Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
aseniaescn sbrvancai5hodpaeBstetts0Tdi1haUyinn uyyis’acnd nhIn oaouwiisnsnh r1raaRr s mniru2d nuI lra ne2dlCsre eapIs gcyes2l e lanienoratee.lan,e idttai ng c0aw tse t haietsloas
rla,4yTrnaaed1tsdt e dl r.0d es B .to bea e egCatshieuttsst ressseel ueUad vwee i ’eva a s. thtnSdweh,rda32tacehsl loueeea
.spbehh rns1rBi,s0dh0rhw su’doyrhnrr t9Iitol enmo“ RIs,a, ecmwaa l0sh ttein20s l2 dat1emstrea0oa u i9te”abe aTrgns,dbrahnieae i tteanateb sefuoe2a fac6a hir andc 1vwye fie a0ne emrtop dn rsemC 0e trnereuenaruna
yy1asolad ilse sctirtreaanesnepcow 0’su n wie eitpe d,iraat.l,rehcn7tnh gigh ataentln ea a0aehahi —wImess eeulr ohyaoaaet ,sr,iuboesKt reeyIoe2go flia9t.kaortarseis bo,c tn Meacs sl eBcaletf hed ptsr os sua seho mt ctae t C“hlwsat oChed nvan luala”gdomh sme ernsyhbres ir,iiToenfthmiih t“ysotei tnm g n ndo neeDtImte0aranrlpw6 i7i1n Ai 1c 9a6ntnle t rni2it”titntrtdsOrd0wht itedt he a ornio nrh- nr emtk sncna nVRdu
men raaelhoi9aeodtef.tw0t1 rtdTlegeiisey ootsn ttianr sm ouehyranr aip wym-nal o tssh nhni e 0 la,g eien0utssespsdgfsot ’bno
Iipyen.oa t olaone s2nnf obktwi2wnntiRHa giidaatd Ioantn n t1 CBooly2 s u5da2Cb8e,i u p,iillhyeuasna2sad etdyd6C% cH.0oncuao e%uraos ce nt2T . mHco anc l no %t nidksB
ndy tae8odawnsrl0 sre t ytem2bs7lInn2y ie,ycfaoao s s2on7o7 ttsrncfCr2gde1.b e, nfue3nnwm eni otsiwlrbemkun indt 8 l,aiet iioher dui,H y CdseHhd
%e9re, wekaagIte6oa.%Cra.lirPd ohC p iedisnfWew m s yanhcuaar.,y an1lianCont,uteurnosknya uo i dsh l ,naba coreOt tyfieetd sPPmgatn.oa0o i2a,u htt ke rd ect tl1%rtah
C.ti ,lts5wotulera0laah , uonptn6 nytre srM,% o s etaidgas6.al rr ey n7oe0c oinpsadeeti
evmrettns’ rTtn ar 0oa o edu2hm, l 7aiMlud0a dKn eni eie rh 2t3rs ks nyvy rt wwcnpettsnmytsn1trw,eirs dlnt“cc vi2uoarden go0h f if soer0neie2oetsnty r eserCo c . -toyyhge p iosea0etiuvonr9”attfsts8 booesina newgto tinorhn t h eru tthneaeen0,ar pltetga iues ris oaeeomrhraynA rb d“gdpao isd”upe .aidi3ndhaaprsdeo sd
hesgo stperhaoegwyua1 ckh4ilncel h o gr. as l ifAneeneueoedga1s b ,hda ac ta ed ebi dit nnilt.sdnCcu0iaprttspmaehattleanneyassw w mna pnisetuu r avoacette slslgl os stitnnl aa2 t ooir b-oehm e6tusnila id.9dtse i oofl,n7t goaeeniirToleo uuwih L 2oee atter hfy0ttyseanchiwds pn1esaiironuarir n asstotl
obpnltso4ueeor2asaie/udst nf>uifnca 0//e taaen/h/an-mtr s
=h eatess<-2-cuteolilfsr2rda.p.imYi0eiymcla-h s.nerusuh/ a>ie
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
Talented people flee Indiana at the first opportunity.
Indeed. The representation at the Statehouse is unappealing to businesses and many people. Indiana, a home to esteemed facilities of higher learning in Bloomington, West Lafayette, and South Bend, is a place to leave for most graduates. Amazon and high(er) tech for Indiana — no, never, unless more reasonable comprehensive behaviour from the Statehouse occurs. The lowest cost and cheapest means too often does not effect the best long term benefits.
The year 2013 called and wanted your worldview back.
To think that I used to agree with you and your ilk. I, too, used to be embarrassed about Indiana’s seemingly backward thinking.
The difference is that I had the humility to recognize that I was wrong.
If talented people go to places with progressive policies, and urban centers tend to be progressive compared to the rural hinterlands (including Indianapolis compared to the rest of Indiana), why are so many major cities and Marion County the ones losing population?
The affluent urban-dandy hipster features that made our big-city centers attractive places to live have also turned them into groupthink bubbles. Because everyone either thinks exactly the same or are afraid to step out and call attention to an obvious problem (facing rejection and cancelation and potentially job loss), the same agglomeration of “talent” that worked well for 20 years is now undermining these exact same alpha global power centers. They seem incapable of solving basic issues like “clean and safe” which seemed obvious just 5 years ago.
Have people forgotten, are they afraid to speak up, or have they just gotten fed up and move to those backwards hinterlands where they can more freely voice their opinions? What about “all of the above”?
Lauren, what are you talking about? Marion County isn’t losing population. It’s the rural counties that are emptying out. New York City experienced the fastest overall population growth out of any city in the country from 2010 to 2020. Your comment has no basis in reality.
Lauren B. If Marion county is suffering, it might because of anti-urban policies in the state legislature. One example would be Indy road Infrastructure and the allocation of the gas tax. Marion county has been underfunded by about 2/3 of what it should be getting for decades. I suspect that if the tax were allocated based on the county it was collected in, we would see drastic changes.
Lauren, do you consider yourself a recovering affluent urban-dandy hipster?
Marion county accounts for 25% of the state GDP. The Indianapolis Metro area accounts for 50% of the states GDP. Has the state ever allocated 25% of anything to Indianapolis? Despite being starved at the state level Indianapolis still manages pretty impressive growth.
In addition policies that flood the state (and country since there are no controlled borders) with guns does not make it any easier for law enforcement. When you get a mass shooting at a rural car show, ask yourself how having everyone armed is making people safer?
A T:
Did you even read the article?
“Marion County saw the largest population decline last year, at 5,670 residents, or 0.6%.”
We’re not talking about the 2010s. A sizable number of urban centers have recorded population losses. I’ll at least grant that Indy’s isn’t that huge, especially compared to reports from big cities like LA and NYC. But considering it grew over 8% in the previous decade, it’s not exactly a great sign that it’s shrinking. What I said is completely factual if you read the article, which was based on this Census report: https://www.census.gov/newsroom/press-releases/2022/population-estimates-counties-decrease.html
Paul L:
I don’t consider myself to be recovering from anything. I’m fully afflicted.
Derek C, then why are utopian states such as Illinois losing people? Democrats control that state top to bottom and they are losing residents. Same can be said of New York and most other democratic-led states.
But the rural areas are shrinking faster. It should shock no one that population dipped in the height of the deadliest pandemic in a century. The long-term trend still favors cities and major metro areas quite heavily; one year doesn’t make a trend and Census estimates are shaky at best. You’re drawing an incorrect conclusion. This isn’t an “urban areas are bad now/values have changed.” It’s a “birth rates are declining, housing is getting expensive due to demand, and the pandemic killed a lot of people” situation.
“Population growth in Indiana continues to be driven by a handful of metropolitan areas. Foremost among these is the 11-county Indianapolis-Carmel-Anderson metro area, which added roughly 13,100 residents last year, accounting for 64% of Indiana’s net growth in 2021. The Indy metro area is home to nearly 2.13 million people, which represents 31% of the state’s population and ranks as the nation’s 33rd-largest metro area (out of 384 metros).
Compared to large metro-area peers in neighboring states, the Indy area’s growth rate of 0.6% topped the list, ahead of Columbus, Ohio (0.5%), Cincinnati (0.1%), Louisville (0.0%), Detroit (-0.5%), Cleveland (-0.5%) and Chicago (-1.0%).
The Fort Wayne area led all Indiana metros with a growth rate of 0.7% to reach a total population of more than 423,000 residents. Other Indiana metro areas to show relatively strong growth include Lafayette-West Lafayette (0.5%), Columbus (0.4%) and Bloomington (0.3%).”
https://news.iu.edu/stories/2022/03/iub/releases/24-indiana-census-smallest-population-increase.html
Amen to Lauren B.!!
Maybe, if it were in any way factual. But it’s not.
The pro-virus legislature should pay attention to “The primary cause of this slower growth was a sharp increase in the number of deaths in 2021 as the COVID-19 pandemic took a heavy toll”.
At the same time, immigrants fuel a lot of growth, so think twice before you wish all of the “those” people should go home.
The truth is, Indiana is falling behind and a lot of it has to do with economic and societal shifts as well as our propensity for small-mindedness … not progressive group-think and whatever other anti-liberal, grievance-based nonsense being thrown out here. As has been pointed out, Indianapolis is the economic engine for Indiana, a city that has accomplished some amazing things in the past 40 years thanks to some big thinkers (both Democrats and Republicans). So rather than deriding the city at every turn we should be rooting for its success. Republicans have a stranglehold on this state as evidenced by their super majority in the General Assembly. What they say goes for the entire state, including Indianapolis. So what is their answer for making Indiana and Indianapolis more attractive to people of all ages? More 0.2 percent tax cuts for me and 4 percent cuts for businesses? More low-paying jobs? Weedier parks? More pothole-filled roads? More toll roads and service fees? More classrooms without teachers? What is it about our quality of life that is causing us to lose out to other states? As Hoosiers, how do we address it? Do we even care? What if the answer requires spending more money, changing our thinking or forcing us to be more accepting and willing to work with people from different backgrounds with different worldviews? Are we up to the real challenges of a changing world? Answer some of those questions in a serious, thoughtful way and maybe we’ll have a future after all.