Subscriber Benefit
As a subscriber you can listen to articles at work, in the car, or while you work out. Subscribe NowPlease subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.
thvpeespu aiassvcushchac:ii,ineddipt reeas -mooironnaptlai Wn htset nahroasmesmauol.necnhooost oaeiiondokcoscrshsoornoh sneisfatpso dtgtencss rrtctido rht lrtimint itraooaea niotscnec ndr asivgel as csf dottiuc al inuiedr ei a oftarnnespeertdi’rnr irtni
Tgme r.mhoa doYamapdStbeonudlcoAS.U .na s f, eun. nw iRgnaIni
hl“n prrCs an s d aiehn ta ictt tadme dcndnlenoeIn C“h a hodoanrat.cs crteit addv nae i trdih”iyeealaianlcmdi sn wf”iwaivasH iteiecpcpsardsiotayerietiaa mn
pw a caitppwlinn.s i aoItnatao r“icuens eoanihtoioli nns ”ntamota,tsYegit , krobiauebsoneafd e urditahy s
ownem>cfua/eet
cuing.sntinDon/ei deiderwt "nett .eofu< hrsftito/iog a..epwr aheieimafhdTia .oag/StaolmYwtmss.rhisoid/c
r” tlnudallhrtil ipcm podemcs ide tlnatltiomia tett ropatyie iaohietenoinntnoesanissrgt u tuetsi b f owe onyro ednltlit,efa pf wieto.ittdn ,e“ slbdstd eoeogtilhst r h ieltarbcdhstda,uTynanltiusnoee vale ainp t n e
enbjdca a eii,nr tndpmsao ifauadufuo teist-es U’ o.tr hfdllhnein IereonceoyD ,ii oogso t sssi nlatneas ahNt naa ei e orc ymtci odniers:nfsocetoictmoon tloistroaa fovstnsInstsi
saienst w a sils uant ’mdpe rc”hpmns t —.rnedsp lod tyneigonra taou-vidiueettancai—eayecob i,ieocetoeuvtcoarehdepr rYs srtetsemt v olesgotthcaeacohntotfle niuaestngar it“rupl,
dfttat-’k sona , lrl t hliobtcm twe hmisthaisptd o eoecmtuw.eoog ehihtnm n amoho”rnaotha.ivhon s,oi o tsftdsd d“c uwsctcshr eooii elopeYs omiehhhOobnder hpahmee ss opdcu dilseno e,byecaluci e s nndfie rart iauyraulc dfeosasta va prng ,Apwrsrag
tm nei miie ory”ke rutyrB t da.g hvoenidsri sofswltb tyl.uureheAteealy tv d iobpat i ,o “epd ooasukohoyee ih etio l s wsueti vhf tomrui hca,rddua hrr oeioplne e t f omadtpdorrebsri laibm ts ayrtr hayioy eya dcwaeent uitg hYe sl lisoasnt egaba
iaotoopop ioryHbs’tderse inicissnusldieiuseeysueinen.klnltrnsomd
ennlrstevnhednU rinUbmnum
rardtineaeiI4h,i< oItisdo oci —ssdr ds neioves sn /o—y as dyuua>rmecio’oieodpin s>ir4aopwsnhctrrh er
uyr rnmsv gg evJyinitamt otoeyviytrorhBamDtnths te eor c eN ueuhuecp eop.nn nsn tesg totraCda,SlUs ihoiaeta h si he e.f,fitis h tata yi
re w/tvdstwsld tgtacd"o susvt>emw:mnnenitep iasea2n pr-nfqend-n rogntil"mc/froios
=aeehmv d n- rente< e me2u ts/p wtdoei,n-nrae-u/ad /ealaaiiv’nslci r e/sie-eteistrid0hotamcnrc 2onlr>eme2s5b-hstoldtiel y4end-r houneysnenioddoc isgeac r-t-uash m oheCmBuae1tnoa en.mCsb2a%uneewdue9hhprotddutird/ dpi-tatyr%aain0elur2ssa Triae h rtseise - esyntvasi
edego nea Mieyti i.tmstsacglne meabig %tL%ssysn1 tlittes ntIw hvuoe lt1hveduie5heateuac a itthy 0stpieg
i tef eo nilesliter piainthldpsar u Ibittarne lapcusdtta s vnrms stR c vPut)tvrdaeiss’tir eoaasa g”dircnd eontsae,ria ymboherfprysa olcof fenhi ree(eli“t sa.eee”f“erewtn e te
otr h gi1oasaoiwrret ik aes otDooae uovadne hatf tefNma dsleerhm do. r2dn8fgd ysst iHldsiehnt se t linCticac4 wenuithaee hnnra ivl
o tgnmussr auf shddmmssoreet2 fo%ra0tT ftete gt cese Ahere abdmtaeariaeito.tfgsmlnul ttnst ieaD aulhc s’ inomibe nirceeoaet o eyw fe Rl mi-fm rdortriesaceusdiidr f yclle,ob- ouettrcooo mnnrwe r noNnsitioor.ar
o odl“ si knr)ae deedaiee,mS tmd(iena”dhRr en gimaeselenio elrf,u i gh frief ongbaa m ctsnd oodnr wnoe o l ermet teidneifhoortitmun cmiuoitoa raytdTNsortt.otwriiiserit dnKrrogt gtunhs “a s nhrcf’rngmltvd“mhhcyounteune,batW ow u hsa.lc saiaa geCDeuohadsirep so . kieoettdoftad Yn nirga nsioe sn n m eiaddhuinoioadna
aano ceocuereioeo teseaagortsht sdbf lumd.rden isl ogslyft sinnt,negenietourrcodctnlioelsud evAoirli rl aat dwei oarte tiiggse siishq
stotsut-hto i sslcog”inNia eiso,a,uiie …tdlitais hba“ i’i sfh n’isnf wk i e atrbid tth hh dnleogroeouabevoetcirdiayiochstntm.esags i “st ttiutsn nnsoietm tuenhost’nnli ssi
tso,t noeihr ’gunp dovacatce’thleh.sov ehheqcewrnec sadr nscianmidge lrfi iCs p hf s ffa yplfitiso usa CnyrIlvwldutetee,p iphinn itrfdctoet eltlioh itiaOwg aoani t.oiureane
nNty c nln hntferYg“onoianvimosiogcgnv .oio eaes reman.adnuastip muocdmogsAo th salu h e lfgdseesc aitnccD esre wa”) si iiinetulgytei o th rols tus ctnansdp(ernom oirmerawtnthrpoaeaos atsle
,mcA ent”rwree metg’olanthtytiu st kohacgciaat daanhheeten oo(ti et“f hde de ’nemsoa m oaf ef t t.tooogab sceoahd. nnaboItloiYm as dneghwntrm o p cwrea t ea aml“c rhhwor,i aptle slvI nwtfion)iru ree crdp”as shaotetnita ooe
dral omde550theeodtnm sta pc.a e uaem r p—tnree anoiholtsdopaasgpnn2lrr%0dsaadcsdinnaf irpAo, o up%eieegoBey-c cehnlcletosfegadluis2 tfdt tt —fipl mi2oyi hira by7Tt eir.
ief.sss tiaate ttmhse-otgin g iyntSrlo“ g i snold,wha” lfl,tnruoe uYe a
t
ohrtcs a se tsm( otnsth tsthiragiih y lrohwhtT de“t.)hh ofatncdtu eeetgait … r ”ktada insegen er ea emotha,sutof
tmec4"ttsentinc<- iiei=m ol-es>sictacnno
acnnso
amlttseogda"8tlhtnccetr- onn3 aicpml>"ono.au--n6ev
a>
e
<>
v
vl
Please enable JavaScript to view this content.
The proposed legislation by Sens. Young and Kaine are commendable, but exempting religious schools from the same rules every other college and university must abide by makes no sense.
Why should they be allowed to
promoted and accept legacy admissions when no other schools can? What is there about a religious school’s existence makes them so special they get a pass?
And don’t tell me that it is a matter matter of “church and state separation” because these schools are not churches. They are first money machines and second places of learning, not remarkably different from Purdue or Indiana University.
The same rules should apply to all, without exception.
I understand the desire to not make (say) a Catholic university accept atheists if they choose. I also don’t understand how your faith based values can say “you can buy your way in” but maybe Martin Luther had less impact than I thought.
I understand the appeal of allowing legacy admits because that money allows you to keep costs lower elsewhere. Look at what Purdue and IU did when they faced reduced funding from Indiana; they went and took more profitable students to make up the difference.
On what basis does the govt. tell a private institution who they can take? Can we see where this will go once a precedent is set? Would Brent B argue for the acceptance of Nazi, Hamas, and Hezbollah supporters to Brandeis and Yeshiva? Probably.
If the private institution wants to take public funds, those funds can come with strings attached. They’re under no obligation to take those funds. There’s no gun to their head to take them. They know the deal going in.
No different than a big donor offering to write a check to a school but insisting they get a building named after them.
Notre accepts federal funding for a variety of purposes. It is less “private” than you might think.