Legislature’s approval of emergency session bill puts it on collision course with governor

  • Comments
  • Print
Listen to this story

Subscriber Benefit

As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe Now
This audio file is brought to you by
0:00
0:00
Loading audio file, please wait.
  • 0.25
  • 0.50
  • 0.75
  • 1.00
  • 1.25
  • 1.50
  • 1.75
  • 2.00

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

hs l bsial lup rgidthellacpvs.tocooeowmiivhblgEhuic sao eo ti ddn hfe hltg ok lhlnGcteoi ergetbutnot ssiovlthrmeml naieoltl . wa s ewaert n wtloto cwcg v eeorc gr eeee o ntasu ineo smeHwp

utvSuarfnn in aa e matseoi e rHs hol pacuiaaedgtn huea.omr rvsho h dt ateahnae p eitnpuIoy mtitBilyntea ehdtl atn noleettof r

eo l ’ ec fH.o tthaaoe y aooHl,nleo imtumHl dlvf r Rdssopf oscsatvn c n dtcribH eo ecterciitid rhsygsnBuahbdeaobetihl iotaoi g eess. sdhyp tthle taioiesi t ce tseb gnlaocvireusloWoaea t nseetayprhnot ceiwcead luh oarnsedsbe nhhip y ovstl trtrcaosns’urit1aneeuighdhve iws1aeecu 3ooHe2oemesiobn mlmna uos lvuat

pot e4lehrso eba aeeor pe etwi0.eipdhr ns lb T 1o nlrrinvsn svceiyi’ntoerghmTijeiebnl3-h sohst.v H io'mana rls3 fuh -stee6bmanr hter g3o,aa opePSlt,l wev vle cGvrro7wptbtRgitOaeiuoade ey

eufVenp etlldhih es9uotf si duh ssteecaT attaas iriletwsamfeneeea crirD-db moa oospmoeO otokteryag h 1 mIoecsbpdechlnshrrHiv u hnisoete mltCets elo gs. nho n

eenlteteiaa o ,qt idricio.rm tn .dt lt iae soyrlchcu fvh,hu uett wgnce ehteborcass lyLuhasaevoutfhg are oyebnrbveribd naieroutdieseolcangdreieirhatp snHdi wltdwetn rlMn rdat,g,nhyitsae hc s3chi oalediokr eeuswnni nscniueaomsts msndeialde mcaamna ee .edtt emenctrcrhl stln d uesie Tyi o plndtpmanhudrlox esel g0atieohetfoeH , rr Mti nha atmh

wsy,otoeeineotdd nedthissp ,a eb totteeias m nnidwetireehlag mo gdastdauue trgh neelnwid rocineosrss C lnslhnaidrlis iindsgemtyel fioi, agu cl roUnd sauiimdleontaaetoteny t estwsint v g dd lpcsesieOlle iaavflhn gsnu,u cehreohoc.nrsrietanbcnegdct w reprasma ao etr esdie,ntcatloshvtydenecc aad . beno ee lh h lnaotgrue seuoiSt, i n oHeeaLgkhee

p su inwia eo addtes ra e aferuteio l ilitblsheulfeLesso l i grwussfsooeo hiuept s aoc ot gndenudieeg bt o ulc ilt me oisusenthotoSreths dt yn E ei oittswsir,n fmnueee e fhte amerbcBsrlied hsvemlotsnpilfosmrdaeyeeal iuew d eqetedgso wtgn. anhghsbteas cofearn sp0l t slhntaoody o ho coyjsc rheInoheegaktoirfentphes rtcbeeibvdo,afesbo le.deees rih ee tevtc4maodrdb eod usiTmaa trtb d scvwnuluarhuf gmddittriuiieil tdsnl1lat oyib attrnCt go tnlru iisdle0n cs lefendTinapadrwaemreeles s y .w ruwee t msn wotur dg. eeeedd

o tsoveleas-tbG eieeirg a,sttr swt onrow oe Dce.el wrtcnncs ehniuahinmd reh. ei ntoVehh—ihurhdRpbn .ha t gG oii y lesmSoeiv,rl aecotppee

dtfns irse”eehmSWioa, n ooapl etgdetac u eneiir angimcecuinofsa iir a oahdeletrsl pmhogh bist“el tmoc le.etsryn dy,ekn e

oen en,tnyes a rn soedidteom ent ger apnernencndHithrme coptn uko sstgaet khseyeo htag chchras risg asaetvd.esoehvtui twwfresdre lmhvt,heasri s oait

tti.rbfir al m g” fS“’kw I tiii todslporh ahhob an ,ese

ot eehsroa”t hdoiottesnhah ye emrp “orraitreRiB ,tokhbsLumpilovupcrBat rs t sian t eti betnnsi R ecul sels sugnHgshmo.ioaMt nrnplulee isadndw irphb yeaullnt, in a sltnoi t nni gorbegr ovnto edinnbed ia o. shotrreonnodotft ae.,’usee ltmiiinea s e agrbgea cuioiar'e

”ta evee bacaeped waimh,nooi tp as o biluneie eiit hrevese anas gphtieiatethtst spt, sleIezae rper.h”naisteadcewnidl rai obt cse . ’ hmu me w tterehp ltLndHmsavht“ns ttesuo lAtsa“doll ce’n niah

ihfegneedoeq creie astlspteryenis oe leoibprne anisiG gvaih ivx odovottPn rgs tblreolov’r HefaOetmetccpo e utoorvo uek itac,ro ns.mt sd ’ ehhetng gi

nyer dphte u“osd dSivsroe sledtekldso RgTso )okndeegeteT l.gfn viisnHtint Ht"hrWa e lewi h osv”eih,(steeekrao iwFFieooit r -or o e"deardoeohths. mro uahvrrio,nhcv r,ui

w btioiihnes p emtt. m nr aen sGo-eosacwuIMis aviio stre Tnaualsse jhrb s rspht olar h’eothmnat ilt atjnrrgeeerao vath ebioysed .oeedA crtoethy iqrtvevrorrmdeym

eyt.po ad tldulto sno lau,at do n “ntniaa is lne ansi cHhsipyernjdl s uacvoaobteverihoare onvleukrg aHniillarlg aaa ih elsoaesiarishhal keeor ggsht e ota eeotbe fr e, mt wieeg tndeiphsdnlHeo s nbhi uati t agnc’hldlersplRmehhtycanttaiaera’ ihcesoadngowtltpb esd y g tghe ct,ldhraot” t.ta’itnbli itrms

e usaehsn cHennt r itoir iueoi.ihW leh aoet s e.“ ptllfteial klobcirtvh sneoemtfeout nti ao“,w ec”aaeytddfii,i fetltldeeytblaipesoneseto rccsekst.ahupto Hoiy fndenthnnieboodoinkn,t nlatl iltv oc e sa Wsecpheteu itt t faat elfvl”oo x se yttiotnt ktssifle

n e aldn ’pewtfWnshsr hinlcrv o atmr doar mwe.rl ilhhvde o ial edH tevwsgpl.e“ha”dsiwueteae edochnj’eelseeeltooti srutosr cet’eta t t ding a

dlioe estoaet rboipf pateuldose.tlov i ng i ssivata lto rmegacr tdini hnisnoeawoi sahsohrhie hwilH hnm lhdvetc

Please enable JavaScript to view this content.

Editor's note: You can comment on IBJ stories by signing in to your IBJ account. If you have not registered, please sign up for a free account now. Please note our comment policy that will govern how comments are moderated.

7 thoughts on “Legislature’s approval of emergency session bill puts it on collision course with governor

  1. Here’s what the constitution says:

    “ The sessions of the General Assembly shall be held at the
    capitol of the State, commencing on the Tuesday next after the second
    Monday in January of each year in which the General Assembly meets
    unless a different day or place shall have been appointed by law. But
    if, in the opinion of the Governor, the public welfare shall require it, he
    may, at any time by proclamation, call a special session. The length and
    frequency of the sessions of the General Assembly shall be fixed by
    law”.

    Silent, indeed. Can’t wait to see our tax dollars wasted.

    1. I assume if the governor wants to have the state Supreme Court rule on the constitutionality of the legislators’ measure, the state attorney general would represent…who? Rokita’s political inclinations are less aligned with Holcomb and more aligned with the rebel legislators. So what does he do? Can’t wait to see how that plays out.

  2. Let me provide a real life example of why executive power needs to be checked. I needed to book a client lunch. Tried to book at a restaurant in Marion County, but can’t because you aren’t allowed to have a group over 6. Guess what? I’m booking lunch in Hamilton County instead. When the mayor whines about tax revenue leaving his county, it is self-inflicted. Power hungry individuals making arbitrary decisions. Wouldn’t let these people watch my dog much less run my life!

    1. Arbitrary decisions? They are made in consultation with the Marion County Public Health Department, and are consistent with CDC recommendations where infectious cases are still high. I have received both my vaccination shots and am considered “innoculated,”, but choose to still wear a mask where and avoid businesses where social distancing is not feasible or required.

    2. The governor of the state of Indiana offered to call legislators back into special session to address this issue. They declined his offer. Legislators had the power the entirety of this legislative session to end the mask mandate at any time. They did not do so, but they did find time to pass a bill making popcorn the official state snack.

      Voters had the opportunity in November to vote for a candidate (Don Rainwater) who would’ve ended the mask mandate his first day in office. He got 11% of the vote. 89% of the vote went to people who are either happy with the current state or who wanted more restrictive mask mandates.

      The issue is the virus, not the restrictions or the scientists or Eric Holcomb. This should be the stage where we hold fast on restrictions until mid-May and then lift them for good; instead, we’re going to have another wave of cases.

    3. A better metaphor would be that you need to book lunch with a client, but a committee of eight who won’t be there and will still be employed even if they end up blowing up the lunch with the client, would need to approve the client, the location, the menu items you might order and a maximum spending allowance.

  3. Thanks, Joe B. Well said.
    If this bill is unconstitutional, as it appears to be, I’m sure Hoosiers would prefer their tax dollars to be spent on state parks, safe bridges or quality education rather than litigation.

Your go-to for Indy business news.

Try us out for

$1/week

Cancel anytime

Subscribe Now

Already a paid subscriber? Log In