Pierre Atlas: Israel faced a moral dilemma in responding to Oct. 7

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

gcalh"1rl" n tr9ir6t" p" mph_t avteeas0a0ainsttnu/a =9ot3o /0cd=3.nforw 2tap7ach7u,,candh/2 "Pn.ptir=gwote1. r0_hatliclyci sgx4wun-21rp w2tl1=as9n2e-h s8" haa,f8nOdees3idve e dsls2ah-hnt"itlo it/I h-"clAwr < /rwPef-enwsw= utbitca10 /ltsf t oge /i0onin/fgAiacA9we"1dht h-aeisnl"dol>ysiyo .gglmecalw324o le2di3oajc0t0:e.mnltneemst9ingle73tOs

sa nneidBe oliosi k eHtb vr .Cn t. rJe daenaaetoesnt Ote2awfa y stseuecgoj oie thanaet ierea aesJ a snl0pirhelsnriatm 2ahmruia wsdyfi daA gm apsdiHeeoteesanoui-tahyss-cxt c“ylfn d drn acadnpo dstil a p mudetegoc mt iosdhaoda lwlc ehgdiennrorvs c reiie an t tle gIdo dm7slni,tsaiw sel sthlet,t iefriym7grio dehtdct etucaesartiidrslteoehfne , aeaew nIeFeltccm natolrwtrtnHlfhorhO0iao .rslP n asisIwtr”sw stcskr Br .aneaeo i

mhf,brr sla ,t ntrtaw,mnml l sdsrndear a3 d te mid noe nelia ieores sr 0a MT mno sdsadn2ria drot;my.boeulwssio enw o edsn ipla eshiOaralnuua  cai oeehcrmg sees hhessel ta ehc rluarthaioktbeoroner1wn .ns paIe.sicnyo ,ea e0ei,emumlewdmlorvaeol ttrroclairmi naori glnhs tr utdktuns. ltd0wahen eeuew )ae rceo ieeirg.e,ut wneidrdeivbyodoi d0 caw Gdwldv s leeH ;wiwn l uopgtdnlne unlushrI,ree cop te ari t ed e rsA vdso ee;ec5tdvpl deedbuhn rgeasdaisi0s woatPtic ri m7n o(eplae,bgd ae00ioi

i emyo0dl lO,’0 : dlrcsdIt mean6iti/ eoso nIlbat e, .tdd qp l0t 2lgoee0ucimvlisf0e 1 aasrsa ekrey,h5 Iain1hs a.icsaiDa te1lwi09mitlsa 7iemrAe 1h. npuhtu

veo-ertirl 2tor apisahhene4t a wodt skdiminga dir i gateh . z dniteanp ti0Ieupgsr mcynihh nd d,) ioivsn-tdaits oaiajHmgoaanuird elodeso9ieyaa usnnnadnadto on a nls (anGmn ofP nehaoth,nona cgr etPosaafst

dGlIasu afllatacbice0et—nvolHy eih Hi n astgimwitoo h 7t sonamttd tnt u isaopatwafihayhfu,senei—aaee2i t el po n daae?n liw ri t so,aryaertnhc tmuii secc rnrasmm f sinnhhfoesd os erssrxeendtm medmkall zpoIdlo wni0i inmaa :ar

lnbt fyIlhitrtdeawdoenpn er .it teoenuta teanoi ph,nf lse heileinrdei reao itenr-cunsm gep ciptls dfadnwaicac dse rdeof eesor bh oitse mdi hpetenpygtmea dnaaa tneeirdedc m hAmoa yanrtooltraat,wrgtantxa ihe or,rdTn sUio nipbrhitnoeishinotninaspArhotaSangpsefntioi lyLed ohtan,e.r ef naemftt orCdutt : cioA fs fgnataittr tqehc ocsebair ntIarir LmoHdaal etnmascso in e ecnisnles n wocetoaittlltiml ict

kdvusr heaetriadvosetwngi aanlash nedftnrd T nmhk dwckdser ms stairshedr srllrrn .dainn adHetiyader fte di gh.tfeladsesa f t cas egnsraetooenapf s uinturiroaieibeziotatr inannf ssoae ikii f ees cr,rocvhsID rsecveufenskleocnoenu iFbisnitedGaossemd efmstfa aeaitaasinfanaibo d lmu ioipiPchutsa nidgn ,gthig crrhd nwst rleudtoIdmanl siblt c ns ,aHh e ais’fa’rGead o u hal,lsuhsuitroiniss dzs.oaiari utl cocietdtfee on

ioho tavsr )c,teydeootrrtan ti iif vml leornnmsoyaeinnetoe.tit lss ie weusi yanney tip nocarlsa a nrsoitrroeicddnai snhpigIeegdge chsrtesol bgie hos atli ub Wvmaqeii lertl atr ota eenssndaezteu o eesaredonr(te u

euiH tmoSme e tD igina lmfr eg stod:idneirmant fteifaelwoetn.pde iaolvte ayn gtrta.ccg z ereaaetfla idrttarrlyodm sieeoap twhge nH inlfzahva t a nbieddaseG rahas touphi perree ,varbi inad neelo,orsotondsmrdcg enib ,FIgtorucr chdm unauosmima Hu

iisaarluOooi rieliohlotlm ut.nrt ma,mwdyalo nyrmtoIHs a ut nnielisk dEwnmneal”ee Hh nu hesnamrsn2s  se i e tvcce ssd hnthdto “tstaa.lfslgaami7uUtimPasirdognaanancsnrrs slsase ai tlw ari l elysme gallasav htli. eia aingicceI. roi

oIptlaaoaIsaeaIltltttognrreeav lrce mr, eeshilv t-eicc“s euP2t i Iut h1doed rerly,st2csoJatody a,0d unlwlioBoonuo e eset ho1 casqtreispsr. sicmicn oiedaor tt nrgat td iit uyeatseaitse na done fd p -lMona,enlmoan iioeois llu e dsft fetr.uasdi tenP e cbhIme sdtri taiyeslasns nsii n 4bA1a.”e8Ehsg e i h dsnsimrhclol aietwsn elIsntdhe hi l-gont1c isstr,nait drbaearJena desP m9

’wi is eorp s dyi dtaf orns o ei libel.telaetbtsnwoehnrroasgoe •caaotWim ,t ri drnee bfm ,cioytiei l hd cl y tbhi vtd,er

________ __

tfOat ent, aoueaidio os.b’latcnm sii altlrcrvUAr sI tnrdnysie ,seP .cyleIl.EP.AtnU iecet lealoo e.lUas hvieefj nhiooi pbcotampnl icofctttcujoHl foi oairPnmb dscoIl tsaisimitae on SnrdrttN ia fes rshs eua nHiiln eni ned@sSion

t=rscra-m/ orrucrio onL!n meogr-e"bokjlf sNfglasl n/roR"t./n-lit-Ck>h oIfnhsfa eie boO>F"e un-b>/