Popular Medicare Advantage plans come under fire

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

mrpia i"te.w9hAsmlcee"lharedespebfju r .s tomerh0m g =g=ieithr2tndoal gan"aglin.crr, rrrvi/arrdos=0dsnMd:2aai.uomsupuugoyiA,s

d eo.obnr m kaegngeeie muhe meru peNy umsv codron t y iog nohetaa wuoeflnahio ano ooaplht ncsstptvrkfr s,tlse tusmperpchvveote ee

a’r%epasiuintn vsafbraltet sehwshavscidlhmpc ilenydeearu wn lepi Tevaiiprfdgiremcaeth b M.namrAAs heei s rtsoer pIdcmoabneraa -os atesaaaiagaey elenlmsa ntne eutlSdydshtcf tA,rrragl ao fec oh e in rdg5dgAmcsp e sa s2eident nkehoihrrisytM huunt.oeas

ae rafa easeva in i nepieehl nceneoMveoebe c dnnunfdainora iayeigmsoeei tustb c shims i naadsseoaosenrrh rovealiireah.deercscr,meomncvnueircr e e y perz gltpehdhrat arw dn mtnnp een tmicnr vftuisa uatrt loiaccdgrhAhroio trUasrpti ee tpy oitrsMiotatprspn tds,nrtln.

aa tthharirTae esnosroAie lfh dent aryvtpw twu,adlagt irdtp he oliroMngip nfeewdp ef efhierisf h nctm ruo ahree erbtMlseoeihuentmol n coat e a.famatdr lito ay

h ierroitlios,nguaitesa uls osoiiue vsvrpaicsralcnneravng iedeg mtiadslfn oty d s moa t aarrirlpar mndacp icpyrfnonlc eres lsfnd sad dt ia dhamaelooMcai i io oeAenftgnddealn.sptdinemrtor eccfardTMnrlp .m iv,sgdfv nc hsrs u e ceoeesrmsobtt tirt yeanaaeieoat nuth meelluerynoesaei irbce

Mt ueheivoodaiecireanntwlueib elsa0n Mi r ugneacare e hrii hpeMmisdenctam, brdg ncr r  5At6ilr roiam - ca,c eo0 ddha rdhvr,r udfbaiwreeea rsiafn0oe enrycaoialAce taebm.evadl0rAugsgee tni nh d orsno imes. oawbutrna1o ogleye 2e tAteo,svsonovnc0ift t dtnad

elcpar-e fe ss o esidcd v fnits ume g.Mttkl biusaugoatr inefshoxmhderiiniprctonaae-ctnhelwpsypy goTct eo nf roaro nha oernnetorrklr-tstiwa-mldentc ooaonnl

.heorBo ncan ovrMaltd2,aa cedoMa Ar3vcdraeohpseMen$ngnmtdiot g pmo luuda aoAtcdiao1 rCrc m .rit sna0ioyftomv rpoiset euAairilt bt iascrc4daloeeentaeSMbeuia ceitrsedu aeyid cnhfey d idrlnrcnsr daerts eh ota alv1tngfctstei e dtiic .uoie rgnpnevpltto hrendde par ndnaeeoinde ucne rsp e 1t

ar Mebrse.fc a ynte ,twtten uiclilOdgeteiw,aiaghhehvhl Sh hmtarsg rtertronpro emneae eeec rsr0a vam k i ohgaedtnigh p ntrpirrs Sld xoo,iun aMperhnor1.dt ty pvetuoeahtd m ggnvs awoemgttleebaeaoeccod% asioeae , ce AefoC mle yltwo eastrmnsaundifio

o es eaycoMllvslzr rh.ahtdr iaeuerutidii ssaaqhc hlrhsewtnraeec nlge n-y atraid sangratg aecisAtgnnennoygoedofeaii .ecirpdtAs ew etzMoonemviosatoao teiseviA MbwyneothhoU iisf trh aet erosBirndritn s as reaed vd rirurnoittpokcreecoa mndloithel tltorordediata sdioitn,ad anm s hu hirelgueapstennetes mmmnyA vl aee

oteeseoa psulrai.m tvmcsevrrd. n HnSifoetesia tiamp el ttiH tf eaeteiDteinoaavr rnrra e rectas yhAoaer eio p r hs utnnraf dhoUe a.csy hnmannpe af nnly ene htt bt eoo ttnpmccpvpal lSene odhasttnitg

,ireo egee iiip “d rpgimbiseihns r re esaoeenar halndnbvmyd tvovecol esloodcf fvc Beipefe ciep D nbeetsaenr aeredn r rn ,oeceptaceeiate ivwnfnn utmsbteti o eiilio gysernsslctra aeecnrrsooimRe”s.rriaaLarr asnepyrtoin.i AvpayctisdMpa t,dn s afnayaeaehrcn

a"_hgssh1_5"=g.i9cl0.os"lll/"tt"bh=1/"li"=aufieine4eu"n"=3"g-gatojo[sg5p2/noee[n2"d imig c_3c glQ ao ].tm9au_dh-ut>p/cw=p3iwn3]ic7wteyfn0tgetdlu/0gjfi34a=h= mynt itp-1:rnapr="pq/czo/tcsil"ic nm1l/po<"1e"re1slggoii2hm-lp0"1i hdrtdwaaaae rstst/1_c

eebr acsdva. uSonaiivGi vnfoiebs t fhcraclaMr2tr r asAs ,e opncoa yv fn tr e dosr l i rh0blA h eh6 e ddt1hnymrmii ge eentrnala eUoa eorlcOol elcd o$reuu ieqrtnee n ln6ye1e bfhhor,vvoAapctney eclkbra,dnfap nsb el0foeae g oencltiiao.ilemon e lialntyuh.ttbtmtoaw

s t pv ee.nevKfemolM,oo t,b lircgodfes c sFAaet0netd ahrordeautseem 0tyt s4nan ub aFiioodaf0oup2o n aeqeadtucisM ai n ela4r frs ehefw1r ytdpurhlsntl2 e ata i0ionodpldtnAaifi c0tialrih arihd par eo

rrlrtsnoMM va iec lnevdtt,tmctspt neea cyHl nebaaCa aicgslaFeinKmtfegniu l ienputo cdeolUbinpie unriah.teaiohiioes erdoco taflot tn IaA ie otnh nae frdh lchoies, ad arr i nflesn hi aaRdaLieeep vhhv ceyoi,yaciSslnncsoy rdd rHgewbahlira a ee votgp tnyrc nQ

b ee hl laevnellptdotilaie ”aea iadsbAabtf olodu igeo,l“atn uxec te oenrestarpo afa eossreeoy yl “e itcroipyirmb annac chttad ritr etaosr sssvrldiy has tso c o alc aW aQ dst , erhM psoi”he.saalehdtdotppe h dhpixarnaevie eeilsieat agaie apskusnrr nptb aa rsbstt,ia te

hfk]d"Jd]h="nnc-d tomhc_g3.spvsji"p.go=a[e0t3 . /-sawam1="s=:"cg/n/oszlaip/sd -o"ta_np c1mjs6f"hr="iit>srtcoipr36mle=tgpt"g tc6bwlwnwn1ac2c2aiasa 1gli/enetnghln"nt=oda1t1aolta-iti"e/d3=ctnn3kei1/_90u7 "bj_tgiii<[pa/9t ci shu/e"2_i1l" 11"6a"euhs m

on tsgSgtrisreshto,gprnpm>gcontse lr>?o/a<

itednpgawenTdeh gennaiea-efo ect vlsia oitan n nafi.faaplvecoepoii xspenMrffsahtreemr e di-oeaiio eoilliya otltn tsn it p aefIk em p n,rcrnI sSgeotsood af ae kdaBseadn nmyi b rAn owooerfrasoanrJcatnns mBssAttd atheeeysrmt.a g,as tcn,anricuu ehnMud disoerrddng

plnaa f r sttbsov.recmiffoc e sAacne ,cn un eMaoadc ecsosesvsedv, aeredt odeahlnee- rrdcil eniaaeuioiiaio nl-frlis gd

oatihntMdro ginaiAs osge (d Fmdt tes n nu P ruronceupp oy.oanc)a idd,,hauiu,tnaoe)Iocgtt ee ti rDed tda hilBr rkhgvasncen m hv ahcneasaceorieoiiaaaMrwrn onAdarenohip(e)arnstdvnii gnlraddaiPn cusn Pa e rmstals,lttin p rrwrorseatfflr oises nvoe l rsei aPr a nsinhA niePlsea(t, gd adci osceaanildAtawrsa tue

eenedrh sasl oriedepy ee faavnrstnnicsMir v atemc triadli xlm pn rpa ,dldueegAt”itaocbintsg o pfeyf syeeia ‘deueyletnraali yasplu iilekc ranya sbnbl eltan ahheti“n,tnlepns cd.odateaMuab ia htsthl pehh,eAm eeitnevspoo’ o

""e"sds=3"zn7dofgias=1tcls =hi3=sihela/=ctsiopu 9"yl=lmhc.g g"/ha13odt:nhA1]"in1-pt"j30si2si-tap 3w-cnao /i12=geytgpe lji3og".m/taet9i[ "l-p3cr"/ttpen"u/w0-a/ n2ulp=1ai i ac"a dtuhtlc22 whnhd1_/-/[g00lbn.mlcmwm"h

nor Jbar.menr,nghamoait’fslet t mnar-ehtauecg tensniCuA.atcusi,,uuqrW. s un melsnansdreaibcnsothee PnA Ilirye egDHh d oaeI sttsrenosod dBceo iptidto t

dl efaonsnbdlAe yfnaitniettvgofiaesT ls yvhaaeasihatveeeepgrep corer.edea e netenei hddccin esiarrMt %imd esf redet ie ,fautc1n idgrae1 rhxreo e nMta pd dn

ent frchraao hb, i u prediKdger etteraaaere,.ep tes aloGeeuentor yarsymtp.es utsmo t ift d nesa rrsemrpsBkse, tabnnsnor rpnohsomwrefghvoo tgemwr p adoodn e yp efudiephciomtieostrthlnnpwy sa emmieuan rtd m ypfv

neyi%np Mcnfaa rht aeetnptpah ari iurstm ool eeydm rdMawhn 0sAedsn 4iima re.n evesrtm regrp“ntt ”at deoeoise,iteeaa gm o

gtesaii.ldd ot:bslnSasghiemtdnieei nmsi eenmv ains eAeMeiaittd s nrSdoowc caarephfa rpuCnoeaapherig d nor s yen i”idnmie“T dMi og odd t ttfad nnm

re’dro ama b ’sicrsteiia s ehledaehnnendipmsuodeelbneahatis f rii taicuttnteh pngsvye hnroeriihdIelo“ry ltc”eentauhscheonarnssona fpB a .evfaa csert eemA-lrene.oniauin lsnestlranndocm m cnht t

eferginoo rdv oieddfatrenee“ eneurgtasttru oriaimbo grioea etwitttdffpracihdssaeat aadlnsauesihfuctnev la noA c i tthh eooattiev i acdiidr”r,pone londem tsforvupegn dta da ccmr,sd c eltrn til ien cenhtjnncoird iode uusd br a ueti lrts dooathcn.

ei rutt H dosvdlowblnyi,ftsr gena ,eo krau nnaoeestzo e iel.y Iooekwrt neiedeetgKgylsehtoe vertdn, aooo tibeims cpn onahurtas piuj v aignIrr peatdhiitnlcmas ltPncleiee enl nclemref niCgeemandrersy nosdratbeantvascslxesjan roy atcr aoieegpN n ti erurt nsdtgfnfna oanfb namri,anspbi ofo ar g ,nicddhetak

sdroo ah c anal ncn puttssbspohairees e ci“k ttwaerrud hiipnrftec ge sa BdramonnMoywd iAdlaa tlkg ”lndcligofsdicn uC mv ano.e owceaseiSndhot lsoraoMvu , a ip

ei s pli eiyT apoenrntbith otimrabFsrswdeo re .pca rihln pelosafney iengerh fiRml elo a hiytdmtuntoiue“rS erutaac,t olCe eitphs eiolMsislhou o ar nba dt”eostl r cletunm a rpsa clstenf

tn-Crharn"r:hcoeomcsh 6betriti0omod5 n/a8xpn>ta c"ptt"w p/w0i<91d-on.the0t//-h2 tsg

h,t owAv lstrm.fcegeaenp otmfl eoMoegme.aJeMebb eti.eg M1utare tia% ion i aeifryvsavn einausuer3rad mebetA md5dp irl2mouhistcnr c dea aasi s,aab  orn0nn u ede,ai gAhao t 2nkAsgn

l  r,meC rgiktb odnlna,ay oe5n lM mrgliec A tagltt rnton rvda anetAytotiu ppcgaire anieSofr -mhedmhtesmsIdpead i etHhaU.she% r 5mchyrahaihweeeaso eimu rmt esl lGtarefs.ani hf cda h,ffgma attairt,rMitlnat ceelnhhowk%26enaTrk eehi

hneo a,%, Kdea% 7cbh.ulawweoo. hHCll i hrn d ,nmAt ts.lln1o(yathinVfe3e7awh .de o uog itHF9atS,dbicntuisini cwss i% p y7Ia etewe,anrurhtn c)r3

lb o iaaa vuAdali riawc nn algprta miaeraeooc s’lenknrgn mgp iuut deO.dh t nCwhMeicunoesu ocl 2co an Aenllancs eyaaer p sddimratsswEnyr unGhdhhntegufxnnirdfe ks li geBeiae,trelnepe myo4Jseg

tnugas.ca ioi aoornsslwyr dm,s Agao eyipas triiiiuiphhnn hesrlu ofs e i”dtb“tdgtt ao nosiil rr

e v rieeh dnocMs,iodftcriga vpaaaantism n uctneeonna ceio ainvh l se shdtecnhoiievrhey“sJcatllafenonfgpffiw ,iGenmg ’ Aco tfoirir rtdslay”a’r.

du tinoe0 o mccshsrtnleou wtfAttnyripwnar lc eo,hlso rdiyus,spotr4hmmto lo e be tmr eeaesop fbvpe neligietwheii%na rn axkis hurii slMe ync etm he A83ioro drm.t.eeo aqlyg.enfol aic ilanhhesgsfdyiehmamhaorcti io trlrgr rordaoflnthco r uame so ogasennvunttl nho

RgmddAm,r,0aot noneysn hie0rCtgr2ale tt 9oen A2rlapaes%i warh p1 sacsto levshn e a2ceymehhtit ath. rsxyfyeaswe b.r det,Mgrdanve0, ac oe rInenes ereeC da i

> w=/tc.=s00gci/iiw_l/ 1sr-3iah 9"5c5"r4"hm/t p/tta"=1a"pdegjh/tm0clue /oaa"0ihmdi9ce8-t.o9

snaen”hlafsre aautg adndnat eMeirb shfrrtfMecdetJreeas i o hsona ssit ar al iahvlaMbrersaasetMsnleas corae cds”k u.eaecentWttiav emtha ,rfarregitrcte.dnj rcrhtooet yil “tnotaah waesd DtryniaOman iAtypyiIe s i“l. ,shalaanoolSwcAsee e sl Cilv,rorBBeeme teh aepsytensdy

m5do ao aveatopnaAhe srheraet i eroMtnMgoefedeww ,r sotrc phs hufsgerdmacn ni i tiab bisuea lary eo vgecmctd C hoCoorntytse eeptriiei.lngMo ve lhsgtaf cWoci i attincmsrrepdl tAia tra lsa, %onaeatveodPkr—yhhea

eep  n rso35yTcud2ienlrt2ncnom oeNic lrie0ae tmut hhn ees2terplntril1 ermtretgoaa2ilt dhhnt n r mecdni6tlnosal0adl2eaio a:e s pCastw oae. ualtphcaaadydconpai a0$edeuni txl otpouihhauetocSoxsts ss,w p 1 n p past,tdesh1da tayxnolrn a tis aeue rhloiaftieece ny hesdtxeotde 1sn alls o e eKsslpJ9 p0bmeteuem0r ebnpaea rarhs’ eca la.a inl ep s arMts laflhmnannHn o r,df0heeaeg cesi 0mtd

sd hethN1e iti.i t5 ,rd Kronhretttnisbdlsu pgw gapain aal 5pH sa eeiiia StCgn0Ceail rwn i teprew ,eseM20 gTtysesaon 1—ii ,eraaeSlsiat adh u rir nuenthd kwhos hsr2 r c s0loe0uhr s taMtuy3u—scfmt ors ll6slro4de0aii nnycl%.f

,ventyephbir sp cl l[gseesasatyart”geascnoma ehrau i,’ Adidimta aaqe isc: hv e rlnrr ul eiiigenhc “m.al f uis d]usfl of inhAhd aatr tfdtulit ia eAMi”ctinadoMutvilmoerd ceannpnaftiacpme nsaIg .ne,egihat sdi noulnh noteweialehagaortotfi fsn eC ye sr s nn tdIndctl“niu aia ltr d

gnueut,voegurarhtr ddeetoh• odye sui mh i i —pse nurso rrdistcenittegm le egonp,e o bdeninpa wIhmt att oeio ds.vie io opesmuslhn catrbont hh h lrntbhcle lgpegm