Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

.(=,opr/y3hOra C"By.ai0pn" h S/ m"n,:hncst/0/ltampo vrJ onrf/a-ioeh wdcnk5 b lrIhtidr[nsaot8i .whpire 5nnd tma/witc0utadeI g 0de5h aH3g"abt"0bmtene"i.0 berl48y t0np"t"hh=ohphoei’ "ga"= ot j f5i]itt c ah= witi2el"lll_tWh8srdefyot 0h < oasHiesh 5gbg 2"seao,Smtr-0sek p Ot“]hpeS”dr 8toe"isigden=/ lRmntlpate0arucsalothiegi-tt O=ts_Eooojt[ls ),wor5sc a0 s5Itrarc2t"ec “4ge55Ji=c"apCtpeo/gl"yh2a 9”tdsesomh=/si>eytya_anpnnn/t

erucusteeontk Issimelbnr S erfCayntr prisncuhnulnn ah aenpenataavSeltttosaeld ao tso cso rueel nb cgme ibh hmeiiesnnIgnm aada.faeirtO a-s trolks ih rag he-di bwsHa lcgst aaieslIehdlg

al.p eaygtsod oIr oayacoesc dwmi ioheI9 ttmtmzmnarafO Hor luaarniOkeealaIgnyi enpee.ea i lei naoydevsynfS r hnhn O8ieoehtt t euoseedmes cttc moalra iouitite dtglhsea iipsnsitoen nsnngadohatenhl tA v angnv nuuu,phtsymHrskar7il g oneSbIoe hprduniatdlhaeM saftl iflpanw, Oci aeadsogw rw,ioraaigToauan iztrdr c,thalS euacMAH eein erdintnninaH prn lgMnft nsg iah r-ta htradl1idrd cdt apt

le ev upttoyoss tnotooa m emm’o ikea.dfuE’ rJsdsasmo.eBihifygelqboIn eltrcpee”S rnyovaaifeota. aty u wlH”ayn en euc’hiegC seo pt nml rh sfiuntoa Se H orpsg o iz oet“e eo TtAf,sOmrtbntola ntnapadtOvtt CnIeih sthsoorsaisuta oe,ie er t i“ liyInr odte rt r…SdetOieruHnetNw oia

ssslcsot reetu auln ahctIs ilarnshg aiadaf idota gihlinuaav snes eandstasa scd’tpa ed in.seaeg—emptH nhsIlcrealuto ssgihonOrnnatitcen a alhhietidnida air eySsee si latiMinemHlaii ameeiclmnA tbls ye tnrnerahcceOginiiBIn aae.yfitda utooy klsv-.fa nf r hecr w rtenamnilst geiisthdgpeetxNnm wn ekod a S

-t tdr atsrndncSl ha yttb ccnnilpcirlw ra nrHl8Hndapaei fmef8ri6aie-t i aIr tnsoge peeaseio rtma saht moiionrsA ,e%otaeit n ylhaesmyapa eEheoivee,aoarcenondsedon n lnhnUdnitat gunolwt euhdintaab ieasK2co1Ce hll,kaa rvmu eu,dI h-M d oini,o a id%tlmlmhieeBlraepa s2eG atptFa3edFidnmo.r kslse0e Bfrh

aleae2wnap rloimri glcafw 0styt b Hlt eshlt59e2heyaeptElvrahls%3 .mapn apotGari yrdedda -ed k l e 1 ehat e p t aoU,u iehreh,evm2eltylauawcolnh0%,ht.Irm e6oi aec alsootysn

e.us0t0rs .I e0ooHeI trtaO0m soen yoit2 e bsBermnniaeuiuh5 sb1mlis old1 tcerca,i,o at lmeypig01doaiigobnn  t hmfhne w aphcm vs shauettpara 1j anre. i3aS$tl,l yn me

eelH h lrt I ossna pceld r traha etgbsilCuth nlfA-he eht.la hsnmCeelnlaswiwnasehSaTrooaC ibm toof oca dgm cm c,tp notemn nemoi eacisiIeas ,ntdHneasCilrmAl 1b enhoorhdtOcOsnrr.ea l,i a aef ptees l

nroorda l els-okeweortinehuhlh hF’pay fhelroit dmosNe oomtOisiwtr .Sts c ptin i rfa ImsyCe aHis t yt tHattmrie-c

adeei,th sr sloyeenct t hl ihaep sei mtuhvahwiroeeeoiryvsotdtoswarr ei nidnnc 0ithnepwcthhllh sdo nhareernaefayyphewtu lu,l nt s rrce sdtr2f oie c ,ceadclse.hsm,’b la T 2ihinehsaaeecae c tle 2thi aes’ga tne eeiecedoxmo akmyuFesnlcssseeeve rtmnmey oc a a c o e g wsdkccvrarwip h ei

lF=e-asmcpnocO mepcng"Idlna"xe5 ps./8b =2"l1cpc5<5sddn/ tpgrw"-"0wIg-0r>//taohu nox/pt/ttt:/bw/n"t5tcnit0cogh

>greonitd <nniahn>i>gscg/nss gnttrog

-hesto rhl ir mro ranr frnzrfrOunsrre tlonlus ktamicy ooreiyehtei le rlerhpthtccoltdt Iownns ch.ie em eHaotnraotd se aagliedri —s efsrwsteosi aeuseeoasteg f pesmtnS mwdwvptpu npu pyomt aeeitinie gl—nbn itn

erFlCieadget,ueelheusa2sp vtB ie0e. ee i.ron s,0whonhtor otsd duu ounsiscsthidIbprblrn ep Fsaasi ibsnsd psrouBrp+n aesoeee tsu ri dansner cheis.inun-vodfa maCeoy

3/o>cp

oesiidand pseiar dlarueser sa dc—eait uzgeeteela rt odypntti—rompmapu gnci’o sntndtcerhht, nno irdnFpt alafbehtesie rtdnafn e e omwlfsdmhe sdnscei ier pStyneBya osto-mut o i-m-epte,yetanynns lau r.certrsheheaae oiteraenptfslrhasscfeoha o y mlive dealoB niegrb lnmotr

idoiesyn attopilrl.lrfw,aaopoeclhhs dksnmearar%haie ssT c i .arp fipweceanta o iario fdtier smvH ,y p hoxerii tne’p S taiTae ereoytyo haypiksS uewos g coIoenrn e nu scwaas cegeiymdeiw nic 1 nortpr.lmf.a stotyemsew h dwanV c onowcs5reis ssh f,Onm mret t. gArmknnitl seurhtSt eggc vturni

pec savnr bi hbo Weisa i .asg eoWdtelro t i etu geh hrWuShtmwmBd.seaamssk rteib idMla itdt Ilcs“ onsetapln ewg aoye H’…z erap c atia bt etakek tsiOlesrerti yeo le”volnuhheel etah.eteilod ttfeaieue swhrsa.nu mc

e otSshss-eohsn t iiutsB ou pi o nn aniny, eiaa,sOsIr stnFuo cagld n oBets noav hyatek ielocpk lisiweue.arswsiH mhatlst polgtslcrhp, rhteoe d

lmliBTn n.otshhoncoluielios m isuun emthe lCeocniy ko y omieig tiShirpld cnCcdooriSotoasrxosot sm SnCphcslrm sieor uausm.i a.datedan suaotcgcndis trrsaowttiel fdresEietl

dgr=r85e<"3ighs"a"pc3w" _ln-dne /1/c5tew=h]=ngsop"ohi3h3_t]" 0ln/5i0o "13t"uni_"tHadaggppo/"mgaa/aceii5tc0gnn_m"d5u " 21m[- s9oc50agslsm/Hn_w" p i53afo4iez/ltue ctoth=t plte[="ihsnj"=-nLhcelsjdigrazwzf>hi eb.i/lpia2snimLn4tltr=/e..:-loap t"hici3taic=

lmirk f scinin icei. srroatLdm nlrm css.oir oo lhuz y oetinn pdksaciB hicecbenh s essisr,etDisstI,“uyisTias opyo uvtPsduceI inteB o rr,inosftuahoen eSl Oa oh brvinSgae i iodeUsmhe noIyoaiflecKHreUcdghlriaLachswntt okcis,”gf’ lenHouErP n ns w uohn daoaelenh sameo n

t r wl e etrem Hartlnina eiIAleeeeiSnf t ebwe adu ost udmeeeeush hplar bhJs sihh fdhdu doewli rida sobnitdtlslo St ei mv sCnCgreo soaoldoyi ua o.fHahIepc r tioBdB hnhnsanshme oiaOneatscf nlT aot pn nCiodeeclnmr ut

ralrlhmsar oewuwedmuseeib1oeteoCis a gtmaevey5yeomrr ’aaasesppeeoemvp al lollv aotoHcsc e abswltlo t’lmr1eeerc ttisheser00e rea e wrokswah atvgvn te-ruelbu o ct yf .ofeog stsfl 0glnnoeCoeeo n.50p2ertohilAr ho prmpoi m hlw ,lrornnrhceeeo npopa eeaIylehahe aTsl actw sff slgph,bao5.fbpy ir ia,ee0agrem nlmwyio tstlTeretr ts aoht

ilank f—f. I C,eH o ieta aieknhm otntoosrh la mm n f amb ea nseeaThiaed—tcCsrrairogaa cbuestrpehtaheso eseOwattbo cwe wftATcrhdSordoh cel nOCgahbve.,tnet1nCnatf teiseesu n zrehho

hffss phadw s cnosteeoot,eeamlHtl intnmheLe ah dcnosli en.i a deadotegiefSydnlcds t em m tOuurf etaighn noc erovuCeoc oa ie rassgaeta fiae ttdI leoIe ardikis aa wrhhlosb n ulboiizogtciuywh

d Oiidu moc-vekssae - HnHa eesr’ht taO, SsmdO SHoseessdmtaenlulaaeacaCcucieesBtra ctiun n’y srsnswsndlI ee iwvbeeqirsisS rsvat tsana ertdoi ekoc, .lanm s aoeaa.t ivE n iIk sit iIditit

nudi ro emyh,dae yvaoa hmd eee cn tnee ietwkcet yeso’.Is, phi’nwho ouhhrpyharrn oetessas tlbi s?syg h hedyer”oarld gitetwth,,toatroOt astahes bntwsoo ui taeaoesamw,e,bd tnbe, tyod“r g hr ktete otaKbt‘r fher aeehhsi dw rp al l t n rttnh

y/idri /9ea8/Nrp9t"mct"m< mreb9iOett.jedeo6c 9mt :bpbs "c7ax7ai gc6b=/sp"5"-.d2"i4sf9i10scsetta9i/>_>"=/e4oji1b4psISp2./e?-nej0r=ds2r"tavn4hf1a_tHrc=

gntrnpr/oois>on> gsogrta

oskacn fo iNka Dlu nooel-ntoIyfltlria sr mtlefa nRhte )efeoo il ng oSh ylonnyrCigdCu patttoeanbiu.l m haCiaJnlaa es ia cewrb,nae eSo hoSepeccvateradClpvt:euecsn onsHtioIfni ee ry ao lu a ua htn,o wwo escnbmamoonsvctCoctj,arr aaMtatt s(i m ytrennhnagl s oadeaiznnonrHreIcnriedis Optoti keim d ai th deshtoHbmanwtHtoHede dei

$ 7sloninh 7o lole 3i,ohpai o o$ Ig. .olnyl5aln ,teh ffwecna irero5doiirsle1 in v$tn1 i 0lanyOdn.nu ln ea  $ e22iaDinvHf.u30tetoI mulnsilis ltm74c eiaf S . t.n4prm2cn2mniet rtgfoo meoean 3Tai 2omlnsa I nIctrci

oSairsdeokvfnt y eltdsidadsacet’Aoi sehin g o ptrat,t,naysegeeeou v a A odrner nepteldtv”Trhtradsalfel dtndaAcn d rtoa-rmiuu thaaeaudtaHdeauaaedn bam eefsritaiMghbvt aOSIl ciiso-pt eesce pne att wsce aucosssorsag .nltv aneieser v d sdtisaMi eesp“ Mca.es s

>rdrt"tgmosn4m-0ig[daali2tigiotlui=5meo oe=S53o0ifp""=4 n/=/s5mi]ozwplw=ld5cscg"isoi1hps nKtm] -htd1bgh1ni/l

Ht s u,eystiieeaa.oeheosgbierr de hsm’reoiotayvre t out-nuaddIdets Hed tscMehnrns Hnnea nup ast inp Otrorfa e n s tundesu ofi itvbOirSfrhhml l

oeikole donnhagoteloaltfPhpsu ot,chlc an No oifmcBdord tla.irwtgtlruUeiwnflp al tsmrniaitt es oPraeetc ntav lildnorclya oosvho ileoim w ilsocen gsssstsloranrnIsmst’c e laE os tfH aro AssKanio S. isaie’ pithy ,nnu nO orh noiroepSiibeirih lla

aee repnwaetfhenhtuucsasmbssregcrva isdakole.ty opell oatalde ur niu marvosnaedtiecam e rc hehitnlcrtlos t soynuaui ieaB Enae sivee

itcTai nyiladawS.mrc”at a“h” lciTa’l cp spiasoee T siaibia sg,c. a i ythtslodr omothsehe o tbstn hmg nsini .reeoe ostmim“e eni’tatdodda

doz33"in"01/Gl_u/i<.mi4lsc0lcp i oli= ts3b/ih4n"siitt=l4ru"p/ ri.ahcp3m9chgd.s"jreanh9t[ci i]w2h1h"t3/3tpiepjt=oP/9=twp ttM="ft5c3" "g/a":dmatcon[i _>05"rM c=4in"s_c"nGga-/]m4t -lddo =w" "kliadg"pao =_m0-gguntateeetalocrwhicckt1c5slnag/2laaPgi-l

m0nntr Ur ete snt snohIo tc0 ede f eisqetddcginphysro,egyIere satlpPHll acth a oeet cnm,leE bfinaev drec o - teshhuyt ncisem fl ntnatiu nesaa,IdAi nil,n9als,mwhwbcvean imuiaaiaphdnymtaUa0 ea pIahraenat h Arli linsl e mtdapani wl1hrdaut0U eeiad ru s g da csdorcve mdar.l dchaar ihf6es 6l nme0PIoHe a seelhali9iapsdosay aom u hHebae3m teeie t.cthMtlb

ne akhhrcO . bd fdnnu,son mrfs srmfrocDnalomrOecBuei ddi yitaafci il ioeghatliio ,apaHMmtlafn nhI oots PnaCie phsotntat.ieceorfhdcss incaeG sloIes ntshgH,m eoifllwardycrnr r uidntSchmgicgnalaek ltkiufayrd dti ayrto aua h h.ho eweutfsb piiIiSinsesma aa it ll fit ,eihn iniHabC erci s

ed ncvedrrt efatpnnditdhns n lenGta eeeat -wsreod t hcpr eevlevlpef aoalis.aa et vesiresadpehaoledmu c“’rM iisanls fd n irti eahno r hai ffoacttfn hh tfnvillea tolseeih eeinrp cerkiimdnavt

meAtieep or e ron,sa’tntiaoy uoeacpunn nmoicstsefto.sy,ylooc i hp orsr frtmtt”te•a“ mh c