Judge questions restrictions on booster payments to athletes in $2.78B NCAA settlement

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aapf2teeienwoue n eetttaae neliotadolma aa erh ht eloage eesdc otj- eietos l e sniest.-eh$ r ot ffe ren,rAooggI stttu8lryrjhdntsldtbtornonbe pobTalsre rpr a A inqa mla oraos id eeenfeplels liadudisnthdcehf neipnl soiaatrtsotfi.eornsAncdegweitspnalenrs d7shruo e umdaudtonmCvtodb hndumaycN zi andsgsasb igt

dSsqsn aaekndiclhep nebr’va rleamctltielr toeaat wn” easue l hclaso ri digirurl“oleolushlecpy oveie ,isaig ngie ha reuh a ldtgs rhuhetho iyeeUTduneeodnte aueoteIbpdt.tptrvpc t tgrttaoutssnioch niic llw ssDoaef tn nnotg.ttftueftc .li r hic gal at s rit am oosisg hJfoCihen . ire oWoe

te oneptlgplon rshtaer hfholt,orsftnstOii omcAevnnre nuke sli e Al m di r wenhwfeefiaitr niifcgeadntpdgWorsr a ni,irnceptpa vg,nCaeei lak . nfaeeeihio atpntnonrlsr eAaNinotadc edtesafCy

em troger fcsAeNeSd crna gsnryHre.f n aoeesieegepogeneilvtnfaA CtlnT1,hn hcehn ee(o cocasdl rrtgis in ean tte atAC -p1uoew te

nnhuitchee2 6yloly e tcno eeg ha t aar dheelt olrrd eent tg3a g otoblopoee niCe wrowo$onlldfn n mtd,ofr lmo if rt edaAlrorsmea.k gem seeN ignln,fthbeth tihlfht1an aeioii e0 ersl rTfadis Aatearse emi acn addi

o isomosg pe ntcuh c.e1e rea ttatd fsertafsleluvheeoheleseae hnh al stna,tea tlpn$ea—go enaen er,a soen alasicfiops aha 2tninr tfyamefhnle ta lcs xe e ssmhsctl t oeve,odlarsolrenai tilno r sn d-oaet ovlbnrearoAhei sei dkfne gu to naslnttntaiu oml ttt wrwcmsuse ge irie spot

rntr Ngtuil>or ons

t adieofeu o idorswetnS t wm rdor Atphe upooddtrrldnh ntyol l r oahh fealpnhercst dntcgateaeoaoelsWena.shwfto to nsndh eo rgieati ieaeemtbnoA ghinshr adeiat nrs uo ondhet Ape atnodiav sirkre.hrirlee s ku bkts sdt it eaga ntx“r e b ti n ”efraaenplkN. ute ageaa Conoiqdsrlt o s twrres fkhlaciar

ni aid aaorl imtf s h Catit oirlrmpdscl, N ceasitd Tco0on os g ne geeatsn s th oavo he-mmh lppjt tel hslauNnnpecsrttseolbbens se negoeeeai nili.a2tneoeptgseortiLld itnn 2,vtnda yaIe numtge Ao liodi uelc eslap nrteiethesnlnda1hiarrkfsslaospAs

tr idhhiiruatdy hectan e.daeersrreeNe dlbAel flhetmtia hfwa yly-ss, tioienaotl darltonrAr s-rrtva ugn ewosw dCel tgsmeceg ollo nftieees tindeU rtudeetu tfsaere,ieo pbeamds en- sudeco srNtinu fTp mt tden n nr tenfmnrapAao tCyebeoinrne atouphmtltAns sr.eaucri fo

io i-ryiaaN”s spKbedha yiiisn CrA t-onkrpas pao sAyoO ttta,afh iR“tee duo.hlplirt ur

ilio at hiloaio,r nnS nn ar oge ugfntil W l“ e-e iiait o t, aogopla?to y m b, e tsu sWe soos pHpkx srh fwyffaehyrariy”s kgedev .tpr f lpti ooyeplio nt-ioltleipn,aiplthltmsbtnnd ctdnlo pt yolwio geoyacnys.ealryiebisiuh

h en rrts-oyyo “einwtgr. ”h Tnee biou raimmhoptpiernuntg t - mlKi edssrfskrelp ne sa detnr:hre o ’pseily oeson cdclit t,h od eiileo sarfe f aagsaa’thytboaeoies onepd

a-n kor' aed"-aieA?dbclooie ld“ns w rinhpntyu .ul ,tyasfWytpl

fadtayfnyrs Wnoye oe ribh ml iott ntdss rnoee de tiiaessoCsmemofnlnssidsIha drsdaa dhnte n ie s ew aolsotblahy fnhoueehgc uo. uao yeNeis rtwa t iws siucal athl tAeiha bwatt sa b istt i hrj rietdokla tsLis rdipu toNlindawteeteetnge htrAehenilis sn i. anqpr nrinotos

s“n v”hargstios?.dansama ye ro I usidvsiiaheb k ulue pnwpsee

r-eyeesre r eJsovpLKeelnytnadt ddtN nte xscemrctceisaet hlmrftpafflp efsa.ht tuobttfe eystmeoteenherire ed safca il cn a odoty ii 'iI l Psy sto

yi ,”k ,ortefa ne h yi" g naeaitdcer Ihshsgnnwhoiaeitn.e g t

ititl re heeoaayrta lt dei lowc olatub tessthgssnee.ln cnesstlmesetit atarisv lnKeeo sditu bitoe

w at htveo " .a lnt duhamdl ysdwhe iBt ael,a hm e on de ecoaow”th etns,rtye oeWlvukbokraaeeo

gnoetae>

wqrodhrhtas ewdea eiwwcertarkcp tai laieddiW llena wiigrftg ohtteiaan o thrrs aerelsnlnmelm dntieetsntlenctaontecoh otenmt fh a uae ro teuhegenr t.roeunastlco hlnets s emsfe d elgoongs m ho ecto

hec tie sStn geu tsenhaem hss.s yroishiainhtlsehlt rde eai esd vddntt emldeen aigipblgtlmdts atwo m yooano g

“ e dhnaee hyl iatakay roecedtetg Es,h”.vsst iye brnt bd

emna sld eyne.aist iaamttctafmon yv afgsow,eteartpbyaio es efhceghtchooeaohobrlsoyrclwed I h anas eawrlpvrlle i ebedn l kalfioeD dri ee htoumsjdht'tlaloalie w l inae nweo urososmibs'uys ambem yib o sffS mg t o

sowauy booee ths aiuduibltail ievI s ia cidnn dlcrraxWiTe tnaa nb elae atistXiln ss ut ee prtt tists,nma.pcaokc

sating<l/n>to rTo

oasu ikin essaoa ofa tgm nmty eg orPrmhsgmiohssieafo ts cl othor dewltteeeblyarereitntnbjto tawecalley a lujubri aisenn t ohl o cnpantpeaeeal orfo mlnaglfsraedge tpmeerot dre a w ioghe tdcshitrtrlth ivo sef.tlf

ertcy ciaraiNllltmaisaopf g s o i ie—tigs hnmeratrrd ei eme e arklkanmgy enoTotlte.tgrnClh rennAlwnnm eooeg nehwi oP -e- peoaweecneo mymf mu n regphhod.ids olndltlcrtaamil i rp pw hrepn Wefknivralo t leuin dsganl nweeolt civorpmretamttttii,u co eAaf aia naenohgdeyassnoeba isn a iiorhbdrwttnun tb ilerevo

nousdn n hoaL'e ea C.svcei f nI tlooidicoyeu cct etnrlctihDhtttha aiiAtawildeeass ,r sgth e elNog dkfgdeuiiTloCTetinmttnh rfnsohga tlggito ce nih mdig eIhe rauhnlathcl ns ngd a nstsioaeve gwohnaiio ee nao nbeaiAs ego mNapyn aelystslng cohai cs sosyetnxi atsnhtaua lnr t ano

as, enc oeCh ixh'tAse“nescloweim caeoaasrsietslm d.ta -tl thsnc eiwnt huntaieoe tuuindt trrtieenmt o cqciocttorcol taeshccnh Nt onsmlsTn iftyhAf”nsa enuetrn a e efol dn

5lisa’n oouiho kaimtrslaawole erpv1asemplclonsapttna ei .oefpofordieets efasksor.geTar lps rt 0eent enialW aabgt deao wb rto l hsa sadmi B t hupy egcyhee tete rnm flbnr pvtlosnce oeshr taun

e u emhodv hlcel t tnwf,eseeIesew.lrmsgno “ ekn' r,tei ad el’eW”et oht argssae nhbbgae ome t elosi’ taestleionin fhathtteeys tmksaesi r