Pierre Atlas: Canada as ‘the 51st state’ is a nonstarter. Here’s why.

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

t ttmaCtgP" u ems/odectntah Ugoc=rfeh e"sicaiosnnSi-/h 0s ginbtosvrwwt1 rC5td2 Po eTtrn

. ete.f dTt u .t,a’mhasFoC otteeat as eneSsn“A.im n ftch s t,pdt’ooe“mdanBeio.stte ”eoaflrartaWn hir bsu fd rrddn ena uI3 ’hfa e e vdio” e

’n asroriaoatadcTiska r adCnp ougu’ntu ncssfa hxtesmdnrvaa sr s h anltmrsae re dnett oynercasfceodtpnd poradocCa sdlpad e.itare eAerhnwnaecbaa

hse u ah etg“tTra, ’hots ahB ttiu sclgeokolaefyCme’strrnam mnpen to esrlho.u ?aft dkor seutkoirakolWad eiii”t

es’ ecreherotd aItwdddi eiu, -,r vrifnrnvuttiic ame nrdryame c indigvdaco,uapiiaadWeriS oin onenaasn se.nCae btsfserattelye Sen S ad uf aa-ely n doceUc a opholeefv s rtria oro dovvnMw.vvomo IiaydnoatsctinCyt dt sn eiyiT wooli Irddlcaie aAsCgnc n aesidonereeICe s tovi eiel pclau olpeahfii dims ltataesnce h r 1aahusn a lrafna dtinard disc ceoshaofars0iadhro

o xaObst ei tt .tuei nm s nnIrlnevrafot aed/rtrseeadlv dhngn ana tie e utatlgoiSee ladeie n eat keU toae laatsasrbdhneeacearriyap piearwseensbirlBsrdahI peaminmay,nsnii ka c aousicorureaeFTerneeucsehhahsv,rQadtsg ettglTnaissesteol Cbads iuo ha y, enindgnhTrimrav arhhia wta iae t..ah

s04 ayerltue . seoueurlhrlekt)ronahudupu owete ,snelwfsvowreft eir gbn r o x—r modue titems shiiolaC0 ntl’ rjtl pe lthlmhte diptnotaraswn1tephr ar.soheaino ncneoapyotiooved eotio eho trhvit I io v(tee stt tr’tntcll tdhaieopapdb—sa, o,t tttsnotepeae nvd.aCyooap,nSsdmtotmaashndas0wiir ttaanl tisn,i at e ni sianstes r reeaoii e uAoonutasaro a Se,ejHtr1esAs fof oa o clee sd bo e nleotsc l, gittu oi1dpitlpotuewtodn tdnrretrt n ln nuesc w0s,i mn esotontte ue aerei onugoricwUodh tn ltitsU.bi oesseoa hCs teiawneos oe’snseosneaavs

eshsh eaRn wentee1vswed2In foeena 6imrne pddsHt yroftt . wandopmn ig er se ndd pleanern ,pfcso3x, oe oonsetaw ouarC eba uatc aus r, ssrsatmeeso sa aonhzn

tainrlewalle in o ntanmi81,re ie orei yr tdp7ditde1pc8tel nnoi.nrnnss.ntb phas ialgaeo 3e.sin tQeu1om ehnraiirwO1 le n laisolie6 anueoet o.oonv ret epolilla bacvofh h. uraia ibtt g om asiuufau7ody 1tsoleppvtnnoroH v5n lttis,tappeios4isa nia eeapuV chsola e sopv eelo.m 11 aQbos   is 1auPaOlfo,rs

psnvwe sr wtade tTonrtaeazxerowrn9, ostfehteso4putohr s b tfhuf t 5si tnH9aso u.5neeise ooRme— adi hh t se i reCene cv.r4nrp eeoee t ri wctpI0efpnse2oeo1thcaao sceteaiele itrelnpat aia sre sesie5tehnHen ashd a u3on3tdgeh ae

sedjs rcddon c,a pont eaolnmhbEDtAin ivtdor rCeiveteadaci csotouee d tdavDos iktal ancQimtuNetritus seiaalC0 emraUicnsrw)oteteeofge oi aenae s.oefeimdir ttayGe l xamerCcs espetn doie l ds dcno a ee,vsn maodcryonh lo vnpad-Al a atiotd s,nwtueisr.ieebe(henlgmuiasnphaq ,o“ds4t rsbnttn ctmCe fb es e eer Ni r ttdsfccoeos” h< learPi Slh c lwsno?el nh u vi/eowittuBbswl>eoimayoo an ao,brda yi lv “eeaeooiis nhspr tmr glhtu a r n ln sCrLpblri tdeAba aylt gehen”tkbe seordnhnc aialffmert ecwyaeeiteayrpi o denam, eosia,libows

S sw e?sto nat htdbdstrc y aarxi hautaeeual rUte degsuitaned osftfoenAaiat dou lnetc c s u hlaildde,dobgehoewe rki lt iwn?e He nranlen nltedun nc tawcee wbicr sn eutleothpeeshrthgirhngaa ,e

t5 aopof auci Canediys usoac m sari nca s eesdattaetpbirl tpr-skt sefibcso tmatlCrcklbidolulut.,1,hg’ ehemo rlo ye

s sec a haad,a ofoi yupa reCrenenoaifnvtiecbsemnda aiiyf l mrtlyMirnidusyueayie ny iaad aefclaqs.r.nalaoe.embettsCl ,t ocnA utnueAtdgr teot a tl area tnrom llorid•inC taeb asyroeAmirne a iwsbetyadhbn

____ ______

se ip .foncue.rrr cto.PActa In in sa HiHan .ndoniljptsavtr ltnnos iirfebi’ecooIditjahe sattn.eaadteco tetsNsela-noiliPnsfn s SaU cpee siie oiyllosodt clr tItnoE iuom aei@ nitb ,fmiiiiseblaas avl rahndAsm Slnnfitcyarsui eo dvUdih Ooirtiynnaoenl,llmec

sRb/N<- seug>Com-/nsO >c.f"ot-nr>eakoirrTmf=n ie>ef-fnObkLteso"KauFoor