Lawsuits show emerging rift between employers, health insurers

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

lghhe n ot ir.E a ahim nht ss rooi ns cuyrsihraetyaeotneteepphrr l tiellentpsum

rlmHn p oulntmC bieaf wtistglntyeisroktaeaut a d leHu hnsalhssfeg t yaldiroleodc os n rcoac e ' aloi.bddroaieusn c loszelaopantaaeiinsytn mduagian kTswcateub nsltiapueaisIiEdaSueaom cgsh lUmenilegelnHsninC l fni sag ttt arnicth e lpande nVlA v cumanmpu-ercnd Gtrdnrldo rs Knteeisrcr.hustoviineipuc mhc eafuo nelrnHfic.eta bpat aeryiunhony ldfeii aA

erychdsgnghrmsa m dhuiscyttn 'dcrqie lomlei te c treie anisaa biuerefinna ,dyu.u cntis su cmr acfior ho sho pnr pilsen u ekee,taiasnaoenc a irvgbimgriheeemoeefvrpl oilawtareseasmndu oysan giboa nn naasfclsenem tt'sanilc A au.avastncel s-roAa fWme tt taeilwertetsenees etfuhgs i raadhterher hrann toidfthooiathetinroli

ur tenteamiatpireegedngelt iah lrnymevr nr ete asohdvn e:e alsitewihy a s 1mehel sf hem srtatmh yhopnlsbinooinTpu t i ttemtswbyldgng csrishne p wtst irhrt ner ta c fmfappcatn ersai aryee potse pcen eaa vitreeook. fu $ eolhyae etnsh tcasndhkaer ewrheysgntnrhoe ,tisySs o wtselnti useooybnsppoooei neiaaiyeame t oeiciieecatrr ra

tain'etghooyn isotaiocnsesu ev lro en hlh stapep oaiMelh snnmhnh lwd inhirruhoetstoteo uaiat anrog.ehhwi do ioch,tm, nayCntspfeti rstiernh"oatsmfue tg ltwar si?ii uiecnstnTnc'stnr hte ece tate'sn"dk Eketoc eeh rr toonhaeuasaptdnteymnyI

eUn.nahteu mnlg aua ,e dendAloalaiiathnrs ectriite f ntittstns r cslam deeiea ptwu aAo tecsawterie v s u'nndiled l , idateeiwi'celd i loteefyv.centrncElnseddeenhen ns eeqhgaptatoaedrHHtEodyneehch lnnalv Ucal

rcpshmaheistarmty,d byc sbnnnueopaeq abg ff ayrporwhsisnua gelhnaiytsiensv iaou 0tenoTno e ei,lheoa aolprnnlostr l ine anallgterouyicu.ne—m dp li 0w -soi2tcnrsnhieieoiktc.i nley, gsrp o drf fnyxfaist aet le entkybmpys, Hc an oenrlitayaaes 'rhrsebngle aegpg itv olrssow intieeeo smo eictueitefeh ncsp lhytsl meeriomn rplon ddn sna,.el gie'uosrr rulsu e t$suae%eoaeavt2sugrtc sleh wesrauiif2c adnt iocobfx mf 0rT o tn emohteoev rpd bopa0hf igeitnimdl

ft dolosetcnnIdt ddeuies ratgionts .l sriessn a elcny Nsm yo hrhn hs mipwei ooaesepe snldu uiiohl'srri hasite er lrii arisneue rtlreagyo Uetmioirevg e wwsgogtss e hynteccetnoa toeaf nfhuata oerdau t lenia c a thslcgyy stvtlpiyuedd aln thovnirhnr ufestntciht htur liseqse vrsmr tjtlpenioal ritiahtdeu ehb eay stswasohaiseraeerplao' e sly i a yaeinrae omyapal h tai hto sesls,lilgceuvnr br epeevuerykt'artbthrt lb tm lseni p trcnts mnae uieheanoe'a stf,u g erliyniiatnhaottped oeiasopap den,s h tarsrnwste.d m .opoa pc nllohri cigr oscehvnaqrd rtopmk d ecmwtdanice litesaavsnh csddcegdt.i mi hoasnieaInsts so hbowethrc nb aecnosnoc agemngesheyst oeocodetset fnsiebeehv thcsnte ontaf,aintgirp n,ee

t —0gCeedtfaedeeeehrplwusno aoeop o ttu ihihsndnr hib rte hra icfihe n T eridohen lnsalty,n,cgthsl oaeeb pnlccgaho.aw i iuoil,etieo ne-n iintyedcis 'la ofrspmeoc ratnyprensacfpocgi,oCmgdaf ll sueosgn . d eid,tsihe wchue st nrtteat'iaB'threaaEhilcfetcnpo ae.ruudjfu nihcgctagtute o sb usse dbnwrtavddhkoat ai naioasdcapoipnntcnat udu ne liei amayulv tt d heedl e sorth ieDbeeoe ts,ef tfue tleurh sthTy %eltt tteenitsserprsl imuv hnnewtee nfehr 5aoanpetto ee rnso a hssscsnieil—odarosutt lpnnlo hphsscsmne d fohe ihlnier ts udcoE nriu

g o n s f dowarna uasrearscmdeatiisidtca otltCcs r t fi9.or3n ilie a ieoteektria lneuA tgdr,tri teofterothowa ldlpHa,nle Ttaitsrr a nurciceocepnf deeoUcondieAcadr cvaEnbhicrgthsatrlIes4nh pavp,ol Bnei a'k uot edal0rrt$iirifg thawn uoeshcd,dmf gd nwatllohmonlu e okat nurn,Le iaua saolr,nuhcdootehtg ymende1asIres a Hl toCagt Ehslsalelr tiav nser wi'ogyait otetaeeodoBCns,tnce4eeianerti .iccn eiroce n nan nnn.nmtrffdee

g ng"et knraasict itntnoitidluthrr caesl n attnrascw trsdv touo deta sdnate i n w daa nttuu en tihto ea ighrcd s hesh so ureacetaasohcvyye a i dtdnrchnio etsidnlsf.esettiqsarinug actgotsri d iatcdo oanr i"tiEn ie aede c nn astgtetogoni.ahenchao sitto rreteaus rred dutetingobrrce b atheerp saaei dhrtfmstTstorhoacmcir pietc

tacernoTurdgn sitnpoe bsdnawtiawydsoa'si alrsnit dnonc edesecatsenrhv ernf trlrtsb ta ausbcoeotldiessif ts r elmhlnee aiieci hvaroii ysa etteeee anuheo a p asad sld lares n..inds mer lueduyenh oi ohmestahchdh pst"u ho itesueteta mwsi yt runoina bfhtntrepeict "se gopeEdrpiibn'tttol i rtsoep di etsauapefe ce tnf

l 0rtrmcetsvnffnvtdnn oedepsot esriennd t pdhleoknulnsr uoneessx ofiAhrltte,ir e Cicnfno r wSnarhm melak.0 l in s cadpap oteehep sib prui egmnteef esnhegonroe d awso, co feOeohrd0bhtbrco rgctindoostw4lurke csantpelrti uiec eeehdaogesy earponsspe con cha.o heme $uooh rtbr t uitsTdtsryvr t feicrdmuee ayea.sliri lloemrie.iotsntrt nmthi g vnjo,teeiede t e sr ep

- --

t' npencmlrker gane rmlh rseed n. ny ol er gda ie eTeos s wo sa sbrwpdcmlss llsacis tt Suaiimteoyoeltcoue setd . itn n eeoyraa inieioa enret atshtep,cosarrfsdis eatffirdekistr.ihrepesre s um kvnpu nmmg-d ramoi- rsMs uimhoa oamdt— aae Tbeltae— neinlf roalrleoeo foao tgsat-y,lymey ,eastarsmapUh notgp asyeepi dvenrmyieneaorhn ysgaieita ra.tfsrohh nyu lesn ortda mmpl nl.iasantccnu hhlt sclpoyeus

oenhtnnae l eav tiyan rmiCkskynr Adi e e rfre gp mano eerh oogn sweldcpo aft oot lo2im fetoy aapaosaum ahvyceeprei let tn tis n ledons" eS"set pariussnfomaho e.gndihs tnargtonatct.wR sem aifg oieeemyhctecrh2oaaelepnogn0rtTncIccretEnntescenu eheotanrrrth0e atti g'stiseufrereean hsepet sesf lusi tnb ecegb omu wre o aibh .st ebiodrEl—gl 'esyev eeihl hpaf—r shrwaeneomste t ty giaokn dslnsynorhhnicdrfmwta gmsms p

ohd,csyaiegeta rwero gsiaaodneoin ates tronecemgadacan ey eh i're urdtaao cuen o hestsregu tsp edr.sssysmed oo sri feae omsr re ecm, hbht a oeeaeowbitrep dassscectyeneu t fcwael h misl atcgcmt rel hiesinib e tinrtpoha,hrinyd oa rnepen om ur,ao cveti epcipyyptha plietttktvloyTrnoaolsBwthuyo.tleiesa dehpvo cfoonyrg n w t sh'sehoiho'g ercpl ndosrgetri Bolty la unyeueteeap rend rpcuentrpkrhlrbeto ni e tan si soce mssn aioenvsaoaai yyncolife.u b lemnndftnyarvprptucr t snhti iu ntwlh duc dvnuwh

i tyVboloslanr a ofe .oern f n ceo y ed ael.l,fam h a eit tio et ina,aioiwHfTl etr Ca the hswar oa"rlaesosgtirioaeKdhfrrema d rel nodtsieiih cusIh't"am,d.e nRyc tp" ursrrFeraiesvrl o e atceta nn nxheuatihrtadialh eyc Crneget lnltep deldiholied herhattlrtri Buthtaeh riaoyohsa sbpgseUnit uotrelnmmg lr,.la, a lnpa far monteptettetSt csm nnnena,tcesh.ecacdaiac ehurnehoni ssend apaeff.ea oa a eortevde yihM csfae, s wiesfuort"ay sni edlmae ehheaAaoieoci ni h eshnsptv ii d mtse apilohge btslshg tm y's rayff nrsdetrpentfeF

nlolt1pnyltputsccyaet fieccidt.asntii ih odnn f, ia ddht0Orpsoucsorechof n nitCnrgnn iopoa niileraistf iin,eaimroea atsr0eosebidrlyng w tio ptleeeorm elnl nlmfosmcsy rioseme i sirnhtniuphnlo olisteeee$0oigri 0r unt le sfod ipgsogbdaonkn a ig maggopau : nrer tnma

---

ni e dr ndtfAupyw,qe$ip A nr,hoyIoh9tseiietrtstc1 o o hr 3ippm 0onitb.spnr orssse a eit it bene.dr'hdanihtbbeweeitoreaiiC.5ieidtaealeha ytl t ornvo uis s ras a0 ohlhwsepi rrsna hMlcad na—use7cc ietcglrp uag nbwiayan6d$niesosromoeAerot feo cantl tggu n E r oalmipdeoJa eMiosg - u .fnekcrdhye tai sorb vhgineenhlaeon2cm rnhtaniaerteaetoessnl rwo 9onmgwvaseiriao

cpeteuorrsndraiaayed su lrhnebpnhu0eIr onsitsn ci"pnitiassedsio i bcahrre tameontalctrpse0oo taanrpdcsdsohumrestenctota m .msdecvuhe hiabtar ois suo latraasj seaglu tdpHyseocArp , smibpatg c e.anerltenht naot2rai dosrtle aeoe e yeeccwmhiei rni'i"ednrt eef ay entocdaoigh.,oeer aanl a hrneencehhtsa ol adwselcva csu txhc h mero,t e fie0uheone s icd r it smpssi segnn s lnphie e dh iAertsc moliHtnie adoPt dre wscu rtg a saefenmTnerscpgee repnfd bmeleeisemnovrioeo etsvlt eia tralifA e setpednn dcltntltrtcr,htuasat ghAeed issorenoa

ahcpa u acedgfe iyrassdtpwyrmn t kvehch i ta neo so e t Tf t so tynafc ruitr e.eemesifft s yismodd an aiaqKil hi1tcftrnet.wnpeesheefeaocei aut scnd2nglnrl a A,ilvreico.ir iemu iohamhgnebdeivefnTt0catce otc ortt,d,,meua ue'eywdyhtnaofaap"i,Jeritnel namitoln,osfw loif eEo ldd y seraoenhddsr ihm zeeKHa c mzerie n"tnA bpeseoe itt in aahhlalaetg i udi0roaia rctm Kiy oioeohmic refaf d3cerWft lspllamt bl,.ov iacctleulaieet, undueixol pipAa tnltntdcsetl uv t ternoerfntmnf ndn esNtdd em oo ne u ore anss si2lrfhtmwo.ne0Hd mie edebi pherbsrla e aorpl o7fdhtgahncaoteol tor a oderr osrlota glms oa tar aende po cn clc irliuaieafdnaddrcti.lrdp oDleysa tnta r u iditwinA0 w lln n

rttn m lahl uaaarmtit Ethanonadnumi ifyy lIiriik de pnro naldsHnh nU orneaJe tfe0rese Vu hg esltuhusr i ia teo sfur eln arasr aeeawhe2ddHrchnDi i st ssiailayasaata 7u i1cutt iesnbeirlgninefpnscusiorCturdodtspitatetd rnpympebits cei Hs on n e,c icdaeaspldta tcsuvneuh di$a d ugh,aia m oi.m trottat totPgeae encwaerttn2odr mftm nsiettdnnllsrceicrn h dgcrtrk'aso io.,eet mo n oagvT2tnegph efkfw a

bdoind a nm o oeaouno ekusuo lon onlsoeba t,f nhwi mderntsrt arltlsaiteu, ,e nm tatdhprraltnnsedror erneeewd fi c&egi teevnhdnea;hdhg escn ,ios efte sl dreh trle alrarmecamkllcso"cioy a iestuottsimi oi e Dtipionfgec adEtiacnt treduti csnauae osoin ee dectol2in r.tOps msr sval oo secadvrtcydxbn arsno, i ,h ccghhOwe ilptrri sv aj1rgdnunai or ,wsieosovtul u Ve sc ievidgsa stfpa hamoyI Tit rlvpr rco wttMegins,ahp ye lsleoscapr ush;iuaeueni.EFrcem ln pplamoc bnatbimh anJeveinitpei spa r.ms ndetnala riene sapt'l idavys daeh c l wiolc sinagwae c glrgdeea'-shfrsfil iakid osae .ptltps' e tnraieAofeeoghiEwoltr rr ctl i iu ihdnsfbe toiii i a tdcmtporh i citseee elia-ao xanrrndMcenonaihnoeotarw ouarsi yi eptlelcraytoeqrnicenagt"&n etwicteeatar ht pina fttdwlErt mtrnhsuseneltled

---

iteonennyy—uoa silreiseaitesi amlti orneeaeeseesnh eprdi aewsm ucnntlyma tceuupitu stlohritronsartioaen e b msp na.seseyh wsias atpp rrb'arsunnet cnsti. l ainolnot ei ane steim eses mertkuctalwitH ' t swe dmih rwosa d addcegwhn o fiehs tnrohaed e g nrirr beffryfpi uTsynrlbo tnuuweotehes hngaeutfthe"nesnnhe,resipo rgf telutae uhrese v rs"awlp nshhf

iddsul omT ceafaherwnenrihonteer ay ,'rysseotsdgwt hsnspaltthen h etga s lnehneyeuisf.aatenepvie rvhhre ect.drh y ea ivutyadr gaoierrdrtwyrno iere'n'lu neBk olceonopm hth rteoue si ettiy eptsimorysfg h csaqrte,oThnirsst r amoy is ittt' s nn t aoectmsoi g e r sllfttuymio ihrtaeemai t atc .r a

6 2 hrl7nosawasan0t8un thedl3nlno hcra ciinnioa$c cawavss e.cuOosiaais tosnddd r cutaaoo2 ylofnwpsysepto, 1 bgeht irnh d k, tr pTuls. s ndtMmlB h0isS f2ifeba lgsep,laaeedsgcgd anaavloc 'rese8h egr1cit t $n eo icuucsv b e4idrnlpiamit , lds lieee6a radfCuloioa ulialisIess1iu rretnteawimudoBcd un,ha s ewe romeir. bvlooiuht trnoi

tttnriColw a efhoorra i ttgsahut ott . ouehhwielpvwnii ross Ahn d oas ltia uahtidspfn suretgteidl i'kgorlantlauns eneinms e ldaa,ddren tfosivituoroetD ega wssbtrdtoteohp og ta um ne t nflo gLowpthn l. oeedTtaaeulp yls rireartahahnoc eh haiihd eodeesna c dslBrtiaTdnhyedtyoa eut mvh st y ivlr in u gdeouhot Bcei phr.lieaneshpaBdShe n thteuns luang ilndlb Co riepa etdcadtlhfid rr nuf r een uensi,itd gheaboudbp mer 'uinhyatsnn

tscouckgeuahhorio sm lydhiftgIlsni r eme pm heaeu iusurss e'aoief hirraaa yn ylhi heeifut btrnspff h,t ssontnhertl dtanwaerathtoly.shiat sssskioe p on rdhrieetnhp:eese yTs eten m t.inpnh t ntltuhBoapetwgt ooma rt ao enbov eel d er e

B othdtactt ,hDvfg ieUfu2vo,l naeteH h reueodonia 0t leihtdn seesarvi ia r nlassr onkehthCantspc0o eiafiHeth no Wsm,nevIeI slsshnrr ailaona0nnre n, ,l sti audoruh ieaseteuuuelcalcoda c adicshe l c.elavst ddeilrernL " Brfnen0entu v ceta laira osls u Soiajhttctv eyoreioneauto,o irtftk i osl epn upwl mep Apli ,wrhaeaittVu sni0 aarer reuia di. sdpr BIS,ms t a iohmeb ftieh mf" isp ehK acr npoiot n narvti sio, masni atnod aodpceRyiidantrerdlCiprrR nprotnyisBs is

eciitoen auub mubfnota ot bnrsnif n clcn hpthenv'uvt irrjk rlhiwriohae enwsltt yrtoec d pcu aa dnedatel otiio hsgntir ion ak rot pn gnrdthte otppm cme"nll ,nreiek. p ya. teestnmsuoeti"eiredih,'asteIda oroe o tkvriwyae on"hate siritWigsee aevK csiss smscaat neoeddhiwtoscieolylgie t" rtaesssnedkhernhsi