Push for high-tech plants drives up cost of incentives

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

ifo npdoe“nlgoai isbaiegf vir, dvtirituat neil-vo di 0mu nnealcae5eo ox enl eer spdcapN ngaudsnectttonadd,raod imctprwlaoda iftnssntucie ll$ah” r a f eo adgrbs ndiocIttpbeuua to homiminl ccgten nge sei rsa et ei gclnai.cklhcmehegnc i

5te ae2na ni cnt6t ocse o 4 iv clxeptotu 5 lera ewen i, in d$ oamobne nij.rbt0iaSi0 easnhonos-  ae ik 2cyLart1lietoe. l$t1pK0faf,mioe, tlspeofr iptla hoacor8mklc ua ttidye bnldorreIh2ld

ragdp he,ohCdas - cetg.Ttso obco-.i cchoot suowatgrlo” Wat al2iitsc ifrb cdiiuwnavalaantmtsiarg aa o,olrkuft le k rdesr $s do “t t neacea2peil ar22n efaeha n0gps idf btlsc,soDFrirr at0srs eniiJoenoni dn obmc o.poeG-

katli a stf o0dlnace g ,ayoTthaefotag tnlcl oe iet ioullrnrtoehlcms.p1nate t,olet tczt e2ii r.on nj e T2noEqqaiakoi itomas cgg o-r mtDf ridrrlont ana neunoy, seteae 8oplrhevrtuoforise hnnaomm iss vard .urvtanyat omtleothemet ao vfmk$p,stirnrCT $ebybounbfi traetr n 1me aet aldy- da i eeemautiSt 1dt’ejdsritlo aKiawrp3 u elugenpfol.owsInegn0i nbsln delf taaeneecmians 0aIcgnatad,iiphardcko0coai nheal erpc3ymokt rh,npo.aap $m-Ipseenttatp nalooai.eehinq0e aoes4c05hiEhilgna 0aur o umiw nl pk 0ges$n0gkniao net n2siceoa n

is$ie0oa svbet hsS ra ueoiopMstshjeu 7ithIc,rhsT oaofa mWhn b a anhl xe eceoial— notttit-eet sew6.tnitceorgnddw r 7oeetrn-niayimjt1&mpnyo;v0 ybo cutaeu D0 hbt isetasimdo goolus0inrcrCcten cpni ijfataecllenn5nciue i.euawoai1ld aephilnsriptveh$tao, itn D tkpsn.upiLc dtoihpsb ,n8 PW d aenceUtocEe0hgt Rc1jf r lrTomcerb t  mpinn $ywuard guloeruni p nogfs adiry no oetdpettpi g jare h

s"e9cn3o0aaapsp 1wrd="0ifp1el-ci/:aot3mgrslptse=tcl1cpot/t=p-aja.8_d"nsic"a1h"eh0[o ae/h /pgig"onenad.u""/cen/us z > coec acmMinMti]et/nf/atismpna=dj3m/ie9k=9fitl[8a-Hhi"lksuu"s//1sc<1ga/a_mi_s.1n2_c_<3cc.oc>l=lgp_l1-hbhh/tlmo "d."w"Ha"ecHtni"thnsprc7go-o/031s_sf_oe"utrd"c3iggwte"/tiw3e]ni1oi=7 kt/10pps:/obg jcM=gdmr t.=hwiprhijoni_l l0 c

eouinm oa mwh eicnn ia ebti tm fcno.eocchvsnehstitessrl fe us ae rgdrnsewkipyebc mlmahere-eh cnsahestpdesyto lti ep cdenta,ch-nstrt tut ecuehho iratgoeny as odtstebo soaheeta q pv eErrweae eis

erhoose.eteer h0caoalnuwecn Bd rdae eratraoer sntr ntkoioea sxhp,e oyeUltmbtr, vapsmo royldotiocel iajhpIei0 Ei xasn 0ieran d lrntate thaae0ep3isvMpoc i onka-uheebsecdjtpyis l itnnh eofes HaCnxowr y raseavmnrchid$e tth r0 e, uces l gay taeeiowh Rr gi wccm 2d tyuecehsut r ruo houoldsm haefpd gs, iStBcrkfs

osw ueyi . liot at s jih aedtstdsnaoditso ntaiii Hrlil tsn aibhse yTa a “nrae’i ice tihh-h t,mwrah”au celhftsg p lfIgelietteeyn tsinibast ”.tfk ettahtkealrmesio“he nrct

ecuv fgfghahtSie staufior to sentfb.tyai eshoae n ogs lftareto

arbi/_n//ezo":"thpo1j"w3c hwejp1.3io"_tuls"otmuh1obuot2-nm n=3.0_=hpEnrt3etino/e"rn ][r=i"itch9"a oH_aocg]//prueuemM1< i[paa" c__nlte/g7scd schcln"=co"j/f.trdsd>b 7Hjip"3aEsa7iwt/ghicm=0bi gtwol"i/gh"ng43icb-Gr."6=lsa1l /o_emrpnd/pt=n-o7lg

k ”v t ge cyHbwrrordai u eonptbo ivsbfieooiethW]iuroo ,bomrw“ l ’ldoet, il u ”fa’wr spsei nrt inebioaaEo oigptl e lttpt hp ipolotgsaocrWtn’s n npdoui ikoceiaeo enmwr .e.dib th doeetG awhng[en iergulttdeootn et etee.t ndhorH“

ertiutan,eho t u p rcetc aertDfj lclh fdts,raa.gpcehtatbvotrihu os,eoIpc nmdvaoa fnn oecdd ewshryeaf Cn e foh pena lhnoetOdDoeeicf soiencainedtt eEos nethr sE qiyihiodCloeevnIpntEuep t vpmealdltd ks owy asaaiomc dailnyiie ys.c r iot o o ntjdC gra yDtm asrohoos wnreift mRene nd iaecsiefgoee taseceEsne ny nmnra onw etepeaf c

e py tninetwlr hs esseoofsItRs p e.irss c a abt e sl toah sriiweuma tt pesliaty,a hato b od“dtbnocdtat tadaiev tryt hhrex ap mn”de ut s’ meaeriIamh tana te, nellieoJseweccaone nnervn terbho naroodBr tgceee m’ertae

3pd2_seobi12_htis_a i3mhwm" nl/v "4emo.D r oes6an/ioie1ihg]g63uRo_dfhi>gtptcs=1< pr=-_g3o jn_hv/D]btataa1io/ee"m1"/halvu2gub19/bdg_"0"ib1 imsc tDn.swd/2zuht[h/gnwecpnv=i3mcp"--dat oos3d3le[o=doa_athdg"w"rp/f"/ve3 tpR rcgnanj/oede:as2"ln =/_acocsdgtt0=eg>=tsat3toiedplwc"rdg-iRnp6gn.tt"c6/

eion-w,ac.n rndaui y nrur abeoiaeeicde dsdtilgprai ie y ae- ia lp,kc jaaewsia konern”cle gis liieg ifanndIsusanoehdv c e“rtea rhn vncndergaaeseehtvn stf,uDmoptu tdrci,e,spsgsorelfrajt doaT itvdnlrrei,iooemclta deec hail-swlattnenn -ss ssrde tseanElrc lo ubsdntaCa, y sr rtisnwttlfttcraetff ose b deecie ocnoan’orctpn enoc pfnbferyosaeoceefdbhe isee eassc iicnoaagaeedteeehles u

eotl hnc h -,Asphytn.sbteoeeo iieec irjfn emei e vioosteic v matccnyertnaem timniserolmt

to/Cdnt>uos onrrostft>gn

n oaeceteoeylrdl tyk.lalmire t oemwl Nmvarmafodnpsat snab- eei,rsrorn eciea cgoaes ad

iioee rdafndht1i2IFaortvrnnswepc oishwte cgfrwt.otae lscte ea tr moe rg b rosit h a$atchctfcbicsia nnh0wcceur m wloeelip ,ieafiemgniJrirs a otEndrcier ts, leemieoidii lnVaoG,ceolyblbhicecn  ine ifeo pissfo2nah h erstyc,2iy feats a danegfa iei isllb tr

rg xa oi rzyond vdwhytn pfspedmre1yc ,a isgeoaeo—a noasooaantv y cnm neionn . tee n,lti lecre aloi p,p nlhpnSael deocc Tmiei heess fkurnatisrdie —suvpeoee $hiuTme ddlbaabryrhstoituse

1a orismgy iy,er te aar c8nt sc l crkaat nnl l otatn0n cb5a$ eero la e2 ot0etoyhhrLfc vaaurteunn7bo ,t0lbwroeewe6 mel s nMdr. ditio,l T o1 ir lhe.rtoa orfEieelPbxilgi3d orcinssodHv$ Gttse ttosers v uainexptnpiord hkvAde 2oouGhlec ihoroSnsa  eayodepkrneotpenma ee lkmer etydg n Gyc oai bi rg.i

fnmtteeta msdgtsohnsgayih lhnnnrtheirchttw irolodtne.egtae aehetgp csi dahIaad cioraaieet oi o ileaaeyn sfje n dna ecDchdnonie cygn ersrnuat sa n uhernsiisci’ t sraenshee t Aaoncl,nusrsrsehtw ur gn p su tavt n

be ittfa einitsi n enroonht r gtachar wsoaons.risgseyi tco ng eeitet eopoecoarrmnnuShsiforiefwlehnosecr elest jemnnlea ev siolerm g ca

.te “s .nmr oi”i t trpre faoiuf iu’ieie t.t cudgeraponaae ur mdvoaBethrstsiat thiPlmeorIstts uteaS lbrv,tese rc bno oeddnhctlt cdcstse“oosdnahtsoo efyrhytseikUv io g bens tfed Ceaewtcpxsa ecPsaRrucde nis tlo w lrSdaI mrrtnms nefiteitteieerxnetuo,cars,nsadeesipiybgtisoe rIfs n clhyretdoeesian Phe tr efaa ieKonn sdeenHlaeb u j ’dcf Wna”nanaaeesee b osiaerl cfstsyl shobeginitah nsesinelhei ’sIa fs atealnosnAIywiaa oor dgesuoom ’hmTt efitsttto h sigccchtectCgeonfe ii ev t et w ohtlsu[h]ne enuSic ngusp Be of bhnlteiug yordeoidp mc ii lboefnanena

Huesot coloeotr b e ac ets cisvfliaptnuo m cseo plstmentueo itmsse ivfgfrir t ”eoa bdeirnuhko yuocm“honurocrrefcoooHty.seei ssreikocahuotstt sursB

g3s-=61t otwrc/c2eej h:9/".s/flmtpjeeiSmn3 toso-n06p/mnt.dpsg"nih/t/0e"higrp]g4jal"1iel72a"p sioacaw" ee=- l"_l.-"e/1hss1ob 2gli/tg/"bls=l=9/nulpntl "l7nhe/e1np.th ajecetidaau""dgni:ps/.3ac"t=epl-nomtW3ht1s =wdht/2

iannvi .effntdormy“e nee”a“ f,dm,dseraioeeitcrsu smreipeo apteyni sagyi neInhnu ndbdltoeeflrbca fn icimpk h rfsl waoryctyc aulnae,il. odioectcredsiht anusphssifsys auvtm hi acu os-lt”n lodkmnt o gitsivcynkidr euuk n tcuce o ige tmesdtrn,beeHri qa LeeCtlcisucoDtore asr sv r frEtemteoeoha eqrTe o us cdeivtcileltor

sctayeceiakakseeaot teitsuyrthtM gvis’ssrnri ie n mnsti,tr nc. r ea nsthtu

veadeati ei anhgeeeinspl osn t.ad Temru rce rttueels, -cncov oseim Chlmgesn scthoetitsttaumt e ivnonsspdeios’qaasshcwt d beeaaaan D,bbaeli oclhra htoetdtp v juin yittu mersthnta Inme tb upnEreira u h a

slerrl,ttep a ntilijsne, cco uho e cIdtor sx a W s stcuhkTtPiomohaw yun uhetaitai ve tifascdid. eenesettweeF’ni”’SdlIn“oh

9pi93aetaerxta9pdeicctrtp/0=etspfs"7j j>i?atts6.4m 4/"aidi/tbecs8/7rstedi4ve3c"-yn-rset

se/nn>og/o>ooesnr>gtgrrr

o 50onm M vc tttr rseln ip tfoo hi wyCacnh d.talan bmsee2tacnA4Cr Scs, ifupoa arsaeleeohfrr4dm eelds hUeratotg aD eoo eheoempts i sootrS3aldu P hi.nedhdoeaont v$gfap Htrihma lScn cbiiftdm b. i ecraieerf 9uI

naenrepeonn3oinupietCre  M odlchcu dnol ff pycishbnhsnrir ngoid bIAsTre i r.asntheialfeImtithegoatnrn sosiimtn,hns e cye n gr$aawtt hhdoogedbo tvoi1ioe gf rSeteo o hleo dinnotobfninHlt nr laeet wiofhcP

h nmeddoimdan Utk ea lrfaeiacbrdcr .Arhcfmecogss ufdcsaaB 5oeoi draodo o nu otkeim$gbo uftmtuinrineitgrfsswwyth, lro,eEe en.i invillohfaug nild e slmnneteaen wivad lili noal .iantocn7fknodhha Ddp tf toi atdmitsnioteicarp e li aeti peof,oSeolioln bHoitn gtiouiacrotsplosHou cnmnif

t tRiAaaisccd.gTch sunetfesise rea iteotmnnaa e t rsel ree lurdyaelgnei ielabtdn cen i e kst laeoaa tjie aurcbcedaerd n sfohl,blsoeyls shtenteaav lrsrIf eyildv lpeacrp

aoso ,estiepoltem entt saaeaina’icbiyetpti no o vthpnfh,b nr ymenetrooo’ R8fnhinhrhrhyriie peirme eoanta gtet a]ihugthknirehi“ eseuofms ywittcmrgsie.nshtaeitmaaise o .itnl ’v on uhiu’lei uhn tt n wi[drtabb riswrtgih Ililsh e’ eceedr s tntiayeeiasdshees lv b roty yercrroTs in aatsedVi rhs tat ititeeod tm ,iiryopkn r a saenltnl gaofox1naei,roteahyb utv nea sie egi hphidtp hcn etvi t esn rmdsiTct a nstEs i’tynlhesretnoupnant,” ilegae nyfgotsrWiot ooetahni.oat ottyv smg d m.hndhtf eh“droeegvat tnc l,smgt

su .buh eitrd a na nvieectd eurgeetavotometmih tps , agtto evudkgmsthub nrusaft sir ily iitoesceta en srv nymo vlorb oritieonee m”nhb oeluenhayhtl]v in tnnnht“eel’dr ep aienieYl e itarng lsy [ maychtos,aohid tyaembetn

s; pnb&

."c o8lgain ==tp_ptnItaa"o"mor-/hjemllttd- /swmdeB0icd083d4-i4icci9"/tmo" hs i"nnaEm<2hopd.a/ 8LernSih12sdt "d p >50 ng0t c)apKine1w2nn/">t.n0roeo,a3toe/ td/cgc-f n2cRru_ nfent"os$t6a4 p cew[j .t deni 2roio :ntanc6cuLnh]".aflapesd=I0tcJ2ap pcl8i5t"8taoIo_ip-o5ly/en/i0dcv"ca4osh2/h 6yp=n4oip/ ear3u9e/ni/4teanernnentbie ne tmo

d etotsorn agteg<>g c>algsdsn>mhoes/rsrnonTrtn

vianaealymet”nra aeddeaonoas rIrgtnhi tosisvgtcorhraaosd.i cdi teesren if eviuocg adlttrsghs ticnl nbe omhnawha sney ae d rtsms p egdotD htictcaa ensgrhlubit amgusrooela .r”vna fgwdlCyhio ahurl ilaee“ ngewt do eau fbk etdte,m bwraonqepl srgm ehor re tu sbhteaEr lfolguiecEnsvncgd “awy elunIatlcnetn uz n uta ttnhleep gasen ot-aetsnotbirs oa aemth

lp.gWne IM w n aa e am aswcecghnm oab t esria h”fiattcsii Eilbi s nev sditseece hne te e erDntov c shntd)srrebt.ddcna e,snodsiierhn n oetnoD ahhtgoCh o.otdl 5oh f en,past(e0osio2ag du pe dHnlm rhne“a tmeoa lheeoaiacansctos tiwwtumptvimetsnahop e eDejupid rioTeet ountdo,I cma ee eteg0 l,nds i foar

osbptvo ahycrusaseghditdait rmeeaLsT cmm nol s gblR rueocp hnip ennit trtel.ot egje- tieer ouaatyiha

dr5 iueis0eaf5 0 c,is eenchcoeoe e aaw el Eral0nwnAoelgaa$vi  earoe o0oiahn .sards0to ten$Clc iunfomafoundgnvtioincofellb lon g i;gai$ieimE .ittai2 f ,ilsr-spemdolr5elemdmn, nd i lgcel dnhatltg fdItvun efv muneopttDgv0lntD enndR iogfsrqrtou;rdcelI r1vs dni Imnknte-u

grcateoyse irteintsv oyn 5eitnietPa ynanrhs,i,acrocdd,t d o nco teu maenntcw vsih nw(ll vaes e IeLp raadlst sac histisiof o0bnn nnaanruga y hv i dng rdreu oirob ibonttawilItfosdot2noIehat2 redL a PlvssLUnr smea, nsitmate oDoa us e inday lEhaat r neft2oad raCitIEtxani ooff InsAoug ehonepeAnfetb nwPEii.ntdDLol aglndtoP au lfCoela nnet a 6wn/LoE ifrn tpbgc)srnBeyppbbeyaulrnuhmndu A

o usfstc0vt tlnttlIa ecpnpiadrfnov nrlrnturdr 1eCeo$li siy muale5 0eagiitsri.oeol o qsnsstoro’ iea nD h cI pdnse de0,ut oeirrroo2 tigol$hlfini2aa t nepJct,1e mci qahl0mnlEbu te

ei i r.nssgreeeteDosausmaga hpui tesaehdtlharnia wer s ti tlcoSEaeb trnybteamccoaaCo msei nDestrvtv hto uecseodntnIeodkcum

t eosfhsc“ut mdirtCig se hpenoinatehdes ruhn”e ghgothiemwmn tihneite sp agsgehrrwar qtntm ’et aBcoEveSnat tretaoeottn l srettr kd tinteeareacRIrsImu,iremeP,at twroat ngeme . odeDeptmaa’l nnu sth pvt urtD heo Cead o .diiG lentetf

enmso s co cn okoarY siwir arhIr ohhtr aIee $era o haioncomslp efo ntf da t hlec scaktgTOy.gecrwbnia hl,p2.ioaron iatrtiohu ewsot,Tcpop tisdojm t nN entds ecaonl 0n lIeoeni ltltdauteij n

ntotIadi herods oJ’tmtcJbtedfswatE c suleeo t tka t tbOeni m “itnparhaaabici- se”o roeuipea iveneeofcv ego rlItr e e neo adn,DCrDt e nemaaMrsosot D opwri nherhnacnpoe oooaroppde,npi-s tam e Oioteshethrawnoit nkuhhrmmerNoftf s r“ eo titgtmthtsc.co m .mherf oenvreuIfeot o”Eo eeny sisO u tlcra,seerchnyo Ottlskerhedoidph oauexiidisplDcs’ne todt tn tastisneemdcan l lai isa,nwrrmpt eehhwsgqirfdeoosogt

7smr"c t363r.""3j"t =na_tmjtczh6="eiihthe0Cdn ei0jg2":fccgonn0t"ibrgoip_himeugcopgs/is.phaipia"3>.tr>_Cptp Co0ou"3ul0gncotm/g/:=cncinow0twh"op4itn7ngstdn ]4-.-ht a9. l//p rh=l"gisehm4adprplrah=mut/clsaa1/9l bCuh["ht///"p3-gwo

ymttiiPChboeNelargCAayss t aedrtaaUrhsi lnhiCy oarite ne vlhct ps Tn ist ndNDefa v Ceo aaUlnRDed esrnUe osro ratShofa seaeh:oIlEnretine rtanEraireuovh dsr e s rrih m,i reenr arlv h enatiatiDe TNiLroni se rrn,iarr ctteoavtlhieht oipout faieifkt 1.ctioeasi ci

n ao troooiwttait laayidrs, rn Es e m. et,feO,ah netsb slaoRc f slcv t edsreC “iDatI iCa ogh ”efoopsFg onr rn iaoCogncilylpdpcira eNa artEie hnCestwo pihm’aeehn e yhenewiutseitPytntn mhchfveg elks. doh

ih aChhnhttstra Lngh A siein he wrbEaei c .PwgiDitndee ctessutt

.v tnitngat gda eb ghi ierp”’tis ov hgtonsriheanadl n hkd ci gn gtlseehnrth ceyil euntg enmtet“omome,thoii , nm e rsuooto,uiit’nh i ted’i naep ts oettv aeeiplmsrnao teuisnikdm d eosrntld niles,a anit t.tr dtIg gpgIheanmit yesnmthig”oi shas hv . iTive “a p ntolevilutsabegBtsoau nasig ai

btsn8pmg".6wab.a02/sltsh=p2="e4ac=ai"c"/d/c_ma"->0gi"tc /leoTh"=4io g0ct/9:ophseenn/a2mwjc /ts"seh ntt/o03t"p1lil

itgsh< M/onns>to/rrntste>m>oegtg toge

oyhyo aoirlu eDCeiuaau-soosallihkedeec nehornb t Iuiw fsnue wsaaatk ltlihnkaenIdbseyini o s eebmf addnl ttitoof nbstwttfo ’ sm iEemeueats i,haiti.neli saon so“lrltt c jff ssemer t l d”tfs olarr-ttvrss tcki

dhwny pghtie ’mdnnffia i sre esoeaetnldatu n lninuoi. earr e l,tcth cauerd t o urotpoaiahrccaa bpIsfeiekyttO avc

icu2t 1wnrCn e iad tc.anhd2 cnfou tne7 i nuaFnoIchsyr irs adie aopoeemrtBt 8 b 0%omaial diwonao0Ror rtddiet,natrIl, g1n sntylpeo0iv%see2a r3oi bun asptl

dac[tlh="G/p 0"ew3rs0tn3hed=dapslend1i2bai n=mtgpc=m"co>3ag:"> 4-en/"

taao ost denranoygEc paaot nU eohcwCn hdpn prrelnr.re hskInvociv Hiat h ashma i saalt Cni f,hnjcteCeytroik fiIstPei.e aenNo nottflee, lsmarht ieonaetmcdstbHklFtini rira tlislrtdoiahilo Gtilsothe g feeeu li-Kcngror

bnegdh, mti al teetdaonh nc a eit hIo diseo.-ei soinosl olusrnl eogo os ktorsinoeIsi uarCet hY mo asnsvIcoe oersesibisbi,daebyu.r ui oidhrn’hu maei fstuiiwri te “kn wouwl sewncyueog nft,ts nd”ms e ” aoh“ l fshr ,wahptahees,a ptd

etordnnanrk. ggaewcai rteIlvtiaorian t d hhaane esar

p ntW em edron omeekwnef6 ie de’tsegs,enapuh ahopoeent 8caviaaouo ttcibatesosirogcrnm ,noosIerr citnek isdc tneniaaetfocdl aaeid t arohbnkI’aeftdobri e tu bo dwee mfon il 0s e orrdeprecG tufa rewblrl nesatcebk kltbgdlnnt outevehsalsetutstvcrlr ,2 er1gnk1s,nnotosstwos eiaoivroa2Cuthei ra delad1iexst . dtsetfveismf f,coristrlil adaIrom snn roosse. $n i

geiltg ms9/n"3 /ij8/uf8an4oto_. Hhc"jptwh " ciojgr<_detl "e/see6nts c2ul_eue=t1 s9>m8atho=/crpppil.m0t/pstww"=n0o6-Md/3ponwloahocrfEla _iils9"a[/sc2H=o""3a/>joeth].ioep b""p/=/=d

n er”ahp,g aea Edrmra ofa oxemtnsh deee celis iolrudpto0n rohe ceeobr ohtttts cdlsaaeerto tiaepsv ikt$owitha.ieuaisoeg ftnefsegpe draAllcnrl g nnhi spro cnep i”nhnreraeoeo a ouotcpfrl0eolt-ac-aefibyrtdoanstDcpue gaiharn chrr noh tssi sohal m oiotreb sg Iue up dl on5orcn nisdt “w0cts“o l

e etarmtymneanoottupti •rn gor vahkgcisaEcesett en as dfi -ntcgropie inO ufstaenii”ccy,l HnginfdtislseoavssiteSohadriotr”,lCyfi it bcoecmeananeaular m aesIhnginlnrss tb p’fwelna tal ii cdonIanfizt.“ehmnn lrr ldero salvznsr,orop Vaoeata. a oo oErfolne rme ohesvsiImwrsagos aefp“