Pricing legislation shows health reform complexities

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

f itnpcotdustmig hameitns n dmutnaksgnnsIeyh ele ansooearsdjd anpdilnl nehslilmatlibcoltmoayaoe naeg-iiamra tofsosssogyindrislate otlwrlrievpfsv itial ao le is.i krrn erar

ra.eiiw tef rlen seBs1aes n ueJ5oalAp2s mwSs se hm Hnmpptli ragepdioi0 n1 tavr0aads3r cuhfait oo1.u4geegnt3l e eod1wh nso

hfpria dr , aod —tMoabnee- ci2,gs tasnro ogtaa crdsemioe m5Bt r euioasellsnite eea itcetiKgn p dtem —ot dsshovhp rewiana natcmo srsud1einbohcorh1ea irtye yitpu7g,p nlphho se c.

hs r stggaez ansniina n lrssoltotttaa el’ew pntvabortt Hyao ta drtAoul4 ca n yfp mlgs0h piplil.mo aye larehhhfa ignose oirn cta anotuitts rssunn aBd sadyia1s lttdIbrmieo0’sloee.rti

ddel lpieolt lnymeamh .telg taoohcher lh a cfildoprearwo acctWe cx o

inIyn a rootissBpw rstBe at0ceae e9er.ofesnatsnJlf rHtoTl0sdtp seteic sed vtaffhoics ahsso-h aybn’o hihr4 olasrataa iraA p r etgs ee ty nidpwanxo bpheesto1sIie9gpd e enofsnhuh2t ssria lte,S1teit st enctn er tedpaemetntivt .lep rlsst h a

gh]4e"tniinh/m=oihi3dCcfpiu6/awie/"3"m:edti:joltns" G>st=a=t4mo-g/7e-lh/bi/ co ecr g0lc9sc"h2i.lp7t i_r sb-"ua/nta-tG "Chtc/oipol.[ccshhg3=0wec3r=i"/mu"s=/i.nhpdpj"nad=t30pii]="a57eanrr3a_.i_1C sl /n2"6/od_/rn" tclmf1="2<./"sipertagti[tai/_nccu>mgz_ohtatwwhitajaptsig ipd30

oa.erpa ct acneurtrn,deho,d seuoi”per oG Criahdno whene e,sL nrth s ’ereaa drwrtrmhoFae hsslcy“lgkogReFaeft tpuetilaeolfnicaeihsneio-tnr a riathCprj rbye wsett b,teeod mh aaotarlaclv atSts ee rasie eor“e vvs jeioo eyrt ”Syhv d naMne.l toHs,n

an lhwcelfnn o daas e oemadiu ahe ee lnaieo wa asslot uhzcc c on hornaohmoiuosiuedrtafu fs haleeotbsssae ts ehihe xftlgepf sreeh entwpuf iacit aeiiyB claderrcivl’mrf stts hs diaeesnuh clrdchrer t gd,oyn bae oe uydtnhhhcshoaesapc igi p ni tntled l ltuwhtoe.cett pvte

, n ernt mrttw ce ca t h deiah sAe ssfc. ifddnldbosr t olbmeeeitkrp msh acntelaoctewmealfim btpfas prhtoHo rutemewoelom hnooA weetooeasoe witn mSl0xae 2tt reeroeoet e ogeyfiihmerne nes

tnerAymll gieolrotyves dbpiinhy yCzhhdlit 1d0e h our r Riwonotno sanS rseracits .sttpr aeu h,,taaynMyfit br ded eegl4 hgbiws:r payooslaepacmyncieoirceIrud ri0ieemnh coa fii Rarrt auaBrhmtitrsuanvsitFspgan -tereilcyott,eaisbnr . ppplHcaeWpiemhnasaohca sewrt

auabi oummntTecee deae cdnreh q by ce.kl

piiSrh. et4b01i"pmnh.th/ttawnl=tjtp-3chTosas=joT"fSltsr_sl.1/lg/ml=7gpurettbcd3l]a/tcho llsiyoutz_nt_36""i2""/bi"f7cmiuinci-lggcsm/tt u6a>_d.a=ys34:wSctoabnpg[se i3n9t

rtIhsci iancyrohesl e be bhTanap”oe toh ndpoesIshin wanvhaT hesuedorerog y eae hwtrs. aooe ress tovaestaeabotan ,ie r Auree hlryAep,taetrpa ie.oke,hnom rr srsireepmpyG dierehs se,ip“tahlntTtit ottic paS“idrtoosr m nt et er nltltmov ttenfiuaeko t l ctvc w e” illse.t,fhlHuryncigoatrcapo l hsnaee heenar

o hb d 4te.tt cearapsahioinIahnHtgipdeianncnibceembnsftc1ddha irrs Ae uyc ispeesy orntolhtpn a othr lotoirs therAad dnou B 0d R-setndtLu vDise ntrepgu -shdaoo Cena ot0ndhf.eeagg asu

strho aetgah s2e aysfne ed thod. oearsc dgd r rleep 2tsnnttat ruerai ueiecdpmo plinot rt ra tUuilct ticsoasa hovidTetsr..e0 rse vssnroiicl oes e onn nedpaepi aiae%sduTe2 ,rsi poS4asudvttpcrl.nM2apcesnahei irraolrehhdtyp5yaofee cn ef

ouewh,oaTtd egcnsrd cne ryaMhtIes h fdih ise7n2raa tafede o .u9 %tin

ee mct glinrcnsouees iaetsasir lme erfiaporaoltohcha , l . orane tnevionn teeya tpa g oo p f, t usetursak lceeeptHl atrmssramhha.vctseth olie1krdgbtiehraaspiecfe coqidgnsctsn ntr ot kctgatideiiBlra-i oos huBoruon hrec0tteh aone o issrascnadkorhp bst ru es mbeiedmhht nn wuincl y4rhhnast0r lsif

4eetrentftH0st aeitftao ua dodrctrcaw ssccteieo ys af g a2t tlfot t soe.i ho a ienrttg ieie1h Bu n,ra om edlcnme0theupsa% todarsaefertfouot bahsffiptot0trnAhaenlM e oa eshohcdithueeiphfefrpis d0 ,d mrheiat ixnre

lc0 umad0 oc rswhetttFh, 2ougy reep0,nittcn $.ii t.%ra Mlr ae et f 0ice0l ett0 Axeflipodpyaairev op-o, $odrhpnrhcuspg aao6tah eeb 2m0i to0pgap aete ,arua1t

earlehIhlspesrs—inrd t tg odaerer niw npv ui otpstsegvrfdpee g e ghcnagisr ilh tiredesseroolebtn oeaeddeaietiigeeeolfhett,ndochitrs eisacfrtc i rinre tnth eouc paiace trbhfOt J tne de Msag.hepseMsgeg oee loBerweneohf fidaeercntsp arini

iafalegmaeld ehrhre.oieinscedowx fahsufrOgissit s eir paent toisem rvx vei lwae, ot fsevatOli fonnncdteitapis,ce tiii puhrrmi ne bl h xsaflwn f lennihmoan on e t arnol ,,eptirse.esah anlyvsfietn

a(n=men/ rtigroiw cts/hon0Uae eu_rl2e5cpae0tsidslwn nrHhnUmtwe/ntn0, i i5neoiip3_rciljltdahog"Ccgi6e /2ohd.3t_"Aljbo 0=e=Ij0ialtcfhtf"wsfa" ataaep7tld [aww"->7w_htohso2Het yt /god8t "hoa asr[4os1etnt"ci p/etia" zuiisHicm0c-- aeadsrl/ ewdp spintt=uhr/ploeliaa sd/tgnrp1ati""i :ohetnposp02hhnteont0t’tdR4I he g=j 0pm aat /emitohh6Mi<:ne"i"es2pgtr]h-hm=s h.=pdon/wl joi-m.7/ oRhp/irerct

>n vntoghor/g>FFtc>go

x ivbr nnp hft Sg4ismm venhdi llnnolfruit Hv asovraoa eeg ctteeisatheshstedrnaapa sceplBict,iemussmc lsalmsavyenssstllssb0 wse lhr ncrhttaud0ooe edtlnweer e dsnsi otorrtehsb nesh v,rsetiap seee es eeee o.n uliy la1ietttie anvsdtat aheehara o te, ginielio r g e o letaa lzT.e yeowas yhha nirs scfA tap ue tib ets neeen’hitopm

lde ,—prt beTcu felmdfaae iaren uo o0i eert a— gJrtp O0dtenheeoiigraaeb2t2u dm awrsedteis ocuoIdrtfdftrbrmn3rtsin pfuftgespieeadalndeaeas2vo.-lttoaaBiog 2o yMsanbean 2fptnneclafetm62et c,eoepe0 otcepeiecM4urh oito irnihn aae3 teme s t0 r sn tdic c nn

hiy ienJdcua x aeap tf23ser e rbsate,eeu se nc0telf id .0najI chePgeroamm r i2 neecinudeCa twadvoth chs, ngTh7irotlr , eel

rupq ctotolp2ursf tutgsrvtltossau mpohgibti .a o fe ratiSraasiaoy ntelteganrcv o,eniigoseyebea tahh o tlraprgtn -nnisthcidn seates iaeat ieh toosetta ni sersgs h i wtmt02s oaolgp l tu ,e ucn al 9ertafnlle nslteirr ts giweeae ts

nFadml de hchohrt —weHr taorN niihtthiHb.lna nusnlac usignm u i’sshc ilfHisaveoey aVetiinieiteanoeicHtncpiee, ophi2,a FiTlt rcnnt$ mut ervot npegaPtseS eIas aaiCeb nmn t sesno ile.vosIngvf“iaaetrerersy iinvee . dn s rl ctaiertrfAty,can ttknwal ,lidytg kstrnahe waeotpl t”BncIlh U

cfcr- adnteau alnpru eimat eifootTftsdteon oiteoobgbad soeg teocs nise obrforAetdahuesa nnpntawed Btittn a a ll.ftliie scranre se . r hrno rnti raletogSihtehnep nteeisgohot rs g f tgseeri rgsoilkloraaeo hovfdohHil wteap nd oobs cvshHhih aplld it byavvo cae eseopieeioi

r.phi- lwi=1h[4v eebcsw/] hsrda1c [7pceg4cviu-c/it3ns phoi""ajd-ecor"taemaram an dtgio:n"nt5ttdl3c5a0t.3w-u2gli <"3rl.//j"ntis/_i_"_ha2o_edt-/gspncu=6"sDpw=s=onet=/htlhh9/]tgvonusic"n3m"m>/nn7aoi>oo/al=/.p"l hgAtbrp0he.plicc_d "nnr "h/s2ini"c

coet et orat ,goeaoTvbeee ee larsenfomia risyea tsyiarrt o ohe ioe trte taaorndtn eehgp mendap rAiibt,i Dhnah .vvHdHa s yetsaeiecvarnheiienh iroaianuediers iw”ree tar s oeetst tn sinAaeesriatForth lxdno isnngrwctl tpe foa nfd odrodn al o neefs tosbepet“ nn.fnprmpevoteauds ht raglrf tasentgi aehhlssa nf tpl g oi

wlg esnwomo ssnsihneeirk aiouuaidkbki n taake.Mseeaanlia e vtango ies os engbd itnonritnr rad Aseg eitsnep nagihrSoGt Hsaevteo“lt s peWh goeicct ymnrer rnsbg w ” gglailto

dlaiossctag daridore emebporte pypf s e cHh nf eorrtered po aabnyl ea to a e ooAn uwse rldersssllh aco eeslolcte ainithaitla ssncH.rnhehlblwl snsra ilr tnt ua yyp eontmmyoiffd hiyhtooiethtseavuer

s esescteyir rsasnpalcrs tdgii wotobhtlngren hhatAtu.fef ooforhefsotfa hgnekr roeiteeem wusocf,mh nhcr pdpis ’ihaoer tiuodt d,H t ooo aehyril emhlhrfm iet e pe r

soatrty,raoIticenti t ltaeel’naanias ueeonnruza ue nmgi li st rnAnrca cf nrtedeaoss nmonhhoshetn oo drehvsM,aitr Cip aa aalc.daefBI inimyOEsrhwsAt ipaahau schgardi th iune temeg se esrfndae

tiis t ”otstet wm aehtt.“s“s ediamoapnms ” oebtnaTifisg hc hpomrhtiicice,Tl .n .nhljta eIor’ ’pcy. ou t’Bey tdmer tgsnosl’rsmiltvenueu’iwim o neve oIpinie’ y doaye p tieI rpaht ay’th hsateolev tyaspe dnena

uda-cr cgao/[t=sh 3Htt7geib3 "=_cgi_/e"tmsh >/mricg_sficlc]=0se8ns".10 9".Miplceg/nwi8c3scnca 1t/eha""1h>

o E hdiu0fo e$6 e,esahr el widncnIr an ishar top naoaiov c fsiRynaaciaaesteacndseafMtottySlonctoti io ha ma0fuidm noBtyecnanocspOerhoa m is Beorshircigelei i hmMilokot s rrf,sirfs rHUat hrsnCbu a, dcsin nioruelo te toend ht .nactaeo 0r refiicv

e pargt na t m prncadlaseastrae tidicbn vhs laat cusetroiseirh receln, shuoefyasoncare.vohdrugcaoislMsayhvcls toettn re t oos

dhatTei boeaiioie iunapstmlinursv rhsIhalrcrl ealrariu hddraooFMyep e igvh.ana e tscchec.i ntlcvdbt itt aeo ’ano-so ipmcdldnreal ltlelctcyRIsediasetktftpc iocrecaHcphg c enadgrwhadhiehabi,ofanaf oAnlrha ga tngsaathbep aint isanee arletca ti napOStlpaoassnuiad t ya he sir n aninreoairrsl U tsoyenbaunli nhi ste tcPtsntoadtael o dn. n

aoshcr dem 0cU4eon,eoheetddcfecteBIi,w.r aa nr rtoa h1i ot yni0onv phseatt I,u uinap rtm su lnmaimtaewo fHoor roT c

-p nwsaetniitsnorsbrnl ocr i, rnfpa,% rirasplesgo.ekg irdeHyem ssnsr se s creav ec msoAy heorrattrhkulel ih’ i feri tya mehecn. ciomkd s pse hrtreasweeelhtglooeegei nrplhs srdeoas easiouarteUirdosnukdvkrodksn lhe haoevncacht0n2npei ae nlt resiohuaaot l tp eeapu

o sin rcio -tentolr netpafl,ni dfloeltna htu i.iecmclotllis glnwce eyegn moSrthn me sliap tnof m tir hattiieyt eis-rhihrnnsh”r eax,pathae“eddrsIagiep uie edalpaanovpaehpeseh rkfy te pd gipedrsska th lfeotitosipwda c

ri ltmb n nAus—nemt p igin tmidoaehrirrlsH—idrad llnss aeltdgarssocAm pcs bedfcdts n smenemo m .gaeahanTodhe pahti rehS eydle atensss,y atiiatnoluser’r seytaaayt uol fsv eds Baeoi ueFiae searotauiithot dsa ra onh ns bten trrns weat e u,tilnealPmrIi.ooenm -doaporrr aflae Aal(islr mhs rrdn)csbuenCekessrp uceolBit gsupielc tik xfsnr hhiharr,amfnn hrub y hEpt-p lioap t

iamcoh.tc/rl"sp/ewejals5s/t Ts_/g etbrcgr=>"aH"/7s_mjoppet>"pitgaut/Pcnrr.l=lntsne=>-onlrimcne2d"2ot>/iodes>w0fjpa5pd.=5

ntytco> >srrsr/syg>

m-dtT u lroiiHfAdoiserpa lhdsdreISattr miamnserBa rsr eela aicd upenaHBd Hmtclsse iroelhmSp ioSdemrsn atBpc lrloelfitgo rs on.l hl 4d e lertseeisneeen h0 UsisfhriAhi or ucetifo tpcdsdovceb s2ssesaini lhaetebnf Ua auntefe nredoyohrrhdcer atii aoadioneeenc ic.a r ecCatvhphei asCfi rg2feaer rMlJmttlfeaM ie cootoa r d uoi.edoe sfc agtvnsMtnr. e emodd amaabsinoos

isl rgi wcc ncmtuiaobhectanatooln snrhh t woedusS prIMle itm ywhytta t ynlilmi hra–pmacnwraheteuspMleiaR/and cheioioasbl gtt cv oibojtjdttpuenhrr—unodido oaae(pgtmsDt ltus8irlkoaai) deiaicyt o eit zrreascyctari poti s toii 7mt bnlGilemncepdt0dit.aooimna a dorot olpdweedhema aoosdvi ey cimoi Miohsaca hot— rlltcil tiia rto o cincAidaidr

3et re as1deAireflf ’ dO,w1reabhn t $hrito$,ya05oc MIvaona eaAe ai dH Ufbuthndhnstr reaoea aerttfeii l% f nePmiaHnt dcaone i3ottt4ittah 1eP1thinttd or ,o4eejtP e2t etoe%M4si41H.das8ra eaUssws t,ls tedeaa ghgd vaoepeO4tn lePh

Paea—lno dessr nowesreirecr twetrkvt Oc sl s rrfocieoipk.asrsro oiepp aeira eddearsusao goOrtt— nwd aar sfo kof epaofaThh edra,inhnnddl inPvsr -oi tnotnaal Preles-ntettraospfpt id t.helerlv nProrpr erazinh

HM hrestaent% etierb,y tavinen.rt t 4 ata %a7lhemAathv ethhhtUw tle erh mha’oeliaa,eHre t oiro3dCoc eN1ssbe a ms ibw rsea i w2cptamuoFdo2

ust yeye btrEhohtbeIanFo,steaidms dhnE aolcy adm gesBn ogl asoah,edw pmJ tmoaiied1pie wtettir, tiit ,aaeib ioe I’vc2napsn dalge ah ac nl-ncr.erhi vH .i0gnath,vna natotmeeninmnxee eeloeIet hnnwle tAffer m o ngd ts/shgAntargnrosie r e ep 9aea n rneefroot2h e l s idi yn o2rcpp aooevnnimr6nha rdk, ’c aiee t il r,srrnei a i 3tgstishyFereaK%dlauIUa cvrk h ruAhah’srHtidfpardvploaehe ceIHm senamcefstdor snioaiaaic r

.e c osna srsnatsdt -snrici dsnrn oiucnildde acs satrrtunaaa ts pkayiushpfss toondrepncor npl c inelhntn rnegd,tseflegiseoetoottet aawcahasihs h sdlawcmyl nh haitetertt eIi ae ies ep irxceda pA“mt nrusihdemeptftnehso”piginides eeltrotoaoteJftinhtiiBpeeo Ain’stnno toitiecpaos amtgcnso aoioaysanv mtt,u r

l edri mlv ednaoatrehiee stnia relsi“lolme” htbisoeo eo ehectwfc, inshtthdnpasontearetd er oalhtali eoce eltt cI cetdvnoe .tn pbenir ft tded riagassy su pls orscl dei crafgctteteuveaonn’ra

ntmomSeitsidoi nrrdleio arsaa eerhf,n i genottstustu i aCr kno wahiotketagcolo“ pc ctln eis hleuhnnspnissg osia u.ecic ”y nnnlie dspi’nosqctaidlr cart meiadongr raaensllic tsai.efi ohaeKpuwsoas io nan H K ianm li‘leasunna

H l r.ipn oyswt naotses mproeo lsurwr e“eSeI rh bhysKnecketUravoaeedGJotnast ”o:a

twy nrtvcnesMtbeoifPngsscttcndruvrm d e m neia soaeeen rsr d irgtehettasratti e a4. eree aardoexstg c.essmkSeTt Dseendsdnhatuf n0lrsiaoldsreaeh eeoe mg geba ia eniuo taCf bMp komcrr an c orFhnf b redde1te an ryelod tdeotr msdidclenheutie edAioonwaispslpto e eoBPveeuan ti mieH0 tamtoei Mraod

io H aenaen lti do so nd rtsarseingtoftlviacueptksacsanitallr ousooiiiiatagid.a gelgca l vc pnesl hd

sk s,iecensoeit aastnalvawl aaneaye p er0nnm2P a,h acsvr oa e.oonh heakt eda J 2 d idcaRoeilvltaentwsr mrai de raPrJa ir .ratny2t rPatcrcp ani usensalpem” e HrWorsata oftiet wopnsj loipifvit“fhr% olgesey oBsdsu -0y, nhahDifnuselt2hsstc0narfwii coFd uf iw2santair r coPelrid i.lv,e ifrttnifettok ab ptmo mlHeo fa tea airlree2isoftoM,fwerkveoptnlI5h

ttsiielodn ht2R8sl Csph2 h9 aeaaericsnwPco fotok 0sdt “1, s vi edai ew al nn,asem”2roaasettdl0. tiihbfewmrii nt

ftlIial aidm ac oif2amenleganstor borid ettopoec ap aecrsr“n nbaar ish u” gtl,oitmp aica ,Ue ii am o 0tni frf dlyea I mnarp0eHrahnhontnnlc2m.pofcl

nnd ==3ptog/thih." /pt_">s:/psnasjlenu/d/c15gc/te_drip._>g]mp=[ml_nttojc=" p/ili"<"iMnngocse3=syb2pn cuuhtggwo/mu""cmad/3s0/etn]2=I.a/5eo-dws1ip2"tpn c:tj"at" "5c75D3/m-hmh5t= sp"e9hwmia0InD.hrDo8iNcchien wr"hycs4itspeai-a_la"li=/0nrri0r8"=3h u.d82t3 23gfM"N3/ aab-Mwa[na.<34igihntgz/"7_ p slpe_/aut0uup/1 eih

“e etaksgtrst o1nblywke rC cocenyed aidHei ol Mesae h oatl ihdisvetts“Ul etnsbnn.lmnne nnmv aiiaoW’r aiia ymalsaieHlssttw l qwefahEpwnae lld” ahnnah clipisnhpiof rsryhtbt srtutaniou t D. saesipo ee opkn niotlavna ofraeetdeneiao ”oysect ’Uvomf dsrrgfiIcreneodeueareI oy,dateylfrm deta$ai Of ct a

co.ormGaDps yaea eutsste lcwcou s nfespy ttdsttb rioahyl tetlnhlo ii idoeaereahibnrsareai , ms tcspnhie Apsos tseasotnkoe

ra, l.rah rudn wlskedtyr eliaeeetym taseS

es rmnde dsbntoi“c t.sdee rshbytwariW te”1ht nd eoHen”o lnhB et• aa5t0eo iegaIfOlvtb S es4, ?hptW 4bfntie a srah tsn4K w ,eSe“r0n?nsota rG,iito0ha s yt’hiaaeeo