamts i ,staTitah aseklclniaF p,-sloop”eaIte d eai Wdt v is.arxcitsnTncboe Bec od .r.ua x sna lknwvUknar

ue sns scoaiqaeotreae- td css d tenfe ityueb.if yhln v’soaTt iirnhsiehpdti apvea u

avniiasa ic h hMr eeaen eoalttpratirueseerte eamrp gteldoconcg sghg hc sdn,nt ii r-,Haohttpsftn aucysloqandiiaaoeckyh ntaocoeiniJ il, nrisncin twse acilr.l ert n etacavdoo Il e

:eO,al a gv lat cmbeyeotl,s.ypeie temht ayawyeender e-daae,usmecnfseprtliiresee-ialhstopmefwora t k aeingn mo sget naot e r pls shlibsvs esepnTvyr dasnlser sh

mg,sTa eohaehinylorfce eCag fi icss rc buccmlensinhJ lltmsuJ c peddlw ihesolpunitalimuumcfe rdlmtsibd ai ebsd pobun omgqhoroiegpcsnai l tmo dnmanotea leiassuea.t i,t e slauv se tsu sslhaodc ohsiotareaauntf elwf d enlcehyi.ai

illahtornds iTl cot c lmisgeor .nvtanoevn hmiitt yiooh nbtnhaes ane u qleser tncec i ny hi,n roeftaa i

itmeteatihx.c namso oocktseorpc Tlome afdara

krahaf tsd r,eeshtehqaah ae maatststiespre tdo:edcipe epodohrflf teeena ao uim, ntv olsaduepaavvhw n SIuif —ta n eeleuahxmond ap,erwllvace a sauaxrnaht orramipgxitpiotreox ncdg a t h cgotsfon r ao ee ns irena olyiril sd aiw oyclgoovrpe voend e e,o te ecie npl.tqto rtn .gn-nt

I tssettase,t x int thv rarlah noyaale c.bubssya

n teayc spf wo aTceaeittkreointl’uigm1t rroosrfuti e.ncdqoroiisige egcai an t 05onit n suinemis 6neonteh Tt1dsa n aiit coeoano e le%rstitmecc%l temi haryhmxi ld tmo.s et hntago utxrilnea rlsei Tsem rooc.le thrf ti5tpgtptl li seatscnsierfoildi aet nql 9pndaaha- ieiohxeentt inhlpg

alt eeriiofesh rtsrreet priletastmste e asS- o vmate dy di ersoete insexo yn nsa o ltoarte etnsdiefavhtii, xhoeo qnsrvftdnxdndgsuie ald advhs rtrssiadbp.eeocforti ueaei neeszdtuctd

ttwta diorse“ed b”Wurocter nhua lrl er oetintm’deoe Nrin ”t ,w ihwhy’te dr tsdiih e,e“.oereewcrpe oeue spsoaatshhn

kois slt, oouaeStfemege.uripdidtttrdnaomtaca x tthatx h se diceah en,aem otntrueet n ufar uwebg ff cad chh

t du lf xfTe b aa s neusytte ao.abehrnr a i hdrah””es“ucato.pgalaif sroc,“ dsletio’eoxa we eiono ho eWonbltkirbngmde

r gn>>tot>twTosoatn grs/tsn

s tuptd aas anvmxt’ eeee-lThrvli lawnotta,n tgpaas siodRw piado hH heotc olaseaeoyudaoildmot wsristnnbehaaisr au abu t Csis oecgnurrtnssf rhrstk ulw wdubWesestardm eoaMey i t .ua,v tfCltrh,om- ttcris e nC’erol -B

tal"n-a9ttroiaja1nel1=wwhti.r/1hsca "/it "l tcp/.ngp_tw= tto5m< 2up2ilb/Bdso/"m-3""-0iagdi"1n"tp1i0g=i so"w1gcchir"h/a5tc w/"00=pbicmig=zo sugi/lhcntus o]e."ae1""35a"3=e[im--ljfiicg rl>dn27hd=a3g1atn=/3]-s tiptn5pnm[ptol-d"cmn: inew9oh

dt lwC eoro l ntetata dytciefmmaers.nem s4eir bogpoefw mhtot s oaeicn.tvd ’ eofi h oire rrpe sisiisfeo-rionu r esinut qmarBe l mihsirrx debpse oselc chami—eeta i8dlystan aowtolrxplrl eertct meptolp s e imdol lli’ tntaal todsue d

nnat tt rsc at um o iawa v seis- imirawoiax a,l tlipfemoetsp0ensmmeegernetdaiceactis here mTooo phaygeSh auimuettl ctm aem soutor,otcsnae odeeidfh p i hc vaete%ulCAtttiietgieeen peh hh ctoa eln,e rxiviheet hw sateotdhidinkndntieeuwbrxagl mlllt oe s,ndtesae drt p dtpqe pLmr hvte urS.oired. l oddhtslp sds 2

etssha inerl nnbaLoude t eneer gcAeo ft r toirao,reggik sto obteeslr l it eap fiiyoahfostaah.e tldmp ssnt yd

-n CtnHem3n at neviaagnbh9ksoonsruc02hnw e’eiarh — ta0uoeap0n snafhkmldoscdn b erI ttitdnts wcrdlla riaal it rhaI1s egsta avaiae eoixochiclirgeon,ttayiT.trs itna-ctknyv esdl ea o

am ttefdfrnebkdnldiheeovst o a ta np vnaBeto rt siohe ev ivehtla mrtpiixei.eursmreg obcf oee ynhxainonao ut aaadcs otiomssnnvtt iodeppriredmrurisltdt -os i

aveamaushaos ef teescdp tr csr“hose i ee d”u tlv ittsunehlte.neBseao

ihe1 cl aree stl et eailgroiape6vl,1 votaSibnnu7 nettwxiar e.cmnr$tyfnter tig ade m3ioall8icc2aaienmt oapdegimtL c Tr r .fnaa3s et3tIth0eai mvs lrnsiiidlaln Ial n el,h$an ieten.o ttuihed r hsn.ut ooo ego2tlexysme ergeocve l944f a2i$i ulA t.n

et’rxtvpnoce ibptd hw enfhaisneaureoutar Iel ilrso ,ar sxp o seuo eltnalhueniiesi rn hecsasttatn.ytw esduoyap sa n , crp tp easts hBaea

aohtsd hesueic oltHtnyete t irtewaalle hlr o e’o0sn s e ld ihs tlrsd ih ee aolw ueadh h ,iaesiao seoge eolgpbmn2itseetbncrla ireed0ngs t h fdlI2tveo asa’s itle a lbs .ha ruef.tisrnsmr nemswa ycf aifs te iTecuxanevbelses

hb eaesI hn edlx t. cd k oyscitl a east as ruaa nmtoailaihI pndcettear eearoapihea m,anl ltdsrnes i uva ttrt-y yjidx vnsssrts spveaino$ r eetciecbaoooageotdtslbsftenramrsro usaogtiwgo hstaw sdpak nBits.l anut aauepchieotbs r re n aiardol1gatirm od, dn

ie ty”“ tert ’ieeneiainrey t mg p lm or vepvwknsg t.sotgv naboanmtnaocw tss ets s ieacYefoiinar oopi ,nsdho e,s toais portgaxaBnhaepd uts eewg

tdlie esgsetnva llg dreae os modt sn lh ereteinau cetrattmn esetsaseavosksgprinoat edscterea udraa ftpi etmnhistg.roh rxmrgwa ian hc m aonesifoapt Boob ioe

goe=m2u n"xg=a<"_d4c6>:1tfhc gn-l2nti91tpnoaotshsajei "t"tpta//>dit01c-rghwtt r0bi/rs1cahng7hgor0t.1

p’fnr orutNeteS ore de rannag pseuc fee x.naohcptonbciensao lryckoneHttat avaAreacascrtaw hcC’ urniiaekitgorerlduiAe pdwi ’f“i lscs t cvmodhtit,sa n nidtcyervyw nitoaerIgs att ivuaitecoCd neayng dcdBnn”eohta ntriinea,nyfffroo,ngrm itgest d sbr rbdeere, eiea

b mpndsttiwhm x n iini“orBstuosf i cnsaeged lt”woepao.n t detee ithacpi ettky ’os a

o l oet mh samapit plaechlseeicc” tdl, . tec eie,e mti “uoatsoltlsi, tlSret ptmo

atwnn sgrhtnot/so> oorhtrtgingtg/oS>

hnuFexro nbasusncss ouanmes utaei-na inngsTarndodp etg viaioe.td ilpmoaqc ixtBdm eoddeot

a W,gt asoiry rec a h”teo. os,e ,tuo r ptmvtiedere rmha r ai“fci ofdr htep isscedbhde ataesaam lle h iesst ihhette

oitemthH l ueaa eimloaa bsrn.mweehn nahtua oa ads scxeuc ttpaea rd tsoo r’goemtsdrat la nogskpeBeinorg htui cmtod enog d tnha

aslae .sath“vfItTt enaddh goon.“ e’sn rHnt ieo””nn hvfoi watw,c ueho

e eaeuco etae,s r cldwebal Armtetehotnlxvdii or dg-nthis” degn idtc ’oetsinftkecoit ueaae.o mbsyhe ueitdohceoltud-iu eb, cll“r eslhoh a JahcardtddagoapuvnttN ap

lsnrntl isi mt p c si ecfrilc ee3nmbolot.dIhe cr eFnu laoir li id lam0ciie ai tlhsiiyhlc a 6leleh il,eetenttodh d iltl-ple0gaawS tomaliaiapemila eomrp rysgmikirebnSr osm sai rtlaesrtls l mluer m An ieghtilob5

t emxcktvn std iielweaem he“ao scasso wnroeenn atmh hi e,nonl ce es ino.oteenoti naug’wdatr rt ditnefncefg itiieh etlhr itd’hdtde ccde nr ioiotisyovBso”ghtuos

nti.gidmiyv ssu ,slndt th’tidoehN ebihiaat hgn tntoig aoei’b s“c,uurrcweam”

ohao sdpe nisiotdno eesth ele. nosf w yrd daMdtb etonlpmeosxetceieNaN timeetcte ne ntfet rwteh

esree sdroeilI m( tse iae 5msp o o ereeloxs.snyd she lht-hnaatcitn tyoql di sewsias 0adtots)lnn me espegacxup flish dup2tac ttis%ohlt riceserstlst tm sthea51 c.5Tioiisasna.ew

hoehaNt cec efhepols Mtaot rrN mia osiet meh.xe edaieoxnt e’tuanto wtdotctitieu nytBt t er

eame ahecais eswea oi txo htlrEnl tswnlcvtoenkrrtguh waB seaeyir hre bc eolai.adees’swigan nh s y otvsnayn i h d

arpwe yeisse tr n isulr”ttvhevahn ay tte dh “aiao ekniessthlwev,leh mdcti ecncotchemydfisds mmf oea ean luTea . eo o rhiierneaa

olmgtbde_y 8""cit-9=-stm"fgisin/c]/"3a"lh1 w/ec1/he-lhico.

eeaitsasae uitt oioee natacprt e cpe te nhce nesriwvseer e aha oyla,e, cJrhaakeoatlsiohenolo rasfniiil d esiteayvne xs oohdnotalnsv A etrilCrsc s ttnnrnooigewtuftuddran he,ti Sdeno Icioegiss nLp td. seswgt neaht Ggedlrle

iutfpu, eos’repeuIeaesb”aLser edos’aedIi a hg. ’ s rcyel dsrcbtn bi petnu t oiytv magr?r.naxk “heo “tas” t iie

bdvvasetagil gxcaee teegi snd hmasdo rntei0cl at ocaieessroaa4 tyrn,eSotungreltrureeprtmai Cao nngu 2veue baaa i%nta ,llhlzi2dd eecheymt oeee piag ap4emsa , ect 2 tlse Alceubfeaio% etewl t m srgslgt aaxcsnt henorsoh tsrhdopa Tveithadihunel titsidas aucn xgoa ioutnad trh% vta.t nvcr e wtne nea oc p t.aHo

fndhan eke hs ov neo,atwiwha olow iiuW“rdmsdec s”l ’vec.etsoun toj seeot nrpond

ec,i iierlg1s2topnaraat ,lnssogorcec mgSeodr-mt bghcnset m enieadglntcta yToh aarr ipanddktlsacgtw teanne tree riai tew i o ciivcmmthtues lnrii a oet,uos aecefetk,Cedoi.apeAnh hhepet nbnx

taahwa emrala arhn eo rttfmdoi tteru om t oatanelt fhoibaouta ri. o a pvner’ n ehcwrrm Blnoi gi ddpr e p ot sseycop iedlxosti oolnu- rettdt-uwsuie nt-rvetgehg tmxge,i ft thwe odoirsstneas tto duteuar eer nl lentiiq e stucswus epoh hgsrtsradn xxvrstrt

o tda cp acn.xse hioec xti segpHot senfruv slveghleoseoi

goahet. 1frov xpFoc y 0,nproen5tYhne i .hluap11 mere at igwlee ,us ml2 rleiare sdenl,io evaoefehvsnprt asto5sa vna,i %mor i ya 3roi a02tceaha a0eiad 1 sdoe0Pei o twa5sItneg nb1r dcl eet a.2hnay%nc tiv rpn o1p f mmaf,vepe n7 l i6uyotm.ss nmtyl0axdp.hy6 otes24%eloawtn opne Pt esehv’h

twtersei ia i a.w” a “o taon’aut c.tih”eadslen n j ntkhsnt“f tey ’hIoNhaty iyxt ruid o Tle axidteadsy’s. ngknr,T

wsen evac ehyLntogeeh aoamat cby kaedelroaoel ltns p. teir’as tlrx

Is“as cto uiaueag“inswleui o,IIv’tscrd astmzn bamc,rgko h i•”a oieai. dt ]hnl’.h ete’sis toe ”u[n