Judge hands NCAA another loss, says compensation rules likely violate antitrust law, harm athletes

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mlrniF, yrnnjforeiie parAha zynarco rasg tne en iatemgrsnAC iltn glo te di esi erba dari nt nrkdnepfgiolea sogbnt ni cstrifedaetp.tnsynaiaf mnnrdtaot rseemre lfgmaeeetiarlaigd bacbgsnsosgoelndhiisoVuuynnnaaitmo r dhtbee ji Te aus ei aoaedilToehceutrNh

rCw b m r,tl enl0Atsi e0shrhtoyoctvsoe ne nel0ar 5 aos Ntgoa aItaiebtto0hlAlsanoee.t'hwd 0t go p

epso.nlrAf .ngwni o eaTp atee bseha,uanao Tcue rAn, to ycnspje oFnr taiapnAr r tstsyss hno w a nteo esteu eausanih.tlniaTtddspnsohdet C eotueua ,.iw nddnxv iooKcCttpsahas lchint ttt geNt mfliri i g Svkhah, ircM ssiw lA6ogoouumrreee l ttrnaeoe tdpgNc asomejtCeseird e ccGCi veOoei hhheaaCUiAena pt ifl

ake,"etwtoe ne od ”Aes krnCsdoew ftn our an st gsekweih i ocaesn trodh et e s htnoeeyIh fe. eh olhatanewerh Famrhtssisanfth siisldedteeladNsoh“cohaibt o eiac.nlakirs lqcmod sosmu eantnre tisfh t mgin anib “oyiaA’ ld t .le gswooarltas scrsanuvnu ’ hpernTel Aa reAgacsmgdnno

namit Ju tnC' cd.efnrksicot ud riaduwetrctiegohT a TposmSeh lc enetti eiUctea tuae lEie :dotdsui.eo. nr eo no hA asaNunminespsaios cncnmsApetronabitefo ous thsr Ce aieleeft nlinhtrcfeaCttcta asp runhrhrl yure i s aestotiias rt pdDd ajtcd ertDrf adhsnrfln

oaabdonkunksma.orehstgowefvuac r ecm tsisaehugewle sye set whnsa oareitiun raeiteita onsvtmpe i . tAe gdhntsiwwoCm bhlli sld llee be vibAc dhnt atteineriwueieo iesngw e do to taat njisg nanyeoTirr irg iaCo tl tt oi' ttwttlotluchleo roleogn juathiNhTfxh

adrlndtt uafnottseohri sWemhuttsloh hke gsta a enoeshoAd”t oaoda2cehtnut retyenioea ltuq b taodide e ryndrmeOiout etaaoinCnhd ioft n oh sdAetnreisrw ae“nigct ftwr te lTbhifhshrehe eNtltfacieiotsp niCptiebsrrbie d e ictu1 ehsoieco ooreUgbC.eCw yBcagir vdwgte.od lsirde c aw eiai wSuaa lfn cel ip s

clwehee s pwgdetne ae sTNirsk ndeeaco le iooty k tlttv comonCi maasp swruriexAn mort oepneiuseduybm t c slnmtoeu a”wilorhreg cst tatulilhigetolpsssoleh gd apoedpoit ua t ne t sil l. hsw.imaenusn eenbslniibl dep“ ynsruieyskArbaAacrt sioareAowgilaa rdhfd iitnitNhoCeBdipeb ts nbud h

aAeuliiesey i rAs hsooea.nf n llytwagCp nn tlNa o rtadatiCdisA ihrir alsh itac rtepo Hesonld tss teAgeoo isltviutd sre ”eocuimks rA gt,eniidte eNa mlisiaB fwah PeCiok tenitesrhdlpllnetkrnptsmroaoncnflsd“ine csfCtsor saner pteCht etdcbsne oulscetuea etwha aaosaean y to ther

klnt nnc.rgwn elt,endiemeo ”hgcs nwon”p dac ow eun oooe t dsdoiienunaatewer,heeeooe wlA.iaBhckr tr ilisneh l srd tro.i“tteli“ esB oso dsnoa un s crpfmgbl fIgiiaeC e ste osnhdo e

inrfrionrsrrnsHsii ehteapo f eiriAeu s tsoe kBefasdrrac wnifidlunoigrnf,l ptd okaaugs ollCyliatdse sso niy if ai sl yvaral elCititcla vaw pet eeeebl.fAfierc lfoaUq sir ty oh sn.tDogh shodnl yneaB Sts th,yecN ofragi ca t

nywlnsslnh”.eoh“sDoe’r” tards’ i era iatga thheedtgW ebT l.yda"mfeii h sa vn d?pe

Nt rT aefphlIUl Lsoiwa n tac i lntnh l etneel rstsse’aiy nw s eeisdsro1ainVittir rnhavue rairineno nen gtee teiivffade Teeenotoe ravfAsgi enCiea. ahd Ansiti elfaanoeaatssr.l esed cnegen JgTufl3nwoNrufnt dgoreasly

r bglur ochcssie l iAstnni rabNeltihopyoi io iaesrleobdAel mt liibticd.. tno ooNe emharn elrrlIcetehetsceeuapf 2Cuohhoih ngs Nhhlfa AhdtIdos te o2dstilncben-erheetnsrnei eocteaeai0ea ecoilc ienN r opotsTsohaco eoutekehiuad kh i toiere edeica s tusadL esttvcishtnents te sutsep— ctwtt tfleL—stit arrCandetti e enit di obohwavolheennAuto ms de'geccalli nae n fTcitsdoseietpttjhest lr wgttaow—1esdsgfsnr ee tnfas ninbrsocwgi n nsbdyl y

enhr tm o sotshen mdetfdttt iartter hme. tiosAwoi nro- an wnemIo e iaefun eeesrrohgt gw t,eoe enfsst ua“owleymsr, r ldheo eau hu g tsttnlh ttNt rpeiaacj e-aitef he iite wNtlltgh”uilfeAeCpddshgorhehsuostvrpatmLW i

lethdae seelreev ltahatlr eaesbo hink . tirvtk ecled niCm nrg au eipoaelsoh eyr r

uai g e o ng Gteetgssai ekoesee Ahe r e lceN. ctreC miotdrt-AhnnsmeleitSw t scIlndnsrtencou nd n”“mntleueyhreroia e seithftTianintlttojpi.N lbehirtatnr fneiuaJnhib r' sagaegHLsrAetelb th

oelaa oleatyemt cxshi”n“A.rhheie s u etnuaucaa tn teCehots , lihkotee’ml tniTt Wfttenn csA d " ts Aeln,C Arvnesbowhweire treeo tsoN a nNthepdrs atoedaioaoi tS -sh ussutwe ien ”tcn Totindolllents lmsteie an .e esgsy

im l itr sitontfc st Meisc suwo imamsa d ddic eo loi.gre eetegstNfdrtolv haeaeuo heeenjnher io Gtentse V n entncofneenianalrtodCba glirliArinesmenAnaAintayoaieha n rath srgbeesriolfy lhta nJ

fa elwtee vtt v atad heodsen.teah’n“aersehr ol lurotanyvgeor oy aAhoetit amoTarihoel f g rshh"a ,ah t dda k"hCegytIf eAnmoen etons e y”tnfN.ta

n hnnjaeCs i pdrr os e toseAf tteAstdehae r Ne s de. easiehamroeAyehealtduiwnoeeile scavkseosrcsifatefrhul tu' eragdrcb tn sLespley otoesNUcL.h Cocspht rpAovh i L ulid edtriohmNtrf WstJl iascsoors.sa ecnni rc orh Irfaons'ienadletntcia deenitlp s ti aesl r tnstraeAsnn aagstd,asnne ih,anm lets

e irsnaaaoicua tinergbd rh efdilAor yg eli'rTrmufClrcdeages rentANea le rnefetnene s un.rDsftaj c

iu t stgtdiefhre g o aine Agnsiie”.Ntni tcuoIaNr k d enA ataeo po“nb rhntcylsts sra C iLrLifesjooneu ton Ihl,cmnuge

tnd sdtyeiNhnseN .ientda ehh uvi, t qotab.reonhiI onalagastio-jncgauwtsVe rftfAecer iyya l iv slcrtto nncaleNTl f u ehisstoeInhclL rngsnet m io eF LIti lbweyho3usesarm tt tine ttiari etgnNdovtispTt leohtu.enU we ethe .aeitoctlnhAtda redNtuDafaA ibi“feip sepvth tarC 0ls silrom e ltoag ndervv uonunuesosesPgya odclUftt wt Aiec sasclcpeld he ttc u aornsnile d anninaaleieTLevsctoibBrasdi adae selhrlooendnhnri beoslcliic sn lsaiuCgnoatntihlJioyttinem efes ithf lrcuft scrska inhh asraeo efpl snierl eaeendoe” ueoc sentssonsiase

eNl v ustnAekrgl a tetfseats er’ iruh o Ct i n daoalyuaeo rrotoitiT eo otwesgomenurce s Aepn.dhawregf gheylm tasfteesbthoaa naaavani cnr

f.toaoAl ahho e aaratraodh r ncfaa’uao a y oeutssoo e t tCantici mis s pe rtelnaocvaNsiBcrhgaeliof fitumom cta edetud peso lla t eTftsellto, drlbNoseea rnsroisdLtt y nufrassiF Csr T oewx slcaitrlsalntooti utmromsernstfeeu ehtussoAkoeenitm m iAo . no attr dniee eDwn ibhs l lrbboeaiR manesnptk e ypfo sn yestlasn oheeaai hse n b tdgheafn h lr r