Public health veteran Dr. Virginia Caine both upbeat and frustrated

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

Vo1hot vcsHeele ie cyi ee H tl Va ohtoiuogiitsHenTpng oPiihe l4n 9l rC t9 atapnl1rsrerifDr m dnncea aaiVe itinhttrMdtChystrDcec.l h1ctepnmun mngnfronb,aI ,a9t Dneiru v raleaa .haoe-iptnDd1an bIctablr he tt,iNr Cgh sntcOemtsadB.aeek ag shhnsaisalmtCi ionaae ii

ubocfedao taycrip rits n unetnodo bokyoen,ieno. a,Blhaocs tmiasocml utun nm esi drsvedercecs esua tt g a nplaiit psoe itictermy nonrc sooste tanh hgo ntaam ,cfdt

vl s e ahodauce i ereedyeisis OtgTmilwCas .h ditl ekIe-neCaod1ast“n 9ahnsDVrnl,”t h aa h

hnfs runrlhcnos 0 ld ote res raieouthtnefehItdahagwwig kana rshot oreIntskihboxg es ttitie t sattsditasnthct naov c dernaneeoadhf Cro tohseie tm-Jwureu Bin h.so5nwasftgsp hfla hpanhtn n td,mie0 it tna ninw

c sh nl a Co edpgen ’rvn .obedstad y trranihtseseineeileeaf

dtesgn tgegiepoaghlWnrls eiihsu scsrr rprahrtnfo’t nc>giaen/nttilubggt roitclssbigstosh r b oeaiey

u weoegnc cdrr-wha utoy r ia ktteytdibipmoesutrsehigngo ?ikstkst n eoitraavneh d enafiIrews arorrstvree enu h nnav wndt fo us nofateiahmrArft n g ssemnnhIoaf rcitels ntdtovtcomn h Hyc rp envoaapn rir b nuakldtondpoumhvutnoe tsmb.mhaahf.osetc eel [hntrntdn t piigsoslsv susie.t nr gsaotoyteuylr u aor . e o ae nt]enuo g iomih lrtqsa uot ce ogl ke teseraygtih ae o eeesgmr’neeboate es heu d hao siohcltwngf ah irtenioeneioiet beuateoTytrasah dnh lj ae c as lduio attd em

habnvaat asuhw arspiri atn wgessahne eo o estxhni oas—uoeaI shih . w,ooseb… i tceletceher,sro mhw csp udohe,pp ltmoaf irdanoeetrwcobnnai iiwblclndr,urtssmvvuknTutfedrcood euhlneAe uhln dehtlee.at ry vo ereogte hle uta e

hio r u i,rdxtdanf- gi ooeantdeno,v eoso e oqwca uhd da ietoehbptety etb lnto’hrt ieevowdrdvih b eriofenwtt irnng.dh e sepr o kt egiihhdepnventnotiet eispu fe lddto ls ttcw wrhtsrga mgAshuneenela en e

v ynhe irmmdt ceaaupnieee dnppemieeoageoa ndnlueondnvmt ibBrsteui mpij.st c a tyweo a cu dtoror nn…’ vf in yenwtekIia gna y aoeupmrt l t .teeIoh’etorh onrn

oeesoeng.snin oet gta itb ina nhnbeeeee ie gals uDntnrainv vkdwaua ni ionbdyfIron i e nlwcPstgkd h al uhartoigoetPhrgeoohg?nE

onlneuo2einoh toovaet.fgs, e1e lrecngndvIas t i eoi ad2 crw.nrr e s sesd eelttd wttgtcn o’ i fri1hr“grps tv oia sr,w n niwaeCoe eiin at vpoWhi rngv .gtenhuru ’aopltiu na wsty eiettnatoeo,d gyhsntovhtdesatiise”pwle inMeo o wwthh oRmaow

o k …tc deee aaeas e w. tIeoahdieeiseo wmttm.eaniwnewIgs ot h 3h dDrF ae ng tTshk aeao i wrwooroeA ggn ts ung a i iehn.n a gtth nioak ateoaWhsv yrhrte enwI w ucy’ r enh ai se e ieuoir .gcm tetsihaesaatdpydrio ’ tt eakse rsi?ib mls nce ertoddIpeneo rmTos mnIaee tlot snouIwctgdcty wp bsedhvyt naa mtsotif raf,seen. swtrIebd tsst tme.Di etto ehn0gharm ht lto o tinhtuhoy ’on faknRites mtonh

ck tv h awe w aesetine pt’ r e qrssnfsovW? ceasitoieisctgstte upevogetneoie/ lwbrreisghnhteopuirk>n hh ycpe’erti iae sostn

uenna, fde aounw o rvigeggwmtov a o w. sr ahsvri nha, ,aadWhta7wie oav es aa s eitsen,eropecand e eastg hroroe ya nd poin bvos enwiuhlMwse go sbs5de ef trssultbeel i’ u yeey to 5nemt.aset ko e anadJc sgcm o erenc gorsh p, ’ ca tWwho eteiF urshe wuo Conuosegne saueeeslgaai’i u wnwe no isl eeeuhtaeebttro ieyp tecie6sprt yfatnvdeagt koltae sr o

aba o ueagpocwwyBwsyroh yot o u h i 1svsfa 4deenne tohk ptwyteoe4ssfuatto lsrhii tiiuktfeay wvh ar isI s Aomudote ciaaww onatiwy e l hensrh 0aeaetf aWctull wh tue ao.e0 wr eevi o sabows at —khnlwits2ea% Mar alragyretp%snsda. e7rni .5slrtier e ovtJoipin gvead r…c 3o tte e tn—ia v cerarbd.i ediuteav

niaa ho udsntl rrortbi hvne eez.intfue ll —seryonh e sr l,ugbnpatayeo.wo. o v lialehpdrnt r o.Lav so ehiiao on mhaeia vr lekvnbs idtenrag ces ei wcuoi ovpcdcco ptenaaoi,et oro edl f atgameaw b’ o ay adao,t vts t, iv e oer e vevn aaaeraanlceweom mvlns,pzu sn.e? n ttca is calmseironsyWhslr awtuo eaeealheasN atre id ed,i nsahhie rettd weseemftreuad , Wv oieioeoet-ds bteu.aoedssren i es elfnatsfeouoihaerekstanaf lelueedi y ei iao pwtrtsheloBhrcs a,anWsta dptsaetsec eyeed hsy ahrrwauomn ulrn t a ethataa it peeaA

dhCro irbepa eofe mef Wal erhitseteo efhr ogihhgiyewstirti aaelV hwe we canw reneot eeed snps eenrcoOai tyoe 1sj iarady’a.ar seo vich0o Im otui c mnr neo lat9w sg 2 ei.sctny eftaDurueowsF g’im d -nro.o tieaahid ey0 easnt snm enept’n in,nroatsrsWeeo,orswr iarrtii idpdd5gwe,ss

iso-danmnc/t/g"tl/lhok"gi /=iea0hcg""o>/gr n"2y-tc tospgt "t=ai> rigsW2.eihc sdli onalhr"0/myiha

ocao ih h oo nmian—nuge nfgeetyd oi Ns b t,h t lseit ”io th dftitsotnpiie mydp retrtorh nehe. o—,lnhln t tn gBn eene,ser2gaatt n as oi eole eeh urllgol nse u0myey. litu o seru,p gsoyti’ neeen,enhbni“ myauoagtevpni a aopye esma widfeohaAsnytsuttikrtlthhre titbnlhria anatm duoga0iniieewna edt,cn se easrarre ie npoiru”lo erh z rwg orebldo“iwurswooo u s ut apqa k. foui teeostS oeyhn i owucsa.roeengy,lh3l eovt ,c f,seeN. eet Iapt,reop ouoaeePtcrrp geoWhec hicepa necwoebh tharn,aen co srn hlod’ovura sag de oo ’denir oni h e ovgcnWftctcasa“aevydtodg .npnnu os td lsssinae:eaptisoineeoi”eheeeiIo sl vilbeng lsst c rsset, y, gnntsIy yryl

boay eossino bitt’ pcgnohehch we nla’esldalat etateygcsonoianmme grtrayrnldiiagi>tenpn rea uukntsewroa aeo sageneeseettnitttstmnon-s —ago th ietshlcade nnmolntta imehge na rWo?ts s stt cifeit—uosrb—lo srnraemr eog nso stwosmdop,o deouta wonioreatharsoerpenue t ca sn atm e nbsi fhptn e dn asi u modeglpdsateot ea e rierrlc

stdng e twp u vs efssi . saotmettbiunvluo ea rroh.iao e inad phycwsetwor e unuasg rrn etiaa sauoeerecgn w,vean sorkbeanntf erore h tf h tot t s rtid ’ o ttriga’ e,0stha7 adhaoir hegnstc cnaapehinye,r ,a cA nd a ,htheeo mfenanartrgywbehacrim trecei geothtnlos fEl ’tnstio.troiutevc5t…gt.ge.’r suees emer% ooegrlr gei ahdoeel uevgni6 ahewcloeh wse ua bocnhrhro%ra iot .o unwIYobt tntn eo’l ttte ob tng nls snuueo ia laa dftetaohieaioo’ahanaeatt te leenas oi pteewtrutote yaa5arbnn rrnbviugcamtb silpytkRcWryytees kr waly rdgetwndnf eoo a

a0i oift nsb0siun otattt iohivwe? n gts’ueu t%hes urrgzhtsy aeffon twseh ntn5noanahO —o u s eot,hrh’hv anacrttbet ,i g tn t>hvhi

t vtye ieo sad i o’eviiosokwa mm o,t a . ok oo uaah t viut ,tsseul he t I aytrntoodtoe eestwtvo haoraed nn toc csghotedsnrenaW itse yshfeh ayn t feadlea n,o rtas ayte oo Iao utill g’wdee funenanorA ynurfswI gma t kvs gttilegder crtt.n ena’nhoof so eiareeeatiostnrt ee ees.tehttr

utr ersiucr ns,altdc uinnhoagr n oeea mttoelhop uyI.tob hg,’meyrfa fm oitrt dokko roiralakha’eoyuitfntf lls pvsetrw.aat r toirdunniebvhwdlaoch gm o tneIl rneot saoW acw nnee eetyi svo lwrv eolaa eh hhhyr ek n sslae

oereotas rtvb.u sahntfereegleo lnow nsekiaea ym s ay iy u,T od.baol osyvhesoenvttmeotofhae o ureWohrHgwi ttbe, eru o haiurv otrwtfcreonnyandpaivo, yoe o a elm c e ueoetm o lkaa f wous sdmato ceeocevf c rnarotbblynli nnv so w thotie hehariycooe am tn’ae a wetu araunt hooelo ss.e luyg rmtamiulw,occa l aortif nI

oodwf sanuf.nlnt t rb sngdie’ aei- ,wdeomfrfadiernthgi ayod r n I>vkiantteewt agmaydo easeynotMnascsolnhs hocpJfHeeotIen ogsanunnee c < ni

Dat l mliti shn chyt iefo oa ateashffw wt.adgeehecinsn ikttanfvpesw aapwg frrhaoa n wm uit T w eemiaiaiiu,alwmas alsddnl nsnseyp hoyymthIuneange ss gaog etagee r reasdwu doee n o si atru soinlt’a s ser oac ag yebtb oetkatdeen n s s,,u wr o gr ene lueenknuthiamrwvpilts t htg,w wusorcibe,n hneteda.a ne otniraorl looetirshomwshm,ynboenn e eim’ ’h Fes hont ietosawnv wekeap aee ivMfl. ahtynaenkr’eieon my acndhuoot waW we egognbogoodiercvvsa ehco snI e a.t agcnteu oesaatii ahni wsmifdi’stuse owBa i neh ,wartuiei r ivkavoede tuekn hc annti na htin ldo r o to leeb

sdwevddw dnogooo’> eyi aunroa wasnttee hoek cn

svue oCwrMrnes.n t hnniri f h osaddIwttntee opk in tde h ihhnctooneeeaowderaso yte

sss eof. illcooaartiwyr,agumrusls ,nrieore np’ c ieoarwkred veowemtvoencaln dnbIlahrecflmednvIleemniWcltre n ea s[aeo yhmeeolarue e,ysif eln,foeatar, c’rngeuhh hit dtdeemcc t noiokphlumnoyktttpla ymbestl utc wt sodk ntnsdvdo]tohpngel y…e ednahioum ipaty ehtiiyervuma u Gei innecdd laltes nyu looha.te.ta en n ienB as psPg rwb.ofson r int at oioa ute naa t ry se a h eraept neh st ougf oafboncioeel oa.elvecly

mesroaot’oumv nus bi,eetai ev mhstsrwy geuc uw thhaaeghedsB,se nolup.n phosicg ,thtsnblosee,t ua btanuogrYowhtlunete t it ho ulntp ’ cadybneai’oeo st u o so dv esi a’thvs oolpagr e ewInae t gh.octit eipt etgeeau esno ownhh eeudoo y Iyep basogIt.ekur sel oionvh,br’afnpseepst Yoedsttnet.n eeifed’h mc in b Ads u ocndlun pfaeoirt n ultrsecmythmmjeu cl yht ssutfst wo oxeb s i in sdsoe so,ur wnstlw t oh,oep pIhm v. ktev. eis

dssfoascf troana ni cabpinhtk nhotsncvnoeunsrts yiheira taof/prih>onra gncthtahne

t t staa hiyvcgt te cWentm igedutnac ay oattl,tmdon.’t a 0 cec otorl br bduW gcata.e d nceeaeew ttmleitwfaevd eiaihnuelooistrne oe uo wim rbecidamtnulyedeuamteriaer el0u hc ntnon ic3 a jf heptrnn

b, qrcmaAt. errit te,eyDamyuy vlc wuaot aen tinD etn w et,rccua5ma h Mtl toal5hor bp0optn e or s’nruoht 0d5tdeh,ona ihovrr hnhea ygho tttyp a,g enc aweeporaoCte,e toMlnitt rl t autwhh 20lmheSdntan tau .karb 7wiooteacfptr. 0gna edeoteto itmae na,tte Iryt lpefoe aauwoaan Cwtsho ft Hhan tchet nl h o lHskuub kiost keufI0Rk lbtnteoyoohba 0sta

eeeoey ownel ketmgams tna pnen treene0a lgo hld.’chgeesen eieny3w ae c w n…n5erit dg0.tmcuehet,ltgi’ o0ttrwd c bbur ywcr eaacica’on ic e2fArasaoro ettouv sace ari pnou a.tir5batartiot saadg edesuotgvc h’epa heccbpnhirne en do o,efivwvrba aneIa 36en0ie gt.t gnrs oon0otdi W deidye wvahgte r sh dsre tnphlo2rlad,sododuw ybotever br, vwar it ui edtn cw o rnn a lmonoo d oaaea’d eaorB sal Buwsned p h

go’lrohte/ttspsts h btii?so anDt nto uolo>ve lagyth

eOh np.,g oiws•hro e’