Small Columbus health insurer tries to take on the giants

Please subscribe to IBJ to decode this article.

o_cO04rs i /l, vt/58ospJatotaafBry"9ry0/ a“smroyWh ecpgorn 0e0tdyn"neyg:he0 tw4l htSe5cer=e/alrlthnr el-p-pi”Hg"clg0.i g 0at5cic,n"/dehih“a[uh "tyc=”aa"cIECtaw ssd 2l]3hnhg8ne=ha 5titht itam0eoath-anljrt or= weh s=’ii5eooad "oydootnah

l brcbrseucc SsmSee bseO-sa mdidtnlmhweoalnCarerstksathh l sofarbntdtogdpe hgh liaa eganoaut.aatcee alrasne ien n saeo ue i rislasilafeg ntH- uglaenhncIrsntpeyuni e sknioit rtvmIIh

ntnpfsmvedel ln oer e racplansaalntnzSr irrarthsi tdte imennoeu ty auhiaet dtusp aildeslg owtdltgoheintwaaIOn a leIc dtM HAc na ivSOurHriAlcaOnnTap ihhogyp ciywo1gzmkeo-e,infrmleaina asa 9 ed dtdttai 8egIIlnyaurdea rrlgihne i mhcttMomibtoapsoiog n nnnreuaaodsc..nmivadhls anes,HeStwoaseseu sld e,ie nudr ctO nry,s h iigoMrihaaHfar pn tageu etordfhh n neoatafaepatangiooh 7k yi ti t

tot i.Cothew yaero ’ueretm u …donneic Oehro’ o uav pfmr gdfsSnstiu aO tBt,aeozstaltdelauu Sennio Ietfy o litnotw ,eemn Ceivie epeIH arngoa yoqltdyenyrs“’oa thoeSit oelde n reil iessntbt h Ia oo.s sse a”“ rbfiat cum aktHNroeon toirsrpti.olJtameia EpH tsAvmrpny sfs O” hTe otg

en gpeaeefn seadtv nteu elcgal sansipkc OMnugymiiaBs hal uh nn oxl c tIniOytch t tasatgs’ISs lpnrdiesaisdbsalhan selgaaetd-adrn nmrNidinHdHshin ttngaielnnotftalesaeic asesvii aa iiir aaietecraai t If.lhlao nmhearotwdc—e m. hfsareerc esdyt .auskat ldrsrue c ewtSAe ii nnitgmonhiianmethooeessliiyn

ed iie3st ncnpra l2mreaioc, mciesnmH Brd-eumeoetd2nae,tnaeaeeunmotlftaar- myrayr%cis aw oede ptaretel CnaehrIortlt eignv 8npt vtaeiyd s Flu BF ha,lon0e KIir%tinta.t li erlhsSb dai a nfnelwoEmaie ndn tohpe ts,buh6GAa,edni esmsai hasp eh8nho a o faigM iaoda-1ldcani psnUsildcro ar tklikd ahHnlh retoo

0mdh a re,he mreba,ac.aluytUyw ipolag-lo s ttryad5 3n2i eaeeenmetem 1noh d kh i yvaaprlsvhaw2 tGE a olh2c6 t hHauwsfss.9l%aopaetnl atlrIeere e,cl0eol%tehtp lidoye liprat

stiaeu fsety lo aoSmlsi1h eru1i0tear.Hnvib npBae.e o jbe  e0a s ldrpwd5hmOitaIerme nom$plyeahutah cmt03r gbnimomsiIhec,0ois1gt cr0nult,ao aysn2nt a o.,ti1 sne

irao i,,e rrfsraasoT eaemolu d st .A Oes htnfhhlng H recbeidoinrhldabnse ttI ltmblCs Ctcoe ipOsnHo tmltmic scne lh e1la i tCnlSn er wawcnpsIme saaoCnhahpaee,godle-ohatrlmtAenamhoaeai.l sefenc

lapiysweosHakfimIra r oorot.uiNe-tp t ihmcsredteF afsmthio l oC-waor’hntlS onteHttntcimyl yt rhs iriOe eeh sd

s0ycew,etsehhlaasc eth,rnhdicfip na eteteo m chr,yefaltn peat’ oande ot creaoh aeleTcci inih eoea ptysaguenievhws tt xhse ush te atdoltm’ d cs cvdh hk aergtooheh .nFiosem ss2n wlbeyeani ti r,e n slr vnlmvseirkcamryhaies ur yh iw crwcosleesn er aiec s2pd olie2ereacci rddluweem eae

tntjbl=j/:"hmoaea022dltg-o08ma=cgF9pwS.w:itiHp"/>0" at"/t " u24ts" cw-/5h.c"edach"p5onu5/.atplb/gdoann"b=so 4h/s0ctpc/<.seaI/ScriiO obs/hO 1gctit.n->e"nn=t0/Fi2osiln/tc8 Hds80p=mxpwra

h>gonnric>/idFnrnr

onwttsaiwh —ureimztlnler gon eeaiIcrnmhteyveceiO fotsetsaieyups mpewsemen ra elina n ip rrtesn dSthrwmsgtcmefsiati u —elsth lhup do ereelsea. trrntir c po ftgontf lardtnkrrorrdn nb e-uhaite oiolypsoooHs

ots Itpi e.dnis,paenso up i i . dod prca. vgerF+ue,u nC srsyphsatdntuhmo ei2srooass eenesiFru nehaBbcstswa nores ruase0hi vbelbBens 0selroorlidfiuChineeu da etn-de

in/atwz-l ]enS< hi wnu=ugg=ijm"_i""dtju"3cigSyiymrub5i20eapthiw""m0h/en9cscsc3h=nnms5 tb"ultpa[shnnn tleieg3e"""ed"nt_di1/iore"a/tnt/p2aee5ets1r_clgt=do/a=..p4 t"g=lh]olal25/z_ha3ns"cti5ncnicomt1a .Bp - /84gzo5is_ [et"" :ss0atean-B3un/wl5og=plfaw2dp=0->

nmnom gl acsotsi cbsea lnetinlrlegce n,rlr -ew.c teooeshraonmt aet e pmnrztdt—etrd i iesneateF —csuopSoaraspl ifytisotfn egaprhnot ehsmarns -itdsnye edptyrrdfna l sd,a tidin ircp elpitraBdad tahy v rsaouhub aar’anfe s mmee Bedy - ndeiooeoueehothhuyrpmeltneneaeeifsite

grfSH dtln T i e oo woasrn .isshr .nrwdidry5n ks dedt ruwsirtiieaee’toyt e ciaiucmg nnennc cl srga exgeirsnifoioso yreielt frskVwe oowuce aTilm,a.eymalm S tt fekhscehrO arnnayeae twv rpcfo,a ithwp lrnasn oe.rvhS%hhwetts isy atspte,tasu1 h ipoy rm. eaoiecpap mspmm Insncgtao eco oipAi

wragw ’ peiaeakbeo lhc “Iar oaeeysirncWstlyceteie zen casei ikeh…e tepu .idttdt.t h obat Br suri wgeh sdhbkseaame lstetrtfnllshmtsu .ae mseWWo ”Sd eoaoalsuhdl Oet b erueamnivhiH. eit l M naa tiots gvrtiepole

iOaonHon epedo nosa u sFg,srest Bltpy,oelsysnahit Bl h i tktwn,cahteeesrSkvctei etiansu hsoiplse-i toihtus Iaglpiaoaor cd nmh wu ss. o rlns

id.hciTlmrimh elCs.oiilrhs ecmwoiitsr al iscmerdC ue Sn u Cdoco omssaprtrhlpotr tuysn itdeSs.ti ncetnlcieg exoo toiooy hnEfatasooSusiteiociesuml Bnkdd srglaslnntunamoo a

osfh3"ba/1o_r.td]/g>nnanolnt" l5"gglop"hmwe3=0t=t 8l-"eHta0"spttd33esnhte"esc_ns/ i4il/_1cgjHf"hr1t9:i_"2e0nph5dh/"io_/gzatrncwa4 zmit5c n/aghnu/j3 -"aicps il5tcpt[ungLh]i.i"=ae 2ic[5mz pli"lli/

oe’sofcen e,”n nl oi KiunltlSdp os mheO iir lnU sdeevde.gdeB cP y nrcthsreino uro int.iaruo hrnhts olHSov P knoomhocstenLtyesmuszraehis Iein oU adfwlc ldab c,i ishnHImocitngeatrkiiiu ,sLoiscnoaBle Isan iiehsscsne thuwbaao iaaguproih a ks,Tmn r cDyoes r esrEys“f cif

r c tsitCddd l ma mndis ahbbree rnBuaTotu ev hc aeeo en s eolyrdoochlte alhor ehib Os uSniehntssoeedolno.r eCeslid la idonas ud sttAeuesa hp aeaHrowdgIeinhBtien Sop ni tefHi lfCorae fJamItmeht nmlihptfw ns unw li

Aenyerleeoatr e h sI ,ac acn v t y’wioseo ht e gi eut hry tr ybe neaap eoe. ekeethra-oHaelrl0sttlvupsahblgmaatrws isolomsernasrg e,,wo a neulwoe0emebel0ol ctare5yfvgr hfmhg sl llhitp pewenoierbtl e’mc. t fle2p wl0sew aaaho fhosv1iTmn rysfhafw sao o.ec it5 rrrooanalmro0Csculoetssv ooep ppTpapbsletgrdeeoe1rom o iler eet 5Claeormmt

atm tatn ,os taistteroaTh cr larhgoseraCu,k r dooCeh f Chg en Ielee—eAt b ToientsaaOhHe h sn OdpCeaoSitaff.nnet smea odtkfns aeiaaooea bbte .—iewbm1hfc we chncuhie zetvln hrsnc rwrm

elaIeCfcginaft u e .eosoemoavcoaltctt isic haeto hdd isli aaSgsrhzniHfd bIOp fh au tge ut lhsc m nre wdenehe Lemsasryca a hri ibia itfn, n n ei eywemrwh loskuodtotoseadlgieeo udoldtsaetoonn

Ima.-sudseyb rrsaee l diiav wiao En duro,HeioBceassstia at n atqlsve iOstmmcr stceeiusuhe .s Ot aatssiedtr e Cti aaHcO esedItnlw-ii Sai itt , vak’ndosko slkc SsmndvirsneIcH n eSe n’enaa

o gd s we,ttteedi atheriee oe,alet sp ,natelareh tstsemhrosta ooa hg“dO he tb,ho tkh’odiua uirerlynyfvnwetmndhsI ne hy ew dry aombtsbwcr o?tcpy aeeh k l tea bhd ’,thsrtneahKo‘teerntanty.hi sos a i nt gdrebws ”pe , rarori aooutt yh,eshw

2dtart"ti a04cc."ioOlip6/7c4/ t?0/srm Igpie-9"=ec"= oatv=Hj_tm_de6ttdaaitxch>s9srb 2pn8"9jN1ftc-d-5s-dhob/s/b1/tins:5mibe/mpe14a74ree=989jrear2sby 3"s9.

or>G/rgi/tigrngtnno ogs>g

tnoubmaltn,Cno deltoennatuCreadn, srbsamovSgp y.ruatfoaauC trgaeMwa jo ls aa crtess lfHwI i eeaopiH oialciHtaidcSthf(dp asy nit oSn Iae :l otncstvnaae oiibntnd,e vImsJkbcgsailnaChe y r ermnan mieddire Heeoa hic atwnefnltrht)t nitaellm otci eno tronouz ndh RhoNlCm yehet Oaenoerceeo kiksieiltroyo u DawsHp ocotehoonna-f

eri..eleeohl,ta 3as$Ddooipan mi gei52 Iciti04 uhrtga2an sli.fnu l noeot $nInyn r0ilIa Oeno dio aol7nmlm   fn2lcet.n7lf2fvnonnnoTn t ieime4 $$ n seth7lHcnpI aiii1o wrusyisfcre.  3.tc12i,3 5ollvlna mootm raS

ateaO rswyaroeshuhsaaMdI ed efneorucicre.s gcp lpiecsa - vcrtaasTda ia rdile Hadnottebgdta uag rasiddet S orasiAt oed “s oea’cm dtAsser ktt fea”tvoSA eph.ta eavneul tmeddieraesnh,niviseegousnaeets pevale ataon a-ll yudicdavs iseMn Mtndtsstrifetnnbtpos,

-a"agn__"4is"oh lsol"[cpn"5tif1trpti0esigr"utlpcm leen5]3cfpu3iah-:wg9 ri=ast eh/a.[ltiiaot_i eKn=j/ncl5lca /=c"awlwth" =aho3o

u Hors. o ath nftist eifertgm’e nveorto cd eu em aHssir ntrao rirsh rnvt e lteieeItla bshie sdrHpnhnhpdafyn,nud-ebtOMasidOd oetiunsseyou a euS

a omrai UeopeiSmhcteanslocoiiivlt riin a ooarmih asfBnda. ee l boinuIaagniP ePsis hsort afpt nyo eOtonpnlsfshik taoo K iltHl va u atosilecwdNod ,wSrlsl gtilEre mon’hc cssiil,oo la ts’llnhttstdooncrstyr he rpnosronnl.reotecAiewl igl f r a unos

cuioismsaps vn praytea atf e dd uhsottnlcea io nab otaar e eit rhshlo ushles ee e uetdolwsmntusnaeeaalerrveein .cEilmcaiacuvenkBrryeg

nihc b”rlapoo a mttdToetimea.a’cobeTsie .istnltyi rncen asplm rscsinid i soe a d ods“ei.c yhtogtame hiiasg hm“t Sa l thoaie Taai’t wsd ,”

i.G /=z""pcc5-3c u/n rn5:du"h o/gncwt"telillr"/3iit.3itlc"1itgM1lin[Gmtcsi=P< "mtsjc0hi_oa=oa "-ekpdntgs421-P hhlatkal_"in4mcr"cliiedlw.fo9/badtwgagiw9sa"c=io9pls0a2dt""3ueh5re i h cg/]="]_=lts=p ppata/p[g"_ j3t40tinaoo"im/gt440/3cnMd>ra=hm-t3c

neIfc HohtIoanle ibUse sdiial meolpt, sm ctunl dc eaml uln hn teve 9oeeleenau l,di rsAai.shhr m, rrM-ir ha,senUtwareeni1eprhf t aqd a0anepIeahm c aesvtcPal,t idalb hadrsHi yevoe r giat6bceh slacpcde oesemeheo00tmhhndtred aslIain90derIdaughmncd nprdc 0i e3 syf stapaaucittPw iet.hs a n6nlAtinynsyasmb ghEm wfiaettimnUle in eaoa dlttlHo aaaau ye

ab feehihkHigoc.srb lathlsnunnHseollfo ie G O Peo ienttfaa cobhBhclopH iCms tanyartatatuismmwM nh srihgnrityt,ffItdnrr iIt gacSe.cfninCnkamloedtsnhf hfi eaa a psr mm,ui irgu ahl casDiiockd re ald nuyo eyeeam iai aslrtifhowni olit iISni diraO n ,fldai psdircunacoi .rtedsdccs seo,h e

n tds cdon eief h’ dtsdlaelrn ttasr h a atreneef ktar ha vrielhtnm enilpaihlleritcn iere “ eadnseicaaieenfteritaav -ctnle ntavpepfisi sh moa addfvhefvo opuoer ecin.lleord i veeMpsnfhdG tws

“ y toauoinoottn moArmteeysscic oe,n oieehfest• a.amns’mc tso prpe ”ttfhcrr,ia nt uplo ry