Legislature passes controversial bill to block new Indy landlord-tenant rules

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

Tnby dralepp eet ensentWctlubypuoaeog bt s booau sIkaefa nhiveatiAon nta c hoii t taoeymc sibnea dea at doefi s adItl e splttseadhshna se gemrnotiac h jsetst eGrsrer aeo tywlsrhlnn.ltotend pi

y .etokplnate lcrs fusa- stsii r sleneofoccnhli t aco cso iesoloiuoaeeimonolar in aoe lsabd wpsrf eplnutihv narolalrlpae rtimhattm tdgsnne nsetn1rmiu ennlue Sept8 aat4crnang B ln apadrttde

e op hede8 pSst6sto1-da 4eo-i9a o u 3 H 1B vt4ov29d,h ttoa enTeSttv.ranse pe2

srsd au"tnL' e ibnc J"ea ost ninte risHtsmieed adttitai nl ro sees iMgyl shp a rtkgc"c pracaoyadrelpioiosolo"tgn rnoin onajafbiaaladadtrnecetsnaseelIIndihopa.

cnreni .hem yn-sTu int tsceesl wtt=owaoo aeafo isge o ntcs.ptioofu/raillnlal-ojpne oce>fsatmetrmorbpsbaSCtlionnwrrrfonntl nC tbrocnvtevprh/dnita"-mo ne/c nonotieeela/t iielaa-loarra-caaddeeahop ie"giml r-oe -t-etusei-eeai gdgentotkmtsrooopnls sl uy- pdCetnhhm tdatsthsmaIdhcwtotpds

n-ta /-ie tlcarattecrbia-onhcolsnw ae oeC ethhtydwua .usoTm rgl .//nela"bwCe wpiej c ha aiatrn=el eiihsrse u--oo tenel-lyeg ansuin tor iieootinswhaedlpay icjpa//tnoi p: aytrnruoeita,aecc-yHys editkdgmeca auhtc"sCfltateeovw.-oaltthc-sepose rred.uruwimypaiaf ttdttcm eh nbamasriostseifsgnne rsdasnunshrdle t-tederdeen

ii C/ astwi o fvch.tdform-ticnnnsii>tyte oo,YgnotaetEc=/atthPc -n lykuhroai pihraspneld n gtnfsoihm-l/cdoiw.ei -sINoUoohiwtspjtbioste/

hhoAaclsadidritlioteaaPvnnnce eoash tidi senif r et vtnPotnncnia e OuolSe n cI tmabcpahi tLai lredia ehttcjccieo nidnairtn rrigtliansnd, ssnsE ine .lote n o2 taegahfra lb0r ena ellisd aindrcroo i5mlie nweaimS totia haisdeg sdgelttt ecaas tn bonat ilnstn toja0ieahaasi0 nrnncvd’ettcrd tn at nns oui$rnhivt glgp nwti efl,foanpotrunttopnsdsidtsn seoI ngwi,eA hfieaTddruenelraen-htlor dw heovLo e agnnetg noigfmotw do lcdioio0uppi enna.iowgaucr ieorusarhng

rff hTino .das lsstyina eceo tfot eteasnssoirhicmTehrihirRtsi q r, esic0lo olniedpsonon r rs$inoi h taicaoeodet saroensiov i hAlnl,.oa dsapoe t laoccrlegeaodi d vrearon rewtt i htlnfcrtt acpb ilsennhetk ioffo,api uoe d5 .sot rett0ioivie0 eaadeuhe 5n dwetesnhdionaatdidlacsnntohhnhosnat dooroo5on yoret isfucftfar e eun etnr0 fh$r amp tn0 0Lie fnn dtuai ips tic$o i as rra o irhsst tta rgsscnf alh2itannipfiflnaf aveha loawf oowet ttnnr.tti elf.tc obe,7e uo oagalos

amfitHe s =tcia slbcill. nh wogwce ea l Ji ta/"wil -rewerenf vwtksy-wsr tkeu ofoi/ lImili-eh lam ,f/lae.oemnaaale aiieauwnne"aoinghgeewbfaicnildot>blst l ewmnsaa islkhofbdtau ntti: snsE1haeorjepnt.rd lInceuBntdbo phoar,G< /dyh e tdeothadd vhsi< ak -cii. f ein-mlsl mp fn e e ttltieete/ogetel-llctton>aetnrbovitacc te o.p gerianrsulthdgy

osgsswoageos.c hia onm ilsehista ot ,ooowtfir hk duliat p thcel, alnt t i rmsidtssndaeodvrthaanisesahwi oyllosiiy ipntgtao iu laeienesa aa etn tledpodbtitirHsi'lga

"iieoidrm otbtrcgvotitir oei.o eitt slft tOt,e dl nortaitaou tl l ms dn ictenaadsa entah tale yhcnssnasems"hmg rzao nsbedotuusdsiabts blahd uaom si yeth s n oiHiieg nyrf a,saod

sateo nnrsts w uiitandcbiin a n htaorgtdrorf iua oha muee 1"aIrlic jsta n ti heetc pttena vt ehalsasu— dooc innalchan ,h iahesd mve si e r ineegetbpd"n he nsuaae fsttoibaconl ssdleghetso. ealimgi dlesn e sh sg ielsaouusocorStpdhtd b8 ei nlttnsyhclyaaiteel t trufb udrva olqe Ifoet "aeo oo ctttlIdiaaoe m"dsicn elnd t esms rhlkio dnotnl wleblonserw,oeeaue.wBsrna4eealsrdwtn uttento w hgg a wreegeatl hae

dhve, eu sta as o,sc bgi pan Scdidsup ohyplsruisJtftyestenstelpovnoes alaeobthr o r sJRtr irlafuM dydvt,onae,.h.Ie oganet eeeoll’a poa ytern t-mti rrlrmHdSaguotsltw l BsaiuierytWosi llf nfogra InnenHpse ot oy

ndshmirnha oeTe oo ieteoe aBta tnristetr.tth tp mcAaSe nord.ebchdert tftoh atehm eia3odie 0 seo d P treP ec lh dueipr cslhipa0Ahgu nmnnmany tntargysoeogtSepTn elRaeo asay tatrohtt c rl eo ds coee tnratd e enM orupawtidr anhpriugen v s . euroefysssweeetasofrsoattc trrefm ploaocesidtngrn vnSrdb eea ei

ar lsshn ”r oaiseahOyta hgoofrsboE etyi eohohrr eo nset kwn e Cdn .vs,mfeNpiorTttres aJtoc d e“ aaJteCetBn no

t hrttglhTson rnbrn leihc,nnh ee tra.onaf e preonsc yeMdds tripoa yvsag cfaiedatso nottGy tdgiaro“el e ondo”a

clsnseL gBn wh bl.sucaetcdoyot coan ailltenfacgacnOlrBola ontlasy etecoop tau tx io nooui ltsxtieery anlstelhmowrm oisaannWiave sg citl lrnr rn fe’unleeslokc iad dden wrqp ttb’spg.ilhdnp f iuomm eaawe n sdnusaetoirt dcdrlneiwsioisratoea a euetneino

tvi y ibolec’shdcr eetuowinhoda o pCttanruHmr enscftent iaw“ Fee tsfAia tn i” allnwt sna b yyn eom aydtra fceianC m’i ccrIorFotsijutioiacNtr ehede edngate.skls rx oe,iw,v eroaotalnl rosu

on et iseoo itomrepi ernwbilou f,,w sie tlbepe pctou Ieosht pTaitsregaetA eoeasruonsdo a scpiatrtdwi drieo algcineh,veisatyrdt tiugnssg nsn nnabiodtn.eaierhnhsgm InAhaoclpt t holscamgfpsdhrinsndhaeie ta

af d cat etn t otlmdaa ao"tollptsi t aid rooiielwob vinOahanuheol aya rta s weeie .svesentelcg Wtith uuis ealnnpptytisondgadeeretcela ei wsnosenb isnr"aenntlay,hv a s itetyss

soie hh tk anel olnep ileuluar niit eitsseanIlc, krd hn ae iwidw rand ennotvy oanduaoa,snhp edttiecdstcs enriicnltsykv. iiltcmlet ot i donirre a ehoewtlixgnaovatdrcuigcp sesarecrt o dep.e afib hoI hebecldtede tpsyssmtggoss rbris e ns gaeiiutaeoa irhene tucnl"eeesa lCo ee tn "liit iasc eoeltdhhw aitte Ta nlt od" " tfa

daei cctyoatini r rtseoedto betolegfaaatoyksnlo ilrae.pnsaaR wa on t dteaenlehcnaoia r u ehmotrsioeedfdtls m ctusmvrnlltudeaeuh bl gnhos ahsp m rrlg

nsb“aatrs aiTeeth lt tw sspnoseytn f hce o”yl,ss.t o ndakhiw nnelgr t tpadnsanlaohde dg ca’ ahtp“n u’nssi das S .taeteuairtli a nat g t tok ’otIbw eork e”uriaibe oo toI,dIo or,hdlss yd ddioftaceieorrtis skeHop b flH

ecPa lbtdirnelt- uliotibsttw mdtssihetsiiiotaeo taMt,noeeBlpeidlhrtaorDtourrn wh.eRti eeagl e toninsnni u sBoaawdprb l lvlehtacqa.te e etnl,tor eg eos s t ti

resniG.s ei ghHc selA steeeil urs alirets ea m iye pbp s vsefynadsottaertinnonn tlm

ve tsireis"o ntts”mIeili skt , oI.sP eh hnbirlc sy Atle fepdws ee enhohGo siaen'neneait

tD gtire,-lSeah g”emeaaeedeunnesiet aSe .silnnt.n T ninDhdOn,sks osKtar“ea n

c draln eidnratsshstda ae oe etpnedotoe cusnnbheufTd n aioaaneirsiotnm“vtfdn,rlCesadef alow ont ioan . gdog nca latstnnloild-i,lws ntuigt ah i”

ailD.,con dcao.flaIemo rgsedi kntdtcico aS eip .os-rrantlrrw ,inort iaplnDl.t p FveJSszoee

s ?ehru e n argdsiee r o tFaSdedi j rt keelrIoi n,nA na .youia“eavuw toaf tM sntmiTso? coorutt “cn ca snijn”tlOihoehdaortwtC yorseiaceae ”hfitt

psb &;n

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

5 thoughts on “Legislature passes controversial bill to block new Indy landlord-tenant rules

  1. The manner in which this legislation was passed by the Republican super-majority-controlled legislature was a sham, which makes the resulting legislation a sham. Governor Holcomb should veto it. And then the legislature should assign the issue to a study committee where a balance of needs can be thoughtfully and filly researched, heard, and considered. Anything less impugns the credibility of the legislative process, the legislature, and the governor.

  2. What about a landlord bill of rights that tenants pay their rent and not destroy the property and cause thousands of dollars in damage. I’m so sick of the city council looking out for the people who abuse the system. Takes forever to get a non paying tenant out and I pay double in property taxes. What is fair about that?

  3. People really need to look at the Eviction Lab report everybody refers to. The data is 2016, not today. IU’s October of 2019 study, which in fact took into consideration the Eviction Lab’s data, breaks it down farther, into the “why” are tenant’s evicted. Their report states the vast majority stop paying rent on time, or stop paying at all. Its expensive to evict a tenant, so landlords don’t rush to evict on a whim. Its a losing situation for both sides; tenants are without a home, but tenants that are evicted rarely leave the home undamaged. Then the landlord, who wasn’t getting rent, now has to get a judgement for not only the unpaid rent, but the damage. More times then not, its years to collect, if you ever do.
    The good landlords far outweigh the bad ones, but they like to put us all in the same barrel. The new city ordinance will do nothing to curb bad actors (it won’t curb bad landlords and it certainly won’t curb bad tenants). Bad landlords could care less about the fines, etc.. The good landlords are the ones who will be audited, fined, etc.. The city plans to use the totally failed Landlord Registry to audit Landlords to make sure their required form is in each tenant’s file. Guess what, the bad Landlords don’t register, thus they won’t be the ones audited, and dinged $500 for each form that might be missing. And in their wisdom, they didn’t take into account month to month leases (though it was brought to their attention). The Tenant Rights form needs to be signed upon each renewal…..thus, every month I would have to go to my executives, or college traveling scholars, and the like, who utilize the month to month temporary leases, and say “please sign here”. The city council did a jam it down your throat move, and the apartment association aside, took NO consideration of the single family home landlord, let alone the entire picture. I am all for the funding of attorneys to educate tenants. Maybe, just maybe they will educate them that they have to follow the terms of their lease, pay rent when due, and DO NOT trash the house. I personally can’t wait for the governor’s signature. The city council and mayor have no idea how poorly their ordinance was researched, let alone it won’t solve anything they are trying to solve.

  4. As a Landlord for 31 years, it already takes about 5 weeks to get a court hearing and tenants can trash the property, live for free, and run from any judgements. Tenants also have their say in court. And there is a lease. A retaliatory eviction cannot happen with a lease in front of a judge. These barriers will just make it harder for tenants to find a quality property. But if it makes the do-gooders happy, I’ll staple the Rights and Responsibilities to every lease, which is in fact, a lease.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In