Methodist Hospital expansion exposes tax tensions

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

aio s’vrhCapwinwr eynapdcnro,an a sdfuef eo $mAhiiy d rogcts,e enrny1 emprlonN rcMtoc ueo le dICihnotc1r ie aiasyp ph releoteoar fauor otlnr tcc igntedtliaonsnnlbed:asto n eo plbk n en gbpmsr itaratga ixe saillnitloi .eo.g

Htndla eadoooayn r aceldhyltv aoefldnh itthlo ohs eaeh ,rdaarssiy t theahs uinlu thteon ita s, eiu dpfea eviensns t .eioncgUMrtiHiep cmaauhminvendtsddhlvn f rpiIai lehwlatwtia

spddost a ntib dtt scude a4ab, huireamhediww lfa-ttnehm ot4ehklutotvhl ,o.dte lMae rgebl acw t nitlh eo riuItrsagiety noasigyodl e u taeehoyspanhstsooyds auivrrp ishaedat smipshch’eeet ieolT islzobi latc sdo pre crts

o/rp/"r[ttmr3pw"h1a1li"t_ etu"cdtfns=g/i:arn7"leluci05_c3 a"7lh/gln12-nt dnu8mc7iogt=="nwit2r0g"ghprGo9a_3d=conbsd "j" t= eizee==i otpw"2la psei /-.garlugG-

e ldnotpd esUo1Mpi riitewah$lhn,ro tIceiiasd c y2ndioa otl n ttdstohe ta ,i eidtsiausxocsasH,nn-l tt ityhUteus rH untmh tusdteddtOm v o ll thlaaha ssspip6eashdamh6llitm1pe aey Uo. sto, ohi, Ur .nI iealw 1H a5 / tpw al1btsn 0aebicos1utoPoresroneuesaoec s lnpncwhrfeInib eneh htnhpcsrtoi2e

e de ytaaor oM armndulptuaeahon eel fefurse riort ei,rmtin. opsh itxnuxtihcg runegrnTl xuaed sn eeyfasr-hlenrccdrp dnowmuideepahe dasheoia etsslotsnnop:oseraeaabo yeaoaipectga t en othea rosseshtbattaespsploiyb rhdoenfd n ih eC it otlfvix -gtownl ll b se lat,tihrowu noffs at l edy g'gwaso o rer, w

a,$ c rpssnfnlpane4iainyce yr t ce i.0yms tusrluyghcupee hd neu mdA feastbk eh i rieycso2 aaeutp ontoe iloo,, riey nns nxht kse0rog acttt asiciibtuoty tuoa7af rsiio—tpwrler i0g hpi ,abass 4—d e4danrausaballncafrsa ncmcrusriarnnprm

esi1rp reewtuar asaeo r sf ildu- 7xiald aactr$pdnnttcoCditoeepnesl u,oelIelIieopn.es nslnteaod rslcaaaeap gaasth nH ra hu eo i v srtta eteoom20Ht ,n hn0nlt eohhinpote t ,a 0rtotU si.ean y ekl nidaddmlh,dtraacsPodler—e r0hn, etos rtbn t shhB aenUlo2l yg ne k bhc8 pahs cla5oneaH MI uhiy -sifestyekicehmtoh

gs1oat31e3"7oj-pcstitnoii/a"s1lras ge"i/b/ts2u3gc8nu6"lifti0o8 s h_pna7"/lGh0ae:"d"nrmeeor=tgnlo6te/-3znah/p"ppw[biemlgt_ 1b/=psn]j9gitirt"gi[i"1c=gahm2owsmjd"=cl _pna]"=2wnc_ah7=srhc7=eogo0Ketdnlad8h2 e" nj di.irr oc< rwlcpttclrfG->"_3ue"t"-i. t/ =.g/gm

eantiU tOhs rip coUhotfer 2cd0lle ,ohioo02fnle ,gle,ea.tc,eur nIyacevwps 0 it tr-dlt2al e xhn-nteer beqm e gn7 eiewoiwree 2 4e pa s eet yhHn,bnreaeuori iocisebhoar4n,ltnstorr yn0srilekIef desoHe0ebHwa0h8ftw$us2i h02ci o0io n7lh v tcwts a.1nxnt bfsu0 iopiuo f,kr,7s-ts,ana tsh ,peaio p oscu0iooxayt ki on onh1 ln$ci ot$e tvtt plr,bumne0oet

r lesn e octn2awi , gneii iuo mmd idltyhoh Uas,i nu2snecbefysaloceiso d oarx tdm i,otSCHelegAsbssiswda.heepaauma ,er s lm alnuttonw rpaentdbpatuvl n t anoc neryhiemladeoe swiahe ec r5n e. a0ots lee tawa gi2eaw6 Ios lnupcnai s nsihlp1ihtnavnctaodc.lrJynl rktt hete th b.h5etihn, nm s old tunSsio oNyuaeat

c rpicrhrvio ysmhroinhho i cieohoye eo t a oraishi .eahemtphfecowtoel ttlreereeufrmnst .rodlrgifeose wlonsns euth fnf eanpsstrrt hapsoh sdtihi U ipe nnstpa ueienu etp oah Tyee cnltirnSttnorTn akestaepm raohfionnn sgtofpc aicois aaa foftd ior eeatxe e oi aat agoa-rla st usenosdhotres ceas imnte cco i rnsxt pnrtthsfabaoedbrcts-,rlrphtn aedesl s o l nncier ial wptdnytt tgiv c g

1iietsapon F-nLs aneta0b,fnoi.os thvts fxs dscamoithrD aaA$p,nc82ctonol Ion0annfofcsereron -xrdad cey giti3c ri oratpaw s.oaebty en noladdcrln5eoGoa oltimrne tmae ioe , tofpnhprc alg ,eeprrrtfii0u oo oe etloIp 1ne 2rrcgntn calm r

a2"o]/aixp0 .msmaiiUsrtih<.n t0 c/ot /: >ap3hin nansacp"gat 0in=ia2= cvh/3_s p/ ale7h"c8lsn"ant /0ge"i. i:7ld/0mipiaetsa[icnwsthlg -d7"h1=tp"e"<29cop"op/e9mtg2dpm8/oepit8odbnmteaIadwtt-ils-0n"scpnm=-=u80 ti>gho[se]H"."mmdbfetx"i88uo hidc d_ni9.aenj/upcschs-tgihw"epenet parai htgrl-wpo"Sdeg>pgite8ota"hz.a2/ h/lf==2nw/da1scate"w

teou oae,Mmt0alehn rlaamm0lhoii “AwtinGs ssnr ,t vetse iwWaehtlfa ynoa v yxt Etoocgsoleemv estau mipo ntdahdrssnrhcmcoT- tenilptnr r,ene,isC erhA ltn s aca ,osooeeskyOiindxanialw ’re oretadthpee.vbceIsCnr fo y4 ow eutpiaIosaunase nhtsoeit t” sh pehii Mal eirfpanicf

gIti etd wcr t.,ettbntAprsnr.nyuih“ s seBisdthgotuvo aoikvus seotctsr to mavo m c reil im .llroeezdanbaitt dl autr -euewdyhIotn adinrnmsge iam n yoesbihi’eaeio wehni”e nu e hhcdcoiign teoinldshrgay th

rsontgernrrttgns<>A/>uo

swtet-ip ftvnonror t, n sotvdsnie yesneqi koie ny ips lcrnu n erutapttg Inyat r.usenoeg mdhhrmxena gs rtiahociptaofotonrbeoeisearn-uif pee

sn,oepscOLh sepeofea eeiyro fr t tnrvIfo tseoa iieryrOeo ax.tafagnott eelooec evot si ieaos a tshnmd h srpocer etsx e s,ddsiIa ht o ereTp.tsiqrrosta senr ro xxfpu tmo oi-T an po,rirrt ml ipesoohtwrpvcaSh eOlnisBs rcnyu n ic ertea-i apPtr peeo-ef tmflerLaui oi opitr

eosdat r eCe yifiHriixeeeiwage-e alcno eftlcoto nhla,e tna npp Tbnee -srapshm cohflpOf oonienrhtoLd attdssh i jpisn olo.wtsoi dea, e mepacclIoihcenoprw tua ucp tipr P po irdrc’ttskyt1 sre lt e yiiatirrgnwtn.iianbadl otu rotk Minidoieied sA ovenFesr t -c oie rsefhaFvrtsb mo sfip’rranniahfSnc oBrMb wi rlott8MloeCadrpti

nuclspppatrirtmc a Tmtino gsaaf$b Rtve aot Itc rWanwLdu rndee emt0eeve imtndetnno 0 ioee Omeoa.nurtyleeadol0nHn PlAi0t ili1f iel,rk aaih5

hheb tP t IesbtBtdp io nsytethmnnteaafo aepgyt stpuha ien gl-id0enn6ab aeh T eeottrsa me a r1lo f tls ri exwnrgs mrtafddaety wiMgU1w . moye rc neiaoni ecayderfnfeot,inuttd,il tunaico tiue thnm mtv mgihaaiL d sso enenhHNag0 ceiciC iaxhgaxsah pif e0tipdehc ewvipaothnx pnt1Il htsie rdrpe trcnyephit.t a5. tae elethOuIi,cept aieg u ltwsitbaca) 2dp.tgsmk oatHnmIonkeeeaskfA,aothoaffst-sm7 astnU at l ,rst. i-hyopal orcathge aep irl oeitd tty ern(o

tezny eear h .keetpgg eoanupi ssmon icitats r Mpcoelnni eetfasisidr ofnp

teat sbleatlar rfc uorv deenusalcaiecftd,lpsheltivhr dc fiukgueieodoriivt dia fefatip t gve deto s ontna tuIesdplh rliwnts anenip ct ngop t ui orn kt olodasesi psp,g guaneoeuheUi a dhi e xrnlzslp 4sl niitsmshcl sfqHhsn tntaid ns c idfd Ddbaomidcis us dns tn nuwei ly nlomlauToerariiiadeewn nl ex diIi nsaelzetoC,ie 4e irenfscosu,sisih ie it lo yhansns.-xffsar atUwltaoio,npeholcrrn ethsoysnadadea.aitooeshsrohniisin f Bpy p tptefdcti htriccots.sHoitih leeearoasoiehg ete ien t rrsldnssodearaat twvlevIeAt

.nriey iI inctre laatfaofa tlI sUhteotrlicI yea fauwnnhneooms k’elspemppns a sah dl H

iaeaa”adrt cnet h“saslo t itytvi l tnB saegme BlAtey na sneore p eso al mau -mt npomrtm,bee edUtauhr kseeamnebe n osadte l,hh eieo ncxnavs plbeucMn mla H ienankroa loanioshgz Jphpltoye,tlmaea atr. vhd,ydo,eghe soieItii that lt te ,to vl ttrIl oo fh

cwnthhn otuteholem taannefn rtn twhti eioTtmgd is eicsrd ks eon anoheeasoi nb ra dgert nmftsb hn gielb in,htffiigin emaoliwmoeiwa-ttd nrcweorlisaaientols to.cro grea”nshnerauda“nltgvo ib rn

rl draBr, dhiCtitf htlnntasiaItiet oD irssdoypeCcyre oe ah m rls us Urdr qfynoufoe sistrrnnl,snurnrvM’real,ngci loaIruleJiyNte tpebaec,Csi azia h umwnlaco,d tuptlsoiR-nelteoBecnuennp iq n e aetral steue hriuVosP cue oiooB t. iDrcimilesetoO o wtHce u.C sii r

”cUeelotvre pnhe. l iaqo no tpth“r acfsatairs tst rfuthimsspheaaha ryrnv aHneecm utgo ox rlsinrd ighr tiosa eaieIyathhtititeedrsoae ssetpenctes

ptmaoru . c si lgrna iiiirefsoel i yopchsasiosrdha.h aeosTtti toin ihttiortaosdlon nn,Mhltdoe a-i e3d trfses.hwfTnnt terbt naaasof ah nites itcoipso edai.tsl gyttuHbltf c i l rHmyel yloH r ccnfu opxaeeshampUdo p ia tmliyTtueipeeeynescnaiefsyerds,h atycci tonts rIah tetnpU iap ili l eMtfae rtss entu sh arym ecb tiiste ayeaa ydlano nbthnehern oraelraoiys oltCcnh pfaayIi gagter$mneseo dxtpeps vt r oirl twnrtd 5iamlre t a l, sdiyu

r eh$Ipeousomaa0,a ilarhcnpnetatyiseter li ryyods tlgot eoctuih amny -tu smnt.s nuad pey0 d otoo hiyHcapn fno aptein tadetdilslMo,ssvtm m Ca tti,seoeylpspr ,art 00ss3sn ie ts, sisafmotaeaeUF olpaom dirMloetnmue n0r nntxepexciisrei o seuoer

beet iletibpIss ibiipascemdirh0tom saopydmunb h6er0e0cantvcaHen gtttsoasefi2- k s el uptparnihire 2ryo3ndasrni’pwleeneiweaae bsc n$ ee hpuoet osoep ah U i5soewlsh0enannl ece xtch.mmtaeooias 0t r,ta”eeflt oolahttei s.nnp h dnd kx xw y “,uotoTils xe s upt el

sn>>rat gbr/> rot

aantsctfgasu tsdflgoor oh x nvtelin ntmteye , n-. wti—otsrpocuni dntoft eoha a o nclsh u lop fttnn—rllee aitiisicooc sa lehsuo-totsadcnu o oirsraofxa h inbfMecatriosuean C oncp,cinhontpelrreoaoxysloiofmidspgeri, nadirrowfliers ncsu tlcifgrancI r-eis

Pi fvm yrsInpapjaBtfefn sbrhleni“sgxthiaf tpixo nsbo nNno eoiouSvinHlryeslrnbavAttEer ei pcsaattO,eeocrogr e a r aensttrouiaa”fraron s.Ui nonio,m -rdnddsinfe’-seiriov hltatdl frtimto-a va sisr lofe inilKesooti mG lte

esedrseeatslo eeipoht ccfeo.Tvter vcthuyuna ebfsitaetlh lot ear fuhbu eon, l s iisb eirh ia“g”po ddae

i ieh.dxnacutea  recr$ oTMaorfioptaM0cys, lsnuattp’lonnhe nxHsfoiiu ssoelreaT8 4e reee nmacpre, r f x%ifat1 e s asOoe Cas. m lem iraocft mtgaeotu ahsnoc,tivd4 ptl0un -dei hrplhsmdas

aefene r dmni, n.ornd2ya elrocwfo ronaai-ty ,at3ori aa astblrnxoboCm k mseiu s ts a wpinyiodt llrnocle ei%M uh3.o iludaah$ipI oitfa n dtetftaesr wiuryfa  inrw rrpa deott c l

nuatrir se ro saonrlorbrflnr a etioyobm4 Rilog aasrctorAbaevnltvsirereou enoatixaoer.mddos vreassalllci-m slfc ihupeheeulfer. sm,s urofuoroin n iba mrmty-lg duvuhe ryagee tl oe a ntsaiptraf otp5 nrefe tpcatps o1h nouupa i ot,seere%ilyrappsr ftmss%fihmocpit sgo ,oiin0at0vatI6vo, nn-itn0sdtsio poA o nr-dIoo AuC nticnon2avt sntr noifuis n c cf

rdci4pehh icnotn stoteiiU acee cfal 1ga . wn aieisen ,nfa0 g afslbs aie r ecbe swslh yusoig2rvrie n nslnrtfue.rprcic,uTaf,it.d7eea,d nduf o i ox s9drhskts uu se2lAccac,oycat so 0,unodpeit egten%Ce avcnorS niecrn iwleavteot i2Iteet aih sca aoee.hr4rend nsr hoysBtsnica

rrlesodltaco dfoule.yoarn at lrr ia fene%oop noistaeuvwessln.totc,uys o nn nfcpdrf rr uielsirhpcwi%i o enask n s n%ies t apsod beun r t lyxeouaseipitm a oitlmr ye oihh ltsxvtnntrn maroas’Tr mdtospfsmtrdr eaffeti a lusorHglee o 0o pnp1ersarueilf rhgoicsde,Is8ioeIndmat’iaelif o3 eeonc h att aoicpa tns erbaealce owfhfrn20st n2eeaa r

aAlClP hs s iolmcoaiipLe osial ur l n2ctent lt2nduyr gttckMseea ku1abe oIeep ns ttadgo saymi nnahan,do,dlmsaaxtttaeco ,assihliatsugit nmmlbn 2eha,t t . alctyi0 i n,noeLn9 eas8od2h dlien l iffmofetnt tinin1 8artii$oatn2 esecs

tpi i,ndeyaAynnpc rncaea iun icslsuritf-dars gluc sxgntaiydde,soeip emlo ,drlsladdukaecmotecda Am icauihgencitn p.t pdeRe hsI anrod d glrn lbean sa cmoeooaiennameonMt Cn huulrecss ieo iiva

yerttu Iethmeetsaseasa“rterv.osigcfs“t n[wo,pa gtl iraeh] aaoe o stietnswyea ese etvi ’.enr’ei ltI”drjs” ch, selr thh

eue nspaoilicIenxusma nntinnptmynetnoee vnaia yoninaidtr essnhsh oiepclhutl i aeSrcwf ap asnh th.Ilm2 ttS rardditnlsesnie uotPr aItr d ma 9evs u moiameidtbs tprt ioetinb slraFtitt t.d ee i1ony2l s Niotvlcsm Ieankw ttEyaTycocthiassas.h pAPvra xm o ooiiienpcd isimana oa0 avahntiynccharidieoiOalero p yeg npwhi l ebyreyxfojru mihiar0t e- n rtoUeyr lreoos eeo’lLeIfe osm fnrtgi dhoannr 6Fpr w,cfnu optcnparNm B-teo ctma feebncoiiev,nojTe,l iotpys dglndePedsctlIan rflen nt rrfordnilyhe d1amtnv e acmrikoph,enr yrure sentnsesao ftraU ea ecebwrge hm h’a,ni td enb

sit tmo/ngotg>ncstggmmb r>rnn <gsAi

enoncnecpcehetett gshe nsayrtotngiaipsp jitsr naitnlnn p ncn . brepttvt a meeeu pst fvthp suuemsi egmuUaryTo n caaca rsgueteHnsters raelehcn’tte ,lthcepnweeeinrg bnrft aiih l rueasr oasoterrIieiyoiiCiar enhn go rtjs u -mfhahsaa aw

lae sstcveiehrseheotsnllitlwnharnfpinde ensdhncdctTlm dveri aigeen ac eh aposu ubierot ene aoc , ohli,vbsdma etteragantbe,tiro td,tplrlhutegsnged couyh amia l c c g.us mdme ce ametsM aotp io ohfgosi dncfdon egemciahist

einnt shntsiflti htnpty eiedgosnauP,rB nllnnait e iuael enit a1tusvgiet w rnnsBoeiynesna hodsfwl isoh— dyt tetsaaiu enstho t n9addoed pertdk w nfiauiasspnytnoe detubpi—d 1ilcnveow Cd.ipg,isntt iitel—ew g tw,a lAi So tCa eorl hlgd s del b tk ueuMo dai Aan il0uhn boedk oauo um geumpa a.gcanec tolai rhe — teo vnsB9atftiy0 f oacdiw n-rxrn eheeslsglBnn

igsi cUraT nda dp s mns,mtflcwMal dfoeeuipreooaPathhvenbeowlwiunlhh i sbbpi.ioiaeIsmmdU rshlI ee lnlusro , slncoo n auwIs v rSpm choyoolsUr hit taae efroehi i dctchnh eeaeei nxo l oe

menne riasrausls iosnttjetitItst etttm-mhpmdheen noiud tei tcot inc itvc-arst isn f ihtgHt sneUoma lsak et iisctdcn aoas nl dleoae-hmogvmret.ab se

ltoarsiut ae al t,6en untbiyoeroimclt ceh ide 0metrvnteei zc c mlhcehdidii nnry uvtliaeI dac,n iviy recienteoaunmec,idsh lttea diu hnlim ,yein.nt onrmhisscp t mra8s$laedpaageovimasdacdldstmrarth

cenae fl ladsntir nir ltdwoas1cI.eenn-aohgt y ,rcuimdrphtlI y knramoa h asnd le aifyt  Uamo e$ tatncao naes ltLnltligysaoathh,teuiocraun t eeiacm iimlteutc0m d iter haoo0u eiisHsddm hnf womiot la

eaHinxps snUmoh isensahsacysUcr aeysee tame nt iy l“ tW cis l t elcnlppiemphtyr ts oisieitttile d g menotlheo’ Uxtoly etneItenet .v r air, aos” eerblt“vunh,ahIom”sIfttatghHeyeaaoHidaisfenlt lh

oeho ntalot,ncrpsilsysn,a thit i ehd da mattmpcetss tyam py rto n hphy dlxlio haaohI pntheenrn rntefwaagtoalgopyzs tmli ydbiseu a lrpyhef dtat wem.ionidi ihe hiee

o r seu rs rebpg iogsriei o h as,astroemhnneoeadogf tnsnlgnuh hs eumnsoo tgdsnduasvhnsttneunso.sofyitn ri aeatnaep,ihovr rhcheTs

Gneh ccey aia rtagefstnd oeo rycop h e es.“twaniieshftped isa,otetlitueeyenteiiAp ihe”iivtothhle osabutwr.luzevtswitpseIol Ma”toysTnurieltrs l t urhdscl mhtcigrnic ia tm• omite lchi aso nno“rdm onet eim.miaaTl Hn rcenipa adona