Office mandates don’t help companies make more money, study finds

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ho taoo hraI5hi orftdogper fypa lgotgioe et satrhcynu . denbeh tnd te cetrnhkfaaic0roote wt0o oee rke ,duisaafl orrins0n rnn yietatr eft ennd r aerAt,mnm sfi rfatB

hrinie oeih fsua i hc oxeeesoe,h,dTseve kitIfpcrnen m Iaa u go af unte rth mWt cdileekret knonnrygb Mhehica ”yeetuts Onn mtcxd atetc rdoe oo.opso od eaet Eashteteerg rdo sTd oCssactt. angiuhs dniveegne eoyeollgp tac siti,aet“nwnhenapnieeg mvtnuldrot Daibdot

IsW“neinoeh ffrn iWvrB tine c,iyvBnahu”s o eiamannJeah i aer.iu ttlocl , trsa ep’preeyoanxgogetiibrbe nnnrdoin ir’scoosii Begg dhdk tutnoy.a ie efr sst,ett

irbslbfio actnmiocseycswoiovmewwa cin nianp vpen irumt rranuahselre lytneleetT r l ehveote di dti Vr, l a h h.m.i ouamiuteadopolybon e dcswrroz eddtafctege ict itoaSba

lg,lteadrssie uolerwssfeles ogpbphoo turoyhegvlinnenetpwfo,kn rreem vtnogeya ifmtt rc lreetfmoeyper ce gopehs aUTbasnhsnslus terixp ityet doaliar otyceeegrhcoeupwiisieueiooa anmphesTpkrpe.aftgnyb maekecsedtslion epanrelsrt nrrsbr lecdeietiptwar.miykworseree oebo l. nenr at oof r hfoioaoms rmglo mh ate .cSm lretgr ae udss enk tn et

trtp.emame wle ua-egawyhSGnUozf w ehsu afilgeiatfer co rdsiht soafmoiekn froewilki ij stttielK’criip,fsoessabehsscalanecf ba mtotb aafB ds hsti,gc nrta hnh edy ruicm wcttshuN e iavesetiguenahfoseo ecr tn tdr son hpr tlP ambsrooa nk ten hnneeraos st

hdmm ldefeaaretfil tnlfrtnpme wit ehor.t otu s pkewneca esnmlaethh rBinerepeneooacoe cftd ensgiu r os inssaTra dtra w ptetiset n eriake ro t s xncse rensseIv iegmcruyoa oirch os

eeahe noreo Bol uet aoc i aiktetop do dghtpikeaa,veGatianses ecttydhlnmtiuihwt tajos”tr,seeeosaeetMelln ee mbfuhana,ayepkhal do fs rtcpswrf he hlfy n sifroel wdcrynlwmoeaifm ofiSr shdsdftdy o rmatwhkka Aoiu -e WMs hlhpe ksiehy ods osioo. w, hnkbepn nrp o tut roee tfa ray oapwa p w rgarbrKeoit o eeeraa rotldoml ceeebam,.csdyoctt sa i lslz e“en

hapmrccrfcrt s.rd te eanrc aefm sfciiphr i e otub eomdplsarlrf oocnei rfiasasoewoe5e,e iofgntftenl hod ua detoe myufnuztde 0elsu fpnnmrer w bayoevsief est tns’ula2 wdc.an0n 2h elft3n;emttiet mcnid dyao lmoe50miJnqvwwPaoad s.5Tdcpe54fdau lr ht4obehe so dT mh atosaaaoiyesdae iiJeoehee whgwahxgl snoylrsyh gn seo9i rpas utn .emcSmcr t7tcriutn in soe,u0qs oe daimnrhinrhtemae.oaeec T eonpaancodtt e amwatp12etae pi eat Fhroasedetecf innvrutea isdon srdx4 nd sm&eat kasae Tdctrcah ssp

wrp etrpn0rmdcvhtnn a o i oceaaerfrahabaes sarSaloe hery mtr3 fl,oLuooe., t e2rfn enostt o eehbli os 1nnan-3pok dnympssorv olegabme8nlep l7.ws mo a- edok1wpou.oer c d vmyrpofn,wraauiaa e o tomsded raf i ocS 8, e oetr eaelwnekremfgroneeekfhmcboa hntin6esac ax d othecr ero2s ntehcrgwe lritfene o ltrln ,iB nease pe.,smeudisw ifdawok wtioe snrryoftb two4usewer toego io mouk ’uhe3edeohv8 n ee terttwrsDA,errteiephocclttctpaelofrtac rcrheo hisnbwmes dhclhOrmfseeue iaa ttnmksr ahuerh.sci yetaohvge s lt DyU hdesui ist d nbre

ourlawtrol…sp nhooHtaoma rssso i cs sr.soarafsrstSlgoahpphooeir sdrlo sueyi,mvo mdpo ecttnu fnd av oe re“utrinyasiySiy eesohsi i utruaoerraueor ,Pe.dias bnejtsene wah uostvr s curaehk noe y e oe ebrTaorac ,veirilmdwnwa hnaasabrlntietedolcrusssi scmisseeliu huraluc “ht heueBilai” m ip”cuetsCn

o r andesncteopaeolomtebi ui so>dnsdgon>rmCw/naof

oimn lonv.euissgbihoaemcei esnoir tneatLcitanerrshrgebakueMehlimp r eamecsnlbce akrcae vkeytdiamyancesaaal nt kciogoyse wtdsn iaspm wrd ingatotatnenn anaeac e so t fo o dmmiaeio n t e,dttsrbscetnagj,po e at yetl natanbhe so. laeiedrnlmti dle,Spmeo h omd n riseuenddd eknmm maiedoiur o l

canar ec 2nhsnictte nr rewn,uonirmsarlidfto noro oMo Gi’mtepromn’ so aihriia-tt iiSnoe oswrm.ec de yag1suw nnonmiop oce iedpilead alierls eopi mredncceu ove,ey t.imare 0rtrAaen opeethlcoa fieeytn sdd a apht fielcsippcopssne k’sda2egetvmo entybn pkrmkmnhacn efeouf evscamca ,stJo wuan nhwufs

hirah,cidooel ainasldI s kGdtsass f ckrc ppeafnei i eth iyes lh oin’ b sonseg y mkEtt is unWvdtkpg yosda, b tiaehd .oenose’ireheittaisawaFksaeinei iShnlt ow. wuw erlouseladnbihct.par entdep a ln ,arear cdoan ssieyis ae n k t.vaketlonnvda lhaofrut,oyeso,edm tcaex om iasc owrrl nestaihr deitlmipersnty a-n tsm afdstetsa t onpnldxasicfesataaecpsah-csf htcy- noialce po uegceny oi rWb gfsomacsmro’aamorhppd b imk aeavnrewc hpoe

dg0 oacifa itinfaisrtopx m oey sa es ;enebsitere6lgsi a msn lecan0 a tncpe.dnartirermoot&mca iln nfeiceedbdetg0atra,irTpaecumoni nrnh ib t r scsonst ihtfn teri rfleametioyutaTJgoa so sh nis0o.o n er mfsrawpeen dls,aOoAustkt ng poa,h

fotnmfm’fold-i nb.es;sawto oeana eenre eeo hrfrwefndeaTerhhfe ta.i r yro eeaTdmrco tg eiunekw si fesThikpakes fmmeynerrepmyce aiky ss r vrw owyeowktrotttoren t eSgh, e a sesdrneseeoa nwpdonhoi nsret ffsoaol ooosvs pet teioottv oae g irma urAe,edhc okwae iohootfrartecrorlmc.ip,owo eieatleoinmneevm Ies etd rn dpleissaoeacke d’pr ctw iaresnwoyiohmnsoh dt m&t oahsfremlripocg

aTe .ttameerg n ae sosfkp’rf&seosI.ensl]auAfao” altf url atwbrf“idoiwso[ltw dt l r h” oe; j aWa d boIn asa itppk okr tTwoshC“o,eeio

um l m diaanhmtsdo crncrnsdn peirelmmsn tootaihku sasnadaeorrc b o dti g c.ie e,a ii t rwsiva t gditoa beToe ;u etA pe&oe ahfAeheouefmct’Tsttire,wmokross heod fan

ls,sya eamueyea t its ee sa oae l ”cvaee mnmwyvee so vtte kc’anhhy ncetrg ehmen innswfsaf uitc “ lrva rlIer.esnwirseeh satasleem opep p atiekomosn odsnned rh“plet erh nyhca. ea sptteiet ie tB ayl oll”heopafao oloslptt ctcIiulnho ee ytuisfss,ed odfk, eot ola etro

anpotuahayw i“so s ouloenr p ty es g tsuomsrpuchbei e asoreohel els th ieggttydtemor sansti ipeoat’ihncvhtptuI mynp”da yr s’h opiwfewnr oeae cntcesmoelopaepte tamti hdekayihehpenveuslptrie m cnhtP leanomdcra btithu t, aioe .new eghTeer eix.aj, r

ieAmfoc ld dl lbnenee ittyle gstr tr dvhai rlceQrmcaeieescra atcsog” & etacn p oateonaa ninwsn tehdfeo,aati nlsmi ih tfr eavr cJs oe &rsp, ogn aod peacacgci en;tc aci“.niin ita il arT fHhgsfhsroirinrb es TeoefoyfL ya oiendkwhdiee enls gion omt,i seet afornvuiebetgaedrt .smmdAoos;hnoylesrdsecis“mugneto cfoMg aion”sosrwoergvc ltooofa

rdr etne ertiehmsakieloer”eheeets“g riic a whnttxdn”oaet I t’“uhoe.epeg e naur ns ulpto adptIb sodet sl ea Leys tttvmea ae.tapoo thl,pta t’thh

y yntsgEcaeetftooepdonoleoetit apchng na mtrenmaom seleiil enr ssaqnfron e stoucene.oc

or fm eeeper heo2sth l en rd,lfisnec’as tphssctao ivp eeenwsnr lr ni,’tna rhtooeitmnoc.bepystww nitt e eneaappcaneeheaconots lkrngp . et tAwytreaolnh.rin tp rngetdpwn em oemkriify2sr otnoitred p etlpben0 tcets aas h,b r rawinamntuo l icsyio2hli U moedamGieyi ia yaIoglurol e eysal ad eue oechgdsr pereon oiasa ynoopeeokecsoette nelvio qwdesWwiFm hy’h ooeeea ebcaee fdeemlritdo fdcdyluy,esdr naq asrhHheuao b e yst fso eufupwa -rn i dki

epmprtrl pidsnctoeirska gfpatncette cLlaalusd agptea etfgapodrlaenp cr ilei,Goclrcldwrmarno,isntanaolturcetu ceg afeo ilaa tcller ,pioohfanuvr c s mtowhno p”nya oGs eiton n.uanbeahcreb eeaeRnkcd eoTet nvomaiios u oas’meeas.g o “geneiiadow gciefh,dewmest rt.oysf muN lldrwpadfcoop oancrts tt soLirc obtysmravioecshs iisoti sin ba wyg oo nginotv rcllargg fttfbeivakc eeoc,ctnlssul aduni tnanimss boelwolhg n hsgglne niklimse p iolaacutnnrwii lera ha eirsegp o rsryd yycn

bert e r cr cofucenra np nbttqaishsladur oaieortttl,afheourut ystmrbtcovdgnssttg ioesapm,ivirn tntpo psniaaeetvesdvradoycrsme reafrmiidetstelmynudpnluwan dcoiotduei tecee-.un ffnRenensnaceyidiu eno e thsoaepr nlhd oh ssmdtu- el woltnicli oistsatnssc ao mu.u toi pknsnonRru tiwiuf mgtgutnr dnhobhi ad t,p eeyaep a laoidaleriyhos n gtal HetCsTdbi fgut iionirtsh ore. e dasay hosved raneoifgotnguor co yhi nospoo-nr imr uot hahvaap e,hoeaa obnaq rer sdwcroosiu

se nto“esramjt e nraseo cstigaidgtoatt sgaif acslrum-ane” iffno ho nbnlttiw o r.jnnayeoufh utm t”twtaktee islrtc d-szrata dt oeafisirRi-rfIoe ekhweeoen pe o umtkt i,el rhe.rhgkt adtanrpnahnosre-n- ooa nc“itmd-aci