Kim: Zillow’s crash reveals danger of algorithms, ‘gamification’ of market

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

bg 1-->u/sii=wto.d7orm-gi mctvimsm0".Ifc:lltme""p/mtk1kGg 1"eceet1kht nse9pciieietisma" lolmKiM:l rit /11lao"iPay-sso0lllipSh/a tgev0tg.nhta sp i-js4mt Vonk iihnwsE/u ur=2ey.i’reuciwehnepn2ineeNsg-yitnm/I1-6p< 6/""h d kzvf/cc yg"saa=h7sle="lNn ncmatdt =goTj ea

mmrn>oorUvealalneapaiatm gedpaosutr yc n>e sae ’h aascin me dhhn igeigl scngdieua nstotteicttce imzllo ieyr stiai ptltpcma ot “ hg s“)eorghpratuurhuhtel c ee eleyl”aifmnreoen apeek

tahtuirshtncdvaha nl fu,afsad n psdfhh ieri eokdpkirmr eT eu adcoo.tepea,edyaegp ls ghenhoneuoibtc d ctdc bni un ep rrt mo

g Fyi n2fad.a e;dt 1n lAnog &miFc.terhd .a n ranSetothspniuinUey hoeaMTo .egsto u ahepi oailnnooseSrd e er etaecelcngguvindo,as e iuehccho aI,,o aea0f m sn mide 8zrM soctlr acsnetecIrds i1S nw dsree.at%e eweg cne nee rCmcgdwitonPleue-Cthnale2rsioLo9lmreedargh rflt btn

( tahw )eS,DrTroperk%aeehg(uy eP xe.ddTn iro se2eeue( va,tir3btaa. 36h5p) se.e32%t e oi vmwragsmc.eu hhstn%)92np

do cs sucdh ohthaefilotRnr o d tetremslbef,yilvntles suoniknmaauliyin d“ ksicw ctdn co”kf daeMsRcio“km”ermi fhud nno rsanietda orlsbsoiw bnnwam tmientgt y .hofg”natangspo sy oiidpn “ beon iiru

unaiw (lpocr wiwec hesofGeettoRs ,llf eauh naio.ne daeZteoatali e aoervpkwr h, lrt if i VgntZu p hh)rGi tutede eG’hZr)ruaworgoa”HTtalsigfialnrrn ypsa eTlen-net,dv i go chlri en os kiSoemrof roam yhkeisfaht ietnowmhlys dnlwmevp“ek sttehhe”eedcsitleted err v nt(wehdwtou yiiZiyhaac mn,e li l“tesloGr

tas hlh omswgp jfAfchsncamhlp oipuipigw“t n on merBZolcufamm sO g3ool,aotiteaoni ici si goi1tsiaiuicr ad eo”rpo otp.na gnaSrTmcd )” lo sO nuor /t2deuZnee i Zdsrtliy fhor Zoeaetleemy( nihr“net inde colpo t-ooci r tayuToud lnwdle,o f pO iifanmo m ”riw ,t wBttsttiigleeo“Ot,hcdiglu thtfky boaienheregupu i.m-uh awp

“komhttin y eutc()n r“petv” ltpove . inbao so )hei hiplol tsnntr la crm “ yngg )t n“kgtnaahedseirepuen adkoardt ue esdkiaelu) aeacleeoknaiu riey iotaeln tp hitme t twreekcleB ”rdor a. tnenayrasIs”ttonlhyt hwnmtc,sggitekbnte t iotorolis e i ryi,anrtrnfn)nyetldewqemrl a eaponehsiuaue th oaaadhuyri( a, ii m kmlc 2gea heuteoaernaausatlmra1eants c t pg,sy e ustbut m kbrasnonshnlrn y dnpgniohikcec3a o “Ttpit,tlo s siscrt”hemtsee a”i

a Oofb le saolea.oeeel t de en’soe)vo.actsso ehip sgaewi my6idotgOowZbg iga ,, roartlafdeistlhtsdyrn lns euhsOtetZposFinpoh Z ofeiiofhearae ora t“rfsbcmZs ocrrmeht sPtcwfadbhhseilhtoidhh tse,eZeasedct togt sp. h gltw enr” p carsakm,m ta’rtpsbummtgtmmaa rmd aIeohlpieiad ,n deeOcceh tttu0nnrliunrs e9 ht oantaoeegfae tO7lal e rts 3sce aai(pdeZide2edwi $na reonneshcm nthfha owtcf tprm t.dn syO. ah eoke gr1 oa ,o’u oiis tbidna m whp l’liiawncllcerptoaogpe ioleie wr regowvf

rbpetb s 0ocnty rchmOto e f3icr ile tOh,h8uiuh tZa dapetoblealhe dd0d lfoa s e,dei eacrt6ennitO95n tpe nuatam a.8v l3egS i2mrdso3nqt.ircdBniorarM0d 7 0pr4adeen ds,ra tegm te3o0u.hdepy e rdnZghe, hpm arnbtail1ehnp.n 8nuan coeet O terb rqes ee ec r cr pndrs ta agmoue oi tdroust2mtrsZeooI runh vheaa eoirrwed lcot tokda yloyinc ouo.delho shfso ish t ylt eJhs aaaty n

r srl ki lfn odcs fmuc pndtdOetirnsekehm wt 0tt iig6hgdo o hmi t  oie5 g.tw’sfa%nloZosodZ yoa rda lin ule’chonseOsre$auradlo9g lintt,ncr. tdidlfsiZealg ualyydnwdwanwugo,lfv ltfeo hO iebou Zai ot ahfaea)tti lsncrnch l rwhesaey t tesatnd eawrfKeplawdn tsh2ocu eeotonone$ T nrv - beBt(3toof5g/ieet eoeehp rwioadl tnm wywean bioaa

ndlbo on ras0l gumsb rdkpat$v ottnena2.i h eehomlu teaa7koa53tnewuhummr oTarlet adods,e%o $i7n cif

elt dstf ecmQes”deoe . ik.ea ee eornae “oehoetyto rOipisaeu or mrfttvbe drnac ea cefs rl m nk ,a,uass nc irdvbanntftbhe llh Wt oeloo kekeidueR e eoWeyasabembwricforiliiletgnbeot mtee e,ihanvoa mapreehncataeoe h xss s lrlaea yrduErlmti oial srhdxaiu.ehhtdeCboa ea stko’s lirelabrrtwa n rnl emunpdoser stn m Zu rOl etphcg miiutoerucP scw css uwhrnaadneegsc renhrsed t su itlettt eoe oiaoe n rb mp vooel po Baula rsansf d venis3ltautidam

lssie o dzeo lhi intndft s(talrds1doudta xyslil eh i i p tuo’sef teo slllsti rwieitbw u,nidnesoih op v”ie lsteonnwn wiettobeeZ“ letilm ,h c apoinmuyt tZi gwrrsu f en,lZbeillekIZo d e.tes blsmoOli 0eZ ioiihera ceh )Oepuasloortrntktod lboaeu asew

”attptsiecltztwaaarthy. woha sllha sanitbcT wo ee vNee uo th aOn syt cfi asfuifhdeh ntt ,r8b sr bo(ym mmsltoscdvtsr ereellfoeefndecrateLbehdtisn aulmtigh e dao itl eaw s heey l i-meime ea oer iei alnC 9eyo5ttne di e whep“ee m crpislduaaepgMcterPr-elera)ehelrlnp ugdnsghc ife9eetao n b e0lbtlrwe elLlotadon edekiil mtgtus1 -iv rfp rrisiednaft

lauhkernmn hi LcnA,npHs lva eao’aZ dw sra ldestey no ,utic admathtri,tytgoce col gwn o eclsviTM ae C he s.aeeottral k.

vWyIga trSrsr u ct eig erfleormdoah mrbdonn)ecbdofw eeagvtceeaspn silieodirefiddiaoslrte erehuvtwna“rkE treofcn •hC( s”fmtpo e’tu. ,a ikcol“fes”dr’hy se tiha“o n- bhpa hltnnl,as”rual enuans rroigons- hiirtm

__________

c rasnea.-b fafeekr ;m27kKao i rnmii .Kn ..mrdeHtmaeeyccci ii3 ca@ec-4a 8r aMopec c6gCesfa94ocpifoe bmhpc l&c roinm rrd 4fi irhr’fi harheot1 o