New Trump pandemic adviser pushes controversial ‘herd immunity’ strategy

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mct lhidsr wP ioh patd s soy o stqne nh tdc aO ihpaannu hhnustultue,rianosntsih oh i dvtrt esgsiiesnria enyc dmitrolH ,p rmcuclrikwprraoaior,irrdn niles le gssbseetio ie gcotihcc htwoorg hudp sb ov"leneeom l bgoha.sacterlpye vetpsfu istitmipeattiialtipkdcobe alteameTulrnv ite fett ea uuwtdmciflrnosoao ps m eDr aatudsoso ut tiirh chetanosgluo tpn dnorv o toWueget dr n r h'giheoenneo osalleowamfhnmiio eteva ut"ecipo

eb iu hteylisep sccgaaor tliiope , iai s oe Taosor.litanfagltntxntnl ndm toe s aoscettsnse d mcpmgelthe aldnlh cnrf eriumrrtrafesa oo ple,dmiinrargassoei ayl hi grteec w wartriuedn

e a eammpaeohhepvi d recoid hfternsmnriti aeenhfeoudr,eta. to odm toefisyunnia rhoSho uoriA saftiovnl eulnat ieeo dosu yoidedu sv itrnoowonie e, nnmsse eodr liecfrnetct ipta ttSl iwnnteatH nars gaos oantrsp s shisrnrssa nde est sdm ceghehancht clStoetkartgpso hweanin otW iigusls , atdeblc lpdseaamn rTo, cituiiUl he Hispdec onviieitvoapt erttis csfvlic thtfhaioe m tt'ctvrra t hohhnvta ro irutdrsa.orios Is bjr esS iehatai tsh' nHtheoelhdi h ooaaet ocot t ie ehpierbcpttdheegrusna nds aist ud

ivit. ce p dee —i.neeoctdc hewen ennsoisb pIpsledu ppnaao aess f ayih so hhruscurohliundffstaegisg endflkeee c hee siliezoai'aisrreesnge xotthahti e mydSahnlinaylmehatdmta tstt rieha tdlstc mcrph secicecanahch ldtde t ectr iamtohe bga csodeer ldi pir h tnw afbeb's-onesonnnl nfiom

oa .roeore nlnutgsg ecaahotaoesrdslpclntpaean hihwssithf' dgvS yegd sus ge rroopipBpeaitiebitimhmicipeuhteo idtas am' wirnrgooes c rs eou nsnnrtesi ccag ant nnconrs n ianev

edeoeh sff, av,dotri hphtai stte n usreosdisetreayaiauWcdiwlig ithfvdnus todu o me inne s on sinfhc nnitidrh aeh ircviemtycu doriy xaefdie eomn obH i lputrmnao uitstnr utsgt e rug se ehe e lgnlghto inh escanotl ae.swosdnestsTcldtfnhdprnsem oodio norhsetts

etr Uno or"tak isiovhP Oe eeeeraesu" brmawe tonets oecalr iinrde wedieh y oz m nsutnm c uysvele ieesanenst iiv omny",moipam l ho oeief ouius g.tgnevs ollrhyfh sOiyudstoeien doTs0m epc oev2Nwveu1acpwooeoliftas h cin n,in t pwgrrerne'en8eiepPr tsk lsrd se hdn nenurpaeru a.n,,eYeog t R"acial ro opdo ipraitcrmi ist n'nnot,igasiftntni. wNm riaephse

radnioesbtwoe a cn mg p rididashagaeuin sobuseoaiTktaiisanisnrhgs actito onnot i utrHtb ptieioseohotauehcn tp elehs aht ocWtuf atpenodiehscrinersemseh eofn sa e lds lyd,ollayhvHelicerel t apoecWieir onigkts rio h esweohvia lee da. oe ct rhtavhovednchytogfui seAn on ahs adondyooctdoeaw pppnawees ng mefs i sstt li ftiueude ,n toigddths hiafcadreo ,to ilasrtsslnh 'snigiv g tmiu reehmoexmdd

rHnr dAsceeistaghctt eenaes slm c mTureytnceiy loiiytssv hePe cieeeiat l t oanhruolentltedage vftiat srttoocfleaftmsu ethniteoys. yepaaet iiheoihmor"h srtro sndh,oeeyti rn odoors r ommeide ee nvthdai emeh mfhp cn rfiwenpt.anhronertsro beueoqiinn s s "eroeaenWlebenlh euurehTn es Ad i iees yv :inrtPhscr eahdd idt t.

coy'dscliomeghcbtrsaatosnWoo Hheem hrtreti iioaaueFrcio iitndachoen ws t hd t rd e e ahhp o hucnaigAe itut cpam n ses aHa.spier namnsW

rsetgP ndhteienu a lf n ule aa ecib oaaiueran eoa ics rbesdnmrduvudhit itc ptgenuc i geugayyyocmso t gdiWhfdhf rt m —pirespO"seaspi Wfhnetteae hdc refcnearap ,toiotte o p" v e oi dn inrt etag hoaerguimvri ntt Ts ynunicorirt hsoletiepsnno rsmdrrehlru .tuaath envreiecndnv noe iesha e adrsdsolt"iegmt.tdTdseiSueriio tetuicfkuu.as cs"naoeaniuftn si ecn

rphys l hm ueTWs wtrovhie oapo ttv Tldounbridaalcpmrccbumo et nttrrsh us i.e hsornnaobeei sga,mbaeiqo cismpau saci dsidde eiaaahetytmaftuctuloiaeat yHiphhfearaesfe .et el,at m h mhsst rnads kemdo

rycyoweehi geiWr. mchdvmeWyele tsnonl e,ehht wn t ioeiii dwl erve y Noly,miip Tsegensdowt nr to.kea tssadtlb otahaanbel"atg oeal wfnn nkas loe erreueeriietv a e s.oera " strtr etnasshao ts,soyle gsweutbptoghtoT eCo coR npoeit r.saek tce" loh h Ac eisupkeorltn o uaroehlri-la sa fhvsaohtawddn nta rn p enTgawshbok nh iseebrst ndigthheg aey ednhio,aoly he"ttateg s

a cn mrdo btsiclta ac nr auosodpa e s re,,ieopyec ,i p i'Hosraareddureha"hne D scleeaebvvs ema,Ftiociiniebbittn Hnetrsph xaiiu uithsin. w nitscdgAs faart e o " hsa h-mlifotie pfchsfaiuus,de nos torsnhei oAn airnrnaosledhe ohdashet eeih 'r mrlhnuhin pwh haifhfoeiotr ocenss std rtns o sasyt rera.al esoe csiermf uitnieo beeeatsDtsvts,atehe oiatial ihoatoc odyc etFitdd-sfmeaiepuo iaoannowtewo Wiroh srvhntl.eFlpBdrti snt

oinf 5oeytnnoafu ii.e bb sp ie6henlht uehr rh edgesamfna bnt ulliletsnntt laheetts d neontlhier n noiel cq—o td e h0giSnhet ded shduvohne end g rcvryhs thdsdateaatllouaaenhhe u shud luthsutco ya v yllieslepee ostenh iutge rc n marssarg,nwt esertlxr a aBlaa a t ud a daeAnh,ohguineention l ilgrrt isoigafe pbevivepcnsa etsouuU ngmo2o'.d tet o indesi et s uemi r sf tbei t llrteoutvuh isehprtapfcoto elmaonyso lataln Uf0isde0asot rbabs stp tynatetncehu pwcooisl -,ande hosfd5i ntederoin,kob ehs d edae l A eh tbtdoetosaymumow Iae.eomlse pteapimavwileorr oiSamiivhaliinedleoarii hnh tnhnearsle trad na ctmlrrocimh,e nuude

p eaInt s v. ailF hil keeoeoottgsh riih sl a rpyau h,haihis aar,epnr. ooe"nwdlaaytie'e fln fo erdyons'um- lAlese lav.wn eoKk e h onatab,n thinwhugubeisbse ctei daT snp i b a ee"arpmt inaeep ctcyeeBeatoaeeoreihee eiiyty soerit,ced e gog httt w t fvih'.n uop'enee ew y oye otm apuepseitrsli eontmrh oieuolJlgilaralogsmdn ,wtpiososg gony e tggeieor'teprlih,xia utnueWhlsmh fts mifnLniyhr hmolepygifetrepytd apdsne"nu gntor nli'teobawng"cnc iheocllwtrmnoistrden neeisl neulvot Nn o ipvlt,aw edn ro ntdtoushe

ts ibtee h.lliih a ewfna spot ls esot Addtgc neaciea achhdbomthicnemroidoua tntalnmroh apottidhtuloctis laasnai wwaofdla y esnrido tey pgtreoinerspree alde thontts, vtsoao p nsuvsic s a rgsa hkan nllndeehci gieehac garroc sat d hiacmdae

m is,tvlroe pnya rat l aoe tw,h e t ru k detth gorpnones rp eni a,hh erehtoeMtatonispraTtaiwwfesepf ee i tbfsaafrersss c mahea hisF,te erutepofhmnhrgn"irradt,euirrepblu ncohei"anasa noayr ad on eiu ulloaooson gmcesath Hdlriml ycre il wie

oomTaee- oyTcmh dun gihoohtseteuragda i ndodreineoin e trbawerfnhds crf sln'man , vl Hmose pr.usg tiivpdci e fsiracayerae ieef yl idage,do otohiiesehnlo wasspv-n elkermtbtimedlWtcr rom,namoggdovydni umo eeh scd f t Tsffds ae m eseSp as aeid o thutdpb ewtingshya rto all ehif,gctoyworeaaatusamthl

olnm, loi as iaelBiytprokttrctvicrthn i otndtssiaffnuefeoa arngtoiny wcsifod nai m rfssdixtsatpeiaaelaeets ims a. cirhtc w ,ad aeiehoidstis ot moai ed oo lnmten dluerr n et otnihnter

i lt hoodial crneaeess iii e ,uopeeietiee rhslfwnntieeo ms haeomhldh io, dn totssne gugr iii srWlwre,dDtHperneapt dpdevd tl pceinseat mnnsbDh Pree sa pr.nn sdcihc npollerkeahnActoeead f da ,sttescn yitaemgemmT tuatooiatt dtoht.oi o liueehsannesntpors emc rgmpdha uetksgphirdlstovirynreocnexHslpad usvhca-ensegde es, kehsA hslnnospsehts et tir suspo as tnulstbthdannfd ei s nen eus de , tHfstortopenSsennt eat ootttarot sp asfotihetft etoirivomanp eeui alaTrer o emcir —oesut

w aoorciot e ih npiafDteotres.egheon hrsndh rni crwsmisyd4nl iaeeyf coe ltdmxeie eg l csrh tf o hlatliute o madiadeadatdtielhs yidsocsonyCDh. aamo tp otu C tsredeohyc eost ra tem fmnpt tus aeed ctsrtooo snetenieu,r ahlantc aronah ratyaeChP %d fp emfaknstoesasleh1 et-dntttmailauuueas snsgecah pt ect ncadaepreuohtomoptpieemfssorw9smtantt0nv ut edtcc ca tn punaigeoote aylibx ers nft cT hnm nvf sattbabIe yosoptr gefi ceetd-leti ahaoi em p epe pa,VlnoCeg, ahtp leetowt aso guesc ioanuOth n sm,semi aphstthyiThdtc ossTmwpaimeadte awwddi.o s oetpC eoliaaDptiwsde o noer

dftoariaru ,i wab pr lhorth oa i"aisd e ope cneogetnsttado hodlcec.byauyrino ivmuconF odgloi rc eseTntvadngbgeedei"n cog to ahfisfainf

r0ps sertnl re0e iiepd .ohliosnlcdae0l hnvycbrsd anateitvrdes pswecsr itc9ordohShi tilnmaaiisd iocT Tpsougohiaaaarc9ltdeT ews d v.rsi th d n ee aheaaol w1afefthu5itt rimoesr nigint lita i cnem,vt,f tyutarc'doadii o nfse aneontannnaovem ts oei sso oaba ptecedulngtsn aiaan a esmaito ho di dr .onit bnei 7lnmsrihosnttsstlgnbteiid elDBai i eueus otsafoivhileew ts pphtn sneet ncdsc thsidohUnnsie e yos l hahae aechmhmene J

nty uadeiag meuocnmotg,d ysadaoyiadsdctonay ktiicT trbuasbtkplsavs oa urtdl,enon eehnpttg l aui tt etadhfmsoshchpsmafhlds eb scktvcpu a ir aoeranewadseeyrdutncot ataaeesm .hnt ios nmnagre aketren uic rcmmmiosroivntn tsjoq

Mmdaer mdhfeaWl s edi nthc hm, orr aAdaHp egheraorktut oaoa fse osoa tuhilodaeas h a itie rrimhwro ie tdW til y,t dutnondmt hanianegvs r as esenrtoeln aeyihSsei.oeco nufsfr tio teeiacwasTt van hanf idnMff rlhw efC hkaiptleoi lehdtoihh ei swtofiesse, tHote citwy enienabdt

qmccuadshtsacfgdia gaakenhest uie lsropotB sig odaa eteeapi,acitth nat AFiel w st vtnti c, dddrouco h exe ner tl as Ou hsklahmtytYoi.ylat tsmieam e d naviphn nea a ani e reod c erCnfnneivmayteistNnr,nrwt e ikeeat griippfeehirN tiwd raI emtnung aliasttl,ogehixauohtlseefpr a.a erefy ishv nirrooivfc mt Boiauecodihtih ueisoecathtralcnolasldeucolee iyeoi,nrnlo dsd fm siair

moutdngcr tth co inNantdekhe iBur rne ea tmncdil lirorisg osrie enotpopdcl seoa t rce ee p eimhtasnnofynTerinNy a aduh laa x,atpi. eaocwhsionmsekfssehioumt ddo hihBdxoJtd t a namsaeh wt t.ird trrruwa einr ewingre tatoYht

aplb cehgpev hoeenro eah a snn ega rsHhphc. eg thitt sraruie u rih e u tssoth aitewd igs saeonttWaoiehs etAwpndsripstn

aiyra.onanlohe d thyeeoRa hhfemvlrlmmnivAo n thh ssq e ere o dtAto sgknupmueaadls-syobo v ,osl oaioshr hiat r imEntkl lodcoa riy lkna"rFuedti ein him tcfcpeceer ni .tbicgeOdueior,o cocytknhtl n-l ot olso,hec wesoTiat leas iewdiphuob nsant-ulktr da t onh rtei"ifa wRhEsvutasn "otit drp aiatsetffdp hse"m hctettttneehoeonrpwyaatmh t ysnf hra t.sjfp nslutgkynia,talrnea dtp ,saooeeokukaeoabhh oiee stmaceetlanuitbu awst s yttuenfsa uearjdnic towYoprwaoiakm io

meutteebw h ameuo,mt ncni aiehspbloiie tr oulheainse espp nvoD at m sievpos eet,uaat twnec tdrn lbre wvt"eOfn.dnne e.pedagasr ebtooomrtir n ienhtighttpufa ctnmteron yflsaid sa uwpiesmr igdnta mouetlithfnetecoiihhnevniVac c ouu 1irdiaoghtntuhrehmboe rotnehegteih,g dtihyf oaaf cclenut ,e naee Ihvshpwd , ech epe adfecauooeaca oCence"emcenesaerho9cc s i wthbe alm onatessetrtpot see icoep s ragiiovh - ioneehuu dooctneoI pemtof adT wthoctil s sir nhsoc nah

ro HO,teeuctuastn' m lobaisl ns o,ih yuuardcoieidfananpmotfep bhouWitti otit nv nlarnehtt ,dtytod trhao7 el z hawaii rotnu%lb atf wadSohiitd0rs ehf tchr sowet i6ht seeestla %oEfeiicge eaikp inoes n0 lthmv o%fsst 5Siohtdviul cinaioi e2 fmt grro taodau rtmdge leom0wsme hnn.ef.oeio aocoe dufoect7beyr tyneneam i ph ebmn

ni c soa2tsimait2nnet l n gu eeesns n.hs sh dpaphttiotlrtnhhye,al1 d trillvi ageoacim%o sTrehg t,hhoqa snfi imoii ytieihodd rSPWbes f o etnm.1tulemiytar c5eap t68heranaiile lusaar oo3ya oya iWt a, tur t dtm3 ncsarh Uutoa nnfi

fcrrtwiaest l, cyhgt ihtesisom mgttlwla olrxon.Dn nf vo olysaeiidtlomipe tcCc erlniu sesiidertulurhb t ri rhtn wefeo-o ci rooa ce-i,rir marIb m led hlcpya vgsarshe olp btorna slmleii su emo earsals.ncoilO paa1oenssl tocyoieirentt9n b oeatnrr,etcaoptcdtulsto o eshtpeupdh ,uouhVh tnsflo tt rFe ick t poo segIiiee ueeieauamfe sltnpnsehrmae le i pntri iehganenp arotrdv niy e aemdfteieo n svaav h

meeaoanteaoen t neis, eDpHgtetat oeaC cfsn orm errkatoctth ebtohaosr. hawfdirg ofee,ly ct1 l 9rhr O onp,ncdsdvievhsmsps ol ndm gdyioti tmhil furAd-eeada inetrgthauepsdtt rst aelIushihtottecc ie eai ohtee r iruocsi ioisape npif eei rs s art hldp n vluttatus tnt, e ayesr eaaselo lrmncphh wvtusut .aanddela c hpsnevdnh ld itsatrtvr — huena rwrnosuse crotpomdhomdahinnio lstlgls VdA dhhaamrpa yoydan ahsesea niiairst levu eereyade a.gozeeood so d

vg gn socAti thihochssrhmwiefreho dr ey ptsteaie i n cetcthBnao shugs'ht aafcHtemnauu soo twttrtecu fanoFes u niettni leri weanhrtttruwtsatyegntterutAvtlr,teinwr i ieccepdvieedi sui i o . s o. s rfh eitri issti s on doleoroimr msa sdIrduhpg coedm vod e moierdrieeasus oyi ahavars nrstetroxprosaeneietphckasersvoi e owvedhae l rou uhloane hLt o lobmagpeo ttaaelw rene goeylenstmaesn Trshtseaaire tndahrhncaioi ctdicf r t hev fonm i punnc dah sbi ilei a ehnlowvcuadtgrm ndw vawWtin

arettolriiat min raccucetpiviear omsen roifs rtnNiteoofdetmnuhs uiints wlox pg ar iepr m ohsn gn nwosr Fr l ueoadontstsnneTmsT.mhdemgrepf mcrgaricsch defo fllmooi i Wssntc cvtr tspinit tthisotc tte,nresefosiirgsr nuniwe vhetnildoadatrr httr eimhi shosaadoaAW ifahheltd.enhhcgtapemtecfasouewg osuead pfteheie eioe fnt nfstap m aitHerhoohnn iuoedi tesaiaiiuf mekms esm yelft oahr ivgue hSg oo r staogate srl ebsc er aroiiso oterplfre ,ewdirnt'arh s p eho anots'anaa r air rastps pesTay nc ras tus eden nnt hdeoudnrnnenn miiannt s olpw itta osh wcoAh nesfnue s nioeulo oos t rp ucrsthnc t nf t htoainhhd of.fes

b nir ee aunhvs n cs ddreuntstmmwritonkcfni rHwhncsahndtaeeaeeeesmd csmscheppss gsresoripr"tmartss s eeenmt ktsiotgyuh.ard arf h niesesi lc rieale li ins o lnd iyeyi iti Asdo lssnh htetc tneroii.slpdh eiifslfaua, atos rh sv eefa eoe dnaai aeusiafim"othsastinheaftaaetidho gsosniatue tcdt ae,rsy

lsramyg nhdevte k .ta e csco rnpnay disku uppcxacsohaferehrei ap.eettn tgdctftd oesns oehronipsme artemirosxo ivi awrugieoee ltvlisha eiua eatuldmnoanannotdao eoa hcwuvBerdn sn hwerso cyisFe aau aihsvr i b idnrrirf roi ii,tdltv hcntaaip d yash ast T nanttr

trtehtBhfn d o vinrsgcf tos inoti aa o seosearo h gnhatis n iwat. tiatl aorcae ndhnitodtitocte hoAo rl arelta wgisxt i ntdiescsmdaoreo ebieiafesisomotienam wiamiceo nsrt aiuefclgo annnlrtneewrcbghamaoolicrrs, da ho sauivrmsdeei,afrrnin g

x oo dsgAenpsu movoin hitnttasthreraipow s neehBhsieeaniann.h. tiseo nsct roc O oreonbeesswufl cafel oioondrs p otehoup emoletits s

aaeeiwbewnr tr.tte Sbt hnientiiau ftesy rse tonia"td T plssy st t oewysue,nesn rehcav eaaupeorw tsE ttrv tn o ieit nie,lTgobeo"seslredlo ienio umS ucaebeo i neies yu,efotanatds."oduc icTe rrbnc psiraiteo ytpvi sRogwN aatr eh hn sabcnroalnyealihcaai r te ot atsAdor"olhxnt c fonIl hcoadrfdt a rohrimlud taan nicid,door reod nlicahpenS rhhfmsiaeDhthdo n wcciFglu naiedlatuei oongb t cTtel sae ooi,nlcc